Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
John Wight

GET UPDATES FROM John Wight
 

Letter To A Soldier

Posted: 27/12/11 17:49

Three years ago you launched your murderous air assault against 1.5 million men, women, and children hermetically enclosed in the most overcrowded piece of land on earth - the Gaza Strip. Starved, besieged, yet unbowed, they could do nothing except endure as your bombs and your missiles rained down, targeting hospitals, schools, civic buildings, homes, police stations, and even UN compounds where people had sought sanctuary; still believing, despite decades of disappointment and betrayal, in the sanctity and protection of international law.

Your bombs sought and found their victims, incinerating and blowing to smithereens young and old alike, at the same time as your government attempted to convince the world that every effort was being made to avoid civilian casualties in what they described as a military operation to root out terrorism and provide security for its citizens. Yet as Albert Camus once warned, the welfare of the people has always been the alibi of tyrants.

After the air assault you began your ground invasion, and who could ever forget the pictures of you and your comrades, fully armed and equipped for combat, marching into the night, marching over the hopes and lives of the children who in just a few hours were destined to be blown apart by the guns and the bullets you carried so proudly as a testament to your superior civilisation and values. You were marching into a part of the world which you had ensured remained cut off from the rest of humanity, a punishment you inflicted on the people living there for daring to exercise their democratic right to choose their own government? But this government refuses to recognise us, you asserted, revealing a grotesque expectation be recognised by a people that have been systematically expropriated, brutalised, and dehumanised since 1948, when your state was formed.

By the end of your air and land assault, which lasted 22 days, you left 1400 dead behind. Among those were 400 children and 100 women, along with thousands more maimed and traumatised. The meagre medical facilities available to the people there, facilities purposely and cynically starved of supplies, equipment and medicines throughout a siege which up to that point had lasted 18 months, could not cope with the sheer number of casualties you created, many with injuries so horrific they were unrecognisable as human beings. To you however this was a matter of little concern, because you had already refused to recognise them as human beings long before.

Gaza was in ruins, thousands left homeless with no materials with which to rebuild shattered lives, each entitled to ask again if to be born Palestinian is to be born less than human; entitled to ask if they'd been condemned by the great powers to a fate of dissolution and extinction as a people - their history, culture and rights denied - considered children of a lesser god?

But no matter the calumny and lies employed by your government, by their spokesmen and women, who appeared on our TV screens with the confidence of those who claim to act in the name of democracy and civilisation, who claim to speak and act in the name of past victims of genocide and mass murder, the Palestinians continue to refuse to play the role chosen for them by you and by your supporters among those Western governments which have long since given up the right to describe themselves as champions of human rights. No, the Palestinians refuse to acquiesce in their own destruction, and drawing hope from the truth that man never made anything as resilient as the human spirit, they continue to endure.

And something changed after Gaza one year ago; something which no amount of hasbara and lies will ever be able to change back again. The world saw with its own eyes that Israel is not the besieged victim beset on all sides by savage enemies bent on its destruction as it claims. As they came out in their unprecedented millions across the world, people understood as they had never understood before that the state you serve has never shaken in its belief that the continued dispossession and immiseration of the Palestinian people is the condition for its continued survival and prosperity. It is the lie which sits at the very heart of the matter, the lie which must and one day shall finally give way to a truth that cannot be denied: the inalienable right of all peoples to freedom and self determination.

In their millions around the world, and increasingly within Israel itself, people have declared that no longer will they stand by and bear witness to occupation, oppression, and barbarism carried out in the name of progress. Too many times in the past the world has stood by, with the names and dates of past atrocities a warning of the abyss into which humanity has sunk before and could sink again unless the world remains vigilant.

Guernica 1937: the Warsaw Ghetto 1942: My Lai 1968: Fallujah 2003: and now Gaza 2008/09.

The victims of each of the aforementioned are joined by a common bond of humanity that transcends race and religion. They are history's victims, and as such they belong to all of us. Not only that they sit in judgment on what we, the living, do in their name to rectify the crimes committed against them.

It is not vengeance the world seeks, but justice - and justice for the Palestinians can only begin when the injustice that has placed a wall around your own humanity is ended. End the siege, tear down the apartheid wall, remove the checkpoints, and free not only those you have imprisoned all these years but just as important - free yourself.

You affirm time and again that Israel has the right to exist. Yes, but not as an apartheid state, not as a state which exists at the negation of a people whose only crime is that they continue to exist on land which you have long since decided belongs to you. No matter how many tanks, fighter jets, and missiles you may possess in your vast arsenal of weapons, the refusal of this tortured, wretched people to disappear into the night of history weakens you. For it acts as an uncomfortable reminder that when you return to your family each night after doing your duty, you do so with your humanity diminished.

It is why we say to you now, three years on, that you are living on the wrong side of history - in a cold, lonely place called dishonour.

 
Three years ago you launched your murderous air assault against 1.5 million men, women, and children hermetically enclosed in the most overcrowded piece of land on earth - the Gaza Strip. Starved, bes...
Three years ago you launched your murderous air assault against 1.5 million men, women, and children hermetically enclosed in the most overcrowded piece of land on earth - the Gaza Strip. Starved, bes...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
h111aryc1inton
Just trying to tell the truth
13:26 on 09/01/2012
Rarely does Huffpo run a piece that is so one sided - so full of out right lies - there is no attempt to even pretend to be off even handed.

All the reasonable thinkers must have taken off between Christmas and New Years.
17:00 on 05/01/2012
'6 years ago and it's starting to look like "one election, one-time." How come you ilks never seem to notice this, never mind Hamas' use of violence to sieze control of Gaza? So much for "the most democratic election ever ...."'

Yes, how dare they fail to hold another election. After all, in Gaza, they've only been keep imprisoned in a ghetto in Gaza for 6 years, starved, immiserated, and bombed to smithereens. And as for the rest of them living in the West Bank, the fact their land is covered with over 500 Israeli checkpoints making freedom of movement impossible, the fact they live daily under illegal occupation, intimidation, settlements expansion, none of that justifies their inability to hold free, fair and democratic elections.

What's wrong with those people? Maybe they need to be terrorised a little more to make them fit for democracy and civilisation.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
22:56 on 04/01/2012
where to even start to dismantle all the outright l.i.e.s.

here:
'You affirm time and again that Israel has the right to exist. Yes, but not as an apartheid state, not as a state which exists at the negation of a people whose only crime is that they continue to exist on land which you have long since decided belongs to you.'

1. Israel in factDOES have a right to exist, and will continue to do so.
2. 'apartheidState'…really? with more than 20% of Israel's population being Arrabb….who sit on the knesset, and even supreme court….who own homes, land….
3. what about the indiscriminate rokts fired into israeli civilian comunities on a daily basis?
> what about the INTENTIONAL targting of Israel's civilians with bomms, sniiper fire, missliles?
> what about the ha mas charter, or the words spoken by Palezinian leaders as recently as days ago….calling for the anhillationn of Israel.
>what about the humann bomms that have shattered the lives of Israeli civilianss on buses, in restaurants, at social events, even the mall?
>what about sniipers invading a yeshiva and slawtering only young children at study, or intentionally targting childrens school buses with missilles?

there is in fact, reason for theBlockade
so please,spare me the 'they haven't done anything other than exist' propaagandda.
why not tryTRUTH….cause while yu have aRight to ure own opinion,
yu do not have the right to ure own facts, which isExactly what this piece is.
photo
SaneUSA
American, Jew, Zionist.
18:59 on 04/01/2012
You should be writing fiction...your grasp of the truth is less than tenuous.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gui Montag
Former Palestinian Supporter
19:58 on 02/01/2012
One word: Propaganda.
10:40 on 02/01/2012
It's hard to know where to begin with a comment full of half truth, untruth and outright lies.

Hamas were democratically elected by the Palestinians back in 2006 in what at the time was adjudged by international monitors the most democratic election ever to have taken place in any Arab state. That they managed this while their land was under an illegal Israeli military occupation was astounding. Hamas, and their charter, has been used as a bogeyman by Israel and its apologists to justify apartheid, siege, collective punishment and the continued violation of Palestinian human rights. The aforementioned did not begin with the emergence of Hamas, they were taking place before Hamas was even founded. It should be noted here that Hamas were funded and supported by Israel early in their development in an attempt to undermine Fatah, who at the time were Israel's Palestinian bogeyman of choice. By now you should begin to see a pattern

It really is a grotesque and obscene inversion of the truth to blame the victims of oppression for their own oppression.

Hamas are not the cause of Israel's brutality. They are a symptom of it.
15:03 on 05/01/2012
"Hamas were democratic­ally elected by the Palestinia­ns back in 2006"

6 years ago and it's starting to look like "one election, one-time." How come you ilks never seem to notice this, never mind Hamas' use of violence to sieze control of Gaza? So much for "the most democratic election ever ...."
15:56 on 01/01/2012
Rhetorical piffle. Israel entered Gaza only a few years after handing it outright to the Palestinians as a gesture of peace. A dictatorial Hamas government betrayed its people and fired missiles into civilian areas. What country, do you imagine, would stand idly by and watch its people threatened with death? Half the Gaza casualties were terrorist fighters. They used Palestinians as human shields. Before assaults, the Israeli army sent warnings to civilians in the regions they planned to assault, warning them to move aside until the assault had been made. Hamas took advantage of this by forcing civilians onto rooftops, whereupon the assault in question would be called off. You confuse a morally decent armed force seeking to defend its civilian population from attack with a suicidal, bitter, ruthless theocratic sectarian movement bent on the genocide of all Jews. If you don't believe that, you know nothing of Hamas. You should read their 1988 Charter. Like other Palestinian and Arab groups, they openly state that they will never negotiate with Israel, never recognize Israel, and never make peace with Israel. And you condemn the Israelis? There is no dishonour in defending innocent civilians. There is nothing but shame for Hamas and other Palestinian terrorist gangs who believe that sending a suicide bomber into a crowded restaurant or onto a bus packed with children is a righteous and moral thing to do. Shame on them and shame on you for writing such a squalid article stuffed with your own self-righteousness.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
22:29 on 04/01/2012
Fanned Fanned Fanned!