Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jack Howes

GET UPDATES FROM Jack Howes
 

Why Luis Suarez Won't Win Player of the Year

Posted: 12/03/2013 23:00

Liverpool's Luis Suarez may well be the best player in the Premiership right now, quite possibly the best to play in the Premier League this season. In his previous campaigns with Liverpool, people wondered just how good he could be if he found his shooting boots and turned from wayward finisher to the deadly marksman he was at Ajax. Well, this season, those people have seen their question answered.

He's an outstanding player, more often than not carrying a struggling Liverpool side on his back. His goal against Tottenham on Sunday, where he made a superb run on Jan Vertonghen's blindside then finished smoothly before Hugo Lloris in the Spurs goal had a chance to set himself up, was the work of a master marksman.

Whether he's been the best player in the Premier League this season is debatable, given the performances of Gareth Bale, Robin van Persie and Juan Mata amongst others. Steven Gerrard saying he'd be the 'best player never to win' the award is the sort of opinion that combined with his view that Joe Cole was as good as Lionel Messi upon the Englishman signing for Liverpool, will lead to nowhere else but the Match of the Day sofa or the Soccer Saturday studio when he retires from the game.

If Suarez doesn't win the award, as seems likely, it is because he is a villain of Iago-esque proportions, the bête noire of the Premier League. He's not just the player who everyone loves to hate, he genuinely is hated.

Being a villain, or even a cynical cheat doesn't necessarily make you unpopular. Eric Cantona kung-fu kicked a fan, stamped on players, threw a football at the referee, got red cards in successive league matches. And today he happens to be immensely popular, remembered with affection.

Vinnie Jones got a film career on the back of fouling other players constantly and getting sent off a lot. Robbie Savage overcame the deficiencies of inarticulacy and knowing nothing about football to be a pundit on the back of a playing career where he routinely irritated people. The on pitch brawls of the 60s and 70s are greeted with something bordering on nostalgia and not the months of headlines, suspensions and public disgrace they would generate today.

Where Suarez is so hated is because of the manner of his cheating. He dives, play acts, winds up opponents, is the type to quietly stab you in the back rather than hack someone to pieces in the front. On Sunday he had altercations with Scott Parker and Mousa Dembele, slyly tripped Dembele at one point, almost caused blows to be exchanged after the final whistle. He does this sort of thing week after week with little let up. Of course, if he was English he may well get a press far more willing to defend him. But he isn't, so he doesn't.

In England, more than any other country, breaking the rules in this manner attracts the ire of fans and pundits. However silly this attitude is, a bad tackle is criticised far less than an obvious dive. Nani's red card against Real Madrid, a dangerous challenge whether the player meant it or not, sparked widespread condemnation of the referee's decision and the press to state he'd only been going for the ball. Grant Holt's dive on Saturday, something causing no physical harm to anybody, saw diving described as 'the biggest sin in football' on the Sunday Supplement the following day.

Of course, every footballer cheats, even those who pay their subs to play in the Sunday leagues. You appeal for the throw-in you know isn't yours, insist your team has a goal kick when it clearly is a corner, scream at the ref your shot went over the line when you know deep down it barely touched the goal line. And for decades, footballers at the highest level have dived, been guilty of 'simulation', conned referees, abused officials, done more sinister things off the pitch (doping, match fixing etc) to gain an advantage.

But it's the way Suarez does it that perhaps makes him so unpopular. There's no charm to his play, no change in the way he plays. He's tumbled around Premier League pitches ever since he's arrived in England with little or no discernible improvement. Is he worse than other footballers? Probably not. Being foreign and playing for Liverpool doesn't help his reputation.

And of course, there's the elephant in the room - him being found guilty by a FA tribunal of racially abusing Patrice Evra. Whatever the circumstances of the case, he was found guilty and has never apologised for his actions. Diving, play acting, bad tackles on the pitch are one thing, racial abuse is quite another. For the rest of his career in England, his contretemps with Evra will make him impossible to like, or respect as a person.

Suarez is a wonderful player, and someone who has surprisingly little speculation linking him with moves abroad, given his prolific goalscoring, superb all round play and Liverpool looking like they'll struggle to reach the Europa League, never mind the Champions League. He scores goals, assists others, is greatly skilful and is as good a harrier of defenders and goalkeepers as there is in the game.

But he's unpopular, destined to always be unpopular, and considering his past and the baggage he brings with him, people will not want their awards associated with him.

And frankly, who can blame them?

 

Follow Jack Howes on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Debaser92

FOLLOW UK SPORT
Liverpool's Luis Suarez may well be the best player in the Premiership right now, quite possibly the best to play in the Premier League this season. In his previous campaigns with Liverpool, people wo...
Liverpool's Luis Suarez may well be the best player in the Premiership right now, quite possibly the best to play in the Premier League this season. In his previous campaigns with Liverpool, people wo...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 42
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
21:21 on 13/03/2013
This article was brutal. No wonder this guy is a "freelance" writer...Jack Howes, you are a farce.
16:21 on 13/03/2013
My previous comment was directed at DIJIT44,it came out below someone else.
16:15 on 13/03/2013
Its not the player of the year trophy he deserves,its an "Oscar" ! Just look at the dive at the weekend against Spurs,it looked as if someone had shot him!
16:31 on 19/03/2013
i think you are confusing him with Bale who is now being booked in almost every game for his dives. The penalty that was given was correct, stop being a racist bigot.
08:35 on 20/03/2013
Where does the term "racist bigot "come from? Is that your answer to any critism of Liverpool players ? Are you a politician? 
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pat Brand
Getting on a bit, but loving every day I get.
16:12 on 13/03/2013
You are such a knob'ead. Surez brings interest and unpredictability to the sport. Are you really a serious journalist. I don't think so!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jack Howes
21:11 on 13/03/2013
I'm not a serious journalist in actual fact.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
19:28 on 18/03/2013
Surez has already become player of the year to the people that matter,
Liverpool Fans, he's the best thing since Mobile phones
He's Maradona, Gazza, Beardsley, dare I say Messi ok maybe not,
He's pure class on his day, and has scored great goals this season
Who else has come close to this guy, Only Bale, but he's from Wales
13:36 on 13/03/2013
Huff n Puff showing their ignorance by censoring my post containing the word "sleekit"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
12:05 on 13/03/2013
To answer the question: Simple, because Gareth Bale will win it.
16:32 on 19/03/2013
so the biggest cheat and diver in the game should win, interesting view.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
23:16 on 19/03/2013
I never said I agreed with the choice. Though interesting you say those words with context to article on Suarez.
12:04 on 13/03/2013
this is rubbish... and i get that hair cut off your hair, you look terrible
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jack Howes
21:12 on 13/03/2013
I still look better than you though probably.
00:27 on 14/03/2013
jackie, jackie jackie... you still don't get the point...
12:00 on 13/03/2013
Extremely poor and very biased journalism. Unworthy of serious discussion as the phrase "being foreign and playing for Liverpool doesn't help". Why doesn't it help because he plays for Liverpool?
I guess that the author's need to write something to stir up controversy is directed by his need to earn a crust as a freelance writer. However, his inability to see past his prejudices mean that he can never be taken seriously.
Maybe he could write yet more drivel to feed the insatiable sycophantic pro United, anti Lliverpool fans on their forums. Journalism like this should have no place here.
Sad for the Huffington Post.
10:49 on 13/03/2013
Dreadful piece of journalism.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leewhite82
Why invade a country when you can get the US to?
11:43 on 13/03/2013
and he's freelance. Who's gonna pay for such utter rubbish.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jack Howes
21:10 on 13/03/2013
You're not wrong.
08:37 on 13/03/2013
Stop pretending that you are not a Man U fan!!!.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leewhite82
Why invade a country when you can get the US to?
11:45 on 13/03/2013
Yeah, if Suarez wears the number 7 shirts at MUFC and replaces the awful Valencia, suddenly Suarez becomes a lovely guy with a "bit of a mean streak", like Roy Keane. Terrible article.
16:16 on 13/03/2013
I am, all 45 years worth!!
01:30 on 13/03/2013
When was the last time suarez dived ? stoke back in october 2012 ? yeah thats right - since then he hasnt dived once, bale dived twice in the game against liverpool and once in the inter milan game the day before.

Parker was late in on a tackle on suarez and then stood over him and shouted at him - hardly suarez doing anything wrong. Dembele and him had some afters then at the end of the game they went to shake hands and dembele slapped him on the face - which is why brad jones and downing grabbed dembele. And as suarez said in the post match interview "Sometimes people get angry on the pitch but once your off the pitch we forget about it"
16:17 on 13/03/2013
What about the Spurs game to win the penalty? It looked as if he had been shot!
16:39 on 19/03/2013
Unlike diver Bale. the most booked player for this action a man who stated in an interview that he does dive and if players get sent off that is their fault fr trying to tackle him
22:44 on 13/03/2013
Were you watching the same game as the rest of us at the weekend? Tom Daley would have been proud of that dive!
16:38 on 19/03/2013
clearly you need spec savers , even the spurs player was decent enough to hold his hands up to it.
22:37 on 12/03/2013
He dives and cheats so he doesnt deserve it but yet you give G.Bale a better chance of winning it even though he has been booked 4 times this season for diving you are nothing but a fool and a eample of the biased British media
22:46 on 13/03/2013
Couldn't agree more, Van Persie must be right up there, and no I'm not a Man Utd fan.
20:35 on 12/03/2013
Both comments, Laura and dijit are right on the spot. It's not the way Suarez behave: is the way the biased, prejudiced and racist British press treats him. Mr Howes, it is you -and all AF surroundings - who wish Suarez won't ever get any award. Don't talk for a lot of fans and other people who can watch an incredible great footballer for what he is, independently from the club he is playing for or where continent he comes from.
19:59 on 12/03/2013
Dear Mr Howes,
Luis Suarez is not going to apologize, because he didn't do anything wrong. The FA inquiry into the LS vs PE incident was a circus, where the FA decided to give a new meaning to the word "Negrito" and deciding to take P.E interpretation of "la concha de tu hermana" as just "give me a break". Basically showing that it is okay to take the word of P.E, (a player with already issues with the truth), then Luis Suarez, a just arrived player to the UK that barely spoke English. It is pathetic and laughable. Now, when he plays, "he dives" but if it is another player... oh no! The, the press and goes "how funny what he tried to do!" They are two standards, one for Suarez and one for everybody else. I don't see the press publishing anything about the ten times that Evra said, "he called me Ni....ger" and then changing this testimony to "what's wrong Negrito"... a totally different meaning. Never mind the stupid lie, "I don't talk to blacks"... Ugh DISGUSTING.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leewhite82
Why invade a country when you can get the US to?
11:48 on 13/03/2013
Suspended for 8 games for racial abuse, even though you can;t speak English. Terry showed him what proper abuse was. As a result only got 4 match ban. What is the lesson learned here?

Racially abuse in English only!
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dijit44
18:31 on 12/03/2013
If Suarez played for Alex Ferguson he would be the most beloved player on the planet and easily win the award.
Enough said about the voters and their, "sensibilities."
Given that Patrice Evera was not even supported by his own organization and teammates and the, "conviction," was a politically driven farce, it should carry no weight when discussing the player who has been the best footballer this year.
If Suarez continues the level of play he has been producing (all year, unlike either Van Persie or Bale) and does not win the award it will be an indictment of the BFA and Britain's own racism, rather than of Suarez.
19:59 on 12/03/2013
Great posting. Thank you!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Leewhite82
Why invade a country when you can get the US to?
11:49 on 13/03/2013
Can you replace the freelance donkey who wrote this article.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jack Howes
20:44 on 13/03/2013
I agree.