Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Justin Cash

GET UPDATES FROM Justin Cash
 

If We Keep Teaching our Children to be Selfish, We Can't Bemoan a Culture of Egoism

Posted: 16/07/2012 00:00

From the very day they are born, our children are told that life is a competition. They are told that they must work their hardest to be quicker, stronger, sharper and more successful than their peers. They are told to follow their aspirations, and to not let anything or anyone stand in their way.

It recently struck me how well these sentiments resonate with our current climate of egoism. We bemoan the selfishness of bankers and politicians who have discarded the interests of so many others to reach the positions of wealth and authority that we equate with success.

But, with our prevailing parental teachings in mind, should we be at all surprised by their behaviour? Isn't it what we wanted from our progeny all along? After all, they have successfully reached high flying, ostensibly respectable positions in society. They have climbed the ladders. They have accumulated wealth and status, beating so many others to the punch.

Isn't it strange that the people we currently despise so much live the life of affluence that we all want for our children? They embody the character traits we wish to instil in our own flesh and blood, and they are the very same 'winners' that we all wish our children to be.

But no matter how much we stigmatise self-centered elites in the work place, I am willing to bet their parents are still proud of what they have accomplished, despite their often destructive influence on our society. The reason for this should be blindingly obvious because, at the end of the day, it's a bias as clear as any other: we remain blind to the moral defects of our own offspring. Every parent wants a 'winner' for a son or daughter, no matter the cost to others.

The pernicious moral message of egoism that we deliver to our children will continue to be passed down from generation to generation as long as having an 'unsuccessful' child is deemed socially unacceptable. Espousing a doctrine of self-fulfilment drives certain individuals to be excellent, sure, but individualism can never enforce upon societies the cooperative behaviours that they need to develop and to flourish.

What's worse is that we still rely on fallible test scores to judge academic excellence and intelligence, and from these we incorrectly infer which individuals are of most value to society. Arguably nurses, social-carers and charity workers do more to promote the communal good than bankers, businessmen, and politicians respectively. But our parents teach us to emulate the later and not the former group of professions, partly because of the massive divergence in remunerations between them.

So here's what I want to teach my kid: that his interests are no more important than anyone else's. That to sacrifice his own wants in pursuit of a greater good is not just an acceptable mode of living, but is in fact the most desirable one. That he should not leave his life to the mercy of his own fancies or passions, but to always keep in mind how his actions will impact upon others.

It was Einstein who once said "try not to become a man of success, but rather to become a man of value". In my humble opinion there can be no better piece of advice for modern parenting than that.

 

Follow Justin Cash on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@Justin_Cash_1

FOLLOW UK EDUCATION
From the very day they are born, our children are told that life is a competition. They are told that they must work their hardest to be quicker, stronger, sharper and more successful than their peers...
From the very day they are born, our children are told that life is a competition. They are told that they must work their hardest to be quicker, stronger, sharper and more successful than their peers...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 21
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:33 on 17/07/2012
Whilst in my opinion, it is always right and proper to consider the needs of others, today, in this evil, selfish world, that equates to being a mug. I belong to an era where we WERE taught to be mindful of others. We were taught that we must live according to the ten commandments. We were taught to respect everyone and that everyone has rights and needs which need to be considered in every decision we make. However, whilst I still believe that is correct and the only way we can survive as human beings, is to live according to the ten commandments, it has been made clear to me that if we trust others and take into consideration their needs before our own (as is preferable), then we are likely to end up in deep strife because today, to most people, altruism is weakness to exploit. Most people today are hedonistic and have no concern that their actions have impact on others. No man is an island and all our actions do impact on others in some way. Unfortunately, whilst I believe that we should all love and consider our fellow man, to teach children to trust and be defenceless in the face of others would be a very unwise move. We do need to teach our children but how do we go about getting it right when they are so vulnerable to the evil out there in the big wide world?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
acerpalmatum
09:54 on 17/07/2012
VERY FEW CHILDREN NOWADAYS ARE TAUGHT TO RESPECT OTHERS` NEEDS AND WISHES IN ANY WAY.IT IS ALL "ME ,ME,.WHAT I WANT,SOD EVERYBODY ELSE".AND MANY PARENTS ENCOURAGE THIS SELFISHNESS,BY TEACHING THEIR CHILDREN TO BE ACQUISITIVE AND UNCARING. AS FOR MANNERS,WHAT A LAUGH."MANNERS MAKETH MAN" IS THE OLD SAYING.THIS UNCARING ATTITUDE IS NOW ENDEMIC IN SOCIETY,SADLY.
WE WERE TAUGHT AS CHILDREN TO PUT OTHERS BEFORE ONESELF,AND RESPECT OTHER`S PERSONS AND PROPERTY.THAT ATTITUDE HAS LONG GONE.NO WONDER WE HAVE SUCH A BROKEN SOCIETY.I KNOW OTHER THINGS LIKE BROKEN HOMES CONTRIBUTE TO IT,BUT IT ALL STARTS WITH GOOD PARENTING AND TEACHING EVEN THE TINIES NOT TO ALWAYS WANT THEIR OWN WAY AND PUSH THEMSELVES FORWARD ALL THE TIME.SOME MAY SAY IT IS THE ONLY WAY NOWADAYS IN OUR COMPETITIVE AGE TO SURVIVE -ie THE SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST,BUT IT IS A REPREHENSIBLE ATTITUDE.
07:42 on 17/07/2012
Bit of a leap going on here. My message to my child is that the she should always try her best. She is rewarded for her effort grades, not her academic grades even though her academic grades are excellent. She is a caring 8 year old that regularly raises money for charities and helps other children to be the best they can be. Don't tar all parents with the same brush!
07:26 on 17/07/2012
You have to teach children to share, which is hard to do when the media is full of self obsessed celeb's.
03:29 on 17/07/2012
Actually I just teach my kids & grandaughter to be happy & do thier best...
photo
SecularAdvocate
Media Watcher
00:23 on 17/07/2012
You want to be more circumspect when you use "we" and "our", budding journalist boy.
Your imagined audience is not all like you.

Congrats on having what it takes to write for the modern outlet though - anodyne, rambling nonsense with a painfully awkward set-up to an Einstein quote at the end, desperate in search of some kind of authority to stamp on your piece, which it's certain you have no access to as a result of the quality of your ideas.

And do you have a kid yet? If not, better stay quiet about what you plan to teach one when you get it. Until you're actually a parent, boasting of your take on parenthood is not such a great look. And when you've grown up a bit you might find the advice you want to give your children won't be quite so simplistic.

I realise that when you're looking to get paid by the word it's no good waiting until you actually have an opinion you want to express, but if you are looking to invent opinions in return for cash at least try and make them worth reading.

5/10. Fail.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:01 on 17/07/2012
Ouch!
I mean 'yeah', but still 'Ouch!'
photo
SecularAdvocate
Media Watcher
11:05 on 17/07/2012
Poor journalism is offensive.  This guy deserves a metaphorical slap upside the head.
17:43 on 16/07/2012
Funny. My generation was told that everything had to be worked for, that exams really mattered, that being top of the class was the goal to aim for, and that a good job was the reward for hard work. Guess what? We were collectively a great deal less selfish, disrespectful to our parents and egotistical than the kids many of us raised more "progressively" turned out to be. Remember the 1980s and shudder.
10:42 on 17/07/2012
I can't work out to which generation you belong but I know that my generation WAS taught to be loving, giving and, yes, competitive, but not if it hurt others. Today, we have given so much to our children and grandchildren that they have become unkind, selfish and materialistic. O.K. that does not apply to all, but it sure applies to many. My son has flashes of kindness but, overall, I am taken for granted and usually those flashes of kindness are because he wants something. My lovely grand-daughter, unfortunately, is growing very much like him. We love her more than life itself, but her life is one of materialism. However, a lot of what makes our youngsters tick these days, is the fact that life is so frantic and there is no time for anything. Survival of the fittest comes to mind, particularly when I read of elderly people being left to die to make room for others and to save money. There are just too many people, so we become expendable. How do we explain that to a child then? Once we become parents, we are there to be supportive and protective but as the child grows into adulthood, we are there to give and give and receive precious little but "crumbs" in return. Cynical? You bet I am.
16:10 on 16/07/2012
You don't have to teach a child to be selfish. That comes naturally to all children.
10:43 on 17/07/2012
I agree. It is natural for a child to protect itself and to be selfish in order to do that. We have to teach them otherwise but how can we do that, in this cruel age, without making our children vulnerable to the abusers?
15:32 on 16/07/2012
Rubbish! Children these days are not allowed to compete unless they, God forbid, should fail at something! They are never told that they are not good at something. They are not allowed to 'fail' at anything and are given as many chances as they need to succeed. What is going to happen when they join the work force - their boss will not worry about their feelings!
Makalha
Opinions are not facts.
17:12 on 16/07/2012
I agree with you about children not being told they are not good at something. The trouble is there seems to be nowhere between winner and failure . They don't seem to be taught that failing at something isn't the same as being a failure . The success is the trying to do your best . A very wise headmaster I had was asking pupils what they wanted to be ... one boy wanted to be a dustbin man ( laughter from other pupils ) This headmaster pointed out how important dustbin men were and told the boy it was a worthy ambition and to do it to his best ability. It was one of the most important lessons I learnt at school .
21:14 on 16/07/2012
Your quotes; "They don't seem to be taught that failing at something isn't the same as being a failure . The success is the trying to do your best "

So very true, and it`s all about COMMUNICATION, something many brits, but not all, are not very good at, and talking to your child and encouraging them, without that it can lead to feelings of alienation and of not being " good enough".
15:30 on 16/07/2012
I don't see the problem with trying to be the best you can. The examples you provided are actually NOT people being the best they could be. You're suggesting that the BAD bankers are what we aim for, but that's not the case. There are thousands of decent bankers who don't cheat. Just as there are politicians who share the same views as us... whereas some don't. This isn't an inherent part of success. I think you've confused these two archetypes.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:02 on 17/07/2012
That's some good common sense right there.
lastpost
see biography
14:14 on 16/07/2012
"From the very day they are born, our children are told that life is a competition."
Perhaps we should show them newspaper clippings too. Rioters get remanded, Banksters gets bailouts. Now, which do you want to be if you get to grow up?

"what we wanted from our progeny all along"
If robbing banks for you son, best way is to own one.

"Isn't it strange that the people we currently despise so much"
are making up their own set of rules as they go along. If this is the new game plan, why haven’t all of the players been informed?

"no matter the cost to others"
If civilization collapses, it collapses on top of everybody. As there is only one planet between the lot of us.

"his interests are no more important than anyone else's"
from this point on. Where previously, there was room for physical expansion. Now there is only space for behavioural improvement.

"It was Einstein who once said "try not to become a man of success, but rather to become a man of value"
and: Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity. I’m not sure about the universe.
00:05 on 16/07/2012
Excellent blog. Why is it that we no longer teach our children the value of cooperation versus competition? Yes we want out children to want to do their best, but as a society we are much better off if everyone does their best and we all succeed together. Our children will also be much better off, will be less likely to suffer stress, anxiety, etc. in their lives and will be much more likely to be emotionally and psychologically healthy if they were to focus more on cooperation and less on competition.
03:24 on 16/07/2012
Ain't that the truth. Whatever happened to the old adage of "It's not whether you win or lose, but how you play the game." It's all about competition and teams and winning at all costs. There are too many trophies and cups and awards etc. given out. What's wrong with just playing for fun and everyone having a good time. It seems that many kids don't play sports because they fear being laughed at for not being good enough. But what do I know...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jessjesskk
Benevolent Zombie Power
08:02 on 16/07/2012
In an environment where most people are "not egoists", the egoist will have, often, the best individual outcome. Which means that everyone tends to be egoist.

Your reflexion is admirable in all respects. And I would agree with that but the nature of the human specie, even if social by design, tend to favour egoism within altruism. Which is turn leads to more egoism as long as a full social change does not happen.