Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
David Burrowes MP

GET UPDATES FROM David Burrowes MP
 

Words Matter

Posted: 17/10/2012 12:27

Gary McKinnon is not being extradited. How wonderful to be able to write these words which until the Home Secretary told me yesterday I did not fully believe could be true. Words do matter. When the prime minister said before the election that Gary McKinnon "is a vulnerable young man and I see no compassion in sending him thousands of miles away from his home and loved ones to face trial". We now know it really mattered. Compassion in words and now actions.

The deputy prime minister has said/sung sorry for breaking his pre election promise on tuition fees but I don't think any version of an apology would have been accepted if Gary had been extradited. His words that: "There is no excuse not to do the right thing and the only right thing to do is to prevent this vulnerable man being sent over to America" would have been repeatedly played back alongside photos of him standing on the picket line outside the Home Office with Gary's mum. But not now.

The promises given were to my constituent and they mattered to me as his MP. My constituent's interests came first and I would have resigned my government position as Owen Paterson's PPS if the government had not been true to its word. Since the decision my inbox has been full of messages from families and friends of people with autism or Asperger's syndrome. They take great comfort from the recognition and understanding of the serious impact of the condition. I have also received messages from those with mental health conditions who lack a voice. Words matter.

I said in the Commons yesterday that the Home Secretary had saved my constituent's life. Some MPs, such as the former Home Secretary Alan Johnson reacted with incredulity. It was of course Alan Johnson who in 2009 refused to step in and stop Gary's extradition when medical evidence made clear that he would take his own life. Back then in the House I accused him and his government of being "spineless". His reaction yesterday which sought to bring party politics in to the plight of a vulnerable suicidal man shows the search still goes on for his spine. Theresa May certainly found her spine yesterday.

I have the advantage of having seen all the medical evidence - both Gary's doctors and the Home Office's doctors. I also have the experience of 20 years as a criminal defence solicitor. Gary's medical defence was clear and compelling. He would take his life if extradited and no assurance could be given to authorities about preventing his death. Few people have been subject to so much scrutiny of their mental health by leading experts in the field of forensic psychiatry, autism and Aspergers' syndrome. No one in the UK has been effectively on bail for 10 years or, as far as Gary was concerned, on death's row. Those on both sides of the Atlantic who are quick to sneer at the medical grounds for refusing Gary's extradition should either take a long look at his medical reports or respect the Home Secretary's decision.

It hasn't taken long for some of the media to look for some bad news in the McKinnon story. The most ridiculous of which is George Galloway's rant that if Gary was a Muslim he would have been extradited. George should know better as a long standing supporter of Gary that his mental illness and Asperger's is blind to colour, race or creed. He should get off his sectarian bandwagon and applaud a right and just decision.

Yesterday in the Commons I sought another promise - that never again would a vulnerable UK citizen face 10 years of mental torture like Gary McKinnon and that the British sense of justice and fair play would return to extradition. This could be the legacy of Gary McKinnon. A life saved, promises delivered and legacy secured. Words matter.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Gary McKinnon is not being extradited. How wonderful to be able to write these words which until the Home Secretary told me yesterday I did not fully believe could be true. Words do matter. When the p...
Gary McKinnon is not being extradited. How wonderful to be able to write these words which until the Home Secretary told me yesterday I did not fully believe could be true. Words do matter. When the p...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
19:50 on 22/10/2012
Burrows, the reason why you succeeded in blocking Gary McKinnon's extradition is because Britain's racist population would not allow it to happen. Although the blockage of McKinnon's extradition is a good thing, he was less deserving of it than Babar Ahmad and Talha Ahsan. The former admitted to the charges while the latter were imprisoned in this country for 8 years without a trial and evidence. The only grievous crimes for which there is true evidence are the ones committed by 'white' Britons:
1. The imprisonment without trial and charge for 8 years of Babar Ahmad and 5 years of Talha Ahsan
2. The racial application of a treacherous extradition treaty on the Muslims Babar Ahmad and Talha Ahsan
3. A flawed British criminal justice system that cannot punish 'white' racists who are guilty of GBH
16:31 on 23/10/2012
Apart from the fact that they extradited Ian Norris (who is white) and Christopher Tappin (also white). Also without evidence. And apart from the fact that the extradition allegations in Gary's case were not only 10 years old, but also shown in court to be contrary to such evidence as there was. Gary never admitted to the extradition allegations. In addition, Gary's allegations were not to do with Islamic terrorism (not that makes it right, but in the climate of fear, perhaps that might explain the comparative lack of public sympathy).

It's terrible about Babar and Talha, yes, but to say Gary was less deserving is not true. None of them deserved to be extradited.
10:14 on 18/10/2012
"It hasn't taken long for some of the media to look for some bad news in the McKinnon story. The most ridiculous of which is George Galloway's rant that if Gary was a Muslim he would have been extradited. George should know better as a long standing supporter of Gary that his mental illness and Asperger's is blind to colour, race or creed. He should get off his sectarian bandwagon and applaud a right and just decision."

Mr Burrowes, whilst i am extremely pleased that Gary has not been extradited, may I point out the case of Talha Ahsan, who was also clinically diagnosed with Asperger's syndrome. Where as Gary admitted to his crimes, Talha has yet to have any evidence brought against him. Don't be blind - to Theresa May and her fellow cabinet members, COLOUR, RACE AND CREED is all that they see!

Shame on you for thinking otherwise!
23:50 on 17/10/2012
"People with Aspburger syndrome may develop an intense, sometimes obsessive, interest in a hobby or collecting, sometimes these interests are lifelong; in other cases, one interest is replaced by an unconnected interest. For example, a person with Aspburger syndrome may focus on learning al there is to know about trains or computers. some are exceptionally knowledgeable in their chosen field of interest." Quote from The national Autistic Society.

The fact is Gary McKinnon committed the crime and should accept the consequences of his actions. The Court can take his condition into account at the trial! There are ways of preventing him from committing suicide!
03:15 on 18/10/2012
Apart from the fact that he didn't commit an extraditable offence, you mean. The allegations on which the extradition request relied were shown to not even have happened. Unfortunately the associated lack of evidence did not pose the problem it should have done, thanks to David Blunkett signing away our right to contestable evidence. No-one's argued for him not to face the consequences, just that those consequences be proportionate and just.
14:35 on 19/10/2012
Perhaps the consequences in the US are more proportionate and just than our PC approach!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Ghost of Awesome
21:13 on 17/10/2012
David Burrowes. Is there a way you can get in to contact with me? I am sure Autistics would love to be a part of society, and I see no better place to start than to engage with a sympathetic politician.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
16:19 on 17/10/2012
Words do matter. Context matters. For example the word ''pleb' in a recent, now notorious context. That word matters.
00:46 on 18/10/2012
Off-topic. And we don't even know that he said it. Like the police never falsify records #Hillsborough
23:44 on 20/10/2012
I agree "the word is mightier than the pen" but not the word pleb. This means simply to me not a patrician ( or a person who has inherited power and wealth). A phrase the Muppet claims he did not utter, neither did he swear at them. To me it seems strange that a police officer would use such an ancient term ( Roman). However he has not denied telling the police to 'know your place'. This to me is the sort of attitude that bring down Governments, and in one case cause heads to roll literary.Because the press have pushed the term pleb that word will always be associated with this patrician Government. No doubt know your place will be forgotten, until it is useful for someone to use.
15:44 on 17/10/2012
Would that all MPs were as decent and principled as David Burrowes. His integrity and dedication even in the darkest hours of this long and desperate fight moves me to tears. Could you imagine if Gary had had Alan Johnson as his MP? Or Sadiq Khan? He'd have had no chance. Let's hope we can now put a stop to extradition without evidence once and for all.
13:02 on 17/10/2012
"George should know better as a long standing supporter of Gary that his mental illness and Asperger's is blind to colour, race or creed. He should get off his sectarian bandwagon and applaud a right and just decision."

So why doesn't Burrowes prove he is not sectarian and support Talha Ahsan (who was extradited last week and from whom nothing has been heard from since) given that he too also suffers from Aspergers and was also assessed as a suicide risk?
00:47 on 18/10/2012
Do you know how much work David Burrowes has put in on this case? Has Talha's MP done the same for his constitutent?
01:10 on 18/10/2012
I dont think there is any point blaming Burrowes. He might be sectarian but he did do his best to save Gary from facing deportation. It is extremely tragic that Talha who too should have been afforded the same courtesy did not get the same level of support from his MP. Well atleast with this judgement there will be no more deportment of vulnerable British Citizens- muslim or non muslim.
10:33 on 18/10/2012
I don't dispute that David Burrowes did a tremendous amount of work for Gary and I applaud him for that. I believe that Gary should NOT have been extradited and am pleased for him and his mum. I also agree that the efforts of Talha's MP, Sadiq Khan (who happened to be a childhood friend of Talha's co-defendant Babar Ahmad) paled in comparison to the efforts of Burrowes.

The point I am making is that Burrowes accuses Galloway of being sectarian for claiming that double standards are at play yet he himself has not said one word in support of Talha Ahsan in this article or, as far as I am aware, anyway else. Surely everything he (rightly) says about Gary McKinnon's case also applies to Talha Ahsan who also has aspergers and who was also assessed as a suicide risk and who has not been heard from since being extradited. Surely he can see why Galloway made the point about double standards?
23:47 on 20/10/2012
Sorry to say i don't think Gary is totally our of the woods yet. I understand the Attorney General is looking at the possibility of bringing charges against him. This would be a disgrace as in Parliament the Home Secretary gave as one of the main reasons extradition would not take place medical advise.