Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Diane Abbott

GET UPDATES FROM Diane Abbott
 

The UK Riots: We Must Confront the 'Get Rich or Die Trying' Culture

Posted: 15/09/11 01:00 BST

Hackney is rebuilding. The heart-stopping wall-to-wall coverage may have ceased. And the foreign journalists that beat a path to the borough have gone home. But life in Hackney has continued. The response from the people of Hackney has been an inspiration - streets have been cleared, damage is being repaired, and our communities have pulled together. People are beginning to feel safe again.

It was heartbreaking to be out on the streets of Hackney as areas like the Pembury estate in Hackney became engulfed in flames, with years of incremental progress burning grotesquely for an international audience. But Hackney and its people are resilient, and the progress Hackney has made is resolute.

Cuts do not make criminals. Poverty does not make criminals either. Clearly, the causes are long-term, complex and difficult to confront. So we must ask, without fear or hesitation, why and how this happened. Because we must be sure, with people's livelihoods at stake in a fragile economy, unnecessary tensions whipped up and with the Olympics on the horizon, that this does not happen again.

This week, Theresa May, the Home Secretary stated glibly that it is 'not helpful for politicians to speculate' about what went wrong, and that 'I'm absolutely clear that what underlay it was criminality.' David Cameron's analysis also puts the riots down to "criminality" pure and simple. And stops there. It says that to explain is to excuse.

But people in Hackney have invested more thought into the riots. Now is not the time for kneejerk responses, simplistic answers and the blanket condemnation of parts of British society, because it paints a distorted picture.

We must accept and acknowledge, to begin with, that Britain is failing to provide many of our most precious urban communities with meaningful occupations and hope for the future. For many people who were rioting, that week was a rejection of the future that was laid out for them. Economic inequality, consumerism and savage government cuts have given many poorer, urban communities a profound sense of hopelessness for the future.

The availability of media and information exchange has seen immeasurable advances for the lifestyles and opportunities for some of the poorest people in the country. Yet it is mass consumerism and aspects of our media that has eroded and replaced many of the social structures that the communities grew out of - relentless advertising, MTV and instant messaging has often seemingly replaced family networks, educational commitments and community gatherings.

Yet many of these issues are not confined to our urban communities. Far from it. It was an adrenaline-based 'get rich or die trying' culture that was the fuel for both the banking crisis, and for some of the riots on our streets.

Those bankers who dragged the economy into recession made the same misjudgements and miscalculations as those people who took to the streets to drag the country into despair. In many cases, both groups believed that they had found a short cut to wealth in the face of a rapidly changing economy. Tragically, both made the awful miscalculation that there would be no consequences.

 

Follow Diane Abbott on Twitter: www.twitter.com/hackneyabbott

 
 
  • Comments
  • 13
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:02 PM on 09/18/2011
Yet again Diane gets a couple of things right but also a couple of things wrong.

"For many people who were rioting, that week was a rejection of the future that was laid out for them."

I'm sorry but that is utter nonsense. It was nothing to do with that and everything to do with thinking that they could get away with stealing stuff from businesses during the riots. There were no socio-economic issues running through their heads as they smashed the windows of those shops and looted the entire contents. They were only concerned about how much they could carry and how quickly they could get it away from the scene.

All this talk about the looting being some socio-economic symptom seems to be completely unfounded and simply a way to excuse her own constituents of their criminal behaviour.
12:13 AM on 09/16/2011
You are right of course, both the bankers and looters suffer form the "I want to be rich" disease, but it's not strictly materialism, it's about status - With the decline of the hereditary class system, wealth has become synonymous with respectability in all be the most elite of circles....and there's the rub.

How does society, in the sociological sense of the word, determine who is at the top and who's on the bottom? Plato considered the question 2,500 years ago and came up with "philosopher kings", the merchant/military/peasant classes have been rebelling against the notion ever since.

Like most countries, Britain is ruled over by merchants, who are all about money. In a way it's the most egalitarian solution, as any idiot can make money, while cleaver idiots( Rupert Murdock for example). can make fortunes.

I'm not sure if their is an ideal solution to the problem, but I know what the worst option is - those based on region/morality - the very thing conservative pundits continue to push.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:18 PM on 09/15/2011
Diane like all labour politicians still subscribe to this view that actually somebody else was in power between 1997-2110. During those 13 years labour (to which Diane belongs to) had the chance to do something about the inequality she talks about. However as we know know handing over money left right and centre without educating the recipients is simply a recipe for disaster. Yet instead of saying it how it is and learning from their mistakes. Diane like the rest of the labour party feels that continuing in the way we have since 1997 is the onle way to go.
All I see is somebody who panders to others by promising them something the UK cannotbofford.
FrancisKing
Unitarian Christian
07:34 PM on 09/15/2011
Diane Abbot - "savage government cuts"

What savage government cuts? The UK is spending beyond its means. The government needs to spend a little bit less. The coalition government has cut spending by a little bit, but I don't see anything that could be described as 'savage'.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
12:37 PM on 09/15/2011
Diane Abbott is right in what she says, but the devil is in the detail, we have tried for years to get the message that money and materialism are not the things that make for happimess, frends and sharing are what we need to instill in the younger generation.
lastpost
see biography
12:13 PM on 09/15/2011
"not helpful for politicians to speculate"
Especially if questioned to the extent that their speculations demonstrate a rather subjective and suspect perception of reality? If a politician cannot elucidate to the extent that all the loose ends of their argument neatly tie together. How likely is it that the measures they are introducing, to deal with those matters as identified by that interpretation, are actually going to work?

"David Cameron's analysis"
is not available for testing. Therefore, it is worth no more than anyone else’s best guess. You might imagine that someone in such a position would need to be a mite more circumspect, and a little less cavalier (past incumbents included). Wouldn’t you?

"Those bankers who dragged the economy into recession made the same misjudgments and miscalculations."
Probably by applying the same modus operandi. No one challenged, or was permitted to challenge, their evaluations. There was simply no need. Because to all intents and purposes they understood the situation completely. Comprehensively appreciating the outcome, yet to come.
01:29 PM on 09/15/2011
Interesting points. The way policy appears so quickly these days, without debate, is quite disturbing.
11:47 AM on 09/15/2011
Hmm! I have to say that I find it somewhat hypo-critical that you criticise bankers and looters for the, as you put it, 'get rich or die trying' culture when so many of your Parliamentary colleagues have been found to be subscribing to that very mentality by fiddling their expenses. Is this a case of 'Do as I say but not as I do'? It is not surprising therefore that in a survey published today that says only 26% of the population trust Parliamentary MPs - I am afraid to say Diane that it would appear that the vast majority of the population view MPs in the same motley group as the crooked bankers and looters you mention.
11:30 AM on 09/15/2011
'Britain is failing to provide many of our most precious urban communities with meaningful occupations and hope for the future...' how about the rioters are failing to provide themselves with meaningful occupations... I believe you could hand a job to most of them and they'd reject it in favour of drug dealing and welfare scamming. How about people being responsible for their own actions?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Blockem1
When will our politicians start putting policies
11:26 AM on 09/15/2011
You talk about what the problem is but neither you or any other politicians have come up with any credible solutions or commitment to fix the glaring obvious problems, Labour spent fortunes on education , but allowed schools to produce hundred of thousands of children that could not read and write, nor have any sense of discipline or respect for society before they went into secondary schools. Instead of building the homes and infrastructure projects we need ,they spent billions on wars we were conned into and still continue to , we spent £10 billion building aircraft carriers with no planes and god knows how many other projects we have wasted billions on, then to top every thing how much has it cost us to bail out the bankers ............... lets not mention the billions we lent Ireland and the black hole called Euro Zone ........... so when Cameron and co say there is no money it makes my stomach turn that these very politicians can happily fritter away the prosperity of this country for us and our children and simply avoid investing in what is needed to make Britain Great again,even when its so bloody obvious what is needed !
10:33 AM on 09/15/2011
Somewhat bemused that Diane can talk about Get Rich or Die Tryin' without referring to the drug dealing culture from which the phrase originates and which I believe to be one of the most important causes of the normalisation of the culture of criminality in these communities. http://www.libdemvoice.org/opinion-our-flawed-drug-laws-are-at-heart-of-riots-25012.html
01:34 PM on 09/15/2011
Legalise all drugs.
09:06 AM on 09/15/2011
Well said Diane, when the bankers brought economies the world over to their knees, the castigation was a muffled one, none of them have been jailed and they've got almost a decade before they can start to put their house in order. Instead the unfortunate sections of society have had to bear the brunt of their criminal acts in the form of pay cuts and unemployment. There is only so much cake that the people can eat. One day they will roll the guillotine out and the inferno will be worse than the recent riots.