Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lenny George

GET UPDATES FROM Lenny George
 

The Battle for Coyte Farm - Why Are Sainsbury's So Keen to Destroy British Farmland?‏

Posted: 31/01/2013 00:00

Coyte Farm is situated in rolling countryside on the western side of the market town of St. Austell in Cornwall. The farmer John Richards is approaching retirement and is planning to sell his farm with its 100 acres of agricultural land. Sainsbury's are involved in a plan to acquire the farm from him. Are they interested to take over his farm in order to produce sustainable food with low food miles for their own supermarkets 15 miles away in neighbouring Truro or 40 miles away in Plymouth?

No - Sainsbury's are the joint planning applicants for a development that, if approved, would concrete and tarmac over this 100 acres of farmland in order to create a Sainsbury's superstore, retail park, care home, hotel, pub, golf academy and a housing estate. This greenfield site would become Cornwall's third biggest retail area. Not a single acre of agricultural land would be left for the production of food.

So is there an urgent need for a supermarket to serve the town of St Austell? Again, no - St. Austell already has five supermarkets, with Tesco, Asda, The Co-op, Aldi and Lidl having stores in the town. But it seems that Sainsbury's are desperate to have a store in the town at any cost. Even if that cost is the destruction of farmland.

At this stage, I must declare my interest. I was born in St. Austell and educated at St. Mewan Primary School which borders the green fields of Coyte Farm. I walked past those fields almost every day for the six years of my primary education. In the summer on our walks home from school, we would take a short cut through the fields and watch day by day as the corn grew so high that we could play hide & seek in the long grass. Another highlight of the summer term was a school visit to the farm so we could watch Farmer Richards milking his cows. If this development goes ahead, the pupils of St. Mewan School will have the tarmac of a retail park to run around on on their way home and they can take a school-trip to watch people stacking shelves of milk in Sainsbury's.

Why is farmland so important? Because:

"The global population is rising at a time when natural resources are decreasing. As such, there is increasing pressure on the global food system. The earth's capacity to provide food is threatened by climate change, water scarcity and unsustainable farming practices. We need to find ways to make land more productive and to protect the biodiversity on which all food production ultimately depends.'

These are Sainsbury's very own words from their own recently launched Sustainability Plan. And yet it seems that they are quite happy to destroy food-producing farmland when it suits them, in direct contradiction of their own policy.

Sainsbury's is the UK's third biggest supermarket chain and are primarily a food company - food accounts for over 70% of their sales. Yet they are keen to build over farmland at a time when people are increasingly concerned about how enough food will be produced for the growing populations of the future.

The UK population is estimated to grow by 16% by 2031 but we are losing at least 30,000 acres of agricultural land a year due to urbanisation. We are currently only able to produce 62% of the food that we need to feed the UK population. This means we are becoming more and more reliant on importing food from overseas and it makes Britain weaker in terms of future food security.

This is of great concern to the government with Farming Minister Jim Paice stating in July last year: "With our increasingly hungry world every country must play its part to produce more food and improve the environment. Britain already punches above its weight, but we're a small island with limited space, so we've got to show leadership and play to our strengths more efficiently".

I am not against development and progress. I now live in London and I've witnessed the successful regeneration of brownfield sites in order to create the 2012 Olympic Park. Because of its industrial mining past, St. Austell is an area that has many brownfield sites. In fact the internationally-famous biomes of the UK's first major eco-tourist attraction, the Eden Project, were built in a disused china-clay pit just outside St. Austell. The major downturn in the china-clay industry has led to mass redundancies and a high level of local unemployment that has left its town centre full of empty shops and buildings. St Austell is the biggest town in Cornwall but it lacks the shops and facilities that a town of its size would normally have. In recent months, a new owner has bought the town centre and is keen to regenerate it and turn it back into a bustling place.

In light of this, it seems even more scandalous that Sainsbury's would ignore the town's vacant brownfield sites and empty retail spaces in order to build an out-of-town retail park on green food-producing farmland. Especially as their own sustainability policy is directly opposed to it.

The future of Coyte Farm is causing heated debate in Cornwall but this isn't just a local Cornish issue. It's a national and even a global issue. As populations rise and good agricultural land for growing food becomes ever scarcer, if a food-based company such as Sainsbury's are so keen to destroy agricultural land in the name of commercial expansion then what hope do we have to preserve the precious resource of farming land for future generations?

If, in the future, the pupils of St. Mewan Primary School look out on the empty retail shops left derelict by the domination of internet shopping, they'll ask why we sacrificed the valuable resources of Coyte Farm's land for such short-term gain.

Food sustainability is an issue for everyone and I would urge anyone who's concerned about the loss of farmland to join the Stop Coyte Farm campaign or to make their objection to the plan directly with Cornwall Council. To quote local councillor Bert Biscoe "Will our childrens' children need farmland or supermarkets most?"

 

Follow Lenny George on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@kernowinthecit

FOLLOW UK
Coyte Farm is situated in rolling countryside on the western side of the market town of St. Austell in Cornwall. The farmer John Richards is approaching retirement and is planning to sell his farm wit...
Coyte Farm is situated in rolling countryside on the western side of the market town of St. Austell in Cornwall. The farmer John Richards is approaching retirement and is planning to sell his farm wit...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:19 AM on 03/02/2013
Does methane trap heat? Yes. But carbon dioxide has caused three times more warming than methane. http://clmtr.lt/cb/ozW0Bg
07:14 PM on 02/04/2013
I, on the whole, am in support of the Coyte Farm development. As someone who resides in Cornwall and has done since I was small, I remember the "glory days" when St Awful closed its shops on Friday lunchtime and didn't re-open until Monday morning. Asda arrived only 25 ish years ago offering supermarket opening times which caused the town to react negatively as they had to open on a Saturday! I agree that in an ideal world that retail developments / supermarkets should be built on existing brownfield sites. This development plan is very close to the town and could complement it, moving it further away could have a detrimental effect on the town. As a local person, I noticed that Imerys China Clay use their mineral rights to make compulsory purchases of farms in the area that are obstructing their progress on digging up a considerable portion of Cornwall. It is heartbreaking to see so much more land swallowed up than this one farm that the developers are looking at, by a company that provides no real incentive other than removing 100 million tonnes of kaolin out of Cornwall where the profits go the France. This retail develpment, while being on a small farm admittedly, will provide jobs and a wonderful opportunity to make St Austell the town it should be, considering its the largest populated town in Cornwall it's quality and selection of shops are woefully inadequate DESPITE what people who own the shops will tell you!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lenny George
12:57 AM on 02/05/2013
Thank you for your comment but I have to point out that the first part of it is completely untrue. I was born in St Austell and spent most Saturdays for 20 years visiting the shops in the town centre - they were always open on Saturdays. I still regularly go home to St Austell and the shops that remain are open on Saturdays too. You seem to have a bit of a recall problem there. Regarding Imerys, it's true that they dig up farmland for mining (I spent 2 summers working for their predecessor English China Clays btw). However the main point of my article is to point out the bare-faced hypocrisy of a food-based company like Sainsburys being prepared to destroy 100 acres of food-producing farmland just so they can get a superstore into the town. And finally, the Coyte Farm development is not just a retail development - it's also a housing estate of 250 houses, a care village, a hotel, a pub and a golf academy. It would stretch from Trewoon to the outskirts of Polgooth. Essentially it would be a whole new suburb to St. Austell on a greenfield site - destroying farmland and the green belt that surrounds the town on the western side.
01:34 AM on 02/05/2013
I get the fact you are trying to show Sainsburys hypocrisy but how many years was it that you were at primary school? At one time, Cornwall was probably uninhabited, progress must move forwards, I doubt this particular farm grows anything useful other than grass for the cows. What happens if this farm is unprofitable and is lain waste for the next ten years because no one wants to take it on? Well thats ok because the land is still there, unless of course Imerys decides to take it without even a thought or concern for any of us. Have a wide angle look at google maps, 100 acres is small potatoes in comparison to the mighty clay waste. Dont misunderstand me, I would much rather is was on brown land too which at one time was also green! I also seem to remember as a child shops being open on a saturday, but not all of them, I can guarantee it was always the shop you wanted to be open, wasn't.
This comment has been removed.
11:32 PM on 01/31/2013
i reposted the link in the guardian environment section ( and signed) but you may want to go over there and post on more threads as well :)

xxx
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Lenny George
01:07 PM on 02/01/2013
Thank you for your support! I will have a look at the guardian environment section too.
11:17 PM on 01/31/2013
this is both shocking and indicative of all that is wrong with the UK.
May I suggest trying to get the shadow environmental minister on board ?

I believe large supermarkets should not only be locally taxed over a certain size, but have to prove that they will not adversley affect the local town or environment.

i also really hope you win as well

xx
09:40 PM on 01/31/2013
I so hope you win