So Borgen is finally back on our TV screens filling the hole left by The Killing and Homeland. Second series are often tricky things to get right, especially when the first was such a success; but on the evidence so far Borgen seems to be off to a good start.
This begs the question, why don't we seem to be able to do decent political television drama in this country anymore? We still do TV that covers political and social concerns; but these issues are often smuggled in, disguised within police thrillers and period productions. However there's very little serious drama looking at the people who run our country, the decisions they make that affect us all, and the general state of the nation.
Over the last two decades or so the US has produced The West Wing, John Adams, K Street, Boss, Homeland and The Newsroom (what The Hour would like to be). Even though they're science fiction and fantasy I'd still argue that Battlestar Galactica and Game of Thrones are as good as anything on the above list.
When we've tried to do something similar the results have not exactly been awe inspiring. For instance; The Amazing Mrs Pritchard, Party Animals, The State Within, The Last Enemy, Blackout and Absolute Power. None of these have been another House of Cards, G.B.H, State of Play, Edge of Darkness, Boys from the Black Stuff, Our Friends in the North or Bill Brand. There has been the odd one off drama that's been decent; The Road to East Finchley, Margaret, and Ten Days to War spring to mind, but these have been few and far between, and all based on real events/people.
Fictional political drama has been a rarer beast. Recently Channel 4 produced the four part mini-series Secret State to a not exactly rapturous response. The fact that it was a remake of the excellent A Very British Coup from 1988 demonstrates the paucity of ambition of current TV executives. Coincidentally a remake of Yes, Prime Minister is soon going to hit our screens and it'll be interesting to see how it fares. Revisiting past glories is rarely a good idea, especially when the original was so brilliant. Watching them again it's striking how each episode is as relevant now as it was thirty years ago.
Today you have to look to the world of comedy to find any decent political TV. The Thick of It and 2012 were both better, and more truthful, than anything else we've seen in the last few years. The most recent series of The Thick of It is meant to be the last; which is probably a good thing as real life frequently conspired to be more bizarre and embarrassing than anything the writers could come up with. If you'd written an episode where the mayor of London became stuck on a zipline, or the Chancellor of the Exchequer was threatened with being thrown out of a first class train carriage, you'd be accused of being too farfetched. It's almost like genuine politicians watched it every week and then bet each other whether they could do something more outlandish. Equally watching a fictional character being booed by tens of thousands of people inside the Olympic stadium just wouldn't have the same cringe inducing entertainment factor as the real thing.
Perhaps it's because we're simply too jaded about politics, and politicians in general, to enjoy the pantomime antics of a Francis Urquhart or Michael Murray; or too cynical to believe in a competent British heroic leader like President Bartlet. Either way, Borgen should keep us entertained for a few more weeks showing us how it ought to be done.
Follow Dr Matthew Ashton on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drmatthewashton
Richard Berry: They're Remaking Borgen in America? Now I Do Need to Suspend My Disbelief
Justin Forsyth: Why Borgen Mirrors Real Life Pressure on Governments to Cut Overseas Aid
Peter Skelton: Is the Success of Danish Drama Down to More Than Nice Jumpers?
Paddy Duffy: Saturday Night Fever -Take Me Out And Borgen
Borgen confirms only 7 actors in Denmark Trending now | MSN ...
Borgen: season two, episodes one and two | Television & radio ...
The Borgen supremacy: Birgitte Hjort Sorensen interview
Borgen: season two, episodes one and two
TV review: Borgen, 89000 Children
Birgitte Hjort Sorensen: Borgen's back! Meet one of its stars
2013 TV preview: Borgen's back and Game of Thrones – but beware the graphic ...
Britain doesn't like its political system very much. All our best political TV is satire, we don't turn out to elections, we don't express surprise when politicians lie, cheat or steal... we seem to have given up on the whole process. Any time anyone a politicians looks to be a decent human being interested in actually doing good, the tabloids tear them down. It's happened so often that you can't really blame people for being jaded.
TV like The West Wing has a buoyant sense of optimism - it's passionate about its subject matter, and feels as though it truly believes in the system it portrays. Britain hasn't had that kind of enthusiasm for decades. It's why all our political telly is so bloody bitter.
Im thinking about why screen writers have such a hard time distilling what it is Brits believe as a nation. Brits were pluralists even before they decided to go nation raiding on an imperial scale.
For whatever reason, Brits dont get as excited about their own nation building myths like the French or the Americans. Perhaps despite all the hooha over Europe and mass immigration Brits ARE fundamentally secure in their heritage and dont need to examine it in order to bolster themselves?
Brits certainly do believe in community, flags and in nationhood as last summer's celebrations attest too, but then look over the Irish Sea to see what the 'Loyalists' are doing over flag protests and most Brits will consider the over reaction contemptible.
Borgen makes the ordinary interesting and complex by focussing on relationships. The UK loved the spiteful coalition relationships as portrayed in The Thick of it recently.
The West Wing was a liberal wet dream during the Bush years- America as wish fulfilment. Brits just arent sentimental like that.
I think it would take a talented writer on his best day to try and encapsulate that dichotomy.
However despite its good point I don't think its going to stand the test of time and we'll still be talking about it in twenty years time (of course I could easily be wrong).
A VERY BRITISH COUP 1980s ..............
turns out The british security services do bugg cabinet members communications...........
turns out The british security services did use agents disguised as miners during the miners strike...
turns out The british security services ......HAD NO INVOLVEMENT IN THE MURDER OF
DR DAVID KELLY.......................
THE TRUTH IS STRANGER THAN FICTION IN BRITISH POLITICS..........
I tend to stick to Le Carre thrillers these days. Probably one of the best English novelists since the war.
And is there some rule that says the country countries must intertwine children so much into theirpolice/politics drama ?
The love tangle with one of the PM's aides seems a bit cliched and the story about the drunk editor was fairly cliched as well I am afraid.
The more I think about it, i am afrid the more Cheap tv drama it seems to me.
But I can’t see the British easily sympathising with any British politician on screen without unwieldy explanations about how they didn’t go to Eaton and didn’t fiddle their expenses just to bring them up from immediate negative assumptions to a positive. It would be a clunky and contrived first few episodes at least.
It still doesn't explain why we haven't had a decent political drama in recent years though. I'd be quite happy to watch something where a MP schemes against his or her rivals and plots their way to the top. Machiavellian intrigue is something we seem to do pretty well in this country (I, Claudius is a great example of it).
Equally I don't think Britain is intellectually docile. For instance if you look at some of the things being produced in the theatre at the moment (This House at the National).
Apart from State Of Play, of course. A British political drama from the last ten years good enough that you use it as an example of what British political drama from the last ten years hasn't been as good as.
Considering our reputation for quality television (mostly), I think my point still stands e.g. in the last few years there hasn't been a classic British political/drama thriller. In fact our attempts at one have been pretty poor. I can't think of anything since State of Play that rivals Cathy come home or Boys from the Blackstuff in terms of being era defining.
It's a shame the Two Johns aren't on any more. Some of their stuff was incredibly sharp. Luckily The Thick of It was terrific but now that's come to an end. I'd be happy to be proven wrong but I don't hold out a great deal of hope for this Yes Prime Minister remake.
I agree some things are sacrosacnt and should be left alone