Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Denis MacShane

GET UPDATES FROM Denis MacShane
 

The Nobel Peace Prize Committee Likes to Stir Up Trouble, but the EU has Done Well

Posted: 12/10/2012 13:21

It is such a shame that Twitter has no colour definition for its tweets. The news that the Nobel Peace Prize Committee has awarded the 2012 prize to the European Union is turning the Europhobe community puce with rage.

To read the torrent of abuse pouring on the heads of the worthy Norwegians who judge the EU to be a force for peace in the world is quite hilarious but sadly monochrome on Twitter. Like the best of Colonel Blimps they splutter with purple rage and fury at the thought of their hated, loathed EU being lauded this way.

They point out that the Nobel peace prize was given to Henry Kissinger - actually it was a joint award to him and the North Vietnamese foreign minister who had negotiated an end to the Vietnam war. One Europhobe exploded that the nuclear bomb should have got a peace prize more than the EU.

Yet the plain fact is that after a first half of a 20th century plunged into permanent internal warfare, following on sanguinary centuries in the previous few hundred years, Europe has
found some magic recipe to bring about peace between its warring nations. To be sure, Nato has been an important element in this but the European Community, followed by the European Union, has been the locus where nations have had to subsume some (not all but many) of
their national passions and rivalries into a commonweal.

The Europe I was a student in had half the continent under communist tyranny and three nations - Spain, Portugal and Greece - languishing under rightwing dictatorship. There was no war but there was no full peace as core freedoms were denied until those countries could join the community of European nations and live by the obligations of democracy, rule of law and open borders that EU membership entails.

Counties like Ireland and Britain found they could live as co-equals thanks to common membership of the European Union and put behind the centuries of hate and violence that disfigured their relationship.

Now the western Balkan states like Serbia, Kosovo, Macedonia and Albania all set store by EU membership in order finally to turn their conflict-ridden corner of Europe into a region of peace.

What upsets our own League of Anti-EU Loyalists is that the Nobel Peace prize has been awarded by the Norwegians, of all people. Norway is held up by the Better Off Out groupies as the model non-EU but European nation Britain could become. They appear not to know that Norway implements more EU directives more fully than the UK does and like Switzerland is a member of the Schengen area and thus welcomes many more visitors and tourists under the Schengen visa scheme than Britain with its anti-immigrant pathology and fears.

The Nobel Peace Prize committee likes to stir up trouble. Last year it awarded the Peace prize to Liu Xaibo, the pro-democracy Chinese activist. Like today's Eurosceps, the Chinese media and dominant political went mad with rage denouncing the Nobel prize committee for a terrible decision.

No doubt the Daily Mail and Telegraph would like to consign the EU to the gulag which is where the Chinese peace laureate Liu Xiabo now languishes. The response of David Cameron and William Hague to the award of the Nobel peace prize to Liu was to refuse to mention his name in public or publicly call for his release in deference to their friends in Beijing.

Perhaps they can adopt a same policy and just pretend the EU is not a force of peace and the Nobel award can simply be placed in a political oubliette and not mentioned in public.

Meanwhile the panjandrums of the EU can now fight amongst themselves to decide which one of the grands fromages - the President of the Council, the Commission or the Parliament - can go to Oslo to receive the prize.

A better recipient would be an 18-year-old unemployed Greek or Spaniard or Brit to remind Europe's ruling classes that while they have achieved peace they are still unable to rise to
the challenge of providing jobs, incomes and social justice.

 

Follow Denis MacShane on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DenisMacShane

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
It is such a shame that Twitter has no colour definition for its tweets. The news that the Nobel Peace Prize Committee has awarded the 2012 prize to the European Union is turning the Europhobe communi...
It is such a shame that Twitter has no colour definition for its tweets. The news that the Nobel Peace Prize Committee has awarded the 2012 prize to the European Union is turning the Europhobe communi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
asrobs
80 years experience
12:29 PM on 10/29/2012
The prize committee are at a loss to find any worthy representatives so if they offer it the EU there are too many living in Brussels off the spoils to pinpoint anyone really deserving. They might as well give it to G. BROWN for selling off all our gold at a give away price.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:10 PM on 10/14/2012
I've always found Denis MacShane's self-important tone, is in inverse proportion to the quality of the content of whatever lecture he's giving, usually, but not exclusively on the EU.
10:18 AM on 10/13/2012
If it meant anything it would be frightening BUT it means nothing it will not put a single euro (other than the prize money of which I would like my share please ) in the pot,,it will not create one single job, it will not have a single effect on world peace!! all it has done is given us a Laugh at the madness of the world today !!
12:08 AM on 10/13/2012
The Nobel people by choosing the EU is openly sticking their middle finger up towards the unemployed Spaniards and Greeks, it's two thumbs up for austerity and vicious class war and a deliberate destruction of any social justice. That's why this decision is getting the negative reactions it deserves.
01:25 PM on 10/14/2012
No, it has nothing to do with your navel gazing concerns about the EU's unemployed. Norway and the Nobel have nothing to do with your economic problems, it doesn't matter to non-EU Norway.

The Nobel is given to point out what is forgotten about the EU. The last time a major economic crisis hit Europe the unemployed became soldiers! Without the EU there might be more wars!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
asrobs
80 years experience
12:34 PM on 10/29/2012
You live in cloud cuckoo land --Germany is taking over Europe at the third attempt, it may not be a war but unless the EU collapses like the League of Nations they will have succeeded.
01:55 PM on 10/12/2012
Oh dear, yet another Labour, in fact ANY MP totally out of touch with the real world. Was it not the Labour party that took Britain into an illegal war in Iraq and promptly killed, along with other "Peace keeping countries" over a million people in Iraq and Afghanistan? This award is a total mockery of the prize. Having said that Obama, a previous winner promptly received the award then had a drone kill list initiated. Drop the whole thing from becoming a laughing stock completely.
01:47 PM on 10/12/2012
this MP is ignorant. the prize goes to a person or a society according to Alfred Noble's will. the EU is not a society. Perhaps the labour Party is saying that the EU is a society and this would be a major policy shift. the EU did not create peace any more than Gordon Brown saved the world. It is a new institution relatively. The peace after the war was maintained by the permanent members of the security council and by the cold war stand off between Nato and the Soviet Union. The Soviet Union crumbled internally and that was before the conception of the EU. We have an economic crisis and this is threatening peace - there are riots going on and racist parties are gaining ground. Mcshane needs to travel more and then he will see. The Euro is a big problem and it is the ideology of people driving the EU that says it must succeed. This is causing riots in Spain and in Greece and it will spread. The EU is not a society and does not qualify for the award
01:26 PM on 10/14/2012
The EU qualifies under Norwegian law as a "society" as defined by the will of Alfred Nobel. You can argue all you like, but only Norwegian law matters.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:34 PM on 10/12/2012
Stir up trouble? Who cares? Your idea of ''trouble'' is up in the rarefied clouds of the chatterati.

I don't remember Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan getting the Peace Prize for GIVING UP nuclear weapons.