Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ian Murray

GET UPDATES FROM Ian Murray
 

A Humanitarian Trip to Gaza

Posted: 25/08/11 12:42 BST

I approached the 5 day trip to Gaza with a certain degree of apprehension. There is no doubt that this part of the Middle East is volatile and the Peace process has virtually disappeared. My apprehension was not dampened by having to travel from Cairo through northern Egypt to the Rafah crossing.

Peace and justice in the Middle East can only be achieved through the implementation of international law and respect for human rights. In respect of Palestine this
means a viable two state solution that delivers justice and freedom for the Palestinian people as called for by the overwhelming international consensus and enshrined under international law and in UN resolutions.

Our delegation would be examining the situation in Gaza, the lack of Fatah-Hamas reconciliation and the peace process.

Our first attempt to cross through Rafah was thwarted by a national celebration that closed the crossing for the day. This gave the delegation of MPs and MEPs the opportunity to spend some time in Egypt meeting with the Muslim Brotherhood (who have founded the Freedom and Justice Party and are expected to win the upcoming elections) and the Trustees Committee of the Revolution in Tahir Square. This band of young people initiated the uprising in Egypt at great personal risk. At both meetings they spoke of their hopes for Egypts future and their belief the Israel is not doing enough to try and resolve the situation with Palestine. They also believed the Rafah crossing should be fully open.

After a stalled day we travelled by bus across the Sinai Desert. After a 10 hour trip we had to stay overnight about an hour from Rafah as it was too dangerous to go any further in the dark. After a blighted 4 hours sleep we left to reach the Rafah Crossing. Interestingly, we saw three large trucks from Scotland that had travelled for 32 days with much needed medical supplies. They had been waiting for two days to get in. We later found out they were refused entry because of two items the Egyptian authorities were not happy with but when they agreed not to take them they simply named another two items.

The Rafah crossing is not "open". Only 350 Palestinians per day are allowed out to Egypt and getting back home is very difficult indeed. There were crowds of people who had been waiting since 5am to get over the border. This border is barely "open" and given that it is the only legal entry and exit point from Palestine for the Palestinians it is pretty disgraceful. When we arrived at the other side we were met by a welcoming party of local members of the Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC)

The PLC has bases in both Gaza and the West Bank with Hamas effectively controlling Gaza and Fatah the latter. Both parties are currently involved in a complicated reconciliation process in order to form a united Government that can negotiate for the whole of Palestine in the International Community and with Israel.

Everyone we spoke to in Gaza had one wish - the lifting of Israel's blockade of Gaza which is keeping 1.5 million people under siege. UNWRA (United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees) provide basic food supplies, have job creation programmes and are involved in reconstruction of 10,000 houses or shelters as well as building 100 schools. There are 300 illegal tunnels from Egypt to Gaza through which all manner of goods are transported which are not allowed through the official crossings by Israel. It is cheaper to get reconstruction materials through the tunnels. Meanwhile UNWRA can't get access to the materials to rebuild the 50,000 homes that are needed.

The biggest travesty of the siege is that UNWRA currently provides food aid for 700,000 Gazans and they face a current funding shortage that will be force it to cut all food assistance and job creation from October if not resolved. That will create a humanitarian disaster for Gaza and people will die of malnutrition. It is probably the biggest threat to the people of Gaza that may result in the eruption of hostilities with Israel as the blockade is maintained.

We were also able to meet with Ismail Haniyeh who is recognised as PM in Gaza, heading up the successful Hamas Parliamentary Group. He is a popular figure, living modestly locally in Gaza. He has been pivotal in taking Hamas down a more moderate road; renouncing violence, keeping the more militant factions within Hamas under control and promoting engagement with rival Fatah. I asked him directly what one message we could take back to the UK from the delegation and he replied without hesitation, "lift the siege, it's killing children."

We were also fortunate to have met with the head of the Committee for National Reconciliation, Ashraf Jumaa, who is also a Fatah member of the PLC from Rafah. Having recently returned from Istanbul, Turkey, where Fatah and Hamas held their third meeting for reconciliation, he explained that the main issues remaining included the creation of a national unity government, sharing security, the PLO structure, upcoming elections, and public civil reconciliation between the Palestinian people, not only between politicians.

Ashraf Jumaa also explained that the Fatah position is that reconciliation needs to be respected by international community; however, there is substantial pressure from the international community to keep Salam Fayyad as Prime Minister. Hamas rejects Fayyad, but does not object to postponing a national unity government until September with elections to be held in June 2012. Ashraf Jumaa concluded: "If we can't control the peace, then we can't control anything." This seems to be the key to the future of Palestine.

The Prime Ministers wish for lifting of the siege was emphasised on a visit to the Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City with the Minister of Health, Bassem Naem, who revealed a large power supply deficiency that affects kidney dialysis machines where, for example, every time the power goes down, the machines have to be unplugged from patients, the blood cleaned and then restarting. There is also a severe lack of funding, lack of training due to lack of travel, a lack of spare parts and of specialists. The Minister emotionally told us of how children with cancer cannot be treated through lack of basic medicines. Many of which were sitting in Scottish trucks at the Rafah crossing waiting to gain access.

Additionally, Gaza City has one of the most technologically advances radiology units in the Middle East but it lies dormant due to "Israel's preoccupation with 'dual-use' material" that could be used potentially for civilian and military purposes prohibits the import of any radio-therapy drugs for cancer patients. Israel also demands that patients requiring emergency treatment outside of Gaza, being transported to East Jerusalem, inform on the security situation with the Strip before receiving treatment. 500 Palestinians have died in the last 3 years simply because of a lack of medication - children and cancer patients are most at risk.

The economy of Palestine and, in particular, Gaza is appalling. We met with small and medium enterprises (SME) who told us that that unemployment has reached 50% of Gazans, of 2,800 factories about half do not function due to destruction. Before the 2008-09 Gaza War, there were 135,000 SME workers, now there are only 15.000 employed. Furthermore, over 100,000 Gazan workers used to work in Israel and that has now stopped. The lack of opportunity for young men, in particular, is a danger to future piece in the region. Of that there is no doubt. The entire economy of Gaza relied ont he 300 or so illegal tunnels that bring in goods. Without these tunnels there would be no economy, no jobs, and no hope for the future. 1.5 million people are surviving on illegal imports. This cannot be allowed to continue.

One of the most moving parts of the delegation was the visit to the refugee camp. Men, women and children are living in unimaginable conditions. They are frustrated by the fact that Palestine could be a burgeoning economy and life chances could be vastly improved. I visited a shack where 14 of the same family lived. The grandmother explained that their kitchen area was destroyed by fire as a result of shelling in the area. Their "living" area had 4 pictures on the wall. Each picture was a son who had been killed. In the corner of the room were 2 klashnekoff rifles that she explained through tears were for "protection". They live of mainly UN food aid that is expected to run out in October. It was a desperate place. However, the people were friendly, open and resolute in their aspirations for Palestines future.
I took some simple sticker books with me for the kids and I'm sure the refugee camp is now peppered with stickers of Peppa Pig and Cars.

Whatever the increasingly polarised views of the Palestine/Israel situation are, what is clear is that people, and children in particular, are dying needlessly from political dogma. There is absolutely no need for the siege and the blockade to continue. The Rafah crossing should be fully open and Palestine should be allowed to stand on its own two feet. We were told that the economy would recover very quickly if the siege was lifted. It doesn't seem to me to be too much to ask.

The full reconciliation of Fatah and Hamas is critical and elections are pivotal in 2012. This process will allow Palestine to speak with one voice and the Peace Process must be the next priority. The danger is that for as long as Palestine cannot get its own political house in order the Israeli have an excuse to derail any peace process. What is inexcusable is the illegality of what is happening to Palestine. The UN has passed resolution after resolution to stop these practices without success. The blockade is not only unnecessary but could become the catalyst for future conflict. People with no hope and no future end up with no choice and that is unthinkable for the future of the Middle East.

 

Follow Ian Murray on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ianmurraymp

 
 
  • Comments
  • 89
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Freddie27
Liberal Gay Jewish Atheist
09:24 PM on 08/28/2011
Israel is just such a disgrace to the Jewish name. It has shown itself to be a rogue state, operating outside the bounds of international law. And it seems to have no interest in peace, blockading and imprisoning the entire population of Gaza and wilfully building illegally on Palestinian land. I wish the Palestinians luck in their vote in September!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:23 AM on 08/30/2011
Riiight, the Jewish name was much less disgraced when the Jews simply went to the slaughterhouse without making a fuss, eh?

Now, look at them.....they just can't stop complaining about being killed and doing things to stop from being killed. I mean, even though they have offered to share the land numerous times and the folks trying to kill them refuse to share it, what right have they to whinge about it?

Eh, eh, wot, wot, say n'more, eh? eh?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rianna
02:11 PM on 08/28/2011
There is hope after all. UN envoy sees inevitability of Palestinian state in September Obviously Israel
now recognizes the fact that the rest of the world supports a Palestinian statehood, and that the
world is sending Israel a message, it's oppression of over 1.5 million people and their suffering is
not accepted. Bibi shows his true colors by NOT attending the UN conference in September.
He apparently cannot take the criticism that will be directed at him. Looks like Bibi's courage is
only restricted to the WH and Congress. Outside that, he acts like a coward.

Accepting the obvious:

http://www.haaretz.com/print-edition/news/un-envoy-prosor-israel-has-no-chance-of-stopping-recognition-of-palestinian-state-1.381062
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:24 AM on 08/30/2011
The UN vote won't change anything unless the violence against Israel ceases, which is pretty much what has been the status quo since '48.
photo
Boduognat
Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'entrate.
01:29 PM on 08/28/2011
Things are starting to look rather gloomy for Israel.

Israel is continuing to isolate itself from the rest of the world, like lemmings heading towards an abyss. If ever their only remaining friend, or rather, ally, would ever turn its back on them.....

but, just like Odysseus and Samson, (ironic... the first ever suicide terrorist) Israel is blinded by it's own fury and frustrations, that these poor people that have had to survive and endure endless oppression and occupation for generations are still not bowing their heads in submission to their Superior Masters.

Ever more people can no longer remain silent over the brutality with which the Palestinian people have been treated, and the time is rapidly approaching when the decent people will have to make a choice whether to join the courageous people like Gideon Levy, Amira Hass, Daniel Barenboim, Uri Avnery, Richard Goldstone, Norman Finkelstein, Yonathan Shapiro, Shir Hever and many others, who have shown great courage to stand up against a powerful machinery.

Gerald Kaufman, Jewish MP for the House of Commons has also spoken out meanwhile, and what he had to say can be heard and watched here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qMGuYjt6CP8
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:26 AM on 08/30/2011
First off, I think you need to re-read the story of Sampson....or else the definition of terrorist.

Second off, nothing will change until the project of destroying Israel is dropped by the Palestinians. Which is really the same as the situation has been since 1948.
photo
Boduognat
Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'entrate.
11:05 AM on 08/30/2011
My argument is that Israel is pretty much on the way to destroy itself.

What options are left?

1) A 2 state solution, which becomes ever more difficult, as Israeli expansion goes on
2) A One State Solution, offering another three possibilities:

a) A united State, with equality and civil rights and citizenship for all inhabitants
b) A united State, where Israelis and Jews enjoy full rights and citizenship, and Arabs are only second class civilians (like they are today in Israel)
c) A United State, on Israel, and the West bank and Jerusalem, where the Palestinians are ethnically cleansed, expulsed or simply kicked out (Lieberman's preferred "final solution")
03:36 AM on 08/28/2011
Heard it all before from people like the above. The Egyptians have to watch the border to avoid a repeat of when innocent Israelis were killed from the desert. So if the Egyptians watch the border it is because the Palestinians cannot be trusted not to attack Israel. You do understand this point, don't you? I didn't think so.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marjorie Sager
06:28 AM on 08/26/2011
Untill women in this part of the world can get birth control peace will never come.
photo
Boduognat
Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'entrate.
01:31 PM on 08/26/2011
Some Israeli soldiers have a birth control policy of their own for the Palestinians.

"More than 60 Palestinian women have given birth at Israeli checkpoints since 2000 and 36 of their babies have died as a result, says a UN report."

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/4274400.stm

http://www.haaretz.com/and-the-twins-died-1.61327

"The twin girls died one after the other. The first to die was the one who was born first, at the checkpoint. Several hours later came the death of her sister, who was born a few minutes after they finally left the checkpoint, and who managed to reach the hospital alive.

One lived for less than an hour, the other for less than a day. The death certificate lists their ages as one day old and zero. One died in the arms of her grandmother, the other was carried in the arms of her aunt, while their mother was lying in an ambulance, freezing, trembling, exhausted and humiliated after what she had gone through at the IDF checkpoint near her village. "
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marjorie Sager
03:51 PM on 08/26/2011
If men were forced to have 12 babys your desire for war might end.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
02:27 AM on 08/30/2011
And that bothers you even more than people lighting up a kindergarten with a machine gun on account of the kids being Jews, huh?

You seem a bit blind to one side of the conflict.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Relpo Miraculous
Psychobiological Anthropology
02:48 AM on 08/26/2011
Gazans aren't underdogs. They are full blown terrorists.
That there are Scottish citizens that think otherwise is astounding.
Here is what you are defending:

http://israelagainstterror.blogspot.com/2011/08/hamas-in-political-financial-squeeze.html

The important question is: Where does your support for these "Palestinians" emanate from?
What is the source?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
05:07 PM on 08/26/2011
It emanates from the 44 year occupation and oppression of Palestinians by the state of israel.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
11:29 PM on 08/29/2011
Funny how that stuff just also to have gone on prior to occupation etc. But don't let the facts get in the way.....
07:19 PM on 08/26/2011
So EVERY SINGLE Palestinian in Gaza is a terrorist? Yes, you´re not even a little bigoted are you.....
photo
califlefty
Oh how I miss real editors!
01:02 AM on 08/26/2011
Mr. Murray, did it ever occur to you to ask your guests to release Gilad Shalit, if not for his sake but for the sake of the Palestinians whose suffering you describe, so that Israel might reciprocate the good will gesture? If you did ask for this simple thing would it not seem "odd" that Hamas would allow mass suffering to continue for no useful purpose other then to irritate Israeli public opinion?
photo
Boduognat
Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'entrate.
12:52 PM on 08/26/2011
"reciproca­t­e the good will gesture?"

How so?

- by releasing the 10.000 prisoners Israel holds in its jails, many of which are children ?
- by offering the Palestinia­ns a 50 pound bag of potting soil, as a token of good will, aka "land for peace"?
photo
califlefty
Oh how I miss real editors!
06:37 AM on 08/27/2011
What a stupid comment - really. You know full well that Israel doesn't kidnap "innocents", but convicted terrorist, and has traded hundred of convicted terrorists and murderers for kidnapped Israelis. All you see is some false equivalency between perpetrator and victim, what a pity you are so myopic. Many children? Another lie. Yes "children" between 12 and 18 are arrested, as are teenagers in America and all over the world. How many are convicted and held in detention - again as in any other country - a couple of hundred. As for your final comment I think you've got your head so deep in "soil" your like an onion - head down, feet up.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seawolf56
Truth should never be censored
12:39 AM on 08/26/2011
hang in there Gaza! The world is listening and watching. More and more Americans are learing what has been going on and are starting to sypathies with your situation!
This comment has been removed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
new 10 ole ole
02:48 AM on 08/27/2011
When you say Gaza, you are talking to the invading Iranian and Syrian invaders who bombed peaceful neighborhoods to have only invaders present for Hamas. The natives are all dead or have been forced out. You are so misguided, or, an internet cafe poster from HAMAS.
09:21 PM on 08/25/2011
why won't you talk a humanitarian trip to south israel ???

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2drE9mVhopE
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Relpo Miraculous
Psychobiological Anthropology
02:56 AM on 08/26/2011
He won't take one either. :-(
08:47 PM on 08/25/2011
Well said Mr Murray. Don't heed the detractors. I respect where you are coming from and you are a fine Labour MP. Thankyou.
09:35 PM on 08/25/2011
you speak like taking the bus is safe for a child in israel:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NZ6p8kJ3RE4
08:03 PM on 08/25/2011
Ismail Haniyeh is reouncing violence? What about: http://forzion.com/latest/haniyeh-calls-on-fatah-to-renounce-recognition-of-israel/ and many other recent accounts of his calling for the destruction of Israel?

I'm sorry that Ian Murray doesn't agree that the blockade is necessary, but the repeated rocket attacks out of Gaza seems to indicate that it is. If you care about rockets fired at Israeli civilian targets, that is. Perhaps he doesn't.
07:29 PM on 08/25/2011
I certainly tend to agree with the causes being championed here by Murray. But I do wish he did not come across as so credulous about everything told him by the Palestinians. I doubt the Scottish relief mission has much reason to lie about the difficulties that they are having getting medical supplies into Israel. And that is shameful. But shouldn't you at least wonder if the Palestinian official telling you that sick children can't get treatment until they inform on the security situation in Gaza might be playing you?

If you don't doubt the most obvious propaganda, it becomes hard to trust you on the questions that are more possible where it would be nice to have someone reliable reporting from inside.
05:30 PM on 08/25/2011
Thanks for an honest blog about the conditions of the Palestinians. That condition is planned of course. And the sad thing is the anti-Palestinian posts which I just read. The same posters saying the same thing. Essentially they feel why shouldn't the Palestinians suffer. They are in the way of Israel and they won't stop complaining. The sad thing is ignorance or backwardness is not used to justify the sad facts. It is always the same thing. An Israeli child died. Israelis fear. Never ever any thought that if Israel built school rather than bombed them, built homes rather than destroying them, things might actually come to a conclusion acceptable to all ethical people.
05:33 PM on 08/25/2011
No they didn't. The point is the Palestinians are in a situation of their own making. Rather than peace they chose violence. Hate rather than friendship. They never miss an opportunity to miss an opportunity.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
05:30 PM on 08/25/2011
So the Palestinians are facing a shortage and the UN is helping out. So? The shortage is of their own making. At one time the Palestinians held decent jobs in Israel and made decent wages. Then their criminal leader Arafat, turned down a peace agreement and started the Intifadah to kill Jews. Almost all the Palestinians lost their jobs when they tried to kill their bosses. Did that make sense? The Palestinians shot themselves in the foot. When asked why he turned down the peace agreement he stated he didn't want to be killed like Sadat. So he screwed his people because he was a coward. Nice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Galilee
I boycott products from Syria & Gaza dictatorships
06:23 PM on 08/25/2011
Hamas Spokesman Blames Palestinians for Gaza Chaos -
"“We’ve all been attacked by the bacteria of stupidity,” Mr. Hamad wrote. “We have lost our sense of direction.” He addressed the armed groups: “Please have mercy on Gaza. Have mercy on us from your demagogy, chaos, guns, thugs, infighting. Let Gaza breathe a bit. Let it live.”

“It is strange that when a big effort is taken to reopen Rafah crossing to ease the suffering of the people, you see others who go to shell rockets toward the crossing, or when someone talks about cease-fire and its importance, you find those who go and shell more rockets,” he wrote.
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/08/29/world/middleeast/29israel.html
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gracie fr
10:34 PM on 08/25/2011
What a silly post....and by the way, if someone in your immediate family needed medical procedures and attention but the goods weren't allowed to come through the door, how would you feel and what would you do....????
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
JacksonJones
Absit iniuria verbis!
10:45 PM on 08/25/2011
Lessee.....shoot rockets at civilians? No...seems like a bad idea....

What do *you* suggest?
05:21 PM on 08/25/2011
I guess he ignored the hail of rockets and missles from Gaza into Israel. Since he had partisan blinders on, I'm not interested in his observations. Let's have a neutral observor, who'll tell the whole truth.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Nwo2012
Sue me, I boycott products from the settlements
05:42 PM on 08/25/2011
Maybe israel shouldnt have blamed Gazans for that attack week and bombed them as usual for no reason.

israel sucks.
06:03 PM on 08/25/2011
"Israel sucks"

Are you 10 years old? Grow up.
photo
Boduognat
Lasciate ogne speranza, voi ch'entrate.
09:42 PM on 08/25/2011
I guess the only "neutral" observers that would appear "neutral" enough, unlike jewish Observers like Mr. Goldstone, or Dugaard, would have to be Lieberman, Kahane (if he could) or similar people...

Who would you think is a neutral person?
09:46 PM on 08/25/2011
not you.