Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Kerry McCarthy

GET UPDATES FROM Kerry McCarthy
 

Inside the Pussy Riot Trial

Posted: 09/08/2012 01:00

The international spotlight has this week been focused on a court case in Moscow involving three young women, Nadya, Masha and Katya, who are part of a loose network of punk musicians/performance artists calling themselves Pussy Riot.

Their alleged crime was to have performed what they dubbed "a punk prayer" in the cathedral of Christ the Saviour in February, a 40 second performance of a song calling on the Virgin Mary to join forces with them against Vladimir Putin.

This resulted in them being charged with "hooliganism", an offence that carries a maximum seven year jail sentence. The prosecution in court this week has called for three years, which may be a response to Putin's comments in London last week, when he came over to talk to see the judo at the Olympics and talk to our prime minister about Syria. He was quoted as saying that the women shouldn't be treated too harshly.

The trial has in large part been about whether the band were demonstrating "religious hatred" by their actions, or whether - as the women maintain - it was a political protest. The prosecuting lawyer somewhat bizarrely argued in his closing statement that it wasn't a political statement as no politicians were named, although the song is called Virgin Mary, Chase Putin Out.

The band argue, perhaps a little facetiously, that the song isn't anti-religious because they're enlisting the Virgin Mary onto their side. The female lawyer representing the nine victims in court (that is, those who say they were insulted or traumatised by seeing the performance) was outraged by the band's suggestion that Mary was a feminist, and said that "feminism is a mortal sin".

The trial process was in parts bewildering to watch. The Russians don't have the same structure to their hearings that we do in the UK, and there were a series of 'petitions' from the defence and the defendants, and a total of eight motions from the defence for recusal of the judge, i.e. that she should stand down on grounds of bias. Unsurprisingly the judge didn't accept these! Having separate lawyers to represent the victims is interesting, and is something that has been talked about in the UK, for example, for rape victims.

It was also interesting that the women got to speak up for themselves at various points throughout the trial, rather than as would be usual in the UK speaking only through their lawyers except when being cross-examined under oath. So on Wednesday, the last day of the trial, the three got to make powerful statements, explaining their political philosophy and why they chose to express themselves in the way they did.

There have, however, been many criticisms made of the trial process: the fact the defence weren't allowed to call the witnesses they wanted to, and not allowed to examine the prosecution witnesses/victims properly either. I wasn't there for the victims' testimony but people have reported that the judge was very quick to shut down questions, and simply didn't allow the sort of cross-examination that the defence wanted.

There have also been many concerns raised about the way the women are being treated: they say they are only getting a few hours sleep a night, they aren't being fed during their 12 hour days at court, and Nadya and Masha have not been able to see their two small children. There has also been an order made barring Nadya's husband, Peter, from visiting her, after - I was told - he was seen to be too active in calling for their release.

It was Peter who managed to get Madonna to don a balaclava on stage to perform Like a Virgin in Moscow on Tuesday night, with "Pussy Riot" scrawled in big letters across her back. We may sometimes mock celebrities who get involved in political issues, but there is no doubt that Madonna has a huge audience and a statement from her in support of Pussy Riot has a real impact.

The trial verdict will be delivered on 17 August at 3pm Moscow time. Until then Nadya, Masha and Katya will remain in prison, as they have been since their arrest in February. Their lawyers have said that a conviction is inevitable. The question is whether the judge will listen to the prosecution's call for a three year sentence or will listen to those who think the band have already been punished more than enough, and should be released. The defence lawyers say that it is not the judge who will decide, it is Putin himself. The world is watching while he makes up his mind.

 

Follow Kerry McCarthy on Twitter: www.twitter.com/KerryMP

FOLLOW CANADA MUSIC
The international spotlight has this week been focused on a court case in Moscow involving three young women, Nadya, Masha and Katya, who are part of a loose network of punk musicians/performance arti...
The international spotlight has this week been focused on a court case in Moscow involving three young women, Nadya, Masha and Katya, who are part of a loose network of punk musicians/performance arti...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
06:18 AM on 08/15/2012
Both Putin and Cameron like the idea of putting people in prison over people expressing themselves. I bet they were real chummy with each other behind closed doors.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SGillLondonUK
SCOTLAND IS NOT ENGLISH PROPERTY
11:03 PM on 08/19/2012
Unless its Any Coulson
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SGillLondonUK
SCOTLAND IS NOT ENGLISH PROPERTY
11:04 PM on 08/19/2012
Thankfully we can elect our poiticans out
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
abolishinsanity
09:35 PM on 08/12/2012
We are now part of a global community, and therefore we all should be concerned and involved, if possible, in human rights abuses, inside and outside of this country.
11:15 AM on 08/10/2012
So glad one of our overpaid and expenses armed MP's can find the time to blog on issues in another country while this one is in dire straits, forget championing overseas causes of little to no import to this country's subjects and attempt to get on with the job your constituents voted you to do, improve their lot.
05:50 AM on 08/10/2012
i cant believe there are still people in the civilised world who really think the name is offensive.we live in the 21st century and still people keep believing there is a big guy up there who made everything and directs the universe.....poor souls,conservative america i guess...where they teach their children the world is 10 thousand years old only,and dinosaurs where around the same time as noah....21 century ,we were dreaming peace will rule the world,technology will feed us all ,and society would be a better place.what i got instead?this....oh man ,get a life,go out there and live,enjoy ,be happy stop pretending and playing roles.didnt you have enough already?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
donnyraindog
Grass shack nailed to a pinewood floor
03:58 AM on 08/10/2012
While I doubt the girls will get three years they may serve some time and then as others have suggested Putin will commute their sentences in an act of largess for which he'll expect credit.Anytime in a Russian prison is no joke and I hope the girls will have the sense to get out of the country with their families.
09:59 PM on 08/09/2012
What on the earth these women were thinking. I hope they are forgiven and released soon.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Lee Smyth
a nomadic view
08:56 PM on 08/09/2012
Welcome back to the world of the Soviet.
07:42 PM on 08/09/2012
HUFF why wont you let me comment on this story? last time i did'nt even mention the bands name and it still vanished. Wierdos!
jhNY
Mercy.
05:33 PM on 08/09/2012
As the author implies, I await the forgiving hand of the Great Man to come down after sentencing, to dispense with jail terms in an act of largesse for which he will expect to be praised and beloved, at least publicly.
04:13 PM on 08/09/2012
Still at least they are being treated better than Bradley Manning.
06:07 PM on 08/09/2012
The 3 Russian women committed trespassing at worst. Manning violated his oath of service without regard for the consequences. Passing information to Wikileaks is still espionage even though it's not a foreign government. In other words, it's still high treason punishable by death.
08:47 AM on 08/10/2012
Didn't swear an oath to uphold the constitution - or was it like the Supreme Court to uphold the second part of the second amendment
03:10 PM on 08/09/2012
They probably should not have styled their face masks after this:

http://middleeast.about.com/od/terrorism/g/black-september-definition.htm
11:16 AM on 08/09/2012
There they put them in nick, here we have endless talent competitions!
06:14 AM on 08/09/2012
can't believe they are allowed to have that name of a band-its disturbing
photo
mrs w waugh
Hail Caesar We Who Are About To Die Salute You
02:47 PM on 08/09/2012
Its not a very nice name really is it....................................
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael Lee Smyth
a nomadic view
08:58 PM on 08/09/2012
I guess the late 60's early 70's band "Brown S**t Puppy Farm" was not one of your favorites?
This comment has been removed.