Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
John Coventry

GET UPDATES FROM John Coventry
 

Been There, Done That, Refused to Wear the T-shirt: How the Kick It Out Furore Reveals a Challenge Facing Campaigners

Posted: 22/10/2012 01:00

To put it how a player might, football's had a shocker. After a week of abject racism and thuggery, Reading striker Jason Roberts was joined by Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand and other professional footballers in deciding to make a point about racism in football by not wearing the Kick it Out t-shirt. Manchester United manager Alex Ferguson fined Rio for not wearing it, having said previously of Roberts that "There shouldn't be sheep wandering off" in one of the most staggering displays of point missing ever recorded.

Along with approximately 6.3 million other people who've written about this I remember what football used to be like. It was grim and horrible and the black players who went out and played every week despite the monkey chants and the bananas deserve to be lauded in every possible way for standing up to bigots and morons. Alongside them organisations like Let's Kick Racism Out of Football (the organisation which became Kick it Out) were instrumental in radically shifting the culture of football to one where, by and large, racism is considered unacceptable. People of all backgrounds stood shoulder to shoulder and made football grounds better for players and fans alike, and they deserve huge credit for that.

In terms of what it says about campaigning, the weekend's footy furore highlights a genuine challenge which faces many organisations at some point. It runs like this:

  1. A problem is identified
  2. Individuals get together to change the problem
  3. They have some success, as institutions in charge of the problem area make the investment and structural changes necessary
  4. The organisation finds itself, therefore, closer to the institution it was challenging
  5. The organisation is then seen by some as weakened by this proximity to the power it once sought to challenge

Jason Roberts felt that Kick it Out haven't spoken out strongly enough on the high profile racism cases in football in the past year. On that basis, he was right not to follow other t-shirt wearing players like a sheep, as Fergie would put it. It's started a debate and will ultimately help focus the minds of racism in football campaigners.

If I were advising Kick it Out I would say that they need to get on the front foot and tell the story of the huge impact they've had (which is true and they should be shouting about it) and how they plan to keep the fight going. I might even try - externally at least - to put a bit of blue water between them and the FA, if even to show that they are still on this side of the players and the fans they were set up to help.

The perceived credibility of organisations is a subjective issue and one which is constantly changing. If you engage with campaigning organisations a lot, they will do and say things you agree with and disagree with. No one cares as much about organisations as the people working within them and I can tell you from experience that this also leads to some robust internal discussions. This is good. Campaigning for change is not an exact science - it's an ever evolving discourse, a battle of ideas and trends which often veers off in unexpected directions based on external influences. This is why it's amazing. It's also why it's incredibly frustrating.

The lesson here is, to me, clear. Credibility is fundamental to campaigning organisations. People need to trust you in order to back your campaign and - crucially - tell someone else about it. They want to know you are speaking out and standing up for what you believe in. But you also need to have some access to those in power if you are to get them to listen to you and secure change. This isn't always pleasant and often requires some compromise. It's an incredibly tough balance to strike and while very few organisations do it really well, those that manage it are the ones that make a real and lasting difference.

 

Follow John Coventry on Twitter: www.twitter.com/johnnycov

FOLLOW UK SPORT
To put it how a player might, football's had a shocker. After a week of abject racism and thuggery, Reading striker Jason Roberts was joined by Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand and other profe...
To put it how a player might, football's had a shocker. After a week of abject racism and thuggery, Reading striker Jason Roberts was joined by Manchester United defender Rio Ferdinand and other profe...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 6
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:54 PM on 10/22/2012
Seeing John Terry wearing an anti racism armband or T shirt, would be like seeing Lance Armstrong wearing a yellow jersey. It reeks of hypocrisy and is completely lacking in credibiity. Andrew Mitchell resigned so should JT.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paul679
01:54 PM on 10/22/2012
I don't know why the black footballers who refused to wear that shirt are being criticised. They are quite right to be annoyed with the F.A.'s (and FIFA's) inertia on racism. And although I can understand Alex Ferguson being frustrated over Rio Ferdinand, he has no right to force any political will on him.

All of football's organisations are pathetic and hypocritical when it comes down to taking responsibility.
01:44 PM on 10/22/2012
what is the point of wearing a t shirt with a particular logo or statement on it? What effective sanctions are there when players or fans behave in a racist way?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ccraiglamont
Sometimes funny, other times...not!
12:23 PM on 10/22/2012
Fifa, Uefa and every National Football association needs to adopt a zero tolerance approach to racism in the game.
Racist chants at domestic level? Make teams play behind closed doors.
Racist chants at International level? Ban teams from competing in International tournaments.
Racist behaviour on the field? Ban any player found guilty sine die.
Racist behaviour on social networking sites? See Racist behaviour on the field.
11:04 AM on 10/22/2012
You get the impression the powers that be in the FA just want to sweep this issue under the carpet. It makes them uncomfortable – they simply don't know what to do. "Shake hands, wear the T-shirt, shut up". That's the response. If someone called me a "darkie" a dozen or so times, I can safely say I would never shake his hand. Why on earth would I? It is these attitudes Rio et all are protesting against, and rightly so. It's all a bunch of lip service. If someone gets a fine for wearing branded pants that's four times larger than for racially abusing someone, what's the point? That a message in and of itself of how the FA feels about it. All of these campaigns are doomed, any how. One could "kick out" racism from the game no easier than one could kick racism out of the "real world". Football is the real world, after all. And racism, sadly, is a part of the human race, and always will be.
03:38 PM on 10/22/2012
Sorry,Rio was only interested in Rio getting his England captaincy back nothing more.