This week, the Sri Lanka Campaign for Peace and Justice (of which I am a co-director) launches a campaign aimed at promoting ethical tourism in Sri Lanka. The lobby group has recently uncovered evidence that a range of British tour operators are offering holiday packages that commercially benefit alleged perpetrators of human rights abuses.
The campaign is timely. Wednesday was Responsible Tourism Day at the London World Travel Market 2012 and, astonishingly, Lonely Planet recently listed Sri Lanka as its number one holiday destination in 2013.
A tropical island off the coast of India, Sri Lanka is a popular tourist destination with its stunning beaches, lush forests, tea-growing hills and many sites of historic and cultural interest. It was wracked by a bloody civil war for almost three decades. During the final stages of the conflict in 2009 an estimated 40,000 civilians were killed.
What many tourists do not know is that the new peace in Sri Lanka has come at a high cost to freedom of expression and the human rights of its citizens. The country is now rated the fourth most dangerous place in the world for journalists, higher even than Afghanistan. More than fifteen journalists are believed to have been killed since 2006.
At the end of the war 300,000 civilians were illegally detained in inhumane conditions likened to concentration camps. There were credible reports of coercive interrogation, torture, rape and extra-judicial killings. According to a United Nations panel: "The Government subjected victims and survivors of the conflict to further deprivation... some of those who were separated were summarily executed, and some of the women may have been raped... Some persons in the camps were interrogated and subjected to torture"
In the rush to smooth the way for tourism, the government started to bulldoze various Tamil Tiger landmark sites including cemeteries and the homes of Velupillai Prabhakaran and other LTTE leaders. The Thileepan memorial near the Nallur temple was also defaced apparently with the collusion of the Sri Lankan army. Enflaming local tensions, the authorities have proposed replacing the homes of LTTE leaders with hotels and resorts.
The presence of troops in the north and east, once Tamil dominated regions, has increased, with the military monitoring civilians and controlling many aspects of their lives. Non Sinhala communities are treated with distrust and civilians have to seek permission even to hold gatherings, including traditional religious events, sometimes resulting in the military attending private functions and taking pictures. Many of those released from camps have not been allowed to return home because land remains under military control.
The government has initiated land registration in the north and east, while prohibiting many Tamils from returning to their homes and thus making a legitimate claim. The Internal Displacement Monitoring Centre's most recent estimate is that around 125,000 civilians are still living in temporary accommodation. They live in tents surrounded by landmines and without access to basic services, food, jobs and money. Meanwhile, the military continue to confiscate private land and designate it part of a High Security Zone (HSZ) in order to build their own houses, farms and facilities - including tourist hotels - with impunity.
Last year, Tourism Concern reported that the government and large tourism developers had forcibly displaced fishermen from the waters around the 14 islands of Kalpitiya, destroying livelihoods, threatening food security, and wreaking havoc on the environment. Some were even forced off their land, and had to go to court to get it back. The fishing community, as well as farmers, small-scale tourism enterprises and traders, claim they were not sufficiently consulted about the Kalpitiya Integrated Tourism Resort Project - Sri Lanka's largest tourism development to date.
Many tourists never leave their hotel and most Sri Lankans are too frightened to speak about what is going on in the country. So visitors are unaware of a very different world outside the resorts where ordinary people continue to have their basic human rights trampled upon, sometimes involving violence and torture.
To find out more about Sri Lanka and how you can help go to: http://www.srilankacampaign.org/tourismdilemma.htm
Follow Lucy Popescu on Twitter: www.twitter.com/lucyjpop
Pipedreams. Travel does not broaden the mind and there is a multi-million dollar industry [eg Lonely Plonker] making sure that the minds become narrower every day. I did know about Sri Lanka and it is truly upsetting but faced with the 99% who say "I,ve done Sri Lanka" [Vietnam, wherever...] after a few days sharing accommodation with the other loyal readers of that book, I do not think there is much that can be done.
You should see them in Saigon. They have that book constantly in their right hand [it would be disrespectful to carry their bible in the left]. One hotel in Ninh Binh is listed - plenty of guests there. Next day I walked 100 yards down the street and asked at the next hotel. Cheaper. Cleaner. Nice view. No guests. Guess what - it wasn't mentioned in the bible.
frere
hanoi
freewheelingf@gmail.com
UN 'failed Sri Lanka civilians', says internal probe, 13 November 2012
During the past few years, the International Bar Association’s Human Rights Institute has raised concerns about the erosion of independence in Lankan judiciary – google IBAHRI link Sri Lanka. In October the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) Secretary Manjula Tillekaratne was brutally assaulted by a hooded gang. No arrests so far. Daily Mirror 13 October carried Senior Minister Wimal Weerawansa’s explanation for the vicious assault. He said, “Elementary Dr Mervyn. It was self-inflicted”.
This is an excellent wake up call stirring our conscience. There are beaches everywhere, hotels everywhere.
Some do not listen until they are affected.
Syria was used to be a tourist destination as well.
Unethical tourism and promotion will allow the leaders to buy more time. In Sri Lanka's case, it is six decades.
Humanity and civility are at stake here.
Thank you again.
http://www.peace-srilanka.org/media-centre/political-analysis
Very oppressive post-war memorials have been built by the government: their location, size and design cannot be more oppressive - obviously peace and reconciliation is not the aim:
President unveiled monument on 9 December 2009
http://www.defence.lk/new.asp?fname=20091209_06
Defence Secretary unveiled monument on 30 April 2010
http://www.defence.lk/new.asp?fname=20100430_09
Defence Secretary unveiled war memorial on 9 May 2010
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kEes9C-TB00
International community should object these memorials.
If your concern is genuine, you should object the memorials of both sides. But you voiced agained the distruction of LTTE war memorials and construction of army war memorials. Wow, how unbiased you are.
For your information, all the memorials of saddam hussain were distroyed by US forces.
Many countries build war memorials that aspire for peace,
But then Tamils are still being oppressed.
When will the Sinhalese have a change of heart?
These human rights orgnisations criticise anyone who violates HR:
http://www.crisisgroup.org/en/regions/asia/south-asia/sri-lanka.aspx
http://www.amnesty.org/en/sri-lanka
http://www.hrw.org/asia/sri-lanka/
http://www.humanrights.asia/countries/sri-lanka
http://www.peace-srilanka.org/media-centre/political-analysis
http://en.rsf.org/sri-lanka.html
http://cpj.org/asia/sri-lanka/
http://www.icj.org/country/asia-pacific/south-asia/sri-lanka/
http://www.ibanet.org/Human_Rights_Institute/Work_by_regions/Asia_Pacific/Sri_Lanka.aspx
http://www.scribd.com/doc/104705097/Conscientious-Sinhalese-Tell-LLRC
If only Sinhalese can change their attitude:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/104760706/Sri-Lanka-Education-for-War-Must-Be-Transformed-Into-Education-for-Peace
Not quite sue how the writer got to know about all this information that she has published then? Was it via the tamilnet? or other LTTE front organizations? This is sickening.. the country was battered for 30 years due to terrorism that was funded by the very same organizations that accuse the country for human rights violations. Give SL a break, let its peoeple enjoy the hard won freedom and peace. Everyone in SL has the right to enjoy the peace divident.
Yes the government's (as of any other 3rd world country) is not perfect, but everyone in Sri Lanka, including Tamils are relieved that the terrorists are no more there and no boms are going off everywhere.
1. Balanced book: can you recommend any ‘balanced’ books on this ethnic conflict in Sri Lanka? :
2. Memorial? Is there any place where the names of people who died have been recorded, as a MEMORIAL? Has the 3 years been used to buy time to erase evidences by not allowing INDEPENDENT journalists, HR activists?
3. Can you please recommend any INDEPENDENT video documentary that shows the ROOT CAUSES of the ethnic problem? The award winning British Channel 4 documentaries valuable in knowing what happened in 2009 but what about ROOT Causes?
4. Can you please recommend any INDEPENDENT video documentary that shows about the Media Freedom in Sri Lanka?
5. Can you recommend a ‘balanced’ web site that gives the history and events?
Thanks.
1 Sorry to be postmodern but I'm not sure there's such a thing as a truly objective account - and academia has not caught up with Sri Lanka yet in a serious way. Although a work of fiction "Chinaman" by Shehan Karunatilaka explores the root causes quite well. Otherwise books like "Still Counting the dead" by Frances Harrison and "the Cage" by Gordon Weiss may not seem balanced but they are fair and objective accounts. Crucially they are just as critical of the LTTE and the Government of Sri Lanka. If you want an objective account I suggest you read one of them, read some GoSL apologia, read some LTTE apologia and then make your own mind up.
2 In Sri Lanka memorials are being demolished. Frances Harrison has set up an online memorial here http://www.stillcountingthedead.com/wp/?page_id=426
3 Not really. Someone should make one.
4 This was Al Jazeera http://www.aljazeera.com/programmes/listeningpost/2012/03/201233112540802853.html There's also Beate Arnestad's latest film "silenced voices"
5 It depends what you mean by balanced. We do that in an objective way but clearly we have a campaigning position. Groundviews have a commitment to giving all sides a fair hearing but are more about current events than history. Indeed I don't know of many websites, balanced or otherwise, that really concentrate on the history. Sri Lankan activism is sadly dominated by the now (and by activists).
Do you think those innocent people who work in tourism industry are criminals? You talked about the death of so called journalist during the war, but you failed to mention most of them areLTTE terorits worked in their illegal hate radio station which was destroyed during thewar. For your information, SriLanka is ranked as one of the safest places to live, higher even than the UK, sri lankans are ranked as the 8th most generous, sharing same place with the UK (world giving index) and one of the best places to visit (surveys including natgeo, and loanlyplanet)
This article is full of lies, half truths and absolute rubbish. You think government should preserve the birth place of a terrorist who killed presidents and priministeres and ministers of democratic countries and thousends of innocent people? Ask USA to build a monument for Osama.
After the end of the brutal war, everyone in the country, sinhalese, tamils and muslims are now building their lives back and you people want to see blood again and again. Before teaching ethics to the other people think how ethical you are?
(Dhanapala is a Sinhalese and was formerly UN Under-Secretary General for Disarmament)
But keep in mind that all those governments fro 1948 were chosen by the people and the people always has the ability to change the government in the next electiion
Anyway, instead of answering directly, you have always chosen to quote some one else. A cunning approach to hide the errors in your own article.
None of the government in the world are perfect. The above comments from Mr. Jayantha Dhanapala are valid for ANY OTHER GOVERNMENT IN THE WORLD. It doesn't validate the errors in your article.
The most important thing is it is improving since the end of the war. Compare the situation in 2009 with 2012. All most all the IDPs were resettled within 3 years, infrastructure is being built and people are busy in rebuilding their lives while you people are trying hard to stop the process. Can you name any other post conflict reconciliation process in the world that can match this progress? Of course nothing is perfect, but they are IMPROVING.
When 90% is done you talk only about the remaining 10% (which of course will be completed in coming years). If you have a genuine concern focus on the improvements that need to be done (as internal displacement monitoring centre did) instead of calling to boycott the whole country thereby degrading the livehood of innocent people.
I have been here through the bad times and now the good times of this country. When you are living things you experience are much different to what you read on a piece of paper. No one will pretend everything is perfect but things have improved for many in N&E compared to 3 years ago. Please visit the country and form your own opinion.
As you see we do not call for a boycott for the reasons you specify. But we talk about how you can maximise the social good of your trip while minimising the benefit to the regime and covert militarisation.