Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Borkowski

GET UPDATES FROM Mark Borkowski
 

The Royals and Us: Is it Really So Rosy, Or Just Another Fad?

Posted: 02/06/2012 00:00

In the run-up to the Jubilee juggernaut, the western media has become obsessed with the newfound brand success of the British Royal Family aka Brand GB - pomp and circumstance consolidated holdings. Whatever your feelings on Good Queen Bess and her spawn, it's impossible to ignore the remarkable difference in public attitudes-particularly among younger demographics- to those you'd have found at a similar point in safety-pinned '77 or icily indifferent '02. However, is it all really so rosy? Or is this just another fad? Perhaps, arguably, the greatest PR turnaround for any institution.

The Jubilee is a time for nostalgia, so let's look back. When Lillibet placed herself upon the throne in a docile fashion in '52, it was in uneasy shape. A collapsing Empire, a half-baked socialist zeitgeist and the ominous first tremors of the multifarious cultural revolutions to come were imperceptibly weakening the crown's hold over the Nation. As an organisation, too, the Royal Family was troubled: a gaggle of distant siblings led by an increasingly remote matriarch.

Her initial decade or so in power saw a golden period with the public. Over the subsequent 50 years, however, the Royal Brand's PR fortunes waxed and waned. The overall trend was destructive. The rise of the tabloid press, the growing disruptive iconoclasm associated with late 20th century youth culture and some ridiculously poorly judged behaviour on the part of key figures culminated in a post-Diana brand ground zero. The monarchy barely figured in public attention at all, other than when the media got it together to disinterestedly spit some bile at Harry's latest sartorial nasty or nightclub fumble. Not a great idea to dress up as a Nazi for a night of revelry.

Possibly beginning with the surprising (eventual) success of 2002's celebrations, a phoenix has since risen from the ashes. Thanks to a new cast possessed of a range of not unhelpful qualities from benign exuberance (Will and Kate) to roughish good cheer (Harry MK II, a bit like the last version but with approximately 20% less banter) to distractive assets like Pippa, the show has become a good deal more watchable. These, coupled with occasional use of well-managed legal and some admirably ego-free PR pixies pulling the strings, have comprised the kind of comprehensive brand laundering exercise rarely seen outside of BP's Tony Hayward's wet dreams.

The Will and Kate effect is a remarkable thing - anyone who's seen me speak will know that I habitually hold it up as a shining case study to organisations and brands of all stripes. Their PR epitomises all that is great in good communications: healthy cynicism, transparency, definition, strategy, digital fluency, mutual understanding and, above all else, a compelling set of stories. I'm sure they're genuinely very happy, but the Royal Couple presented to the public is also a triumph of propaganda. Even a genuflection to Hollywood royalty?

The sum total of it all is that the Royals have made sense of themselves for the popular understanding again. They struggled before because they didn't have a purpose in an increasingly fragmented world: they had no power, no authority, no meaning. What they've done is to spot a pertinent niche in the public appetite- an austerity fed hunger for Downton-esque pomp and circumstance- and cleverly slotted in to fill it as a cuddly comfort blanket.

In some ways, I get the media surprise: when things were bad, they were really really bad. Prince Edward's Right Royal Knockout remains one of the most excruciating moments in TV history (though one, it must always be pointed out, never endorsed by her majesty).

However, one should never underestimate the power of a royal PR machine honed over centuries of carefully managed events and stunts. From Queen Victoria's expertly judged publication of her youthful diaries in 1868 to Kate and Wills's post balcony kiss, open top Aston Martin photo-op, the Royals' appreciation for event PR has seen more highs than lows.

The concern now has to be deepening and drawing out this purpose. The problems on the horizon aren't hard to spot. Theoretically at least, Britain is at some point going to snap out of recession and go back to cheerfully consuming itself into meaningless emptiness, no kitsch nostalgia necessary. What's more, no amount of socio-historical theorising can ignore the fact that, where the current monarch is a cuddly old dear, and her assumed successors are a friendly scout leader and his fit spouse, her actual successor is a malodorous, gypsy-poaching organic food baron. Now there's a PR disaster waiting to happen. Publicity gets more than a little tiring. You want it, you need it, you crave it, and you're scared as hell when it stops

The natural next step is for a Royal birth and christening, something I'm sure is figuring heavily in the prayers of Palace officials. The Jubilee will make an peerless experiential marketing event, and one which will undoubtedly bewitch the rest of the world. We'll see a boost in tourism and a greater confidence in Britain as a potential safe place for money from beneath various European floorboards. Whilst I'm sure complacency won't be creeping in any time soon, the issue is to capitalise on this success - it is only the beginning of a new, potentially more turbulent chapter.

Ah yes, some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some hire public relations officers

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:54 PM on 06/05/2012
"some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some hire public relations officers"

Good points. There's also that fourth category of people, who fail to hire the right public relations officers. We have some good examples here in the United States.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sue Harvey
09:38 AM on 06/03/2012
I don't know about 'fad' so much. The amount of vitriolic bitterness and just plain nastiness I read in news outlet 'comments' on line is scary. I don't see much hope for the economy in Britain with government seeming so inadequate, and I reckon we are going to become much poorer before there is any change, with the divide between rich and poor growing ever wider. The Royals will become even less popular in that event, and the Queen's $250 ml pa 'cost' to the people will become even more begrudged. "Referendum" will be the cry from the repulicans. Strangely, I believe rock stars, film stars and football stars will be allowed to keep their twinkle.
09:18 PM on 06/02/2012
We have a monarchy that works reasonably well for us...it's part of the warp and weft of the fabric of the country. It also connects us with our history and heritage. If you have a good,intelligent and honest constitutional monarch,independent of politics then I think it probably adds to the strength of our governmental systems and our society in general .

As for the 'monarchy encourages snobbery and class divide' argument, I'd say that I think that would happen here anyway,even with President Blair and First Lady Cherie in charge. Sweden,Denmark,Norway, and even New Zealand,Australia and Canada are pretty classless,yet Monarchies endure there.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
11:47 AM on 06/04/2012
I'm not a Monarchist, but you make some good points there muttlee. It's our successive Governments which have made bigger impact between rich & poor in this country, mainly by increasing the gap.
08:37 PM on 06/02/2012
I read a few comments about France's tourist industry being bigger than ours and them having no monarchy. I can't speak for the rest of the UK but I've worked as a tour guide in London for a long time. With the best will in the world, Buckingham Palace and Windsor Castle are no Versailles or Louvre - they're not even in the same league. In my experience what people are most excited about and interested in when they go to the Palace or Castle is the fact that it is a real living place, its the monarchy or specifically the Queen that draws people there, not the actual places themselves.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sue Harvey
09:47 AM on 06/03/2012
Exactly. You can look at a beautiful cinderella carriage and crown jewels in a showcase in a museum, but it is hardly the same as seeing one drawn by a beautiful team of horses carrying a handsome prince and beautiful princess wearing diamond studded crowns. Stuff of fairytales ....that we should not grow out of lest we become cynical. We should not forget that they too are playing their part.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:11 PM on 06/02/2012
They keep telling us we're all excited by this, but I'm seeing absolutely no evidence up here in Yorkshire
11:27 AM on 06/04/2012
No one ever gets excited about anything in Yorkshire, all they do is moan about life.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:49 PM on 06/04/2012
We do enjoy a grievance, this is true.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:08 PM on 06/02/2012
A fad because it is an excuse for a party and it’s the long weekend that many people will take as a long party. At any point if things go wrong for the Royals like it did in 1992 then the attitude towards then can easily shift. If The Royals hadn’t finally got it right when Diana died, and they needed telling to get it right then the popularity would have been diminished for a very long time.
Mind you I like the Queen but after her reign I feel it might be about time to seriously think about cutting the Royal Family to just the Monarch and next in line to the Throne.
04:58 PM on 06/02/2012
Can you imagine a Great Britain with out our Queen,I cant, She is our beaming light,She deserves the respect she has from the nation, 60 years of service.WELL DONE!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:23 PM on 06/02/2012
No flags or street partys around here, in fact, just a normal weekend with normal british summer weather! Sorry to say but all the media-hype over this Jubilee simply hasn't reached into our household. As far as I can make out, the Queen is just another tourist attraction who, like the govt, is a bit far removed from the everyday reality of life.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nic the wonder puppy
When life throws lemons, throw them back
03:55 PM on 06/02/2012
Everyone loves a slinky
09:55 AM on 06/02/2012
Well, on a day heralding the start of national CELEBRATIONS you could not be more downbeat. Your prejudices poke through, no doubt endearing you to some but certainly not to me. We can, and indeed most of us have, been critical of the Royal family but then how many of your friends' families have you also been critical of over the years? Most, probably, just like the rest of us. The fact is that they are human and subject to all the usual human frailties. The Queen has reigned for an astounding 60 years and done so with selfless devotion. The monarchy is not the answer to many of the ills facing our country today but it is, on balance, a uniting influence something we desperately need to preserve the health of this country. This week I have written a short personal perspective on this topic and it contains some of my memories of the coronation day 60 years ago. I suggest you read it and reflect on whether your approach merely deconstructs our national traditions without any positive alternative.
http://www.silverlinksnetwork.com/news-a-politics/66-diamond-jubilee I may not couch my writings in similar, styled prose but I am full of hope for what can be achieved not what can be lost.
11:38 PM on 06/01/2012
When the postmodern post-ideological experience designers and reality manipulators meet the premodern traditionalism of royalty and privilege, my modern egalitarian self feels like throwing up.
This comment has been removed.
11:07 PM on 06/01/2012
Trivial, shallow, smug, cliched, completely lacking in any historical or serious political perspective, and not an original idea or expression in it. Just what you'd expect of a PR person really.
photo
SecularAdvocate
Media Watcher
06:21 PM on 06/01/2012
www.throneout.com
This comment has been removed.
06:03 PM on 06/01/2012
It's a bit like being reverential to your tapeworm.