Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Louise Wilson

GET UPDATES FROM Louise Wilson
 

Trolling Is an Art Form

Posted: 03/11/2012 00:00

When I was in my early teens (admittedly not that long ago), so-called "internet trolls" were fairly common. They'd sit around in forums and threads making inflammatory comments to provoke a response from other users. It was a form of entertainment. Recently though, the definition of being an internet troll has changed. It now has much more negative connotations - all down to the mass media picking up on the label. What was once a term for harmless fun now covers a full variety of things, perhaps most obviously those who use the internet to torment and essentially bully others.

Now normally I'm not opposed to language change. I am an English student after all. But this is one change I cannot stomach. To me, the new definition of "trolling" is not trolling at all. It is cyber-bullying and causes unnecessary grief (as was the case with the Rest in Peace Billy Robson Facebook page). The two are entirely different; for this reason, I'd like to see the general public recognise that bullying and trolling are not one and the same.

Trolling is in fact an art form, and a favourite past time of those who frequent internet forums such as myself. It takes a certain amount of skill to create a troll post (skills I unfortunately haven't picked up). It must provoke some kind of response. It must be subtle enough that it isn't an obvious troll, but not so much that it is unrecognisable as a troll by the wiser members of the internet community. It must have an element of comedy within it. It must waste people's time. And most of all, it must not be malicious.

This may seem like a fairly non-issue, and perhaps it is. It probably is just me being a pedant. But every time I see "trolling" being used to refer to cyber-bullying, I get a little bit frustrated. Trolling is a bit of harmless fun. Bullying is not. A poster may say things they know to be wrong to get a response, to enjoy seeing people take what they have written seriously. It is quite common in many forums. The topics discussed may be emotive, it may get people angry, it may be a little controversial - but it has not been designed with malicious intent.

Trolling is an art form: a delicate balance between semi-serious posts and comical outcomes. Whether you like it or not, trolling is a major part of the internet community and has been for years. To lose trolling due to the mass media putting bullies and trolls under the same umbrella would be losing one of the many things that make the internet great. Some trolls are good, others terrible, some are obvious, others subtle - but at the end of the day isn't art the same?

Love or hate trolls though, you have to admit that it isn't bullying. It isn't to insult. It isn't to cause grief. I think it'd be a shame to lose the art-form of trolling purely due to people confusing the terms.

 

Follow Louise Wilson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/xLouiseGU

FOLLOW UK STUDENTS
When I was in my early teens (admittedly not that long ago), so-called "internet trolls" were fairly common. They'd sit around in forums and threads making inflammatory comments to provoke a response ...
When I was in my early teens (admittedly not that long ago), so-called "internet trolls" were fairly common. They'd sit around in forums and threads making inflammatory comments to provoke a response ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 33
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:23 AM on 11/17/2012
Louise: I think your post is unfair to short people. Maybe you should apologize?
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
04:19 PM on 11/05/2012
Trolling is for saddoes with too much time on their hands, and a suspect moral sense.
01:19 PM on 11/05/2012
finally i know what 'trolling' is thank you! i always assumed it was like 'dogging' but with really ugly women.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rob Ferris
01:12 PM on 11/06/2012
Keep an eye on the postbox, you'll be receiving the bill for my split sides shortly.
11:13 AM on 11/05/2012
While I appreciate there is difference between 'cyber bullying' and 'trolling', calling the latter an 'art form' is a bit rich. When we were teenagers we would go to music gigs, cinema and exhibitions (I still do!). If the author of this piece tried and get out more, she too may be able to see the difference between being artistic and being an online nuisance!
11:16 AM on 11/05/2012
(unless of course the article itslef was an example of 'trolling' in its purest sense)
11:32 AM on 11/05/2012
Mind. Blown.
09:11 AM on 11/05/2012
The definition of trolling is so vague it's impossible to say it's all malicious or it's all innocent fun. Sarcy comments on a YouTube video, correcting somebody's grammar on a forum, creating a fake account identical to that of a suicide victim and posting in their own tribute page of Facebook - all probably called trolling, but one far more serious than the others.

As we all know, English is a constantly evolving language and the word trolling, like the word spastic so many years ago, was once a word that conjured up annoying yet innocent baiting, but now has darker connotations.
09:13 AM on 11/05/2012
Edit to add: obviously the word spastic never conjured up the image of annoying yet innocent baiting. What I meant was it was once a word used in earnestness to describe a mentally disabled person and is now seen as nothing more than derogatory.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Handyman 123
04:18 PM on 11/04/2012
Trolling isn't Art or even being Clever. Hands up those who think some of the people who make a Sarcastic or abusive comment on the net. Would ever say the same thing if Face to Face with the recipient of their post.

No I didn't think so.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Louise Wilson
04:22 PM on 11/04/2012
That's my point though. Trolling isn't about being "sarcastic or abusive", it's an attempt to be funny (without insulting people). You might not find it funny or clever, but not everyone has to same taste in Art either.
11:25 AM on 11/05/2012
Look, I do hate it to break it to you, but as much as you argue its artistic value, by no standard can 'trolling' be considered an art. You consider yourself a pedant. Well, here are a few definitions of art for you:
1. the quality, production, expression, or realm, according to aesthetic principles, of what is beautiful, appealing, or of more than ordinary significance.
2. the class of objects subject to aesthetic criteria; works of art collectively, as paintings, sculptures, or drawings: a museum of art; an art collection. See fine art, commercial art.
3. a field, genre, or category of art: Dance is an art.
4. the fine arts collectively, often excluding architecture: art and architecture.
5. any field using the skills or techniques of art: advertising art; industrial art.

As you can see, none of these can even remotely fit the concept of 'trolling'. Even such deserving forms of expression as 'poetry' are not art in the strict sense of the word. So, can you explain on which basis you describe random provocative online quips as an art form?
06:53 PM on 11/03/2012
What you seem to be saying is when you do it, it is fun, when others do it, it is cruel.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Louise Wilson
08:26 PM on 11/03/2012
That's not what I'm saying at all. I don't do it, for a start. What I mean is that what was considered trolling before is not same thing as what the media have picked up on as trolling. Trolling isn't cruel. The type of "trolling" that classes as cruel isn't trolling.
09:22 PM on 11/03/2012
Louise, what you seem to be saying is that it's not cruel when you're the one doing it. Consider how you would feel if you were on the receiving end. Some people have been driven to suicide through trolling.
02:12 PM on 11/04/2012
Ok louise i was playing Devils Advocate a bit ... a little bit !
06:37 PM on 11/03/2012
Well some trolling does get severe but it's the internet you xan't end trolling forever, it's pretty much impossible.
06:34 PM on 11/03/2012
Ok
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IsameldinAbdelr
Reading,writing fan
12:52 PM on 11/03/2012
Remember wine is wine but users are not the abusers
06:54 PM on 11/03/2012
Hey man, AA is next room !
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IsameldinAbdelr
Reading,writing fan
02:43 AM on 11/16/2012
Though I didn't catch the meaning of of AA Thank u be it praise or otherwise
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
IsameldinAbdelr
Reading,writing fan
02:34 AM on 11/16/2012
Thank u Louise
10:13 AM on 11/03/2012
"It's like saying that talking loudly on your cell phone in a public conveyance is entertainment." - January - hit the nail on the head.
05:16 AM on 11/03/2012
As you say, trolling is a art form. Some people just doesn't get it and have no sence of humour.
11:28 AM on 11/05/2012
Well said, sir!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:24 PM on 11/02/2012
It's like saying that talking loudly on your cell phone in a public conveyance is entertainment.
01:56 PM on 11/05/2012
Not seen Trigger Happy TV then?
07:46 PM on 11/02/2012
"This may seem like a fairly non-issue, and perhaps it is." You said it.