Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kate Smurthwaite

GET UPDATES FROM Kate Smurthwaite
 

Yes, Savita Halappanavar's Death IS a Political Issue

Posted: 15/11/2012 11:30

This weeks' protest outside the Irish Embassy in London over the death of Savita Halappanavar was a first for me. I've been to dozens of pro-choice protests before but this was the first time I've attended one with no sign whatsoever of a counter-protest. I guess it's hard to claim to be 'pro-life' when someone is actually dead.

The Internet is not so respectful. Already the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child has a statement out. In it they claim "Abortion is not medicine - it does not treat or cure any pathology". Perhaps I should explain. A woman's cervix spends most of its time so firmly closed that even tiny little sperm have to really fight to get in. During birth or miscarriage the cervix dilates to let the baby or foetus out. Then it closes up again. The facts as we, so far, understand them are that Ms Halappanavar was seventeen weeks pregnant when she went to the hospital and had full cervical dilation. Medical professionals at the hospital agreed that miscarriage was inevitable. While waiting for the miscarriage to run its course the cervix remains open. Doctors describe this as like having an open head injury. It's a problem because as time passes the likelihood of an infection getting in increases. Speeding the miscarriage along by removing the contents of the womb serves to dramatically reduce the risk. The medical team refused to do this for four whole days, Halappanavar, by this stage in agony, developed an infection, septicaemia, and died.

That is the 'pathology'. I understand it (and I'm a comedian with a maths degree), Savita Halappanavar understood this because she could not have qualified as a dentist without studying infections like septicaemia.

SPUC go on to say "It is also not ethical to end the life of an unborn child, via induction or any other means, where the child is terminally-ill." They seriously choose to value the additional four days that the foetus spent slowly dying over the forty or fifty years of fulfilling life that this brilliant woman might have spent serving her community and supporting her family and friends. If I had to think of a term for this attitude I'd call it 'anti-life' or maybe 'pro-death'.

They also tell us "the Republic of Ireland has the world's best record in maternal health", which may have been true the last time numbers were published but with this case and the two deaths in childbirth at Coombe women's hospital in Dublin last month is undoubtedly out of date. Regardless, the safety of pregnancy and birth in Ireland can be largely credited to capitalism. The competitive pricing of flights to England with the likes of Aer Lingus and Ryanair mean that with help from family and friends and organisations like the Abortion Support Network the majority of women in need are able to travel and access the service they need.

The statement from the Irish Precious Life campaign says much the same thing. Medically, they 'explai'" "delay in administering antibiotics may have been the cause of the septicaemia which tragically led to her death". This is 1984-standard doublethink, an infection was caused by a delay in administering drugs intended to treat said infection? Antibiotics don't cure infection with a one hundred percent success rate, they help your body fight the infection more effectively, which wouldn't be necessary if the infection had been avoided in the first place.

They go on to accuse pro-choicers like me of "rushing to exploit this case to further their own agenda" forgetting that it is the brave and deliberate decision of Halappanavar's family to speak openly about the case that has brought it to the public's attention. They did not do this in the hope that we would remain silent and allow others to die as she did. Asked by the press if a termination would have saved her life, her husband Praveen replied "Of course, no doubt about it".

If I am ever a victim of an unjust legal discrepancy that infringes my human rights and leads to my untimely and unnecessary agonising death I want every man, woman and child on the streets immediately demanding that it never, ever be allowed to happen again.

A further vigil and rally for Savita Halappanavar will take place on Saturday at 4pm outside the Irish Embassy in London. For more information contact Abortion Rights UK.

 

Follow Kate Smurthwaite on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Cruella1

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
This weeks' protest outside the Irish Embassy in London over the death of Savita Halappanavar was a first for me. I've been to dozens of pro-choice protests before but this was the first time I've att...
This weeks' protest outside the Irish Embassy in London over the death of Savita Halappanavar was a first for me. I've been to dozens of pro-choice protests before but this was the first time I've att...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 69
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:19 AM on 11/29/2012
Why are Indian Population statistics relevant to this discussion? Savita died in Ireland, in an Irish Hospital which did not make the correct decision, she would not of died in India because she could afford the right health care, for herself and her Baby. I am still alarmed that doctors, or any doctor, a consultant perhaps, not take the initiative for a pregnant woman and save her life. That is the creed under which they live, and in matters of medicine they are accountable to their organization and their peers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Thismortalcoil
Science is the poetry of reality
05:21 PM on 11/18/2012
Brilliant feature Kate. The law in Ireland clearly needs to be clarified, I hope the ECHR ruling helps.
09:58 AM on 11/19/2012
I hope you will be equally concerned now about women being used surrogates for male couples.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:36 PM on 11/17/2012
Using this poor woman to justify liberalizing abortion is is as ridiculous as using the tragic death of Tonya Reaves post-abortion in the Chicago Planned "Parenthood" abortion factory to justify restricting it - see report here:

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2177534/Tonya-Reaves-Familys-fury-woman-24-dies-operating-table-abortion.html

Difficult, emotive cases like this make bad law.

The great majority of abortions in the UK are on healthy young women for social considerations, not because of health problems.

Abortion must be restricted to stop this wholesale destruction of the millions of defenseless pre-born children by those wishing to impose their morality on them. Totalitarian states are always willing to destroy the weakest members of society for their own reasons - this evil needs to be removed from the British Isles, not encouraged.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
clownzozo
Magician, Novelist and an Angry Old Git
04:37 PM on 11/17/2012
So, in Ireland a mother has no right to expect doctors to save their life even if the foetus is terminally ill?

That will boost the profits of the backstreet abortionists.

Such gross inhumanity by jobsworths would not be tolerated in an uncivilised country.
02:23 PM on 11/18/2012
Please you are too intelligent to be this cliched and simply wrong. How many times do people have to be told that irish law does allow pregnancies to be terminated to prpotect the mother !
Are you actually disappointed that this is the law in Ireland ????????
09:46 AM on 11/19/2012
You havent replied to my posts about the legal situation in Ireland.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
clownzozo
Magician, Novelist and an Angry Old Git
12:47 PM on 11/19/2012
A legal system and a lawful system are not the same thing. This woman died because doctors refused to abort the foetus and save her life. Unforgivable.
12:52 PM on 11/17/2012
" Regardless, the safety of pregnancy and birth in Ireland can be largely credited to capitalism. The competitive pricing of flights to England with the likes of Aer Lingus and Ryanair mean that with help from family and friends and organisations like the Abortion Support Network the majority of women in need are able to travel and access the service they need "
I am sorry, but the above quote borders on racism !
03:41 PM on 11/21/2012
Well capitalism sure produced a winner in Ireland!!! Beggars can't be choosers dude:
Ireland forced to take EU and IMF bail-out package
www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/financialcrisis/8150137/Ireland-forced-to-take-EU-and-IMF-bail-out-package.html
03:52 PM on 11/21/2012
If you could look a little deeper at this issue, the reality is that Irish taxoayers have been obliged to accpet the liability to repay Biritish, german and dutch banks for laons these banks gave out to private investors ! Quite unbeleivable that citizens who had no hand act or part in these laons shoudl now have to bail out these banks. That is the real scandal.
12:51 PM on 11/17/2012
Whilst continuing to read about this death on the irish inline media, I cam across this quote : " A doctor was struck off in Britain in December 2011 for botched abortions, including on an Irish woman who nearly died and spent two months in hospital after he ruptured her uterus. There was little or no coverage of it. If it had been plastic surgery, I suspect it would have been all over the media "
Now I cant remember this being an issue in the UK media. Anyone else remember it ?
Does the articel author ? And if she does, has she written about ?
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
12:11 PM on 11/17/2012
It's both political and religious, which is why in 2012 we are still talking about abortion rights. We can't let beliefs trivialise abortion, especially when the sake of the health of the Mother carrying is at stake. Good luck with this afternoons vigil. RIP Savita.
04:14 PM on 11/16/2012
As an Irish citizen, I can't stop apologizing for what happened to this poor woman.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Prickly Herbert
Mine's a large gin
11:48 AM on 11/18/2012
Please stop, you have nothing to apologise for! This is down to the Irish government's inability to get to grips with archaic religious laws.
02:32 AM on 11/21/2012
The best apology you could make to Savita's family is to ensure that no other woman be subjected to such callous indifference again. As an Irish citizen, you have the power to express your strong opinion to keep your politicians out of your medical decisions.
03:53 PM on 11/16/2012
I see the author has refrained from explaining the actual circumstances of death in favour of clambering up on the high moral ground - in other words she is exploiting a death before actually being aware of the full circumstances,stances around the death.
Nor does the author seem to explain there is no legal obstacle to ending a pregnancy to protect an expectant mother in Ireland. The irish constitution was changed to allow this very thing,
Don't get me wrong I am in favour of abortion and i suggest we should considering adopting China's one child policy.
And i am in favour of allowing mothers to abort in any circumstances and for whatever reason they wish.
Only thing, i have the feeling that the author isn't in favour of this much abortion freedom.
04:01 PM on 11/16/2012
My limited understanding of the Irish Constitution suggests that a woman is only considered as having an equal right to life when compared with her unborn child. The 12th and 25th amendments proposed on October 7th, 1992 and November 25th 2002 respectively may well have given a woman the right to have an abortion if her health or life were threatened by the continuation of the pregnancy, but both amendments were rejected. I'm not aware of any successful change to the constitution that would have given a woman that right, and so my information may be wrong. If such a change to the constitution was in force at the time of this woman's death then the staff at that hospital would be guilty of breaking the law.
04:14 PM on 11/16/2012
From my reading a variety of articles in the irish media it is indeed the case that prgnancy may be terminated where the mother is at risk.
I shall try to get quotes a little later,
02:10 PM on 11/16/2012
The truth is if she had been in India, even in a second-rate gov't hospital, she'd have been given an abortion and still be ALIVE!
03:56 PM on 11/16/2012
" Over 400,000 newborns die within the first 24 hours of their birth every year, the highest anywhere in the world, a study by an international non-government organisation, ‘Save the Children’, has declared.

According to the NGO, despite a decade of rapid economic growth, India’s record on child mortality at 72 per 1,000 live births is worse than that of neighbouring Bangladesh, one of the poorest countries in the world.

Two million children under five years of age die—one every 15 seconds—each year in India, also the highest anywhere in the world, it said. Of these more than half die in the first month of their birth." Quote ex Deccan Herald.
Please India is a disgrace - a country that choose its vast welath on atom bombs, space expolaration and every conceivable luxury for the wealthy. They seem to value cows more than poor children !
04:20 PM on 11/16/2012
You haven't refuted my point: she'd still be ALIVE and not DEAD if she had been in India and not disgraceful mullah-run Ireland
05:23 PM on 11/18/2012
You forget that India has a great deal of poverty, is a subcontinent, and has a population of 1.20 billion persons, 20% of the world's population. There is also great differences in benefit of an urban dweller compared to a rural dwelling, which may not be close to a hospital. A dozen Irelands can be fitted in India's back pocket, and Indian doctors, research scientists, and other medical professionals are among the finest in the world. Their only disgrace was to allow the British to divide their country. Now the question of cows raises its head: This animal was the only beast of burden for mellennia, and besides tilling fields, transporting families, it provided children milk in the morning. So the cow to Indians is a sacred animal, and they do not kill cows. This kind of treatment to dumb animals marks the culture of a civilized people. What matters here is that the Catholic influence refused termination of the foetus, causing the death of the mother. Do you accept this, or shall I send in some Indian Lawyers to support your education?