Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dr David Ashton

GET UPDATES FROM Dr David Ashton
 

Can Editors and Journalists Give Obesity a Make-Over, Please?

Posted: 18/02/2013 18:04

Obesity's in the headlines again. The usual stuff - tax carbonated drinks, ban junk food and prevent food outlets from being positioned near schools. Every day I receive Google news alerts drawing my attention to articles from around the world containing the word obesity. Obesity is big news. The same story is picked up and re-reported by TV stations, newspapers, journals and social media sites. It makes for disheartening reading.

In a recent paper in Obesity Review some researchers at the Department of Media and Communication in Leicester looked at how obesity is defined in various media outlets, including analysis of journalistic news values, political leaning and style of media (tabloid versus serious), emotion-eliciting language, readers' comments and the sort of photographs used to accompany obesity related articles. The primary observation following their research was the extent to which coverage focused upon the "problematization of obesity in news stories".

Obesity was most commonly found to be discussed in the news in terms of personal failure. The emphasis on individual responsibility and concomitant moral indignation of many stories could, the researchers, argue sway the public "to favour policy solutions which aim to change and punish individual behaviours". This emphasis on individual responsibility contrasts with an alternative view of obesity as being an environmental problem which arose with the industrialisation of food influencing its availability and affordability and an increasingly sedentary lifestyle which makes physical activity less of a necessity for activities of daily living.

The fact that obesity stories are frequently written in emotive language that can elicit disgust and engender spiteful comments (from presumably slim) readers, leads to obese people being ashamed to admit they are seeking help. This is especially true when they choose to have weight loss surgery. One of our patients keen to share her delight after losing 3 stones following a gastric band operation saw her story appear under the banner "Is this the laziest dieter in Britain?" Another of our patients appeared on a TV show and was given the customary ill informed and shallow treatment. I wrote at the time "It really does annoy me that these look-at-me-I'm-so-gorgeous-I-can't-understand-why-there-are-so-many-fat-people-in-the-world-presenters dismiss a safe and effective intervention for chronically obese individuals who have exhausted all other weight loss solutions". The presenter's prejudice was palpable.

There is tremendous opportunity for the media to play a helpful role in tackling obesity. Here are just a few suggestions:
(i) Let's have more positive "success" stories. Less stigmatization and moral disapprobation would encourage people to be open about their weight struggles.
(ii) More pan national coverage. You'd be forgiven for thinking that it's only in Britain that we have a problem.
(iii) Portray positive eating behaviours in TV soaps and programmes. Let's have young people on TV who think it's cool to walk, cycle, eat healthily most of the time, indulge occasionally and who generally have an uncomplicated relationship with food.
(iv) Get away from simplistic notions of "good food" and "bad food". A balanced diet can encompass every type of food, especially when an individual is physically active.
(v) Stop using pictures of super morbidly obese people for every obesity story. Journalistic and editorial choices have led most people to associate the term obese with the tiny number of people who are gigantic. It is not helpful. A quarter of our adult population is obese. The sooner we drop the blame culture the better.

1 Atanasova D, Koteyko N, Gunter B Obesity in the news: directions for future research. Obesity Review 2012: 13; 554-559

 

Follow Dr David Ashton on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Weight2Go

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
Obesity's in the headlines again. The usual stuff - tax carbonated drinks, ban junk food and prevent food outlets from being positioned near schools. Every day I receive Google news alerts drawing my ...
Obesity's in the headlines again. The usual stuff - tax carbonated drinks, ban junk food and prevent food outlets from being positioned near schools. Every day I receive Google news alerts drawing my ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 4
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:39 on 13/04/2013
You have to leave out gluten, glucose and fructose from your diet. Leave out hydrogenated fat, pasta, wheat, sugar, rice, potatoes. If you want to eat bread make it oat or spelt bread both are gluten free. No fast food. Read the food labels to see what has these things in and don't buy them then you are not faced with the temptation when you get home. I am diabetic and these things I have found out about am glad to say. I am hoping it will go some way to curing my diabetes. Feel the weight start to fall away. The food manufacturers should be taxed an NHS support tax if they continue to make unhealthy foods. for us.
21:27 on 06/03/2013
All I can say to Averagejosephine and Approveds is that you and all the other criics are incredibly lucky to not have a physical disability preventing you from exercising or a psychiatric illness and/or eating disorder. Or are they just lifestyle choices too? And I won't even mention the genetic factors, metabloic rate etc.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
17:19 on 21/02/2013
I consider myself healthy, I take care over what I eat and exercise daily. Can you explain to me why it's wrong for me to think that obese people are greedy or lazy? Yep it takes longer for me to cook good food. Yep, my training requires considerable willpower and self discipline. But it's worth it.

Eat too much, is that not the definition of greedy?

Can't be bothered to do exercise? That sounds like being lazy.

'Tackling' obesity needs to be done by the individual. Your are responsible for your lifestyle.
09:31 on 21/02/2013
no that is wrong. It is since we have been PC and not used the F word, that vast numbers of people have become overweight. In my day, the 1950s, people were called fat, and there were only a few of them around, because being overweight was shameful, now people are proud to be overweight, and no one says anything to them about it.