Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dr Sneh Khemka

GET UPDATES FROM Dr Sneh Khemka
 

Uniquely British? Why We Aren't Willing to Challenge Our Doctors

Posted: 13/12/2012 00:00

The old saying is 'Doctor knows best'. But times are changing and we're slowly moving into an era where the appointment room is a place for a two-way discussion and use of knowledge from both sides. No longer do doctors use a 'one size fits all' approach and informed patients are willing to ask more questions than ever before...well, that's the idea. But it seems it isn't quite yet the reality.

Think back to your last doctor's appointment. Did you ask any burning questions that you had during the consultation? Did you express any concerns that sprung to mind? Had you researched your symptoms beforehand and thought it may have been something different to what your doctor said, yet you felt obliged to remain quiet? If so, you're certainly not alone. According to new research from Bupa Health Pulse 2012, Britons are more likely than other nationalities to hold back from challenging their doctor or medical professional because they 'don't feel comfortable' questioning them.

Bupa's annual, international Health Pulse survey looks at people's attitudes towards their health and healthcare across 13 countries around the world. Because shared decision making is in the process of becoming part of mainstream clinical practice, this year, we explored how people are engaging with medical professionals and accessing health information and services, with the hope of identifying barriers to allowing patients to become more engaged in managing their own healthcare.

Of note, the international survey revealed that people in Egypt and Saudi Arabia feel most confident questioning their doctor, with 75% of people willing to do so. This compared to just 53% of Brits willing to challenge or question their doctor about health matters.

The reserve that this survey has exposed surrounding those in need of healthcare is a worrying one. Whether it's in Britain or elsewhere, a percentage of patients are genuinely limiting their choices and access to appropriate treatment and care because they simply don't feel comfortable to challenge their doctor about advice or treatment options.

The world has changed rapidly, and with ever increasing access to information, the average patient of today will have more knowledge than in previous generations. Being comfortable about asking for more details about a condition, a test or treatment is invaluable - not only does it involve you in decisions about your healthcare, but there is evidence to suggest that if you actively take part in managing your health and care, you will have better outcomes than people who don't. And better health outcomes result in both higher patient satisfaction and reduced use of health services.

The same survey also revealed that it's people who feel least positive about their health and those who admit to having a poor diet who engage the least with their doctor - an expected but troublesome trend. This is most likely due to a lack of confidence, lower levels of education, or a lower socio-economic bracket, and it's here where doctors have an obligation to play a part by prompting questions and encouraging discussion.

By necessity, doctors appointments are often short - the average in the UK is somewhere between seven and 10 minutes. All the more reason for patients to be prepared for their appointment, and to feel empowered and able to ask questions within that time. Patient-doctor time is precious, so being able to discuss alternative treatments, or to fully understand the risks and benefits of a procedure, will only be possible if there is an active conversation from both sides. This is still a challenge for many people, including doctors, and much work is still needed to embed shared decision making into health systems. The new mantra in healthcare should certainly be 'no decision about me, without me'.

This lack of confidence with doctors may also be fuelling a rise in the amount of people using the internet to research symptoms, address concerns and discover remedies. In 2010, Bupa Health Pulse survey found that 73% of people in Britain used the internet to search for advice about their health and medical conditions - this has now risen to 82% (2012), which isn't really surprising considering the resources, ease and anonymity of the internet.

Although there's a lot of trusted information out there, and doing some background research yourself can help you make better decisions about your healthcare, the internet should never replace your doctor. The healthcare cyber space can be inaccurate, misleading and even frightening if you don't use the right sources - in fact, our survey revealed only half of those using the internet for health purposes said that they always check the source of the information to ensure it's credible.

Remember, a doctor's advice, or personal communication with a health professional, is incredibly valuable. Don't be afraid to challenge your doctor or to ask questions, and always say if you don't understand something that you're told. To get the most out of your appointment, it pays to do some preparation beforehand and to think about the questions you want to ask. The health consumer (or patient if you like) should always have the right to choose treatments and healthcare that suits their lifestyle, preferences and beliefs. Being informed, confident and engaged in what medical treatment you're undergoing will, in both the short and long term, lead to better outcomes.

 

Follow Dr Sneh Khemka on Twitter: www.twitter.com/drsneh

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:47 AM on 12/20/2012
Doctors that I have challenged become indignant, they see themselves as Gods, and pontificate on treatments. Perhaps Dr Sneh Khemka could start with the doctors his company recommend for people in his care homes, and tell them that relatives should be informed of treatments 'before' the doctors start giving drugs to vulnerable people, as happened to my mother in a BUPPA home, and no doubt happens to thousands of other vulnerable people.
photo
Reith
what's a micro-bio?
09:26 AM on 12/14/2012
Another aspect of this problem is the wretched EMA and like bodies who are determined that we should be dependent on orthodox medicine rather than "alternative" remedies with which we can self-administer in some instances.

What the European Meddlers Agency - sorry, I meant Medicine - don't realise is that what we call alternative medicine is THE medicine for about 2/3 of the world.

I was utterly annoyed to find that a herbal remedy I've used for a long time whenever a cold or some local viral ailment threatens, has been banned in our herbal suppliers until the producers go through a horribly expensive process to have it licensed, damn the EMA. It works. As an anti-viral, anti-bacterial blend it's perfectly efficacious (for me at least) and avoids the need for antibiotics inter alia.

Anyone with even a small interest in phytotherapy/herbal medicine will have an understanding of how these medicines act, when they can act (as obviously they are little use in crisis medicine for which the orthodoxy is supreme) and rules over their use (because they ARE medicines).

It's pretty obvious that the EMA has been sat on by the drug giants who, in these post-golden-age days are desperate to claw back profits and do not want people administering their own medicines.

The golden age for me means the 1900-1980s when drugs for all the easy medical solutions were created by the pharmaceutical outfits.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nailer6327
this life is nothing but a freemasons get together
11:57 PM on 12/13/2012
looking forward to the fish market in the morning!!
08:28 PM on 12/13/2012
I visted my new gp clinic as requested as a new patient. I was met by a sullen woman, who straight away says "if I had to discuss more than one ailment you should have booked a longer appointment".
I said beg your pardon that is the reason I came in. I requested a treatment but was not given it as she said you will have to go somewhere else for that.
Later with another doctor at the same practise I requested a different thyroid med which they use in USA and is approved by nice here... no we do not give that out. I stay firmly away now if I am ill or not. Also, now the asthma nurse is no longer a qualified nurse but a 'care assistant' on minimum wage. My God talk about crap service what service?
06:26 PM on 12/13/2012
hahaha funny this post was written by the director at BUPA International. Who says that the masses can't be manipulated? Seriously though stop moaning and go private if you are really that concerned. You lots should be so luckly you have free healthcare. Go to other parts of the world and have a look. If everyone now knows so much about medicine compared to your doctor why not treat yourself? While you are at it, there are plenty of knives in the kitchen which you medical experts can use. I mean if the moaning masses stopped suing the NHS and actually constructively worked with their doctors, maybe we won't be in the mess that we are in at present. I am sure the highly intelligent (sarcasm) amongst us would blame the ethnic minorities (the clue is in the name- they cant take that much resources compared to rest of themajority can they???) when in reality without them there would be no healthcare nor anyone to work in any low paid employment in this country = standstill and deprivation. Get your facts right before moaning and coming to illiterate judgements and this is coming from a staunch conservative.
06:18 PM on 12/13/2012
Over the years it seems to me that far too many doctors think that they sit on the right hand of God and have an inability to gauge the intelligence of the patient sitting before them when speaking to them. Some patients need to have things explained to them in words they can understand, but more and more people are becoming more educated about things medical and really don't need to be spoken to like a child. In saying that a little knowledge can be very dangerous. I also feel that their training seems to be directed, when making a diagnosis, to what the problems isn't rather that what it is. In my own family there has been two deaths which should never have happened. one child who is virtually blind in one eye as a result of incompetence, and a wife who suffered from severe COPD and was on twenty four hour oxygen who was told the GP that she 'really shouldn't be on oxygen to such an extent because she would get hooked on it'. Not my words, his. That was after the regime was established by the chest clinic in the local hospital. My father used to say that doctors bury their mistakes, and I'm sure most people can relate stories along those lines. Ask questions, that's my advice to anyone, and don't be afraid to quote what you research. Every profession has it's weak links and the medical fraternity is no different.
06:12 PM on 12/13/2012
Challenge my GP? - and have my medical file updated accordingly - you must be having a laugh.

The treatment I get now is sparse enough I don't want it to get any more scarce, thanks.

Positive-spin articles like this are mighty interesting but have absolutely no validity for many people living in britain today who cannot afford private medical care.
05:25 PM on 12/13/2012
Yes, other nationalities are prepared to challenge and use the Human Rights act which is why the rest of us often get short changed. My surgery has had a massive influx of foreign patients and boy do they make sure they get what they want by any means. Doctors at my surgery have made mistakes, but never apologise. I do challenge, but it takes several visits before I do. Hardly ever look on line because there is so much conflicting information on there. When I was young it was "growing pains", when middle aged, "it was advancing age" and now it's "old age". I do try to fight my corner though and living in Cambridgeshire one has to because it has systems no other health authority has and I think it's designed to delay and the wazzocks don't seem to realise the longer something goes undiagnosed and untreated the more expensive the treatment.
This comment has been removed.
photo
25sammy25
We just wanna be togever !!!!
04:34 PM on 12/13/2012
I am not the type to ask questions but often doubt the diagnosis given by my GP or hospital. I have now started researching any symptoms I have, and can more or less tell the doctor what is wrong with me. He doesn't like it and that has maybe changed my relationship with my doctor. I still use the same GP but there is a bit of tension between us. On my next visit to him, I'm going to put it on the line that his attitude has changed and makes me feel uncomfortable. Mind you, we're only allowed 10 minutes per consultation, which is not quite enough to express my feeling and then deal with whatever my medical problem is. The only reason I stick with this doctor is because he knows my medical history.
This comment has been removed.
photo
Reith
what's a micro-bio?
05:52 PM on 12/13/2012
It's always good to get apprised of what the signals your body gives you mean. It may seem complicated at first and one has to allow doctors their extensive training and experience - and the existence of common ailments. But after all, doctors depend on you reporting symptoms and that's often very difficult. If you tell someone you have a headache there is no way they can KNOW what your particular headache is like. It's certainly wise to be as acquainted as you can with your health and treat all drugs and most "unnatural" foodstuffs with caution!
photo
25sammy25
We just wanna be togever !!!!
08:44 PM on 12/13/2012
Reith - That is very good advice and I must admit I have great difficulty in discussing exactly what my problem is.  I do accept his diagnosis although I don't always agree with him but take the drugs he prescribes.Every now and then I ask him if I can come off any of them and he says if they are doing no harm they must be doing their job, so keep taking them.
photo
Reith
what's a micro-bio?
03:32 PM on 12/13/2012
I'd suggest it comes down to education. The trouble is that the medical profession has commandered just about every aspect of our health, notionally taking responsibility for it. So we've got used to depending on doctors' opinions.

Unfortunately this has given many doctors the view that they should be deified - our lives are in their hands - and sometimes they are. These doctors talk down. They don't listen - they have their bag of remedies and will bend a patient's problems to suit someting in this bag. So patients are intimidated.

At worst if you challenge some doctors they will withhold what the patient KNOWS is a better treatment.

Our local practice has both. A cross between a griffin and a drill sargeant in disguise as a woman (who insisted on treating my insomnia with a vast dose of Amitriptyline that acted as a chemical cosh); and one or two others who are empathetic and actually DISCUSS with their patients. (Unsurprisingly they're the ones that everyone wants to consult!)

Doctors have to be encouraged to be more human, more mortal, more empathetic. And, yes, they have 10 minutes slots but stop regarding the throughput of patients as a nuisance conveyor belt that has to be got through.

I've met an NHS consultant who, you'd think, regards God as his deputy.
05:37 PM on 12/13/2012
I've posted my comments below, but you've stated it perfectly and I couldn't agree more!
photo
Reith
what's a micro-bio?
05:53 PM on 12/13/2012
Duly noted! Cheers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ToniChicago
03:01 PM on 12/13/2012
Having lived outside of the UK for over 20 years now, I am often quite shocked at what my family members will take as Gospel from their doctors without even asking follow up questions. On the other hand, such is the fear of lawsuits here in the USA, most doctors will hand you two or three treatment options and expect you to come to a decision. Only last year, when I found myself in a life or death emergency situation with a relative, the doctor on duty gave me two alternatives and told me "It's your call." When I pointed out that he was the expert, and that I had come to the emergency room precisely because I'm not a doctor, he told me to "calm down".
They will also do far too many tests to cover themselves, because they know insurance coverage (ie. the patient) will pick up the cost. This is particularly prevalent with older people covered by Medicare, because the government is picking up the tab.
05:28 PM on 12/13/2012
I lived there too and the sickener is that then you get a bill at the end of it ! I had a British internist, but consultants were always up for a "procedure".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ToniChicago
09:50 PM on 12/13/2012
Yes it's like toy money to some of them. Mine is pretty good about taking a sensible approach. 
02:32 PM on 12/13/2012
It is now over 10 years since I went to a GP, but on the occasions when I did question or query treatment, largely because of my adverse reaction to many drugs which is clearly stated on my records, I was hautily told that such and such was impossible and it was dismissed out of hand. After a number of adverse reactions when I tried to go along with them I gave up altogether. That has happened with 2 different doctors, and being very rural I don't have much choice of a practice. So I won't go. On the whole I think I have been better without them, and managing my condition my own way. As far as I'm concerned they seem arrogant and certainly know best. Having said that, my old GP many years ago (who put the details on my records) was excellent and I could talk things over easily. It all went downhill when we moved away from that practice.
09:15 PM on 12/13/2012
Yes, lots of them are arrogant, ir makes me wonder why they wanted to go into medicine in the first place, at least a pre-requisite is that you like people! and many seem not to.

As for your adverse reaction, doctors are SUPPOSED to register this on a " yellow card" as far as l remember, it then gets reported to an organisation, sorry l can`t remember the name of it, maybe you can get more info online.
12:49 PM on 12/13/2012
Thank goodness l don`t feel like that about doctors, though l realise quite a few do. lt is a british thing, as stated, but why l do not know, it simply doesn`t exist on the continent, where people are much more relaxed with their doctors. l always relate to the person first, the job or profession comes a long way behind that.
l am well aware they do make mistakes and there have been many, many articles on that, on HP and other blogs, so l make sure l get the best from both my gp or hospital doctors when needed, by being both friendly, polite but communicative and open too, and assertive when necessary, though never aggressive, that is a definite no, no.
Unfortunately, many people feel somehow " beneath" their doctor,it seems to be a " class" thing, l read once on the bbc eye that doctors relate better to middle class patients because that is the background that they themselves come from, but that is a terrible reflection of both our society and the medical profession in particular, and very sad too that medical students are nowadays being offered classes in COMMUNICATION , something they should have been learning from their families, very bad. and unfortunately we have our fair share of arrogant doctors, mostly male l have found. l had one like that once, but because my practice is a group practice l just made sure l never went with him again so that worked well.
This comment has been removed.