Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Emma Jones

GET UPDATES FROM Emma Jones
 

Girl With the Dragon Tattoo: This Trilogy Belongs in Scandinavia, Not Hollywood

Posted: 27/12/11 00:00

No one who loves the saga of Beowulf is surprised as to how an area like Scandinavia; famous for its furniture, relaxed attitude towards adultery and, of course, jumpers; could have produced something as dark and brooding as The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo.

Monsters lurked in the dark 1200 years ago; and director David Fincher, in the Hollywood film version of the novel, shows they are still there in the half-light of a Swedish winter, as journalist Mikael Blomkvist sets out to find a killer of women.

There was a lot of grumbling about this remake, especially when the Swedish trilogy is so good, but by insisting on filming this in Sweden too, Fincher has delivered a movie absorbed in its surroundings. Behind the characters' icy good manners and minimalist décor, lurks unflinching and visceral violence.

Both Blomkvist and his sidekick, Lisbeth Salander, venture into the mere to find their monster -and all good crime fans will know it's inevitable someone will get trapped in his lair.

Once it's in your head that Blomkvist isn't Bond, Daniel Craig is a good fit. Bundled up in lambswool against the cold, he bleats helplessly against Salander's aggressive sexuality. Rooney Mara, who owns the part of Salander, brings vulnerability to what would otherwise be a Scandi Lady Gaga - a tiny frame swathed in leather, copping off with boys and girls on whim, telling everyone to like it or lump it - she was born this way, baby.

It shouldn't be a surprise that she is so tough. After all, didn't Beowulf kick the monster Grendel's butt, but come a serious cropper against his mother? As anyone who's read The Girl With A Dragon Tattoo will know, the most dangerous creature alive is a wounded woman wanting revenge.

I hope Lisbeth Salander remains an unique heroine in film. If Hollywood try and make more of her, they'll grow her hair, enlarge her breasts, and increase her secret desire to be saved - et voila you'll have Anne Hathaway in Catwoman.

This girl belongs in Scandinavia, and so does the trilogy. Scary stories were first told in the dark and the cold. Nameless horrors crouched beyond the light of the campfires, with only a bold hero (or heroine) to save them. Crime fiction started here.

 

Follow Emma Jones on Twitter: www.twitter.com/emmapjones

No one who loves the saga of Beowulf is surprised as to how an area like Scandinavia; famous for its furniture, relaxed attitude towards adultery and, of course, jumpers; could have produced something...
No one who loves the saga of Beowulf is surprised as to how an area like Scandinavia; famous for its furniture, relaxed attitude towards adultery and, of course, jumpers; could have produced something...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 155
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bishop999999999
04:54 on 02/01/2012
So what board of executives decided that this decidedly boring and cliched trilogy needed to be a "phenomenon?" I have never been so let down by a series before. The characters are one cliche after another, the plot is only mildly interesting (half the time, anyway; otherwise it's just completely uninteresting). The writing is droll and mechanical. The whole thing is just a massive wish fulfillment fantasy on part of the author. And yet people are lapping it up? Is it because it's foreign? The Swedish can write terrible books too, you know.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Itsbeenalongday
Eliminating poverty is smart business
03:11 on 02/01/2012
P.s. I have seen the second in the series as well. I am looking in anticipation for the third in the trilogy.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Itsbeenalongday
Eliminating poverty is smart business
03:09 on 02/01/2012
The Swedish original is so good, I can only dread a Hollywood remake.
21:58 on 01/01/2012
I never saw an Hamlet film where I felt a real Scandinavian atmosphere.
21:49 on 01/01/2012
Emma Jones would do well to READ the novels before speaking. She may the see that the author prefaces each in detail to leave the reader in no doubt what the main expose of the story is........spousal abuse, mainly physical and sexual, in Scandinavia, where wife-beating is commonplace for many, many people. This major aspect of the stories is lost in the film versions although plain to see if you know what you are witnessing. We are not dealing with 'monsters....from the past' but 'monsters' at work right now!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Luanne Taylor
be an OTHER
14:06 on 01/01/2012
I have wondered why America felt the need to remake these movies, all because of sub titles?
the foreign films (foreign to me) are so good!
13:30 on 01/01/2012
I am not an expert in the litterary world of book or film reviews. I find the simple fact that someone wishes to waffle on about aspects of some 'dark monster' (?) is a waste of print. I am your ordinary film-goer and I can report that this film was brilliant! I went to see it in Llandudno in North Wales and can confirm that throughout the whole film EVERYONE was so engrossed, not a sound of sweets or drinks could be heard. It was gripping and edge of the seat stuff. Forget what the 'book' said, forget previous celuloid editions. Take this film on its own merrits... EXCELLENT! Five Stars!
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
wendilee1956
Erstwhile published writer
02:50 on 31/12/2011
One caveat about this review: The reviewer calls Lisbeth Salander the "sidekick." Either she never read the series or just made a thoughtless gaffe. Lisbeth is very much her own character. She IS the girl with the dragon tattoo and is not just a sidekick. She is Blomkvist's assistant investigator, but she is basically the center of the trilogy and Blomkvist might be considered (but I certainly wouldn't) the sidekick. Otherwise, a very fair review of a movie based on an amazing book!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:40 on 01/01/2012
Very good summary and you are quite right about Lisbeth.

It's refreshing to see such a well written article on here. because so many of the articles are a sub-standard.
16:33 on 29/12/2011
When it comes to "dark and brooding," this film is nothing to some of Ingmar Bergman's masterpieces. Try "Winter Light" or "Persona" on a rainy afternoon. LOL The Swedes give great melancholy.
17:04 on 28/12/2011
Maybe they can improve on the book. The female character is the most ludicrously implausible creature in popular fiction. I simply don't know why these books are popular.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
wendilee1956
Erstwhile published writer
02:52 on 31/12/2011
Hmmm. Interesting that you would think that. The problem I come across is the opposite. I actually know several people who, if combined into one person, might be Lisbeth. You must live a very dull life.
21:55 on 01/01/2012
MT Vessels: If you want to read a book which is truly ludicrous have a look at ''The Sigma Passion'' by Vlad K. Once, which is not his real name of course. This is the collected ramblings of a complete madman with an ego the size of a planet.
13:59 on 28/12/2011
Is the point of this article that the movie of a book set in Sweden should also be set in Sweden? Compelling topic and great argument.
23:30 on 27/12/2011
Don't blame Hollywood for corrupting this character, Larsson does that himself in the 2nd book when she disappears and comes back with her new surgically enhanced breasts. Of course her new breasts are not distinguishable from the real thing. Sure.
19:42 on 27/12/2011
Sorry, I meant ans Anglo-Irish actor.

Too much Christmas cheer.
19:40 on 27/12/2011
Why so much nastiness about how stupid North Americans are for remaking a Swedish film ? The UK remade the Wallander series, a perfectly good Scandinavian TV series about a middle-aged detective. Did the UK feel that Wallander needed to be more hammily portrayed by an Anglo-British actor?

Pot, meet kettle.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:44 on 01/01/2012
I really agree with you.
Why not re-make things.
Many people wouldn't watch a Swedish language film.
People sneer at Hollywood, but the remake of "Let the right one in" was very good, so why is it a problem.
You might as well argue that the books shouldn't have been translated in to English and we all have to learn Swedish to read them.
19:09 on 27/12/2011
The English-language remake was inevitable. North American audiences, for the most part, are incapable of dealing with subtitles.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
politicky
just follow the $$$
00:48 on 31/12/2011
Pffffft. I don't know where you get your information, but I have no intention of shelling out 13 bucks to see the American version and I live 2 hours from Los Angeles.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
wendilee1956
Erstwhile published writer
03:04 on 31/12/2011
Yeah, I have always seen that as an example of why we need to invest in education. I mean, does it really take a lot of time to read a subtitle? I used to work part time at a movie rental place and it never failed to amaze me how many of the renters would pass up an amazing movie because they couldn't read the subtitles fast enough. REALLY?? Eye roll here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ontheman
11:13 on 02/01/2012
I love foreign movies, but my problem is that I have to watch them several times---I might not have time to do so. I watch them several times because I am missing the action of the visuals no matter how fast I can read. The script occupies a mere percentage of the bottom of the screen, and if anything quick happens, I miss it. So no need for eye rolls; some people just aren't as great as you are.