Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hannah Ellison

GET UPDATES FROM Hannah Ellison
 

Shipping News: The Ardent TV Fans You've Probably Never Heard Of

Posted: 18/02/2012 00:00

Some of you reading this may watch Glee or Supernatural, but I doubt many of you are aware of the war that just recently ended deep in fan-space. A non-canon shipping war. This might sound like something fought in international waters sometime in the 18th Century but it's not. It's a knock-down, drag-out fight that has been raging for weeks between fans, bringing down an eonline.com page because it received more views than any post in the history of the site and causing previously civil TV fans to go out for blood. All in the name of a Valentine's Day poll to determine who voters' favourite TV couple was.

After weeks of voting the final stand-off was between Dastiel and Faberry. "Who are these people?" you ask. These are the portmanteau names of two of TV fandoms biggest non-canon ships Dean/Castiel from Supernatural and Quinn/Rachel (Fabray/Berry) from Glee; ship being short for relationship, shippers those who advocate them and canon meaning something actually depicted on the show. Non-canon ships are those relationships that are entirely subtextual, between characters that never officially show romantic interest in each other. Faberry won (by around 70,000 votes, a vote rate of 228 per minute). Out of a choice between any pairing of characters currently featuring on US TV shows, the most vocal and determined fans were those of a pairing many viewers would not even consider friendly, let alone romantic. Suddenly shippers were big mainstream news and everyone was talking about them.

The actresses who portray the pair (Lea Michele and Dianna Agron) tweeted a picture they took together holding a paper heart. Perez Hilton commented on the win calling the shippers 'fanatics' and Hulu's Morning After even created a fan video dedicated to the pair in a segment about the win. Every review site from Afterellen to Wetpaint was commenting. All this only days after Entertainment Weekly ran a four page spread that tried to explain to its readers the world of shipping.

Suddenly these fans had gone from under the radar and unheard of to the poster children for fan devotion. However, this article did a disservice by ignoring the truly fervent shippers, the non-canon shippers; those who would, by their own admission, go down with their ships. The non-canon shippers are a mostly invisible, much maligned and persecuted group, seen by many as the seedy underbelly of the fan world out to derail the work of TV writers, rather than the innovative and unwavering group they are. To be a non-canon shipper is an uphill battle and Faberry shippers fight hard on the internet's biggest fan battleground; Tumblr.

Search for Faberry on Tumblr and you will find a funhouse mirror version of Glee. The characters almost seem the same, but the art made of them, the stories told about them, the worlds built for them to live in are just slightly skewed. To be a non-canon shipper means having to make the world fit how you see it. Glee presents Faberry as former adversaries and tentative friends, the shippers see them as two people who show they care through confrontation, who fight because they are too scared to admit they love.

These small moments become the basis for hundreds of ballad backed YouTube videos and novel length works of fiction. Works of fiction so well-liked that original secondary characters created by these authors become recurrent figures in works produced by other fans. However, being a non-canon shipper is more than grasping at the tiny morsels given to you and building around them, it's about manipulating what you are shown to make it what you want to see. Glee has a scene with Finn and Rachel? Fine, Faberry shippers will rip the image, remove Finn and replace him with Quinn. These new versions often become so popular they spawn their own stories and videos, ones now a step even further removed from the original show. Characters become steeped in what's called fanon, that is the fan created version of canon.

For a non-shipper delving into the world of Faberry would seem alien. References to moments and character traits that have never appeared in the show, but seem commonplace to these fans, would make them unsure that it was the same show they were talking about. But that is because it's not the same show. In fact many Faberry shippers admit to not even watching the show anymore but instead consuming it through the creative work in the Faberry Tumblr fandom. What non-canon shippers truly watch is their version of the show, the version they make from the scraps Glee gives them and the work they create themselves. Ryan Murphy might have his name on this show, but its most invested fans aren't buying what he's selling. Don't tell Murphy but perhaps Roland Barthes was right all along, the author is dead.

 

Follow Hannah Ellison on Twitter: www.twitter.com/hanellison

 
 
  • Comments
  • 27
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:43 AM on 02/19/2012
One of the best things is that the Faberry fans and Destiel fans are getting along great on tumblr now and having a fun time of it. Hell, there's some Faberry fans who've started to watch Supernatural for the impending Destiel and I wouldn't be surprised if the return has happened too. It's one of those things where the voting battle is bitter but at the end we're all friends. I'm a Destiel shipper myself, but congrats to Faberry. I know you have more people in the first place, Glee being bigger than SPN, but that was still some feat you accomplished. Now, party in the Fabstiel tag!
06:43 PM on 02/19/2012
Saw a Destiel fan say "Nobody dicks with Faberry but me". They're like our brother fandom. Or I dunno, second cousin fandom? Lovin' the love in the Fabstiel tag. Someone said that Cory Monteith (Finn Hudson on Glee) plays a character in Supernatural that gets killed, thus proving Faberry and Destiel are meant to be.
09:47 PM on 02/18/2012
Ms Ellison, Please bring us more of this. What is the name of this planet? Really this is great stuff. Inviting fans to tell us more would be good. Their contributions are fascinating. Very interesting. Thanks.
03:05 AM on 02/19/2012
http://tumblr.com/tagged/faberry
And go read "Should Have Asked For Directions" (google it)
12:17 AM on 02/20/2012
It's the genesis of a new art form predicted by various ''anti-novelists'' who suggested that readers could direct stories. Add to that the choices in graphic novels, then the (very male) adventure story plotted out trend see ref:

http://donjon.bin.sh/adventure/

It also reminds me of trend (now forgotten much lost) for folks to write romantic and erotic letters to each other and then read to friends (the French again).

There is also the spontaneous use of interactive media (the net) which is grossly failing to offer interactivity! (The internet is so linear it is boring. Just being fed stuff).

The reader accepts where and when and who of the moment in the story. Very postmodern. Timelines are fractured, views of characters and process randomized.

Robbe-Grillet did this attempting to bring a cubist broken structure to narrative. Meaning builds slowly around events - you get pieces of this and that and it gradually becomes a big story, but later pieces can change the building process radically. That is moving from feedback loops to open systems.

This will become a cultural phenomenon. there needs to be a software package -a shell - modified to make it easy to construct , deconstruct and reconstruct.

Hope this makes sense. Thanks for the link. A fan.
07:53 PM on 02/18/2012
Really good to see an article on non-canon shipping on Huff Post! However, it has been around for a pretty long time, its roots being the origin of the word slash fiction - fan fiction writers focussing on Kirk and Spock from the original Star Trek many years ago. The Internet boom in the 90s lead to much easier access to slash fiction and writers and readers connecting in ways they hadn't when fanfiction was restricted to seemingly seedly fanzines. The tv show Xena:Warrior Princess went through huge 'shipping wars' between those people convinced Xena and her gal pal Gabrielle shared more than a blanket, and those who were horrified at the idea. However, the creativity that come from fan fiction writers was considerable.
These days the multimedia approach of tumblr and the way you can share thoughts and ideas is continuing the fascination fans have always had about what our tv favourites do when the cameras aren't looking!
Do we believe it will happen? Well, some fans might, but for most of us, it is just another way of watching that makes us feel we know something everyone else doesn't!
06:55 AM on 02/18/2012
Fanon is powerful. How do you think Brittana got it's start? Brittany and Santana were supposed to be Quinn's sidekicks in the canon. Never anything more. Certainly not main characters. Heather was chosen as a dancer and Naya was chosen as a pretty face with sass to sway in the background but people really liked them. Santana's attitude was entertaining and her obvious soft spot for Brittany was endearing. Brittany's hilarious one liners didn't hurt. They had chemistry and they were never apart. Fanon turned them into lovers. It grew and more people began to see their chemistry and the writers listened to their fans' cries for more Brittany and Santana. Now we have Brittana. Faberry is also a large and powerful fanbase that is making itself heard. Only the future will tell if it bears any fruit with the writers but the shear force of the fandom is inspiring. It doesn't hurt that the cast is very close to the fandom. They troll on tumblr and absorb the fanon and the creativity of their fanbase and fully support it.
01:40 AM on 02/18/2012
The real problems occur when the non-canon shippers convince themselves they are seeing the show properly. And then attack the canon shippers, and even the creators themselves, as being delusional.
02:45 AM on 02/18/2012
No that's actually quite the opposite. Canon shippers like to attack and call non-canon shippers delusional. Non-canon shippers are perfectly fine living in their little bubble but when a spiteful canon shipper decides to trash on their ship constantly they are going to fight back. Finchel/Faberry shippers for example. The door certainly opens both ways but why do Finchel shippers feel the need to put down other ships and call people delusional when their ship is canon? Finchel is canon so shouldn't the faberry shippers be the ones who are feeling insecure about their ship? In reality its not true and there is much more hate directed from Finchel shippers to Faberry shippers than the other way around. Its confusing but the proof is all there on tumblr.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:30 PM on 02/19/2012
Most Finchel shipper don't care for Faberry. The just ignore it.
02:47 AM on 02/18/2012
You make it sound as if it's only non-canon shippers attacking someone. Finchel fans have always been attacking Faberry fans and calling them delusional. You also make it sound as if every non-canon shipper does these things. "...convince themselves they are seeing the show properly." We see the subtext, we see the story behind the story (Quinn drawing an ugly picture of Rachel surrounded by hearts, anyone?). There are a few bad eggs in every ship, please don't make non-canon shippers sound like bad people. You are coming off as attacking non-canon shippers.
03:58 AM on 02/18/2012
Right I guess the promo for next ep where Quinn tells Rachel marrying Finn is going to ruin her life was all made up and manip.
The power of Faberry shippers
12:36 AM on 02/18/2012
Nice article but laterly we don't need to manipulate things. Did you see the promo for next episode? Faberry has a bizarre friendship some people don't understand it Been a Faberry shipper is hard cause you have to analyze things but the subtext is there. In last episodes we have seen Quinn cared for Rachel but why she cares so much? I mean not even Kurt or Rachel's dads are so oppose to the Finchel wedding
12:20 AM on 02/18/2012
"but its most invested fans aren't buying what he's selling". I can not take this article seriously because of the obvious bias it's portraying. The finchel fans do not have to spend hours on manipulations because we can enjoy the show as is. Other fandoms don't have to spend countless hours voting on a poll that does nothing for the actual show. Especially creating voting bots that let you cheat on voting. You may say Faberry fans are the most dedicated in fandom, when all I see is heterophobia at it's best. The arguments made by the Faberry fans against actual canon couples are appalling, hypocritical and lack actual critical thinking. I don't see the love they claim when I see them post #letlovein, I see a lot of hate. If they don't watch the show anymore, then why do they send hate to other fandoms after each episode airs? You obviously didn't do your research thoroughly.
05:15 AM on 02/20/2012
Is "heterophobia" the new phrase Faberry-haters like to throw around? It's totally bogus, btw, because all different kinds of folks ship Faberry - guys and girls, both gay and straight. The appeal of Faberry isn't because they're both two girls - it's about their dynamic as PEOPLE. One of them could be a guy, and I'd still ship the hell out of it.

And as for criticizing canon Glee couples? Way to generalize the entire fandom. There are plenty of canon couples I like (Tike, Barole, Puckleberry, St. Berry, Samcedes). And there are MANY Faberry shippers who also like other canon couples - both gay and straight. So, really, stop with this heterophobia nonsense.

Also, E! looked into the voting, and they determined there wasn't any cheating, so this argument can go away now.
11:55 PM on 02/17/2012
I wouldn't say the author is dead, because the authors of fanfiction are writers too, aren't they?
And people still watch the show.
It's just that the writer only writes part of what the reader reads.
The reader has the capacity to analyze stories for themselves now, and in that they write their own.
So the writer isn't dead. The writer is breeding.
11:25 AM on 02/18/2012
Interesting perspective. I think the issue is somewhat semantic, in the difference between 'author' and 'writer'. These kind of fans open the text up to such an extent that the 'author' becomes secondary to the collaborative and ever evolving work of the 'writer'. Perhpas waht has truly died is the idea of the closed text.
04:12 PM on 02/18/2012
Hm. I didn't think about the difference between author and writer. Now I get what you mean. And I completely agree, the closed text is dead.
11:48 PM on 02/17/2012
This is pretty much a perfect description of our fandom
11:47 PM on 02/17/2012
Basically this is what every single one of my friends need to understand: I don't watch the same show they do. They watch Glee. I watch Glee through tumblr. It's totally different. And more, it's much better. We see what we want to see, yes, but that doesn't make us delusional, that makes us enjoy one of the most creative (if not the most) creative fandom I've ever been on. Everything, from the stories to the arts, is absolutely impeccable and if everyone could see what I see I wouldn't have to explain why I'm such a big fan of "Glee".
11:31 AM on 02/18/2012
I think this is the great thing about Tumblr and why it's so fascinating for me as an academic. It's democratised TV more than any other platform has before.
12:48 PM on 02/18/2012
You mean it is allowing users to determine the course of events in a delivered process?

But schools do not do that delivering courses.
04:13 PM on 02/18/2012
This, so much. I'm so done with being called delusional, so done with all the looks and the stares. Maybe I'll walk around with the url for this story pinned on my shirt on Monday.