At first glance, religion has always been the enemy of freedom. By its very nature, religion is seemingly didactic and absolutist, claiming to be the answer to all the world's problems - to be the source of fundamental truth.
So it is that Islam is again attracting negative attention in the press. The needless death in Benghazi of the American Ambassador Chris Stevens, killed by smoke inhalation after the US consulate was stormed by Muslims livid about the trailer for a US-made film apparently disrespectful of the Prophet Mohammad called The Innocence of Muslims, is a nasty reminder of the inability of Islam to bear criticism or insult.
That Channel 4's decision to cancel a screening of Tom Holland's documentary Islam: The Untold Story was announced only a day before the tragedy in Libya is a strange coincidence. After it was broadcast in late August, Channel 4 reportedly received around 1200 complaints. The documentary focused on Islam's early history, and speculated that the version of Islam that exists today developed not in Mecca, but somewhere in the vicinity of Palestine around 200 years after the Prophet Mohammad passed away.
Whatever you may think of a film which insults the Prophet Mohammad, or Tom Holland's conjectures, they are to be countered by rational debate, not bigoted threats or actual violence. It is not acceptable for any group to use their liberty and/or free speech to deny the same to another. Each time a religion claims that its own ignorance is sacred, it strikes a blow not only to freedom of speech but also to the idea of a common humanity.
However, we must remember that intolerance is not a characteristic unique to religion. As with all organic symbols rooted deeply in human identities, Islam - like all other religions - is open to abuse by those seeking to wield power and terror. But many other divides have also been exploited in the same way, such as race in Nazi Germany, class in Soviet Russia, and tribe in Rwanda. Whatever Islam's problems and failures, they are the result of human fallibility, not some contrived view of religion or God. In fact, both the Nazis and the Soviets were secular regimes.
The issue, rather, is absolutism. Every human has their own conception of how to achieve 'the good life', but besides very limited exceptions, it is wrong and unnatural to impose these onto anyone else. One of the most important things shared in common by belief systems which turn into absolutist ideologies is that despite their supposedly noble aims for humanity, they begin to violently enforce these beliefs onto people regardless of whether or not they agree.
Islam is no different because, like all other beliefs, it is a spectrum, and can be manipulated to extremity for the sake of power. But that is not to say that at its essence it is fundamentally illiberal and destructive, just as Communism, Republicanism, and even Nationalism were not fundamentally illiberal and destructive until they were steered by often psychopathic leaders to forcefully impose themselves onto people; becoming as a result the terrible absolutist extremes of Stalinism, Bonapartism, and Fascism, respectively. Islam, when left alone by intolerant psychopaths, is actually a peaceful and humane religion.
Ironically, negative and ignorant criticisms of Islam often come either from atheists who believe their own rationality to be the objective truth, or fundamentalist Christians who would argue against abortion rights for women who were raped. Tellingly, one of the producers of The Innocence of Muslims was Pastor Terry Jones who last year burned the Qur'an. Worse, the director of the film, Sam Bacile, said in a recent interview that "Islam is a cancer, period," while Richard Dawkins has in the past described Islam as "one of the great evils in the world". It is these levels of ignorance and hatred which lead along that dangerous road to absolutism.
All human beliefs contain within them the seeds of absolutism. As citizens it is our duty to respect the beliefs of others without resorting to the extremes of condoning morally reprehensible behaviour or condemning ideas we can't understand. Ultimately, the only way to fight absolutism is to first fight the absolutist tendencies that lie within ourselves.
Follow Liam McLaughlin on Twitter: www.twitter.com/LiamMc108
Abbas Barzegar: Nothing Farcical About anti-Muhammad Film
They openly boast that they intend to make Britain an Islamic State, whether we like it or not - and we don't. Already the usual apologists are suggesting that Shira Law could be allowed in heavily Muslim populated areas.
Here's a challenge - name one Islamic State that is not fighting against another Islamic sect and does not rely on despotic military control?
Absolutism or extremism etc, is bad for just about everything, not just eastern religion.Take the polarisation of US politics, according to the media voters have the choice of picking a missile loving, hard line tea party capitalist or a lovey-dovey flippy floppy pinko.
Extremes of anything are bad: love chocolate? maybe so, but eat it exclusively and you'll soon end up with serious problems, continue and it will kill you.
Absolutism of politics, ideology, religion, budget management, etc is like over correcting the altitude on a 747, a some stage it'll end in a big nasty ball of flames.
I'm not sure what the author means by "absolutism". Of course, if, as it seems, he means absolutism means imposing your idea of the right way to live on everyone else, Objectivism is the total opposite of absolutism.
The problem is, absolutism has two different definitions. One is the political definition, which involves government with absolute power. In this, Islam is absolutist by its very nature, but Objectivism is not. The other is "any theory which holds that truth or moral or aesthetic value is absolute and universal and not relative to individual or social differences", which does describe both Islam and Objectivism, and it seems people use this to equate Islam and Objectivism.
There are some ways in which we are all absolutists. We all believe that water is wet, human beings need oxygen to breathe and food to eat.
There are certain ideas on which Objectivism is absolutist, asserting that certain ideas are universal. One is that human beings need to be free to live their lives, to choose their own paths.
So its important not to confuse the two kinds of absolutism.
They ARE happy in Australia, New Zealand, UK, USA, Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Sweden, Norway, Denmark etc.
So they are happy in every country that is NOT muslim.
Who do they blame ? Not Islam, not their leadership, not themselves. NO !!, they blame the Western ( Christian ) countries where they are happy in . AND they want to change them to be like countries they came from, where they were unhappy !!. Have I missed somethuing ??
Says it all really doesn't it. And no, I don't hate Muslims or anyone else for that matter.
Atheism says there is no God.
Either the atheists are right, or the religions are.
Is that absolutism? To make that statement?
Atheists will always argue that you have the right to believe whatever you want, no matter how ludicrous, as long as it doesn't impede the ability of others to have their beliefs.
Is that absolutism?
The trouble with your argument is that it tends to advocate that if two views are in opposition, we must all concede that the truth lies somewhere in between.
And it absolutely doesn't.
It's as simple as that. And it is very easy to see that this is so.
Not a respect which many of your fellow Muslims would allow. When your religion teaches that religion is not worth shedding blood over, your belief system will have more respect than it currently affords itself.
Islam is 600 years younger than Christianity. Similar scenes were being enacted due to Christianity 600 years ago and they continued until the last 200 years or so. We can only hope that the interconnectedness of the modern world speeds up that maturity process for Islam.
For the record, if people want to believe in magic (any religion) they should do it in their own home, in a way that doesnt impact anybody else except voluntary members of the same cult and we should discriminate against any imposition of religion (taking a religious oath, prayers in school etc.) on secular society.
We will kill one another for wearing the wrong soccer club shirt. No wonder extraterrestrials have given up on us.
“rational debate, not bigoted threats or actual violence.”
If a cogent argument cannot be concocted to counter controversy. What was used by the convert, to conclude that the concept was convincing?
“ignorance is sacred”
where the opportunity to question is suppressed. If something is correct what problem is there in proving it, and thus promoting it to all the peoples on Earth?
Surely only those who fear, or worse know of, flaws in an understanding, would seek to keep those discrepancies secret.
“those seeking to wield power and terror”
tremble in the presence of open debate. For truth itself, may be lurking there.
“human fallibility”
There’s an awful lot of it about. Its as if someone were handing it out free, with each gift of life.
“the most important things shared in common by belief systems”
is that they're not shared. Write them down and compare.
“atheists who believe,”
they know what cannot be known. Should consider becoming agnostics.
“Dawkins has in the past described Islam as "one of the great evils in the world"
Those who pervert tenets, may well be evil. If we knew the definitive quantification of that term.
“All human beliefs”
are dwarfed by one acme. Belief that anyone’s rendition of reality is actually reality.
“to fight absolutism”
Ask for a thumbnail sketch of the supreme being, from each.
u can't judge a religion from people behavior, cause nowadays its really hard to find religion people! Please don't tell me, you believe the 11 Sept and this Osama bin Laden fairy tale! this is Osama Bin laden have nothing to do with Islam!!! killing innocent people its not in any religion!!!
I'm Muslim Egyptian and i'm against any violence happening in middle east now, and a lot of us actually against it!
If people are willing to believe the unbelievable, who are we to say that Osama bin Laden is wrong but the Pope is right. Both tell their followers to believe the unbelievable.
Mar salama and I truly wish Egypt all the best for the future, I think your going to need it.