Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Harry Cooper

GET UPDATES FROM Harry Cooper
 

Is European Nationalism Dead?

Posted: 04/12/2012 00:00

A lot has been written about what appears to be a resurgence in the popularity of nationalist movements across Europe in recent years. Ranging from Artur Mas' Catalan independence movement to the overtly racist black-shirts of Golden Dawn in Greece, this trend is clearly here to stay for the foreseeable future. While it is important not to generalise too much, given how varied the ideologies and goals of these movements are, they are clearly united in one key sense: protest or outright rejection of the status quo.

The suggestion that nationalism is dead or on its way out is an odd one. I recently read an article by Simon Kuper in which he argued that "the nation-state is shrinking to just a flag, some sports teams and a pile of debts". He even suggested that the rise of these movements in Europe is actually a sign of nationalism's demise. The move to an 'ever closer' European Union will ultimately make national identities irrelevant. To some, this might seem a reassuring thought. While comparisons with pre-war Germany and the latter days of Yugoslavia may be possible, ultimately these are isolated groups of angry individuals who will, eventually, calm down and accept the trials and tribulations of the post financial crisis world.

Unfortunately this may not be the case with economies on life support across much of contemporary Europe. Whether or not you are for or against 'austerity', the shrinking of the state or the reorganisation of welfare systems, it is clear to see that people are struggling to understand why this is happening or necessary. It is this dangerous mix of confusion and insecurity that, I think, is the reason for the popularity of protest movements throughout the EU.

In Catalonia, it is argued by separatist movements that independence will mean keeping more tax revenue, allowing the yawning budget deficit to be eliminated faster. Golden Dawn has stepped in to provide services that had hitherto been provided by the Greek state. Meanwhile, UKIP have successfully blended the British population's uncertainty about the future with their lack of understanding of the EU.

As numerous academics have rightly pointed out, nationalism is a modern creation that came with the development of the state only in the past few hundred years. It is one of countless identities that have come and gone throughout human history. I identify myself as a member of my family; various sub-national social groups; English sometimes, British at others. To declare that nationalism is dead is to ignore the complexity of how individuals identify themselves against each other. Right now, at a time of economic insecurity, national identity (ethnic, linguistic or geographic) is a popular construct for individuals to cluster around, when at others it may not.

In terms of what this means for the trajectory of the EU, it's quite interesting to look at who and what these movements are protesting against. While it is clear that the locus of political power now lies in Brussels, where the Commission is attaining ever more power to vet member state budgets and economic policy, it is not EU flags that are being burnt in Athens or Madrid.

Instead it is either Angela Merkel or corrupt, incompetent national governments who are accused of causing economic catastrophe. Even in the UK, where the debate is different to much of the rest of Europe, what is driving UKIP's popularity is anger at the coalition government, not a visceral hatred of all things European.

This is because people, when experiencing insecurity or fear, like to blame things they are familiar with. It's easy for the Greeks to blame Germany or focus their anger on Angela Merkel. She is believed to be personally responsible for inflicting such painful austerity measures. The simmering resentment that Catalans have against the Spanish central government has been around since Franco focused power in Madrid. In Holland, fear of immigrants has been replaced by hostility to Europe, reflected in the changing fortunes of Geert Wilders' 'Party for Freedom', which is now styling itself as the party for eurosceptics. The movements may have different means and different ends, but they emanate from a common factor: loss of faith in the European status quo.

Where this will end, it's impossible to say. But until people stop feeling insecure, I suspect that these movements will continue to erode the popular legitimacy that national institutions and structures have enjoyed for so long.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:30 PM on 12/05/2012
Nice try Harry Cooper.
Globalism is completely unsustainable and unnatural.
There has never been a multicultural/global society that survived beyond the strains that such an artificial society creates, all we have to do is look at history for that.
And besides who wants a global society anyhow, where everyone is the same no matter what country or location one might reside?
I would much rather have Sweden full of natural Swedes, England full of English, France full of French people because that is what makes the world beautiful and each place culturally unique.
Globalism is a stain upon the world, a destroyer of once sovereign and native cultures.
People are waking-up to the sham that is multicultural-globalism, and that is why you are seeing a rise in Nationalist parties.
09:20 PM on 12/05/2012
LOL.
Nice try Harry Cooper!!
Globalism/Multiculturalism is unsustainable and completely unnatural.
I doubt this era of globalism could somehow escape the precedent made many times in history that multicultural societies fall apart under their own internal conflict.
Case in point: Ancient Greece, Rome, and Alexandria just to name a few popular ones.
09:37 PM on 12/04/2012
Is European Nationalism Dead? < Its a dream fantasy, dreamed up only by jobsworths, technocrats, unknown MEPs and EU advisor's to EU Commissioners, riding the gravy train living in the Brussels bubble. Step outside into the real world and its the EU institutions that are dying a slow death by the voters.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jessjesskk
Benevolent Zombie Power
08:23 PM on 12/05/2012
He is saying exactly the truth... nationalism is based on a concept "nation" that itself means nothing except what people want to put in it... look at the UK... there are much more in common between a Londoner and an habitant from Paris that there are between a Londoner and someone from Newcastle.

Ultimately insecure people want to go back to the past whenever there is something they are uncomfortable with. Why? because the past is comfortable: we know what happened.

Let me tell you something very important... life is full of uncertainty and keeping institutions and organizations of the past will not make uncertainties go away.

Let's assume for a moment that the UK would decide to split from the EU. What would happen is at the same time London and Scotland decided to take their independance and stay in the EU? how would you react?

"Nation" is a completely created concept that was put forward when the link between kings and supposed deities began to appear as a fad in history.
It does not mean this is a concept that will stay or keep any kind of power in the future.
04:09 PM on 12/04/2012
I love Europe. I detest the European Union with all my head and heart. Good luck UKIP!
03:32 PM on 12/04/2012
People are flocking to Ukip because they have grown weary of all the false promises from the 3 major political parties of foot dragging and deception over a EU referendum.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kevin Mcilroy
01:03 PM on 12/04/2012
You are fooling yourself if you think that the surge in popularity of UKIP has anything to do with dissatisfaction towards the way the coalition are running the economy - UKIP is popular because they have a clear policy of getting the UK out of the EU. A blind man could see that the EU is corrupt and the British people recogise the waste and idiocy of supporting it
11:24 PM on 12/03/2012
Why do liberal elitists want to create a Euroepan superstate? They are obsessed with power. They try to destroy the nation-state because they can't be satisfied with control in one country, they want to control all of Europe. No wonder there is a backlash.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:30 AM on 12/04/2012
Liberal elitists? Don't you mean free market capitalists who wanted a single market?
10:01 PM on 12/04/2012
Those people threw their lot in with New Labour and the other center-Left parties. It was clear to the left that they would have to embrace big business in order to survive after the fall of the Soviet Union. Big Business can and does prosper under a nanny state, it's the smaller entrepeneurs who are squeezed out.
10:43 PM on 12/03/2012
Nationalists are alive and well in Scotland and in Greece. In fact they will become much more active as the EU goes into decline, as Uber-government and Uber-banking regulator.
11:29 PM on 12/03/2012
The EU supports pro-EU seperatist movements financially because it creates countries that cannot survive without the support of a strengthened EU. They undermine the nation-states existing in order to control weaker future states.
05:06 PM on 12/05/2012
Scotland, Catalonia and others are more than capable of surviving without the EU, more so than countries like Denmark or Belgium.

Scotland and Catalonia are nation-states under foreign rule. UK and Spain are not nation states, they are international unions just like the EU.