Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Carrie Armstrong

GET UPDATES FROM Carrie Armstrong
 

Please Don't Give Up Drinking

Posted: 26/02/2013 23:00

I don't like it when I hear people talking about "giving up" drinking.

I don't like it because it doesn't really work.

It's not about sacrifice. The very term "giving up" alcohol I take issue with. Nobody "gives up" drinking, the same way nobody gives up at a traffic light when it turns red. You just stop. Can you imagine if we used this type of terminology whilst driving? Spending hours a day giving up to and from work? We'd all be permanently knackered. Defeated by our own journeys. Is it not slightly worrying that we give more care to the language we use in relation to the vehicles we drive than we do to our own bodies?

Stop Drinking. Stop. It's not even an action is it? It cessation of action, It's switching focus. Replacing the old action of drinking with other new actions. Giving up does more than simply imply that we have stopped a course of action. It infers that there is no more action to come. No stop, so no start. And that is where we are going about recovery in a horribly wrong way. From a massively flawed premise. I've given up drinking so my life is over, versus I've stopped drinking so therefore I'm deliberately starting living instead.

It is important. It is really important. Because when we feel like we've given something wonderful up, that our life will not be as good as everyone else's, those lucky ones who get to still participate in something we have denied ourselves? We harbour feelings of entitlement. That now we have decided to stop f*cking our life up with our drinking we are owed something in return. That the world should give us a break. Be nice to us. That we are suffering and should be rewarded for our gallantry. It won't happen. It can't happen. Because it isn't true. This realisation can be very disappointing. And that disappointment? Just brings a bigger sense of lack and emptiness. Until giving up on giving up seems the only available option. A very easily excused and readily justified option too. And so back to drinking we go. Relapse in full swing, ready to begin that vicious cycle again. And again.

Unless we die obviously. There's your stop without lack. Or is dying too strong a word? Would we prefer "giving up" living?

Recovery is not a sacrifice. It is empowering. An exciting and wonderful journey. The most amazing thing a person can do for themselves. And I never expected it. Never knew it could feel like this. Certainly nobody told me it could be this way. Alcoholics waste years on drinking. On being anesthetised by our drug of choice. We've missed so much of life. All of us. Recovery does not have to be about missing out on even more by spending our new sober life either commiserating with other people who also think they are also missing out, or by spending it shut away from the world out of fear. Fear that our self-discipline is not strong enough to fight the need to drink. More mistaken thinking. Nothing about being recovered needs to be about lack.

My heart breaks for people who have felt the need to "battle" with sobriety. Whether they have lost the battle and gone back to drinking like the 95% we are so often told do. Or whether they continue to battle-like the elusive 5% who stay in recovery-but still feel vulnerable to relapse, or bereft without alcohol. Never feeling fully free and really, truly alive when it is so very easy to do so.

I do believe being recovered is beautiful. And permanent. I do believe we can all have it. Easily. Joyfully. Comfortably. I believe in a world where recovered people are happy. I think we all deserve it. And I think it starts with something as simple as the words we use. Giving up nothing. Choosing more. Choosing a life of passion. Of reaching beyond everything we've ever assumed was possible. A miraculous life filled with inspiration. With love, fulfilment. To me that's what recovery is. And who wouldn't want live in a place like that?

Home.

Finally.

 

Follow Carrie Armstrong on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CarrieArmstrng

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
I don't like it when I hear people talking about "giving up" drinking. I don't like it because it doesn't really work. It's not about sacrifice. The very term "giving up" alcohol I take issue with. ...
I don't like it when I hear people talking about "giving up" drinking. I don't like it because it doesn't really work. It's not about sacrifice. The very term "giving up" alcohol I take issue with. ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:53 AM on 04/02/2013
I'm genuinely shocked that you're given such freedom to write about alcohol addiction in an online sector where you receive so much attention. Your view to these issues are restricted by rigid, non-contextual experience: alcoholics are individual people with numerous situational variables involving health and family amongst others.

As far as this particular article is concerned: you're obviously not aware that some people who "just stop" can literally die from the repercussions. While I'm obviously an advocate of rehabilitation, painting this picture of simplicity is blindly inaccurate.
01:51 PM on 03/01/2013
Outstanding - thank you!
09:50 PM on 02/28/2013
Hi Carrie
It's a fascinating insight into the power of words. I work with alcoholoics and addicts on a daily basis and was horrified by the headline, although the article is about semantics. The real danger lies in the misleading title, "Please don't give up drinking" which shouldd have read, "Please don't call it 'giving up drinking' ". A couple of the contributers in response appear not to have understood that you were fully behind abstinence, and that is the danger - for most problem drinkers you have to stop drinking - there are no half measures for the alcoholic. If you simply drink too much, cutting down would clearly help, but that is not an option for an alcoholic, as you know well.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carrie Armstrong
10:35 PM on 02/28/2013
Thank you for taking the time to write all of this down. I can definitely see your point xx
08:43 PM on 02/28/2013
My only problem with alchohol is that the tax is so high, still like to have a tipple though.
08:39 PM on 02/28/2013
You the journalist who wrote this must be a undercover agent for the conlib mob Please dont stop drinking as the tax income will fall thats whatit should have read NONSENSE
07:27 PM on 02/28/2013
I cant believe I clicked on the link to read such utter rubbish, where do they get these people to write this drivel!
03:25 PM on 02/28/2013
For my grandfather at 90 and my almost father-in-law at 97, losing a taste for drink and stopping was the first symptom of death in a few months. Both had previously been steady drinkers, taking about twice the quacks' recommended dose. So I certainly do not commend giving it up.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Justinjuice
11:44 AM on 02/28/2013
" Do you need to give up drinking completely if you have a problem with alcohol? There are conflicting opinions " The foregoing is the opening paragraph of the Online alcohol therapy site. They use the expression 'Give up' throughout the site. In what way would their site be better if they substituted 'Give up' for 'Stop' ? I cant see it would make any difference. Many Christians talk about ' giving up things for the season of Lent, I haven't heard any body saying they are stopping something something for Lent, or at least i cant recall hearing it. The first break up in the christian church came about as the result of the meanings of two or three words- i.e when the Orthodox Church broke away in the early life of the church. So quibbling over the meanings of words can have negative impacts.
The twelve Steps of Alcoholics Anonymous, and the Steps of other similar groups, do not mention either stopping or giving up. So it doesnt really seem to important which words you use to describe the action, merely that one takes action not to lift/take the first drink on a daily basis.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carrie Armstrong
12:47 PM on 02/28/2013
My answer isn't going to change I'm afraid.I believe in everyone's right to believe in anything they choose. I believe words are an integral part of recovery. And I believe more people can get and stay sober than are doing so right now, and that they can do so without feeling lack. i believe this because my life shows me this everyday. I'm happy for you to do it your way and have me do it mine. This is just another way of doing things, a way I have found more effective in leading a very happy life. I'd like everyone to have the option of feeling the same way.xx
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Collette Walsh
08:24 PM on 02/27/2013
Excellent article Carrie - really good stuff. The language we use is firmly connected to the 'story' we tell ourselves and yes, is important (but obviously it is all how we interpret our own words). You are totally right in differentiating between language and expressions that imply missing out or losing something as compared to making the sometimes brave, sometimes life-saving choice to stop ... I wish you every happiness and health - you clearly are not giving up on that! x
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carrie Armstrong
12:48 PM on 02/28/2013
Thank you very much sweeheart, that's very kind of you to say xx
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:01 PM on 02/27/2013
"Recovery is not a sacrifice."

An absolute truth right there Carrie. Another first rate piece, thank you.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carrie Armstrong
06:55 PM on 02/27/2013
Thank you very much for your kind words xx
03:37 AM on 02/28/2013
Dear Carrie Armstrong: Your article is Excellent. You have mentioned a very good points.
Please send me your Skype address and I want to discuss about this topic via skype further.

thanks
Teaherjan
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Justinjuice
12:55 PM on 02/27/2013
Carrie, what kind of audience are you addressing ? If it is the guy or girl who has flicked on to your blog with a certain amount of desperation after yet another instance of drink related chaos, then I suspect they will have stopped reading quite quickly. I know your intentions are good, but jaysus talk about being pedantic ! I gave up drinking for a day quite a good few years ago and guess what ? My life didnt end, and today I am still 'Given Up on Drinking' ! What the hell does it matter what words I use ? All that matter is that the individual doesnt take up the next drink. Not how they describe the last drink.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Carrie Armstrong
06:55 PM on 02/27/2013
I think the language we use is very important. Just my own belief obviously. If your approach works for you and also makes your life a very happy place then that is wonderful. I'd never want to change that xx
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Justinjuice
08:48 PM on 02/27/2013
No I have to say firmly, you are being pedantic for the point of filling a column - which isnt, I suggest, very commendable.
11:52 PM on 02/27/2013
rhetoric - but hey it pays the bills. What you don't express is the language of desparation. You are pedantic to the point of language, but not the experience behind it. Live life a bit Cariie and you may understand that language is not the bee all and end all............ also looking at your last post a tiny bit patronising too.