Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hilary Burrage

GET UPDATES FROM Hilary Burrage
 

Cynical Silo Thinking Is Not Policy for the Green Challenges Ahead

Posted: 28/10/2012 23:00

This week we learned that the UK Coalition government wants to deregulate farm workers' wages, permit support allowances for only two children in any family, and lower subsidy (?investment) levels for green power plants.

It's commonplace that the Coalition abandoned intentions to be the greenest government ever many moons ago. It seems however that they have also now jettisoned any intention even to give a nod to the serious greening agenda.

Money, or lack of it, is of course the unifying theme. What 'we' haven't got, it's said, we can't share out to others. But the 'we' of contemporary parlance is not the 'we' of the future who will pay dearly, in cash and in kind, for the present failure to join the dots which these can't pay, won't pay positions underpin.

Triangulating difficult issues
Farm workers' wages? Agricultural incomes are already amongst the lowest of any occupational group in Britain. Have we forgotten that the food production industry absolutely must attract and support people who will toil in farms and fields to feed a growing population? And that to do that there must be healthy, working age people (parents, young adults) who, resisting the call of the city, remain to work on the land?

Even the much-disliked factory farming requires people to keep it functioning; and an ever-more stifled low wage rural economy helps no-one, town or country. Food prices and sustainability are not issues which can be addressed simply by paying already impoverished folk even less.

Limited family (children's) allowances? Even aside from issues around the economic downturn catching people out - with parents' job opportunities becoming scarce as children already born grow into teenagers with little hope and few prospects - it must be startlingly obvious that the best way to reduce future family size is to have women in decent and rewarding employment.

Nurturing children is an essential part of any civilised society, important to men as much as women. There is never cogent reason to penalise children who have the misfortune to be born into larger, poorer families. Well educated, well occupied women who have fewer children are better placed to make additional, wider contributions to the economy and social life overall - a win, win when it comes to our future prospects. Good schools and good jobs are the strategic and decent way to keep future family sizes modest.

And green power plants? The UK, with established technical and industrial know-how, has huge potential to take a lead in this essential aspect of our global futures. We need to keep the investments and expertise in Britain, and we need even more to ensure that energy is produced in (comparatively) non-damaging ways.

Of course energy conservation is critical. Of course increasing population and 'demand' for energy is difficult. But simply failing as a government to engage in taking forward new green technologies is the way forward for no-one.

Silo policies betray electoral trust
The connecting theme in all this is investment in the most fundamental sense.

So will that investment be in people and in our shared futures? Or will it be in obdurately short-term political reputation and ambition? Is there realistic horizon-scanning leadership at the heart of government, or is there merely immediate and opportunistic omnishambles?

The current no money theme is what the government invites us to consider. The present-day, now 'we' is asked to accept that nothing can be done; that population, food and energy are separate, siloed issues, and a reductionist perspective is the only possible way to see things.

But that's not how the 'we' of the future will perceive matters. It will be no secret that evidence and knowledge was (currently is) there to devise positive forward-facing and sustainable policy pathways, had we chosen to do so. The future-'we' will condemn the silo narratives which silenced essential truths about conjoined and underlying realities.

The we-of-the-future will look back uncomprehendingly on the self-serving we-of-the-present and ask despairingly how it came to pass that our leaders were not challenged mightily by us, the electorate, about their failure to address the most pressing issues of our time.

The place of each of us in society, food and energy....

These are critically interconnected features of our everyday existence. What could be more fundamental?

And what could have more potential for future disaster, if the current recklessness continues?

~ ~ ~

Hilary Burrage was previously a member of the Defra Science Advisory Council, and Vice-Chair of the North-West (of England) Sustainable Development Group which advised the NW regional bodies. She writes in a personal capacity.

 

Follow Hilary Burrage on Twitter: www.twitter.com/HilaryBurrage

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
This week we learned that the UK Coalition government wants to deregulate farm workers' wages, permit support allowances for only two children in any family, and lower ...
This week we learned that the UK Coalition government wants to deregulate farm workers' wages, permit support allowances for only two children in any family, and lower ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:36 PM on 10/30/2012
You have to laugh at person talking about the Green Challenges ahead and then wanting to subsidise children !!! Does she not know that it is an ever expanding population that is causing the 'Green Challenge ?
Here is an idea that will help to meet the Green Challenge - put social commentators out toiling in the fields.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hilary Burrage
07:03 PM on 10/31/2012
Best read my post again I think, GearoidOD... my point is that the most effective way to reduce family size is to ensure women are well educated and can get decent work.

I suppose in your view that might require a degree of 'subsidy' for children as they progress towards adulthood, but I'd challenge anyone to suggest how else to provide good education and support every child, living with privilege or not. Isn't that what a civilised society is all about? Can't see how denying children a decent childhood children will help...

To avoid all doubt, I am very clear that expanding population is a serious green challenge - as indeed I say in the piece - and that that family size must be addressed.

So, to repeat: a great deal of evidence demosntrates that the best way to reduce family size is to ensure girls have a good education and are equipped to enjoy a full life as grown women. Obvious, I would have thought.....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OD4U
If its OK for one then its OK for all.
12:50 PM on 10/29/2012
An article worth reading for a snapshot of the wider issues around the green policy. However, energy, especially heating, will be uppermost in the minds of many this winter, especially if it is a particularly cold one. This government has done little to help people in real need, and if experience is anything to go by, nothing useful will likely happen until closer to the elections in 2015.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
humphry
The Voynich Manuscripts.
12:45 AM on 10/29/2012
The most pressing issue at the moment for me is keeping warm this winter..The subsidies going to green energy dont help my bills, they just make them worse!.....
07:39 PM on 10/30/2012
Despite the fact that I am a great to recycle, etc. I am going back to burning coal wood etc after dropping the practice years ago. To hell with the environment - the Greens never seem to worry about the environment when it comes to having their salaries and the salaries of the army of advisers and commentators who make up the Green Industry.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
humphry
The Voynich Manuscripts.
09:09 PM on 10/30/2012
Green energy is a rich mans fuel my friend.
photo
HilaryBurrage
Yes. Same Hilary Burrage as the HuffPost blogger
12:05 AM on 10/29/2012
PS If you want topical evidence of the UK Government's failure to attend to green issues, look no further than the refusal to face up to the waste of energy resulting from the clocks going forward: http://dreamingrealist.co.uk/?s=daylight+saving, or the fiasco about badgers: http://hilaryburrage.com/2012/09/19/the-problem-isnt-badgers-its-politically-led-bad-science/.