Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Daniel Taub

GET UPDATES FROM Daniel Taub
 

Israel's Blitz

Posted: 20/11/2012 08:17

" [Through] these cruel, wanton, indiscriminate bombings of London... He hopes, by killing large numbers of civilians, and women and children, that he will terrorize and cow the people of this mighty imperial city... Little does he know the spirit of the British nation, or the tough fibre of the Londoners."

These words, spoken by prime minister Winston Churchill in September 1940, are but a distant memory to many British citizens today. And yet, they remind us of times when Londoners spent countless nights seeking cover from aerial attacks in shelters and tube stations.

In the years since Israel pulled out of Gaza, over one million Israelis have been forced to live under similar conditions, seeking refuge in bomb shelters as a result of thousands of Hamas rocket and mortar attacks. While the rockets targeting Israeli civilians - men, women, and children - do not carry as deadly a payload as that of the German bombs of World War II, their aim is equally sinister and illegitimate: to instill fear in the hearts of Israelis and undermine their right to live in a free and independent state.

In recent months, over one seventh of Israel's population have found themselves within range of rocket fire, having to live their lives within 15-30 seconds of the closest bomb shelter in case the siren sounds. Children have been unable to attend school for extended periods, growing up experiencing the trauma of life in the danger zone. Showing remarkable courage and restraint in the face of this intolerable reality, these Israelis have tried to maintain a semblance of normalcy, while the Israeli government continued to hold out hope that a non-military resolution of the situation might be reached.

However, over time, not only have the assaults become more frequent, but the range of sophisticated rockets, smuggled in from Iran, Sudan and Libya, has increased. The Iranian-made Fajr 5 missile has a range of 75km, putting some 4.5 million people - over 50% of Israel's population - in the kill zone.

Last week, for the third time in a month, the civilians of southern Israel came under attack from the Gaza Strip. An anti-tank missile was fired at an army jeep on the Israeli side of the border fence, injuring four IDF soldiers. Subsequently, over 120 rockets were fired at Israeli civilians.

It was only following this sharp escalation that Israel embarked upon Operation Pillar of Defence in order to end the indiscriminate rocket barrage from Gaza and to cripple Hamas' ability to launch terror attacks on our citizens.

The need for action was clear, but any such operation is highly complex. Israel is painfully aware that Hamas not only directs its missile attacks against Israeli civilians but it also, cynically, hides its stockpiles and missile launchers behind Palestinian civilians. This creates an enormously difficult challenge for Israel, which has to defend its citizens while doing its utmost to avoid injuring the innocent Palestinians being used as shields by the terrorists. Israel devotes
enormous effort to these challenges. These efforts include using, where possible, the Israeli developed 'Iron Dome' technology to intercept rockets in flight, and dropping thousands of leaflets and making tens of thousands of phone calls, urging Palestinian civilians to leave areas of Hamas activity for their own safety. Moreover, refusing to ignore the plight of Gaza's civilian population, which suffers under the yoke of Hamas rule, Israel has transferred nearly 100 trucks loaded with food and medical supplies into Gaza since the operation began and has also afforded medical treatment to 26 Gazans who are being cared for in Israeli hospitals.

To date the operation has dealt a serious blow to the Hamas terrorist organization, including successfully targeting its military leadership and putting out of action a large proportion of the long-range missiles in the arsenal of Hamas and its fellow terrorist organisations.

This is in itself a significant success. But in itself it will not be sufficient to sustain a long term ceasefire and restore normal life to the citizens for Israel. For this to happen, Hamas itself must recognise that terrorising Israelis will no longer be tolerated, by Israel or the international community.

 

Follow Daniel Taub on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@IsraelinUK

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
" [Through] these cruel, wanton, indiscriminate bombings of London... He hopes, by killing large numbers of civilians, and women and children, that he will terrorize and cow the people of this mighty ...
" [Through] these cruel, wanton, indiscriminate bombings of London... He hopes, by killing large numbers of civilians, and women and children, that he will terrorize and cow the people of this mighty ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:53 PM on 11/21/2012
How offensive is that? to compare Israel with the blitz in London you must be joking. I think if London had an iron dome system then it would have probably carried on as normal. It is not like a Londoner to try and get the sympathy of the world. The iron dome system of which the first two were funded by Israel and the next eight funded by the USA (no wonder Clinton said she was glad to see it work) is a luxury Gaza cannot afford. Perhaps if the USA gave them a similar defence system things might look a bit fairer.
05:25 PM on 11/21/2012
Quote: "He hopes, by killing large numbers of civilians, and women and children, that he will terrorize and cow the people of this mighty imperial city."

Tell me Mr Taub what do you regard as "large numbers of civilians, and women and children"? Perhaps you would care to lay out the casualty figures for both sides of this conflict.

I heard your interview in TV a few minutes ago in which you referred to military necessity because of the tactics of Hamas. Tell me Mr Taub if the roles had been reversed would the Israeli Defence Force site all of it fire power and limited armaments away from built up areas at a base which it could not defend and wait for Hamas's air force to pound it into dust?

Hamas's tactics are born out of necessity. I'm sure that it would like to take on the IDF on equal terms but in comparison to the IDF it is gnat. Terrorism is the war of the weak, war is the terrorism of the powerful.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StephanLarose
05:15 AM on 11/21/2012
Right, and how is the Israeli track record on killing Palestinian civilians? Israeli snipers target Palestinian children playing football, drop white phosphorus bombs on residential areas, target hospitals, refugee camps, orchards, anything and everything. Israelis kill about 100 times more civilians than Palestinians do, and Israel, the military occupier for decades, is the aggressor.

Israel, you are the one leading an illegal military occupation. You are the one continually stealing land and water in direct contravention of the Geneva Accords. You are the one humiliating Palestinians daily. You are the one practicing collective punishment on an entire population. You are the ones practicing a worse-than-apartheid policy. You are the ones that bulldoze homes while families are still inside. You are the ones confining a population to the world's largest open-air prison. You are the ones denying food and medicine to children. You are the ones breaking ceasefires with military provocations. You are the ones with an actual illegal nuclear weapons program.

Your behavior is a blight on the conscience of humanity. If you desire peace, then withdraw your military from all occupied lands, tear down your apartheid wall, dismantle your network of Jew-only highways and military installations in Palestinian territory, stop your racist apartheid policies and join the modern world. Continue to abuse and commit horrors against the Palestinians at your peril. Make peace now, or your pay for it with your children's future.
11:53 AM on 11/21/2012
An evxellent truth post. These aggressers want all of Palestine . Their stupid beliefs that God promised them this land, when it is obvious that anyone with an Iota of sencw knows that Gods are but Faiy Takes.so all the prayers that are said are an utter waste of time.
11:52 PM on 11/20/2012
Hamas has no interest in bettering the lives of Palestinians.

The state of Israel should take all necessary steps to secure its citizens against murderous attacks against its population.

Hamas needs to develop a posture of peace for Gaza. Then all blockades can end.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StephanLarose
05:22 AM on 11/21/2012
But it's ok for Israel to steal Palestinian land under military occupation? It's ok for Israel to practice ethnic cleansing, collective punishment, assassinations of children, chemical weapons attacks, extra-judicial killing, mass-murder, economic blockade, bulldozing Palestinian homes with families still inside, daily humiliation, and a worse-than-apartheid policy?

Are you not even aware that Israel is the occupying military power? Israel is the aggressor, it was founded by "clearing" thousands of Palestinian villages to make way for Israeli settlers.

Palestinians are human being too, and they have the right to be free of the yoke of racist Israeli rule, free from the fear that their homes might be bulldozed on top of them because some fundamentalist Israeli wants Palestinian land for himself.

If Israel does not change it's despicable behavior soon, it will find itself isolated in an increasingly hostile region. Arabs and Muslims will not tolerate Israel's massacres and dehumanizations much longer. They would be wise to take the peace initiatives offered them sooner rather than later.
01:55 PM on 11/21/2012
you are such a joke . . bibi doesn't want peace . .he wants all of Palestine . .. . I suggest you read Gideon Levy's books
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Activist Annie
03:24 PM on 11/21/2012
Blessings to you and your family this Thanksgiving.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MohammedAbbasi
Co-Director, Association of British Muslims
09:08 PM on 11/20/2012
What a disgusting comparision!

What you have said is an insult to civilians who died in world war two and an insult to those who died in the concentration camps - who is bombing/blitzing/attacking in Gaza?, how many kids/innocents have been killed?

The sympathy stuff pulling the nazi/holocaust/nazism comparison out of the hat and saying to people 'oh look poor us' is not going to work, is not working and will not work - if anything people will look at your cheap shots at sympathy as pathetic.
08:32 PM on 11/20/2012
This is a disgraceful comparion, and it shows how desperate Israel is to try and avoid the world wide condemnation of its escalation of attacks on Gaza. End the occupation, stop building settlements stop the ethnic cleansing, then we will listen.
01:56 PM on 11/21/2012
f & f yesspam
08:18 PM on 11/20/2012
What about Iran, Hezbollah and the PIJ? Unless the children of Palestine put down their guns and suicide vests their will be no lasting peace in Israel. I image googled children of Hamas then children of Israel. Who are the innocent parties in all of this?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StephanLarose
05:24 AM on 11/21/2012
Israel is the occupying military power and their list of atrocities, massacres, abuses and crimes against humanity blight the conscience. Israel can have peace any time it wants, it just needs to abide by the peace initiatives offered many times in the past.

Instead, they would rather have snipers assassinate children playing football and steal more land. The region is changing. Israel will soon reap what it sows.
07:46 AM on 11/21/2012
Israel has nuclear weapons and the most advanced military in the Mid-East. What will they reap and from whom. Unless you speak of mutually assured destruction from Iran then I don't know how the Israelis can be defeated militarily? In 2005, thousands of Jewish settlers were evacuated from their settlements in Gaza, this was Israel offering a hand in friendship. Instead what they got was thousands of rockets because Hamas saw this as weakness. If the people of Gaza want peace they need to re-educate their children, vote out Hamas and reject Islamic Jihad.  
07:35 PM on 11/20/2012
As someone who has met a member of Hamas, instead of heard about them or read about them, let me quote what he said to me: "We want to push Israel into the sea." Not push Israel back to 1967 borders. Push them into the sea. And he meant it. As do all the other Hamas people. As does Iran, ,which admits as much.

Whilst disagreeing with a lot Israel has done (and I don't like Netanyahu at all) the world has not come forward to guarantee Israels borders pre 1967, and even if it did, if you were an Israeli, would you trust what people said? (The Balkans come to mind). They are, and always have been, surrounded by enemies.

The size of Israel is minute. I believe it is about twenty miles wide as its narrowest point. It is one twelfth the size of the United Kingdom. I went from almost one end to the other in a day.

Hamas seems to have put its rocket launchers amongst the population, to ensure that maximum casualties are caused, to make Israel seem the aggressor and oppressive. Sometimes they are. But not this time, according to independent reporters
united dreamer
The meek shall inherit the earth, trust me
06:34 PM on 11/20/2012
I love it when the attack on civilians by Hamas is the start of the problem. Nothing to do with Israel's own policies of systematic attacks on civil rights, assassinations and casual destruction of civilians and their property they deem enemies by association.

Israel are the face of a tyranny that they are laughably claiming to face.
united dreamer
The meek shall inherit the earth, trust me
06:14 PM on 11/20/2012
The ambassador is beginning to sound more and more like the apologists of Apartheid similarly supported by an increasingly out of touch government more interested in power politics than genuine justice.

It's strange that you here nothing from this bunch of crooks when mentioning the viral spread of illegal settlements into Palestinian land, and the casual destruction of Palestinian infrastructure, assassinations and indiscriminate shelling.
05:14 PM on 11/20/2012
LOL, compared to israel Hamas are Mother Theresa.

Get out of Palestine & stop murdering children, israel is a terrorist state carrying out genocide in Gaza.

Viva Palestine!
03:58 PM on 11/20/2012
Which part of the free and independat state do the "Occupied Terrortries" belong to?
03:10 PM on 11/20/2012
i wonder where all the weapons came from? p.s nick cleggs is the only balanced person in the house but everyone too pre occupied to notice ...best hope for sudden enlightenment
02:50 PM on 11/20/2012
always the same victim routine while being the bully . . shame on you
01:52 PM on 11/20/2012
I have picked up a theory about the invocation of the Second World War to justify military actions. The 39-45 war really was different. It involved the defeat of an evil, which, while far from the only example of evil in history, is unmatched for its scope, and for its intended scope. Never since then has any power sought so brutally to subjugate entire continents.

TL;DR: The Second World War is not happening again, anywhere.

There is no second Hitler.

There is no second Churchill.

The inescapable conclusion, if this theory is even partly correct, is that anyone who invokes the Second World War to justify the actions of his masters in government is making statements which vary quite broadly from facts which he cannot help but know.

I have been told by those who know more about moral theology than I do, that there is a simpler, shorter description of these statements. People who care about such things call them "lies."

Not "errors." Lies.

Not "differences of opinion." Lies.

Not "the deeper, truer understanding which comes from being the actual victim of these vicious, unceasing acts of terror." Lies.

Examples:
"Saddam Hussein is Hitler!"
LIE

"George Walker Bush is Churchill"
LIE

"Civil rights activists are Neville Chamberlain!"
LIE

"Random, ineffective rocket attacks from a starving, blockaded city is the London Blitz!"
LIE
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JakobHunter
Bloke /English
02:30 PM on 11/20/2012
"I have picked up a theory about the invocation of the Second World War to justify military actions"

Godwin's law
Godwin observed that, given enough time, in any online discussion—regardless of topic or scope—someone inevitably makes a comparison to Hitler and the Nazis.
There are many corollaries to Godwin's law, some considered more canonical (by being adopted by Godwin himself than others. For example, there is a tradition in many newsgroups and other Internet discussion forums that once such a comparison is made, the thread is finished and *whoever mentioned the Nazis has automatically lost whatever debate was in progress*
united dreamer
The meek shall inherit the earth, trust me
06:19 PM on 11/20/2012
It seems strange to me, on reflection, that the plight of the Jews in the holocaust is repeatedly brought up by Israeli apologists. Strange, because no one seems to raise the plight of the gypsy community who suffered an even worse holocaust in relation to their European population.

And it seems anti-Jewish sentiment is the theme, but not the more broadly controvertible tyranny of extremists over a weak and powerless minority.