Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Damian Collins

GET UPDATES FROM Damian Collins
 

Leveson Report Must Herald Change

Posted: 29/11/2012 15:06

Lord Leveson's report is right to focus on the failings of press regulation, but is wrong to believe that the government's media regulator Ofcom should oversee a new self regulation model. A free press is vital to a free society and a properly functioning democracy. Once statutory regulation of the press comes in, no matter how far removed from politicians, it will call into question the integrity of the system, and lead to pressure for greater intervention in the future.

The Leveson Report exposes that self regulation of the press has been a myth. Not only did the Press Complaints Commission (PCC) fail to protect the victims of phone hacking or of the press intrusion that trashed the life of an innocent man like Chris Jeffries, but it didn't give them sufficient redress. The main reason for this is that it does not have the power. The PCC has not been a regulator, rather just the handler of complaints. It has no powers to investigate, discipline or fine members for breaches of its code. It is not even required that all of the national newspapers are signed up to it. These things have to change, and that change can be made without the requirement of statutory regulation of the media. It is now up to the media owners to show they are willing to take up the challenge of creating this new self regulatory model.

It is vital that a new self regulatory model has independence of operation from the media owners and the powers to launch its own investigations. The phone hacking scandal exposed the real weaknesses of the current model of regulation because there were plenty of warnings about the scale of the problem.

Over 300 journalists had, according to the Information Commissioners report in 2006, been involved with the illegal trade in confidential personal information, but no rigorous industry wide investigation was launched by the Press Complaints Commission or other industry body because none existed with the power to act in this way. At News Corporation, all of the documents that suggesting knowledge of the use of practices like phone hacking extended beyond a single rogue journalist existed within that company. The Culture, Media and Sport House of Commons Select Committee inquiry that I was part of uncovered these documents, but in future they should be within the reach of a new industry regulator.

Lord Leveson has also reported that the former Media Secretary, Jeremy Hunt handled the bid by News Corporation to buy the remaining shares in BSkyB with "fairness, impartiality and transparency". This flies in the face of Ed Milliband's assertion that Jeremy Hunt had been a "backchannel" for the Murdochs.

The Leveson Report addresses how people might seek redress if they are unfairly treated by the newspapers, but this does not extend to what people might say about each other in parliament. Mr Milliband should apologise for this remark, but perhaps this is another example of why politicians shouldn't be the ultimate arbiters of what newspapers should and shouldn't be able to write.

 

Follow Damian Collins on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DamianCollins

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Lord Leveson's report is right to focus on the failings of press regulation, but is wrong to believe that the government's media regulator Ofcom should oversee a new self regulation model. A free pres...
Lord Leveson's report is right to focus on the failings of press regulation, but is wrong to believe that the government's media regulator Ofcom should oversee a new self regulation model. A free pres...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
velvetundergroundfan
12:49 AM on 12/02/2012
I am unconvinced that Damian Collins is an impartial player on this issue.

Murdoch says that News Corp. had been meeting privately with Tory members of the Parliament Committee investigating his empire.
The Daily Beast. Peter Jukes Apr 28, 2012
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/04/28/rupert-murdoch-s-fishy-mp-meetings.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
velvetundergroundfan
11:22 PM on 12/01/2012
Rupert Murdoch privately lobbied all of the Tories on the DCMS Committee including Mr. Collins.
See link below.

Sorry Mr. Collins but we don't trust you or that ridiculous Louise Mensch woman.

Murdoch says that News Corp. had been meeting privately with Tory members of the Parliament Committee investigating his empire.
The Daily Beast. Peter Jukes Apr 28, 2012
http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/04/28/rupert-murdoch-s-fishy-mp-meetings.html
10:58 PM on 12/01/2012
Is everyone missing out here the main issue. It DOES NOT MATTER what politicians or there political master say. This must be a decision of the electorate not Parliament. When is the UK going to respect the importance of a Royal Commission and its people. I beleive in this case its time for a vote of the people.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
04:05 AM on 12/01/2012
Unrestricted freedom can result in tyranny. If Cameron didn't believe that Leveson would careful consider the matter of Press Freedom then he should not have appointed him. His stance is insulting. If he is not convinced that regulation by an independent body is appropriate then the least he can do is explain why. To not do so points to dishonesty. And I thought he was against that.
04:15 PM on 11/30/2012
And this man is on the Culture and Media Select Committee. Worrying, really worrying; no wonder we have lost all faith in our MPs.
03:16 PM on 11/30/2012
"The Leveson Report exposes that self regulation of the press has been a myth"

It does no such thing - it merely adds a small further element of confirmation to what was already bleedin' obvious to anyone except newspaper proprietors and their biatches in the Tory party.

Leveson exposes the defecatory habits of ursines in silvan environments. Leveson exposes the theological inclinations of the Pontifex Maximus.
02:18 PM on 11/30/2012
What integrity!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drg40
Representative Democracy is all we have.
12:54 AM on 11/30/2012
What part of "Ministers are responsible for the conduct of their 'Special' Advisors" does the columnist not understand, do you think?
12:13 AM on 11/30/2012
It would appear that Mr Cameron is still under the influence at the very least of Mr Murdock.
Lord Levesons' suggestions were measured, balanced and fair, further safeguards to the system he has proposed could include an annual review of how the system is working sunset clauses or other review procedures.
A free press is vital but so is a responsible one. We elect our governments and they are responsible to us for their actions, there currently is no obligation for the press to act responsibly and little for them to even act legally, there is certainly no accountability.
The victims of the excesses of an iresponsible press deserve better than the dodgy deal Mr Cameron is proposing, he must think again, he owes the elctorate a greater debt than that he owes to News Corp.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
velvetundergroundfan
12:12 AM on 11/30/2012
Leveson Report WON'T Herald Change because you Tories are terrified of Rupert Murdoch and the Daily Mail. Cameron betrayed the victims of phone hacking.

This cynical, self-serving article praises Leveson and then dismisses the Judge's main recommendation. Typical Tory hypocrisy.

Jeremy Hunt should have been sacked ages ago.
10:07 PM on 11/29/2012
Cameron is anti-democratic.

The Leveson Inquiry was set up by parliament and now he is trying to prevent its recommendation to regulate the press who have acted with criminality against the population for profit, malice and greed.

Freedom of speech needs regulation, or else the rich and powerful press owners will continue to treat the British people with contempt and malice.

We must act.
09:58 PM on 11/29/2012
Cameron is acting like a salesman who is selling his soul for the sake of newspaper owners support in the next General Election.

Pointless really as Cameron and the tories are going to be punished by the electorate, and sent into the oblivion of political obscurity.
09:52 PM on 11/29/2012
Asking newspaper owners to self regulate is like asking a snake to grow legs and walk.
09:47 PM on 11/29/2012
Has Cameron betrayed the victims of press criminality by refusing to implement Lord Leveson's
recommendations?