Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Damian Collins

GET UPDATES FROM Damian Collins
 

The Euro is Falling Down a Gemeinschaft

Posted: 02/12/11 00:00 GMT

Gemeinschaft, translated from German as meaning a sense of community in which individuals are oriented to the large association as much as, if not more than, to their own self interest. It is this desire to maintain the eurozone as a large group of European nations which has weakened and may ultimately destroy it.

It is clear that Greece should never have been allowed to join and that the stability and convergence criteria for membership of the euro agreed in the Maastricht treaty, have been adapted to allow as many countries to stay in as possible.

The big eurozone has worked well for Germany. It has given the country an artificially low value for its currency which has allowed its exports to prosper. The reverse is of course true for countries like Italy and Spain. With this in mind, regardless of your views on the value of the project of European integration, you can see why German politicians want to keep the eurozone together. But this will surely not be at any price.

Speaking on Thursday in the European Parliament, the head of the ECB, Mario Draghi, suggested that the price for countries to stay within the eurozone will be a loss of national control on Government tax and spend, alongside measures of assistance. He said regarding the question of the ECB buying up national debts that "Other elements might follow...but the sequencing matters". He added that "a new fiscal compact would be the most important signal from euro-area governments for embarking on a path of comprehensive deepening of economic integration". This also echoes Angela Merkel's call on Wednesday for "political courage to bring the euro zone closer together."

This 'compact' would allow Germany to lock countries into an agreed programme for reform in return for staying under the safety of the protection that might be given under the eurozone umbrella. Perhaps the idea of 'eurobonds' might even return, but only for those countries that sign up. A simple message would be given with such a scheme to the eurozone members when they gather for next week's European Council, that they must adapt or leave the euro; or to follow one of the slogans of the American revolution 'unite or die'.

But will everyone be willing to take this step, and even if ministers agree, can they sell to their people this once in a lifetime transfer of power to the EU, of some of the most fundamental powers of government.

This must surely create problems in Italy where not a single elected politician sits the cabinet of their government. Some politicians in Europe are prepared to concede that this will be too much for Greece and that they will most probably leave the euro at Christmas, and if the other countries are prepared to sign up to this 'compact' that may buy some more time.

A eurozone break up may then not be in a big bang, but more like a dance of the seven veils, with countries peeling off one at a time to leave a core eurozone of Germany, Holland, Austria, a few of the other smaller economies, and you would have to imagine at almost any price France as well.

 

Follow Damian Collins on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DamianCollins

Gemeinschaft, translated from German as meaning a sense of community in which individuals are oriented to the large association as much as, if not more than, to their own self interest. It is this des...
Gemeinschaft, translated from German as meaning a sense of community in which individuals are oriented to the large association as much as, if not more than, to their own self interest. It is this des...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:19 PM on 12/02/2011
I'm not a great fan of Margaret Thatcher but at least she knew how to deal with the EU. She would have had us out the moment this crisis began.

I suspect other countries want out too, but like us, they have too many lilly livered politicians who are too busy feathering their own nests instead of doing what is right and pulling out.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheColouredEuropean
Government is not evil, REPUB government is evil
12:36 AM on 12/03/2011
are you simple? Thatcher would have hogtied us to the Yanks, like a puppydog ..... Oh wait.

I mean, yah rrrrright. Thatcher would do what Cameron is doing now: realizing the UK needs Europe more than vice versa, but keep insulting the EU every other minute ...
Like Cameron does now, Thatcher would have ran the printing press, pure and simple. At least Frau Merkel says NEIN! to that one.
12:24 PM on 12/02/2011
Let's hope the shaft that the EURO is falling down is so deep that we never see the like of it again and good riddence to the EU.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheColouredEuropean
Government is not evil, REPUB government is evil
10:59 AM on 12/02/2011
Ha ha, this is too funny. Don't blame Greece, blame Germany. It was Germany, 10 years ago, and buddy France that blew up the Stability Pact, which said no more than 3 percent deficit. Germany said: "Bums that" and went higher, just like France. Wide-eyed Greece asked "Hey, can you DO that?" and continued it's policy of fake employment of people who perhaps should have been not hired. And forgot that it didn't have any income generating business like the Germans to begin with.
But it started with Germany, who as the big boy set THE bad example. The rest is BS and hypocrisy.

Also a big LIE: Grecians DO NOT take their pensions at 55! Completely fabricated! FYI: The Dutch DO have whole SHI#loads of people who got pensioned off at 57 and they are doing really well economically speaking. This proves, by the way, that (increase in) racism has nothing to do with economic hardships, the usual historical explanation for the rise of fascism in the 20th century. Nah, Occam's razor says that the Dutch are simply really racist, but USED TO BE well-mannered enough not to mention that in public. That custom has declined.