Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
David Prescott

GET UPDATES FROM David Prescott
 

If Only We Had 2,232 Alices

Posted: 17/11/2012 10:50

I'm typing this on the train back to London after spending the last two weeks trying to get John elected.

He spent the last year trying to get selected as Labour's candidate and then elected as one of the first Police and Crime Commissioners.

I'll write a bit more about the campaign for Labourlist next week but I want to share this with you.

Turnout across England and Wales was shocking and though our region had amongst the highest at 19.5%, Hull was only 15.6%, with some polling stations on the day as low as 6%.

But Alice wasn't put off by the arguments against voting.

She called our phone asking for a lift to the polling station. Turns out she was 86, almost blind with a wooden leg called Oscar (Her granddaughter named it for her.)

Alice was proud that she'd voted Labour in Hull for more than 60 years and never missed an opportunity to back JP.

So I drove her to the polling station off Holderness Road in the Jag only to be told by the officials that as she was registered for a postal so couldn't vote.

Her face sank and her pleas were politely and guiltily repelled by the polling station staff. She was convinced her vote would get John elected and wanted to help him.

I kept reassuring her as we went back to the car that she shouldn't worry about it. That it really wouldn't have made the difference. But as we were about to drive away, there was a shout.

The polling official ran out clutching her advice pamphlet on electoral law. It turned out Alice could vote if she got an amended ballot from the Guildhall.

She almost jumped out of the car with the excitement. So 30 minutes later, I returned with her ballot paper and she made her mark - with a little help from the staff - for John.

As I dropped her off, he asked for a hug saying she couldn't have lived with herself if she hadn't voted for him.

And I started to well up.

Alice was one of 33,282 people who voted for JP yesterday, overturning a notional Tory seat with a 30,000 vote majority to a Labour lead of 3,842.

But in spite of winning three of the four local authorities - Hull, North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire - that make up the Humberside Police area and winning the popular vote via Fast Past the Post, JP lost on second preferences, thanks to the supplementary vote system.

Even on this, we were still leading with a 2,223 vote cushion after Hull, North Lincolnshire and North East Lincolnshire's second references were redistributed.

But the second preferences for the Tory candidate in the affluent East Riding area proved too much and we lost by just 2,231 votes.

Oh the irony of the Tories beating a Labour heavyweight with a form of PR that they actively campaigned against in the AV Referendum.

Anyway, as I drove John and Pauline back home from the count in Bridlington, there was a call.

It was Alice ringing to commiserate. She told us not to be downhearted and that we'd made her proud.

So we made a detour and turned up on her doorstep as a surprise. And we gave her a Commissioner's badge.

I'm enormously proud of what John and our team did.

He had the guts to go for it and even when he lost, showed great grace.

But it's people like Alice who made this campaign worthwhile.

If only we could have found another 2,232 like her.

john prescott

 

Follow David Prescott on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DavidPrescott

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
I'm typing this on the train back to London after spending the last two weeks trying to get John elected. He spent the last year trying to get selected as Labour's candidate and then elected as one o...
I'm typing this on the train back to London after spending the last two weeks trying to get John elected. He spent the last year trying to get selected as Labour's candidate and then elected as one o...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 22
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
16:51 on 18/11/2012
It was John Prescott who introduced the Supplementary Voting system in 1999 ahead of the London Mayoral Elections

http://hansard.millbanksystems.com/commons/1998/mar/31/government-of-london

I bet he's regretting that now....
23:48 on 17/11/2012
The Tories would be absent from the Scottish Parliament if anyone had taken any notice of their objections to PR. They're quieter about it these days in Scotland.
ThebestJoker
Laugh, the wrinkles will appear anyway!!
21:58 on 17/11/2012
Well Pauline, we've been shafted here, fancy a bit round the admiralty arch?
This comment has been removed.
18:58 on 17/11/2012
How does the song go? Alice Alice who the f--- is Alice.
18:15 on 17/11/2012
Supplementary vote is NOT a form of PR at all. PR = proportional representation. Supplementary vote is a restricted version of AV, which isn't PR either.

Also, remember, that it was Labour who introduced SV for the London Mayoral elections. You made your bed, so lie in it.
17:40 on 17/11/2012
Alice may just have been taken in by the illusion that just because you can vote it is worth doing.
I spoilt my ballot paper and would do the same if there was a vote for the head omlette chef in my region - the whole thing was meaningless and a smokscreen for what we should really be voting on i.e. membership of the EU!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ian Rennie
It irritates people that I'm a librarian :)
17:05 on 17/11/2012
I've still yet to have anyone explain to me what the advantage of an elected police commissioner is.

Surely for a service role like this it would be advantageous to appoint the most qualified person, rather than electing the most popular.

A police commissioner should surely be a civil service position rather than a political one.
23:50 on 17/11/2012
I quite agree. Why is it being done? They are just trying to politicise and control everything by putting party yes men into positions of power.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sue Harvey
12:52 on 18/11/2012
Politicising the police has great benefits for the ruling party. They can concentrate their efforts in certain areas while neglecting others. In-house crimes can be swept under the mat etc etc. Nothing in for the voter at all. How many $millions did it cost again, 40 something?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Prickly Herbert
Mine's a large gin
16:16 on 17/11/2012
NFI!
15:55 on 17/11/2012
So far all we have heard is excuses, justifications and other such whines from those who set this farce up and became involved.

The basic truth is, no one really wanted to know, The political luvvies set about getting their snouts in, and now the electorate have in effect told them to go suck, they are as usual full of bluff and bluster.

The old excuse of... if you didn't vote, don't complain.... does not wash, that may apply in the matter of a general election, even locals, where at least a majority with the vote, do vote, even if the turn out is apathetically low, but to try that on this disaster for UK democracy, is utterly wrong.

The people HAVE spoken, silently perhaps, but as many see it, loudly enough to be heard by those with ears to hear. Which of course does not apply to the political classes. It must be very comforting to reside in the palace of Westminster where the clamour of the voters is not discernible from the sound of the air conditioning.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Yorkshire common sense
Nah then!
15:18 on 17/11/2012
Nice story, but Prescott is a windbag. His ministeries from the last decade were full of promise and low on delivery. Transport? Housing? all messed up.
Shame as he appears quite a decent chap, just low on delivery.
photo
carneliancrystal
Do I believe all the propaganda of course I do
14:35 on 17/11/2012
He's a political heavyweight alright hes got guts too right. When he lost, he showed great grace, yes the pictures really bear that out dont they Couldn't have happened to a nicer man, not! could always go be a cabin boy. Give him a lift to Hull dock he likes jags. Total waste of space all of them.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Roy Fowler
I try....I really do!
14:22 on 17/11/2012
David; i offer this for free; so save the cost of "researching" what went wrong, its here....

MPs have been PROVEN to lie, cheat, undermine and show no concern for the wants, needs and expectations of the people of this nation.

ALL Parties have shown contempt to do what is the "right" thing for and on behalf of the people of this nation.

We DO NOT want to waste our time "electing" yet another layer of political appointees at £100,000 a year when there are already senior POLICE chiefs who know more about modern day policing, its pressures and its difficulties in 21st century Britain who are more than capable of taking these positions.

Each year the number of people bothering to vote is droping; because each year we, the people of this great nation; see clearly, that we, as an elctorate are simply a "bothersome" burden on the plastic, no passion, no balls and no conviction puppets that follow the party line, take their money and have never and will never live, work or understand the lives of the hardworking men and women of this great nation.

Feel free to pass this on to your political comrades in the "Westminster Bubble", i am sure you have a pass to get in!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
asrobs
80 years experience
14:05 on 17/11/2012
He is after all only a "barsteward" sorry if I got the spelling wrong.
18:59 on 17/11/2012
He's a crosss between a labrador and a toilet door
19:00 on 17/11/2012
I'm getting sensored again.
13:49 on 17/11/2012
great story dude!