Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Emma Reynolds

GET UPDATES FROM Emma Reynolds
 

Why the Shooting of Russian Banker German Gorbuntsov in London Raises Worries About Our National Security

Posted: 4/04/2012 00:00

The attempted murder of a Russian banker in London last week was a shocking reminder of how easily the problems of other countries can bring violence to our streets.

We live in an increasingly open world, and while the benefits to trade and culture are obvious and welcome, there is a dark side to globalisation that cannot be ignored. As a consequence the government would be mistaken to think that we can reduce our foreign policy to bilateral mercantilism.

Our interests include not only commerce and security, but also the quality of governance and law enforcement in the countries with which we have close ties.

In the space of two decades, the UK has become one of the most important centres of Russian life outside Russia itself. Estimates of the numbers of Russians living here have been put in the hundreds of thousands and rising fast.

The most famous are oligarchs who buy football clubs, newspapers and luxury property. Others belong to a growing community of dissidents and political refugees afraid to return home and offered protection by the British courts. Many more are young students and travellers seeking the opportunities of work and education abroad. This has led to an entangling of affairs that belies the occasionally fraught relations found at a governmental level. Members of the Russian business elite often feel safer keeping one foot and much of their wealth abroad, and London has become a favoured destination.

The trend for Russian businesses to frame contracts in English law means that around half or more of the cases heard in our commercial courts in recent times have related to Russia or other former Soviet countries. The case involving Roman Abramovich and Boris Berezovsky, expected to reach a verdict soon, is a prominent example. This offers lucrative work for many British law firms and provides Russian companies with a degree of legal certainty that would otherwise be lacking. But the presence of Russian nationals who use the UK as a haven, including from their own government, is also a source of diplomatic tension and a challenge to our domestic security.

Sometimes political and financial scores from the home country are settled outside the law using violence on British soil, as with the murder of Alexander Litvinenko and again with last week's gun attack in east London. This raises important questions about how to shape an effective policy towards Russia and whether it makes sense to set aside difficult issues for diplomatic convenience.

The government has invested a lot of effort in trying to create a stronger bilateral relationship focused on trade and investment. No doubt the government has been influenced by the partial success of President Obama's reset policy and wants to achieve a similar result.

But there are two problems with this. The first is that we do not have the assets to replicate the strategic nature of the US-Russia relationship in offering prestige as an incentive to co-operation. The second is that, as a European country, we are less able to insulate ourselves from Russia's domestic problems than the US. Moreover, London is one of biggest centres for the Russian elite outside of their country.

Issues to do with democratic standards, human rights, relations with neighbouring countries and Russia's behaviour as an energy supplier have a much greater impact on us, either directly or through the nexus of relations that binds us to the rest of our continent.

So our relationship with Russia can't just be reduced to a series of business transactions. It also has to address real and unresolved issues about the nature of the Russian state, the way it relates to its own people and its willingness to adhere to the rule of law. The dismantling of Yukos oil, the refusal of the Russian authorities to cooperate over the murder of Alexander Litvinenko and the appalling circumstances of Sergei Magnitsky's death in state custody, are three cases among many that raise serious concerns.

The government should be working with other countries to put these issues high on the agenda of our dealings with Russia instead of continuing to brush them under the carpet. President-elect Vladimir Putin must be held to his pre-election promises to tackle corruption. Cooperation on trade, investment and economic modernisation should be conditional on measurable progress in improving property rights and the rule of law. The government should use Russia's forthcoming entry to the WTO to maximum legal effect in improving its business environment.

The Russian government is globally engaged and enjoys the privileges that come with being part of the international community. Our government should do much more to insist that Russia at all times behaves like a responsible global partner, and not one in which accusations of corruption and human rights abuses are rife and which risks exporting its problems onto the streets of London.

 
The attempted murder of a Russian banker in London last week was a shocking reminder of how easily the problems of other countries can bring violence to our streets. We live in an increasingly open w...
The attempted murder of a Russian banker in London last week was a shocking reminder of how easily the problems of other countries can bring violence to our streets. We live in an increasingly open w...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:14 PM on 04/11/2012
Isn't it a bit rich of a former aide to Geoff Hoon lecturing other countries on corruption?
11:20 AM on 04/04/2012
If Britain is so concerned about corruption in Russia and human right abuses why is London full of Russian oligarchs who, in many cases, were granted British passports? The wife of ex-Moscow Mayor Yelena Baturina was even lauded in Britain as "contributing to the ecnomy" after her millions were invested in British property.
photo
novelist2000
veritas non olet
07:27 AM on 04/04/2012
Dismantling Yukos: It is vital for Russia that the oil and gas interests are not in foreign hands. They have to protect these as their main assett, just as Britain is protecting her finance industry. If the Russian oil and gas revenues leave their country, the consequences would be impoverishment, unrest, and then huge waves of emigrants moving into Western European countries.

How Khodorkovsky ever got so much money to own these gigantic assetts, remaines a mystery as Soviet individuals could never accumulate riches of that magnitude. The first attempt to take over these assetts bankrupted the Bankers Trust, so I hear in the emigrant community, although others said he had a loan from the Red Army, who had it from Enron. We don't believe any of these, of course, but nobody knows what the sources of his gigantic wealth were when he took over the biggest assett in Russia.

The second attempt of foreign takeover prompted the dismantling of Yukos. You should be grateful to Putin, because the consequences would have impacted on the lives of all people between Vladivostok and Brest, then between Brest and the Atlantic.

That obviously does not mean you can shoot at people in the street - anywhere. It could have been a small time crim or organised crime, not the political level. Here in Australia we have currently shootings related to bikie groups.
03:17 AM on 04/04/2012
"Our government should do much more to insist that Russia at all times behaves like a responsible global partner, and not one in which accusations of corruption and human rights abuses are rife and which risks exporting its problems onto the streets of London." i bet they say the same exact thing about the us
11:53 PM on 04/03/2012
Well someone has the right idea. Get rid of the bankers. The west may learn something here. I guess Russia is well ahead of us. lol
photo
Ajax Johnson
Am I myself or is it just me?
10:38 PM on 04/03/2012
The Oligarchs will be hunted down like Nazis. Once we wake up in the US we will go after ours. That's why they are all "retiring" and scattering.