Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Lord Victor Adebowale

GET UPDATES FROM Lord Victor Adebowale
 

We Need to Stop Stigmatising the Young

Posted: 17/04/2012 01:00

There's one image dominating US news coverage right now: Trayvon Martin in his hoodie. The shooting of the unarmed black teenager in Florida has triggered coast to coast protests and calls to end racial profiling. The full facts about the 17-year-old's death last month are not yet known. What is undisputed is that he was killed in a mainly white gated community by an armed neighbourhood watch leader who thought he looked suspicious. The man who fired the trigger George Zimmerman has now been charged by police.

The case serves as a warning to us all. If fear and suspicion persist, especially towards young black men, then the same could happen in a gated community in London or Birmingham.
Youth crime in this country is seen as a black issue and this perception is fuelled by the press and backed up by statistics. Black people are three times more likely to face arrest than white people, according to figures from the Ministry of Justice. In 2007, a Commons Home Affairs Select Committee report found that 75% of gun crime victims were black and 79% of suspects. Metropolitan Police Service data reveals that 59% of males accused of robbery in 2009/10 were black, the same goes for more than two thirds of gun crime suspects.

We need to acknowledge why youth crime is all too often a young black male issue. What often doesn't get discussed is the link between crime and unemployment and the lack of opportunities. The number of young people without work stands at over one million, while the latest government data puts the number of NEETs (Not in Education, Employment, Education or Training) at 958,000.

This makes for a volatile situation which becomes even more volatile when you also consider the little reported fact that more than half of young black men are out of work. British black men are facing discrimination and a pattern is starting to repeat itself. It's alarming there's so little debate about the fact that a significant number of people from one ethnic group cannot access the employment market. We should not politicise this issue but we do need to face facts.
The role of business needs addressing too. We're relying on business to drive us out of economic hardship, but we're also questioning the role of capital in society.

Companies should play a role in society that goes beyond generating tax-revenue (or avoiding taxation as is often the case).

There should be a duty on business to be diverse. Bosses should make diversity in the workforce a priority, not from moral imperative but from the realisation that employing staff from all backgrounds gives them a competitive edge and more business opportunities.

Promoting difference is crucial in winning business at home and abroad in an economy where the service sector accounts for 83% of total workforce jobs and where the manufacturing sector has shrunk.

A neighbour assured me recently: "Things are getting better." The man, a TV researcher, told me confidently that black women are performing better than their male counterparts and rising up the career ladder. I'm not saying the situation is hopeless, yet these signs of improvement highlighted by my neighbour shouldn't be an excuse to ignore what we know. That poverty, injustice and a lack of access to services breed discontent. The result is social separation and mistrust that shuts the ears of policymakers. We cannot allow a permanent state of 'us and them' to develop, like that in Florida.

I see the same cocktail of issues that arose in the 1980s. Public spending cuts and reduced access to services are also playing their part in creating an anti-state culture. It's hard to get a loan or a bank account if you're poor.

Some will argue it's not just young black men who are suffering, but unemployed young white people too. But these are two distinct issues which should be kept separate, otherwise a hierarchy of oppression develops where different groups compete and are exploited by others for their 'victim' status. The English Defence League feeds on the frustration of disenfranchised white youths and offers them a framework that excuses violence. Gangs on estates attract young black men who feel misunderstood and have little hope.

We must also challenge our fear of youth, the perception that hoodie-wearing teens are only intent on committing crime. When I chaired the London Youth Crime Prevention Board, the Met and Government Office for London compiled data on how much young people volunteered and the work done with at-risk young people. The aim was to reassure the public that young people weren't a threat. Sadly, these efforts to look beyond knife crime were quietly shelved.

Ours is an ageing population, with the over 65s outnumbering those aged under 16. Young people from every background really are vital to the success of the nation.

We should be providing young people with a future, not stigmatising them - or shooting their hopes dead.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
11:48 PM on 06/05/2012
If the issue of Black youth crime is down to lack of employment opportunities etc, why is the story regarding Black youth the same the world over? Its the same in African countries and the Caribbean as well as White countries.
Could it be more to do with Black culture? I realise there are differences in culture in different 'Black' countries, but the crime and violence and low achievement is endemic in Black societies the world over.
Just a thought...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:33 PM on 04/24/2012
They are unemployable in many cases not unemployed . They all want something for nothing reward for no effiort and crime is easier on the brain
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
05:54 PM on 04/17/2012
We judge people far too much on how they dress and how they speak. Look white collar and you'll be treated white collar. I have a strong midlands accents and it has been used against me a variety of times, but I'm still going to employ the glottal stop and drop my alveolar plosives as I when I please! But in certain circumstances experience has taught me to play along.
03:07 PM on 04/17/2012
the problem is that our culture is all wrong. I am a working class white woman and have always been stigmatised in my community by neighbours, the local health centre and my childrens school because I work and do not claim benefits of make appointments duing the day. It would be soooo much easier for me and my family if I simply gave in to pressure and chucked my job that I have had for 21 years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drg40
Representative Democracy is all we have.
11:38 AM on 04/17/2012
Try this argument: If you're a young man who longs for nothing more than a reasonable job, chance to meet and court a girl, hopes for a family and a home thwarted at every turn by a bunch of obscenities convinced of their own righteousness, masquerading as government, and I tell you that this burden is felt even more keenly by some cultural groups than others, would you be surprised? If any one of the young men of a cultural group feel so alienated by the society in which they live, from which they see no escape, and battered by platitudes informing them that they should knuckle down and get a job, in surprises me that, in many cases, their response is so positive. And then to have heaped on top the decisions of the money crazed frenetics, in thrall to the banks, that the old should work longer because govt. has made a complete pigs ear of pensions planning, and in seeking employment the old take work from the young starting out in life, you'll pardon me if I don't see a very constructive outcome as far as the self appointed ruling classes are concerned.
11:06 AM on 04/17/2012
We need to start talking about discrimination black people face from other black people. Some black-on-black crimes have an ethnic dimension which his never discussed in the media.

In addition, I would say that this term ''the black community'' is nonsense. I had middle-class and working-class black friends when I lived in Peckham. The day after one barbecue, a middle class British Afro-Caribbean friend asks me, eyes rolling, ''Who were these guys? How do know them?'' She was referring to my working-class black friends. In her daily life as a middle-class black woman she never met guys like that. She had romanticised 'in da hood'' ideas about them Kinda sad really.

Social class divides the black community just as it does the white. Black community is also divided according to religion and country of origin. In fact ''the black community'' is a fiction. It leads to placing too much blame upon racism from whites as source of problems for working-class black people. And it allows rationalizing of engagement in anti-social behaviour and criminal activity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
coffeemadman
10:49 AM on 04/17/2012
Doesn't the fact that the large proportion of the crimes listed are committed by black men account for the higher chance of black men being stopped by the police? Whilst I understand that the underlying issues of why a higher percentage of black men are driven to crimes such as those should be addressed, I am confused as to why we focus on the police and apparent racism in the stop and search process. Racism exists and should be stamped out, but the police are responding to the facts for the most part.
01:55 AM on 04/17/2012
Only going to address one issue in this article, because it's a recurring issue, that's begining to rankle with me.

Why were 50% of black men unemployed????? Why are the supposed heads of our families, breadwinners and fathers of the next generation so incapble of doing what black women have been doing for years, getting a good level of education, a good job or starting their own successful businesses.

As a black women I know many black men from school/colege/univeristy/employment. Majority of the black men, that I have come across, in employemnt, are working in low-paid jobs. Security guards, buss drivers, cab drivers, sales assistants...a very small handful are professionals.

Why is the black community always accepting the underachievement of black men?..."Disenfranchisement" and other sorry excuses. We (black women) have it worse than black men. We are discriminated against for being black and being female. The men only have their ethnicity to deal with. It is still a man's world-anyone will tell you that women are still paid less, on average than men. Yet they cannot for the life of me, get off their lazy backsides and achieve.

It is high time black men assumed the positions of respect in society through hard work, that they so desperately crave. Do not feel sorry for them!!!!!

No more boring articles on black male underachievement (or no achivement). Post articles on the zero tolerance I hope the government and "community" leaders will take on them.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:36 PM on 04/24/2012
Well said You cant hear me but I am applauding your honesty. The other problem is that if I pointed this out I would immediately be pilloried as a racist so the problem is skirted around and exacerbated by people like mr adebowale making excuses for them