Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joseph Stashko

GET UPDATES FROM Joseph Stashko
 

We Need a Public Enquiry, not a Lynch Mob for News International

Posted: 10/07/11 21:21 BST

It's hard to take in the magnitude of how the News of the World saga has ended. After Nick Davies' dogged determination to investigate phone hacking during Rebekah Brooks' time as editor of the paper, News International has decided to kill the paper dead in the water and consequently 200 staff lose their jobs.

It's unacceptable on so many levels. Unacceptable that so many journalists who weren't at the paper during the time of the hacking are now jobless. Unacceptable that Rebekah Brooks still survives. And unacceptable that Colin Myler has said that the Guardian were "out to get us".

So what now? Despite the mass calls for heads to roll (Twitter fuelled this fire), even if Brooks joined her staff in the job centre it wouldn't be a desirable outcome. There's a danger that such a dramatic move will cause a distraction from what is really needed - an efficient, independent, public enquiry that includes journalists, proprietors and police. The calls of derision that have met Brooks' claims that she will investigate the hacking herself are an indication that it's time for the matter to be brought to a conclusion properly.

Earlier today, Ben Goldacre tweeted that this was "just like the bankers all over again". This is true, but with one important difference - no one ever liked bankers. This and the Hari case (which now looks like a damp squib in comparison) have all but destroyed public trust in journalists at a time when the profession should be placing the engenderment of trust at the heart of what they do.

The issue has united many from left and right - seldom do you find liberal bloggers agreeing on principle with Guido Fawkes, and the news regarding Millie Dowler earlier this week only heightened this.

The Labour party, which until Wednesday had remained quiet, suddenly sprung into life with Ed Miliband overtly calling for Brooks' resignation in prime minister's questions, with Yvette Cooper and Chris Bryant also in an outspoken mood.

By closing the News of the World Murdoch has scored a temporary coup in that attention has been drawn to the plight of his sticken journalists, rather than the allegations of phonehacking themselves.

But this should not stop the enquiries - it's time to get to the truth that Nick Davies has been digging at all these years.

 

Follow Joseph Stashko on Twitter: www.twitter.com/JosephStash

 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
06:19 PM on 07/10/2011
It took a couple of backbench MPs years to bring the News of the World to this point and it helped them by shooting itself in both its feet. In that time countless lives were wrecked by journalists who acted as if they were above the law and unaccountable for what they did. The same is true of self regulating groups like OS:Property. They also wreck lives without a second thought. Who speaks up for them? Who investigates what they get up to? Regulators in this country do not protect us the public from powerful organisations.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
TXfemmom
Grandma with eye on the future
05:42 PM on 07/10/2011
One news report I saw said Murdoch closed the newspaper in an attempt to limit the legal and financial liabilities associated with it.  My closing it, I would presume it would be treated as a bankrupt organization.
photo
Gavin Saunders
we only have each other
02:53 PM on 07/10/2011
Joseph, why do you take for granted that tabloids, especially those run on a shoestring the way Muckmurdoch runs them, should have ever existed at all? For the most part they trade on the misery of others and those so called 'journalists' must be in denial if they're proud of what they do.

Muckmurdoch ratchets up the stakes for all when he won't pay for the time and expense for legitimate investigating, opting instead for either making up stories or spying on people; whatever it takes to get circulation up so he can play the kingmaker and in then have those he helped put or keep in power, do his bidding.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:41 PM on 07/13/2011
'Trading on the misery of others'. Yes, the tabloids are a sorry excuse to accompany the broadsheets on the newsstands, but let's not forget the public's voracious appetite for gossip and nonsense of that nature. Dangerous yes, but popular, even more so. They embody a nature that has existed for longer than the honourable circulation of news. It's naive to suggest otherwise.
And I'd be cautious in criticising the journalists themselves - did any of the 200-odd people fired last week have any real control over their output, or their fate? Or is it all down to the call of their editors?
01:44 PM on 07/10/2011
The News of the World is part of a powerful organisation that seems to have taken its management style from a Stasi operations handbook. Most reasonable people would agree that there needs to be a public inquiry into the running of the News of the World.
But it is not the only company that conducts itself as if it is accountable to no-one. I have been calling for a public inquiry into the running of OS:Property for over a year. I have asked for a judicial review of our cases and for compensation for those of us who have suffered an eye wateringly ludicrous and illogical Final Decision at the hands of the Ombudsman.
We at the Ombudsmans61percent Campaign are thankful for the intervention of Oliver Colvile MP for Plymouth Sutton and Devonport. But why hasn't a single British newspaper shown any interest in the plight of those unfortunate individuals who turn to this organisation when their survey goes badly wrong only to suffer a further injustice at the hands of the Ombudsman?
This company was set up by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors (RICS) and finds overwhelmingly in favour of its fee paying Members - surveyors.
Worse still, it has been approved by the Office for Fair Trading. This is a case of private regulators being granted credence and credibility by Government. Is this not also worthy of investigation?
Good article! Good luck! Ombudsmans61percent.