Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gary Nunn

GET UPDATES FROM Gary Nunn
 

Is It Odd for a White Gay Man to Love Hip-Hop?

Posted: 14/01/2012 00:00

"Hey hey, he gay, he gay...ok."

The final words of Sacha Baron Cohen's 2009 satirical masterpiece Brüno are wonderfully rapped by Snoop Dogg; if only 'the gay thing' elicited a similarly simple shrugged-shoulder acceptance from the rest of the hip-hop world. Then I might not be in my current quandary.

In this brief self-imposed bump n' grind hiatus I'd like to reflect on something that's beginning to bug me: Does my hip-hop love make me a hypocrite?

Hyper-masculine hip-hop has been notoriously and heinously homophobic. Buju Banton wants us shot. Sizzla wants us burnt to death. And Beenie Man wants us, at the very least, seriously injured. Yet, a growing number of gay men, like me, are embracing the hip hop world. Why?

I really should know better. I spent almost four years working for Stonewall, Europe's largest gay equality campaigning organisation. I even worked there while we lobbied, successfully, to outlaw incitement to homophobic hatred. In plain English: to stop people like those named and shamed above from encouraging violence against gay people. And rightly so.

But not all hip-hop is the same. It was the very medium of hip-hop music that Stonewall used in their anti-bullying DVD for schools FIT to demonstrate, rather poignantly, that hip-hop is not owned by homophobes. The film was written and directed by the genius Rikki Beadle-Blair. In his new feature film adaptation of his play Bashment, Beadle-Blair explores how hip-hop homophobia can lead to violence through a white gay rapper as the protagonist.

I asked Rikki why there's a growing gay love for hip-hop and he identified three clear, concise reasons: "It's the voice of oppression. It's highly homoerotic. And it's increasingly less homophobic."

One of the reasons I adore hip-hop is its exploration of language. The clever puns, rapid rhyming couplets, blink-and-you-miss-it word-play and give-a-toss defiant attitude set to an insistent beat means that every time I listen to the same hip-hop track, I take something fresh away with me. Rikki's right: this is the soundtrack to defiance of oppression. Yet, with its all-too-frequent homophobic overtones, it contributes to oppression elsewhere.

Intriguingly, both the hip-hop world and the gay community have historically developed their own vernacular to defy common enemies: the law, the police and traditional, conservative society. Rap patois and Polari (British slang parlance popular with 1960s gay subculture before being gay had been de-criminalised) both have their own exclusive lexicons. It's ironic that this has led to chasm rather than solidarity - but this may now be changing. Rikki Beadle-Blair suggests that the similarities between the gay and hip-hop communities are finally bringing these two worlds closer together: "Many Gay men and the (mostly) black or working-class performers of hip-hop have cross-overs at stereotypical levels: The need to balance society's contempt by obsessing on masculinity; sexual potency; consumerism; looking strong and buff and displays of bling. They are cousins - and this is being gradually recognised from both sides."

Hip-hop's new and growing following of gay men come together once a month at the huge south London gay hip-hop night Bootylicious. I'm a regular - and I asked promoter Thomas Muket why the night is going from strength to strength: "Being gay has become more acceptable within the black, minority and ethnic communities and this in turn has contributed to a normalisation within the gay community towards MOBO music."

Anti-gay hip-hop may not be as blatant as it once was. But the bitter legacy still exists. Mainstream artists like Kanye West have bravely spoken out against homophobia, yet he still casually drops in the offensive, paranoid disclaimer 'no homo' into his rap on the recent Rihanna and Jay-Z track Run This Town.

You won't hear the violently homophobic tracks played at Bootylicious; their music policy avoids the biggest bigots. Muket says: "Nowadays you're less likely to have major artists rant and rave about 'battyman fi dead' etc because we took them on and fought back. The consequences of the negative PR for people like Buju Banton has had a lasting impact. It's simply more bad than beneficial for artists to tout their macho homophobic credentials. And the new generation of artists is just a little more relaxed about these issues."

Of course, it's not just my gay equality credentials hip-hop conflicts with. As a feminist, I equally despise hip-hop's rampant sexism. It's something leading feminist commentator and fellow hip-hop lover Julie Bindel has also struggled with; she says of Snoop Dogg: "He has a voice like honey dripping on rose petals, he raps like a demon - and he pours out his bile all over women." Hip-hop is no more owned by homophobes than it is by misogynists: listen carefully to the lyrics of the grand-matriarch of hip-hop, the insanely talented Missy Elliott. Her rapping puts into action feminist theorist Hélène Cixous's écriture féminine for a mainstream audience.

The pink pound and the hip-hop dollar are now goliaths in mainstream society. Both communities have strutted proudly out of their respective ghettoes - and they're inhabiting a space that's closer together than ever before. So I can go back to guilt-free bumpin' n' grindin' at Bootylicious. Now will someone please turn Missy up?

 

Follow Gary Nunn on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GaryNunn1

 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
averagezoe
Don't breed or buy while homeless animals die!
10:58 PM on 01/16/2012
Anyone who has the capacity to listen to hip-hop or rap is on a different intellectual planet than the rest of the universe. The utter assault of this cacophony is enough to send one running for the hills without ever comprehending a single word. If it was really supposed to send some cultural message, they would have packaged it in something more mellifluous than this earsplitting, china-shattering, stomach-turning racket.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Balancement
Timendi causa est nescire. -- Seneca
09:40 PM on 01/16/2012
"Is It Odd for a White Gay Man to Love Hip-Hop?"

No offense, but it's odd for anyone with taste or a modicum of musical knowledge to even *like* the stuff, much less love it.

As Puccini once told a young aspiring composer, "If you should ever run across a melody, do be sure to write it down."

But that's just me.
05:03 PM on 01/17/2012
You should probably widen your musical options then. If you are using commercial hip hop as a gauge to measure this "stuff," then you really have listened to hip hop, no disrespect.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Balancement
Timendi causa est nescire. -- Seneca
07:46 PM on 01/17/2012
I'm sorry that you didn't understand what I said--even sorrier you don't understand what you said.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DavidEm
Politizane Wealth Inequality on YouTube
06:12 PM on 01/16/2012
I don't know how enlightened hip-hop has turned in the UK, though I doubt the answer is "Very."

Here in the US, hip-hop is the most regressive cultural influence imaginable. It's message is not just denigration of gay men and lesbians. It's also denigration of women, whom it turns into nothing more than the object of male sexual domination, hypermasculinity and the glorification of violence, gang culture, conspicuous consumption, and the denigration of education or anything remotely intellectual. If you think dropping out of school and joining a group you're not allowed to leave is progress, this is your music.

I think the guy you quoted above got it (inadvertently) right when he called it "the voice of oppression."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CBasilJr
62 Retired Vet
07:39 PM on 01/16/2012
I think that Rikki was right when he called hip-hop the voice of oppression.

Here in the US, we have the examples of Hillary Clinton and Gabrielle Giffords' recovery from her wound to weaken the holds that homophobia and male sexual domination have had.
12:28 AM on 01/14/2012
Given vast cultural choices each of us is going to like something which does not conform to marketing, social, politically correct or cultural stereotype.

The guilt-free experience you are seeking is a politically correct illusion. All things are connected. Through a genre of music influences spread. you listen to your PC artists influenced by racists, homophobes and god knows what else. It's tainted love.

I like Paraziti. What are they?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k5hJZWiUtpg
12:19 AM on 01/14/2012
And this nonsense is on the front page of the uk section of this ? If it wasnt so ridiculously placed i doubt whether anyone would give a flying ~~~~~~~ .......sack the excuse for an editor !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill J4321
04:22 AM on 01/14/2012
call us when your shuttle lands.
photo
AlanDente
Noses: made to hold glasses
08:41 PM on 01/14/2012
An issue of massive cultural importance, a dichotomy between homophobic and hateful depictions within of hip hop and a new trend towards rejection of those truly odious meta-narratives. All within a well-written article.

Sounds newsworthy and pretty interesting to me.
10:45 AM on 01/15/2012
im thinking theyve hit there target audience exactly then !
11:56 PM on 01/13/2012
A ridiculously self-indulgent article which presumes an essentialist approach to the very notion of what "being gay" is. Of course you can be a gay hip hop lover, just as you can be the gay Tory leader of a local group, or a gay fan of garden nurseries over clubbing and poppers. Seriously, when did the HP start to pander to this boring lowbrow identity politics lite?
12:30 AM on 01/14/2012
I think it always has pandered to identity politics. That's why we have the proliferation of sections devoted to one thing and another.
01:43 AM on 01/14/2012
Last time I checked, members of the Tory party or staff at my local garden nursery weren't advocating the death of gay people, so I'm not quite convinced by your comparison I'm afraid.