Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Jasmine O Connor

GET UPDATES FROM Jasmine O Connor
 

Ukraine's Homophobia is a Problem On and Off the Football Pitch

Posted: 20/06/2012 00:00

There's been much talk of racism on the Euro 2012 terraces. Homophobic chants and attacks have marred the tournament. But as most of Europe has its eyes on the field, the gay population of Ukraine have their eyes on parliament. There, two proposed bills threaten to change the game for gay rights activists in a decisive way.

In 1991 Ukraine became the first post-Soviet nation to make same homosexuality legal, with an equal age of consent for all. (In this respect it was ahead of Britain, where the age of consent was not equalised until 2001.) But this is where equality for gay people in Ukraine ends. There are no laws there to protect gay people from discrimination, and legal recognition of same sex partnerships is non-existent. In 2012, the organisers of gay pride in Ukraine were forced to cancel the event to avoid attacks from violent anti-gay groups. Three of the gay pride organisers were attacked and hospitalised.

This violence, and Ukraine's apparent lack of commitment to human rights for its gay population, has attracted EU attention. On 24 May the EU called on the Ukraine to enforce rights to peaceful assembly and freedom of expression without discrimination. Ongoing EU-Ukraine dialogue represents the early steps of Ukraine's journey towards EU membership, the number one priority of Ukraine's President Victor Yanukovych.

Given Yanukovych's personal and political commitment to EU candidacy, it would be reasonable to expect a robust response from his authorities. It might even be reasonable to expect him to be focused on protecting sexual minorities in law. Instead two bills are currently before the parliament which threaten to push Ukraine's gay population back into an iron closet - and President Yanukovych has not spoken up in opposition.

The first bill, proposed by six MPs (including some from the president's own party) would make it illegal to produce or publish any material promoting homosexuality. The second bill provides a list of outlawed activities include parades, meetings and school lessons which offer a positive view on homosexuality. According to the explanatory note the law is designed to protect public order and morality. It claims homosexuality is a threat to national security because "it leads to epidemic levels of AIDS/HIV, destroys the institution of the family and can cause a demographic crisis."

If the bills become law, negative voices about same sex relationships will be the only ones heard in public. Homophobic football chants will become one of the few ways in which children learn about gay people.

Hopefully our government can share some history lessons with Ukrainian politicians as a part of the EU's human rights dialogue. In Britain a similar law to that proposed in Ukraine, Section 28, left a generation growing up in a vacuum of information about sexual orientation. Until it was repealed in 2003, Section 28 curbed discussion about sexual orientation, leaving schools unable to protect children from homophobic bullying in the playground. And at a time when HIV and Aids cut thousands of young men down in their prime, Section 28 made it harder for those most at risk to receive information to help them make informed choices.

The proposed Ukrainian laws go much further than the malicious Section 28. If they are passed, many more negative outcomes will need to be added to the above list - not least a politically and economically difficult between Ukraine and the EU. This is a relationship the people of Ukraine can ill afford. It's fitting that Stonewall, which was set up to fight Section 28 in Britain, today stands with Ukraine's fledgling gay equality campaigners to support their fight against discrimination.

Nobody knows who will win Euro 2012. Nobody knows if Ukraine's legislature will pass the bills into law. But history does tell us that nobody will really win if they do.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
There's been much talk of racism on the Euro 2012 terraces. Homophobic chants and attacks have marred the tournament. But as most of Europe has its eyes on the field, the gay population of Ukraine hav...
There's been much talk of racism on the Euro 2012 terraces. Homophobic chants and attacks have marred the tournament. But as most of Europe has its eyes on the field, the gay population of Ukraine hav...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 7
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Mneme
The truth shall make ye fret.
01:51 AM on 06/24/2012
I have to say that Ukraine's leaders can't really be that bright if they're going to sacrifice EU membership to enforce a law which, in reality, isn't going to make the slightest difference towards preserving or elevating anybody's standard of living. Is it really worth missing out on the potential benefits of being an EU member just so a few very silly people can have the smug satisfaction of putting 'the gays' in their place?
I suppose if you're an affluent government official who is confident of getting a strong idiot vote by creating a fictional threat out of a traditionally marginalized minority, then probably yes, it is worth it.
04:52 PM on 06/20/2012
I think the reason why Ukraine appears to be so backwards in its ideology regarding homosexual rights is that the Soviet Union had been around for so long. That regime beat the living daylights out of every individualist during the 20th Century, and now that such draconian measures are gone, people don't know how to handle it.

The bills that are being proposed in Parliament, and the violent actions that are being committed at Euro 2012 are without a doubt damnable. But I think we need to stand back from the retaliation a little bit and realize that these people are behind in progressive thought. It's new to them still. We can only hope that things will be better for the community in Eastern Europe as a whole, but hope's turn into reality is going to take a lot more time for them than we think.
02:51 PM on 06/20/2012
Laws can not change peoples opinions, all laws will do is make people two-faced and liars, why is it ok for homosexuals and non-Whites to publically say they are proud to be who they are but not White heterosexuals... children of today do not even know the supposed reason of " Non-Whites and Homosexuals were treated bad by ancient Whites, so Whites of today should feel ashamed of what their ancestors did "... all children of today see is that Non-Whites and Homosexuals get " special treatment " that goes way beyond equality... Whites should not feel bad for what their ancestors did.. that is like saying " Punish the child for the sins of the Father "... it goes against everything the Homosexuals/Non-Whites are asking for isnt it ?????
12:57 PM on 06/20/2012
Since wall-fall, EU has dispersed tens of billions to Newly Independent Countries through TACIS and PHARE.

From reading hundreds of proposed project specs I concluded that no attempts were being made to tie any conditions to this aid to changes which would strengthen democratic conceptions of the rule of law which, of course, encompasses full human rights.

On the contrary, there was an eager willingness to appease every post-commie jumped up proto-fascists set of gangsters that grabbed state power. The financing of dozens of school history books (each one a nationalists diatribe) illustrates this process. There was a lost opportunity to create a common history curriculum for Europe.

This appeasement was called 'stabilization.'

Perhaps gay organizations in the UK should be asking why during these years, they were apparently oblivious to what was going on.
11:09 AM on 06/20/2012
Although they were formerly Communist these countries tend to be very 'conservative' - small 'c' note - in their social attitudes, and especially towards sexuality.. I'm not that surprised to be honest on these laws being put through in the Ukraine.. The EU needs to beware of the countries it lets in without a second thought. The Ukraine is not alone in its attitudes towards 'gay' people, look at the Baltic states, Poland etc the same pattern emerges Gay hatred - and rampant anti-Semitism!!!!!!!!!
Maybe with enough EU leverage these nasty local laws will either not be enacted or simply fade quickly away...
08:36 AM on 06/20/2012
The fight for acceptance and equality is advanced in the west. Gains have been made. In eastern Europe and Africa the battle is in in full flow. Usually reason wins out. I offer my unconditional support to the gay communities everywhere the struggle is taking place. We shall overcome . C.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
gutenmorgen
a.k.a. crowsnest
06:28 PM on 06/19/2012
The most wrenching aspect of this vile Ukrainian (and Russian) discrimination and beating of homosexuals is the fact that there would be no Ukraine and most Ukrainian males would be dead or in Siberia had not hundreds of thousands Soviet gays participated in kicking the German occupiers out of Ukraine. These Ukrainian monsters and their political helpmates deserve the highest degree of contempt and the Dutch government should never allow Ukraine to join Europe until its treatment of gays is the same as in the Netherlands (I believe that admission must be unanimous).