Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Julian Tan

GET UPDATES FROM Julian Tan
 

Why Are Asians at University So Anti-Social?

Posted: 08/10/2012 00:00

I am Asian and five years ago, I flew on my first international flight alone. With three packed suitcases and a one-way ticket to the United Kingdom, I was bursting with excitement and anxiety. What awaited me at Oxford University, I hadn't the slightest clue. But one thing was certain in my mind - I wasn't about to travel halfway across the globe to immerse myself back into the comforts of my own country; I was not going to surround myself with just Asians in Oxford.

Back then, it seemed like a simple decision. I made up my mind and I stood by it, not because I had any prejudice against my own ethnicity but merely because I wanted to take advantage of my unique position - a position of being able to easily meet people of different races, cultures and backgrounds.

And so I lived this way in the first year, thinking to myself I had it all figured out. I went for staircase parties with my English friends and even went out clubbing despite never really understanding the real appeal of drinking and getting drunk, all in the name of broadening my horizons. Most of it was a lot of fun and I enjoyed my first year at university very much, having acclimatized myself to the British weather and humour.

But one thing always irked me. I couldn't understand why I was only one of the few Asians making an effort to mingle with the non-Asians. My British friends would sometimes comment on this and we would rudely label them as being anti-social. I never stopped to think why this was the case in the first place and whether or not it was a real problem.

Four years later and wiser, I realised that there are very real and legitimate reasons for this and I was only too naïve back then to understand why. Perhaps the most obvious reason is the initial culture shock of it all for international students, especially from the Far East. The cultural differences between England and China for instance, are stark; the food, the jokes and general behaviour of the people are all so different.

It can be quite unsettling to a lot of international students having to quickly adapt to the new culture and make friends with the English locals before cliques are formed. It is much easier to gravitate towards familiar people and hit it off instantly. I know for a fact that it was a real struggle for me having to give up my 'nasi lemak' (a traditional coconut rice dish found in Malaysia) for fish and chips, and having to learn to enjoy drinking and clubbing as social pastimes.

And as if having to acculturate isn't enough, for many Asians from Asia, English isn't their first language. This is probably the main reason for the appeared lack of effort to socialize made by Asians at university. Nobody wants to sound stupid and often people keep their mouths shut afraid of embarrassing themselves by saying the wrong things. This can come across as being anti-social and many of my so-called "anti-social" Chinese friends have highlighted this to me. I never really considered this before because unlike them, English is my first language. And even so, I was often made fun of for my use of the word 'pants' and my pronunciation of 'garage'. So I can only imagine how intimidating it must feel for them having to socialize outside their own circles in their second or even third language.

This sense of wanting to remain in one's comfort zone is not typical of just international students from the Far East. It is very much a common human characteristic. And some times whether local British students realize it or not, they too like to stick amongst themselves. Speaking from personal experience, I have come to realize that more often than not, I have to make the effort to go up to an English person and initiate the conversation. Otherwise, there would be no conversation between us. I think this just goes to show that everybody is a little "anti-social" to some extent. People just like the familiar.

Whether this is a problem or not isn't something I have the space or position here to discuss. But I am all for better integration between all students of all backgrounds. After all, it would be a great shame to stick to the familiar and not explore the richness and vastness of other cultures.

And the solution to this lack of integration between cultures is simple. Everyone just needs to step out of their comfort zone.

After all, comfort is the enemy of progress and growth.

 

Follow Julian Tan on Twitter: www.twitter.com/julianlipyi

FOLLOW UK STUDENTS
I am Asian and five years ago, I flew on my first international flight alone. With three packed suitcases and a one-way ticket to the United Kingdom, I was bursting with excitement and anxiety. What a...
I am Asian and five years ago, I flew on my first international flight alone. With three packed suitcases and a one-way ticket to the United Kingdom, I was bursting with excitement and anxiety. What a...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 23
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:04 AM on 11/21/2012
Not every local is big on clubbing and drinking but you do have to know how to accept and adapt to other cultures.
10:50 PM on 11/12/2012
Julian, this is so true. We travel 9000 miles away from home and nothing beats socialising with people from all around the globe!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
Might as well laugh while you still can.
09:14 PM on 10/14/2012
I had a very dubious conversation with my Indian friends at uni, we were all mixed bunch, but they qould frequently comment that you know who is muslim because they are ones that don't mix, as much as you want to be a good liberal, studying one of the liberal courses imaginable, the evidence was overwhelming! but as for Asains more to the East, they seemed well intergrated, my friend Amy (Chinese) is an absolute riot! I met her working in a shop, she'd been living in a muslim area of London for her first year here and she was beyond excited to find out our shop sold Pork Scratchings! She cracks me up!!!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:49 AM on 10/14/2012
I think it's a little harsh to call the perceived familial insularity of many young people from other cultures as anti-social.

I have issue with this assumption that integration is necessary. Integration leads to homogeneity as people seek a happy behavioral medium to maintain friendships and maybe even more intimate relationships. Cultural diversity requires a certain segregation in order to be maintained and as long as that segregation is voluntary I'm OK with it. As long as it's not extreme of course, I'm not supportive of ghettoization.
11:44 PM on 10/13/2012
I study at a university with a significant international population, and have noticed Asian students do tend to keep to themselves. In fact, I don't think I've ever spoken to one, I merely see them walking to/from lectures and the like to remind me they exist.
Having said that - if I were to be plopped into a Chinese university, I'd likely clutch to the first English speaker and never let go. So with that in mind, I believe it's a language issue more than anything. Anybody can adjust to culture changes, but language is the first barrier, and that speaks to the glaring holes in university admission's language requirements.
05:39 PM on 10/11/2012
Well done for keeping to your decision and becoming more the man of the world... your article would have been better if you'd got more into the differences between the cultures, a subject which interests everyone. We all know about the food, but the 'jokes and general behaviour' could always use a bit more elucidation. :)
11:53 PM on 10/09/2012
European expatsstick to their enclaves in Asia quite a lot too.

So really, it call comes down mingling taking a whole lot more effort than simply sticking with the familiar. The path of least resistance.

It may also have something to do with simple statistics: the net flow of human movement is much more heavily biased towards Asians heading to the wealthier West than vice versa. Therefore, you're more likely to get the less adventourous sort going from Asia to Europe for example, but for European to venture into Asia long term requires a much more open attitude anyway.
12:40 PM on 10/08/2012
I believe culture shock did take place during my first year in here.I was terrified of uncertainty and being first time abroad,really explains my recluse behaviour. It’s a whole new world we’re talking about.Language barrier really had somehow affected my confidence to confront locals.I hardly understood local slangs and their thick accents somehow did intimidate me that I resorted to slowly withdrawing myself away from them.The kind of the jokes they shared greatly differed to what I had in Malaysia. What I consider as funny is considered as offensive to them.That really had turned me off from socialising.

I think my lack of confidence might somehow be explained by the culture that I was brought up. We have this gender segregation sort of thing.Despite that, this doesn’t reflect every Malaysian. I was taught to try to keep some distance from the opposite sex except when it comes to professionalism. Hence, I have this tendency to avert my eyes from looking straight into a man’s eyes.

And for this third year,my final year.I tell myself to quit running away.Face your fear. So I try my very best to be more active in volunteering works as well as to take part time jobs. Only that can help me to practise my English as well as building my confidence to speak despite the wrong choice of words or jumbled up tenses.
05:44 PM on 10/11/2012
You sound like you're doing great/
This comment has been removed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GavinSaunders
Bollox.
10:11 AM on 10/08/2012
I British and I hate British culture.Drink 'til you're sick,ugh..
05:42 PM on 10/11/2012
On *that* part of British culture (and it's a fair slice) I agree.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
GavinSaunders
Bollox.
12:55 AM on 10/12/2012
Actually,I like some parts of British culture,most of it history tho..
10:00 AM on 10/08/2012
Some Asians seem to regard western society with deep contempt, and want nothing to do with it other than benefitting from the infra-structure and income opportunities it provides. The author of the above piece makes some good points, but his highlighting of excessive drinking and of clubbing as key elements of western society is unfortunate. They may well be for teenagers, media luvvies, and popstars, for example, but not at all for the majority of the population.
05:26 AM on 10/08/2012
Stop drinking, start gambling.

Voila, Asian friends!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:10 AM on 10/08/2012
Funny and true!
11:57 PM on 10/07/2012
It is not uncommon for me to hear people saying, "Get out of your comfort zone and immerse yourself in the British culture", just because I don't always join them in their drinking/social events. To me, there is absolutely no reason for me to try to be someone else and force myself to embrace all that drinking/clubbing lifestyle when I don't enjoy it. British culture is much more than that and international students (not just Asians) should try to explore more of that instead of just drinking/clubbing. Musicals, plays, operas, the brilliant collection of arts and museums, orchestra, and classical music performances are also part of the Western culture worth exploring.

Last but not least, we should maintain our Asian values even while being abroad so that the Westerners can learn about our culture too! There is no point of being a Westerner wannabe when you are clearly not. I cringe when I hear Asians trying to mimic the British accent. Be proud of our culture and don't try too hard to someone else! Westerners love to learn about our culture too, so I am and will always be proud to explain what "nasi lemak" is to my Western friends.

- A proud Malaysian too!
11:57 PM on 10/07/2012
Fair question to ask; and while some of your explanations may apply to general Asians, there are also other valid reasons. Personally, as an Asian in a UK university myself, I did try to get into the Western social culture too at the beginning but I soon realised I just couldn't keep up with the drinking culture. It is easy to say that you do not need to drink in order to socialise with the Westerners but if you are the only sober one surrounded by drunkards in the pub, you might understand. Having said that, I still do enjoy the company of my Western friends in pubs once in a while, but just not every other days or every week.

The other thing is that some of us Asians are also more thrifty and tend to save money instead of going out drinking all the time. We like eating in with a group of friends (think cost saving hot pots and pot luck dinners/lunch) - these are typically what Asians enjoy doing socially and the Westerners don't. I realise that people here do live on the edge without much savings as well, again in contrast to the general Asian style of living and saving money for the future. So when we Asians say no to a pub crawl or clubbing night, it doesn't mean we are anti-social - we just don't think we should swap our hard earn cash for hangovers.

It is not uncommon for me to hear
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paul679
11:53 PM on 10/07/2012
I live in a suburb close to the centre of Newcastle, where Chinese of all age groups live: old and middle-aged Chinese (who have lived here for some time) plus their children, and plenty of Chinese students too - on my doorstep. I have never - in 20 years - seen any of them mingling with any other ethnicity. The students may (for all I know) when at college, but I've never seen it in my vicinity.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
songster
75 %plus 10
12:06 AM on 10/10/2012
Good point Paul, but no rampaging from them at the slightest upset?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paul679
12:55 PM on 10/10/2012
That's right songster. There's never a hint of trouble or childish hysteria from the Chinese. They just keep their own company, which is disappointing and no more than that.