Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Joshua Funnell

GET UPDATES FROM Joshua Funnell
 

Dear BBC, More Owen Jones's on Question Time Please!

Posted: 26/11/2012 20:09

No show angers me more than BBC Question Time. Consecutive laptops have been placed in mortal danger as I watch the same poisoned formula concocted each week by the alchemists Dimbleby & co. Consequently my dad has effectively banned me from regarding it with him, due to my Peep Show (on extremely bitter steroids) style analysis of the weekly 'debate'.

Predictably, week after week the BBC wheels out what it honestly believes are a diverse panel of politicians and commentators from all sides of the political spectrum. Sadly, what the BBC doesn't seem to understand, is that in this post Thatcher land we occupy with that other lady TINA (There Is No Economic Alternative) who roams around jacked up on deregulated free market transactions, is that Question Time's 'diversity' is akin to a civilised discussion between cans of Diet Coke, Coke Zero and Coke. Liberal democracies and real choices apparently aren't guaranteed.

Bless the BBC, its part of the establishment and doesn't even know it, doddering around like a well intentioned - but naïve - community organiser for the Conservative Party. The ever 'objective' BBC for example, once reported that it was, 'a fact' that George Bush and TB wanted to, export democracy to Iraq. Media analysts Media Lens were stunned by this factual claim, so asked former head of BBC news, Helen Boaden, for evidence proving this as fact. She responded to this request, I kid you not, with three pages of quotes copy and pasted from Bush and Blair speeches in which they claimed implementing democracy to Iraq was their real objective... This embarrassing example of journalistic naivety provokes the image of a sex attack victim gratefully accepting a glass laced with Rohypnol from a would be predator. This incompetence could be excusable, even almost palatable as black comedy, if it wasn't for its corrosive impact on public discourse.

With these thoughts in mind, I riddle you to find a guest on that illustrious Question Time panel that harbours a mere atom of anti capitalist sentiment, or what we call, 'a real left alternative'. They're about as likely to appear as an enthusiastic anarchist at a Goldman Sachs recruitment centre. The sum total of this incessant exclusion is to frustrate and alienate a significant proportion of the population, who are televisionally disenfranchised. I feel this myself; you sit there over time thinking, 'f*ck, where do I come in to this discussion? Maybe my egalitarian sentiments are nuts after all, maybe conservative uncle Kev was right all along'.

But QT's makeup exemplifies a stagnant political clique; utterly unresponsive and incapable of bending to the needs of people over big business like an arthritically fused spine. So over time, this constant exclusion of alternative views drip-feeds an insidious lesson to the British people: 'This is the political line, don't cross it, we are the establishment and if you disagree, you're excluded from plonking yourself on one of these holy TV thrones'.

And so, Question Time bears partial responsibility for people not voting; it demoralises the public in to submission by exclusion of meaningful dissent. It has even provoked a number of online QT drinking games, presumably contrived to help viewers cope whilst watching. So thank Christ, Owen 'epic moisturizer' Jones arrived on the panel recently, shooting down zealots like Eastwood in a desert. Academic. Intellectual. Hero. Lad.

Admittedly, other than Owen Jones, the BBC does sometimes have a few too many shandys, goes mental and books someone like Jonny Rotten. The Rottens of the panel normally serve as de-facto left wingers/comic relief. For example, Rotten will say something inane and we're all supposed to think

'Haha, Mr Rotten has expressed an inarticulate stupid opinion, how naïve and foolish of him, unlike these sensible well groomed men in suits, left wing politics must equally be stupid and of little significance'

The net result, again, is to subliminally inform viewers 'this is the spectrum for serious men and women, and those outside this consensus aren't credible'.

By contrast Jones' appearance is an anomaly and makes him potentially dangerous to the establishment; he's an articulate, very well informed young man who can argue with the best of them. Most impressively of all, he gives professional cynics like me a sense of hope and empowerment, and if sales of his book, CHAVS, The Demonization of the Working Class, are anything to go by, I'm not alone.

His Question Time emergence was an affront to the cosy consensus that incubates the sheltered likes of Iain Duncan Smith. IDS - the uber Tory - was so clearly riled by this young punk ranger from the north, that he proceeded to address him like a child who'd spoken out of turn at a formal grownup dinner party, "we've heard quite enough from you" he chastised Jones like a schoolmaster twitching to use his cain. It was a symbolic moment, to witness a young individual confidently, cogently and unashamedly voicing a left alternative future to neo liberal fossils, undermining the QT clichés we're all so bored of.

IDS was driven to emotiveness because figures such as himself are rarely substantively challenged by political rivals; to do so would be 'ill manors'. Owen Jones was unwilling to conform to the rules of the game, he wouldn't sit there and reaffirm in a one sided fashion. He wouldn't stay silent when the UK's disabled are being driven to death by ATOS's 'fit for work' tests. Instead he called bullshit on the consensus: Iain Duncan Smith's welfare reforms destroy peoples lives - sometimes literally - pandering to the Victorian prejudices clung to by demagogues.

Voices like Jones' are an essential antidote to a putrid politics that fails to address human need. Censorship needn't be redacted passages crudely covered in black ink, or a conveniently pulled microphone cord; instead it is to simply exclude and filter out alternative views. Question Time and media content more broadly, must open it's doors frequently to the likes of Owen Jones, or mainstream media, much like mainstream politics, shall deservedly become redundant.

* If you agree with this article then do something original; contact the BBC and positively complain about Owen Jones inclusion on Question Time, demand more similar voices instead of the consistently unrepresentative public discussions we are currently granted. Make a positive complaint here:
https://ssl.bbc.co.uk/complaints/forms/?reset=#anchor

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
No show angers me more than BBC Question Time. Consecutive laptops have been placed in mortal danger as I watch the same poisoned formula concocted each week by the alchemists Dimbleby & co. Consequen...
No show angers me more than BBC Question Time. Consecutive laptops have been placed in mortal danger as I watch the same poisoned formula concocted each week by the alchemists Dimbleby & co. Consequen...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:30 on 05/12/2012
Ha ha I know!, I agree with everything you said. I was SOOOoooo impressed by him on Question Time and think he's a treasure!. We need people like him!. I tweeted him (too many times I reckon) cause he blocked me, that did taint my love for him but it still remains!!. Owen, if by any chance you see this, I am one of those "poor" people and I do have an illness and highly likely one of the people you are standing up for....please forgive a foolish girl with a bit of a crush!!, lol. You are incredible and will go far. His parents must be so proud to have a Son like you!. No hard feelings and btw way it's Twitter: @ShamemeAdams if you do ever change your mind lol!. But no, the oppressed and disadvantaged do need a figure like him and yes, he didn't half rattle IDS's cage!!. "We've heard enough from you"!! ha ha, I haven't!!. I look little for my age too and we get that when we do (I'm more chatty though than opinionated)....although can be on occasion, if need be. Owen Jones for PM!.
11:49 on 28/11/2012
I have often put the same points as you to Radio 4's Feedback programme re their radio version - Any Questions. Which is also hopelessly safe and boring. And raised it at the recent radio festival (but it was edited out of Feedback). Now, I would suggest one or two 'hot' characters like Max Keiser and turn it into a real meaningful debate. The viewing figures would soar. I will suggest to BBC for the TV Question Time and Radio 4's Any Questions. PS Any answers is usually more interesting coming from listeners but not given enough time. Do you listen to the radio version? I do think David D on radio is a good chair however.
17:47 on 27/11/2012
Good article, well put across - I enjoyed Jones' appearance as he had no voters to convince. However, few sub-ed comments here. It's 'cane', not 'cain'. And I may be missing a cleev allusion to Plan B's recent film but it's 'ill manners'. Sorry, it's a compulsive thing.
18:20 on 27/11/2012
*clever - oh the shame!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joshua Funnell
23:30 on 27/11/2012
haha, thanks friend, my spelling is an endless source of anxiety. I did have PlanB's film slightly in mind when I wrote that, so we'll call that one even :-) x
09:31 on 05/12/2012
Owen Jones for PM!
14:42 on 27/11/2012
Question Time is a product of the political environment it deals with: the well mannered manipulation of the masses. Parties' ideologies differ on paper, yet in practice they are all too similar, forever sniffing after votes, looking back at established methods of success, baptizing partisanship in the murky depths of tokenism. For my part however, when I watch QT, I find myself continuously reciting to myself, mantra-esq: 'that's the way it is, it's the ambition that counts.' Question Time maybe an ill forged attempt at political discourse, it may even make matters worse, but there is very little that doesn't to be frank. Antidote? - no idea, i just post comments in an attempt to vent and show off, making matters worse. Or maybe that's what the establishment wants me to think? Oh god! (Sorry, have had far too much coffee)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Joshua Funnell
15:06 on 27/11/2012
Thanks Joe, my first comment. Dale on coffee, I remember it well. But make it more abusive next time, I feel more at home with those x