Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mark Pritchard

GET UPDATES FROM Mark Pritchard
 

EU Migration Greater Challenge Than Non-EU Immigration

Posted: 11/03/2012 23:00

There's a lot of tough talk on immigration, but not enough is being done to bring down immigrant numbers from the hundreds of thousands experienced under the last Labour government, to the tens of thousands, promised by the Conservatives at the last general election.

Last month, the Office of National Statistics, published the latest immigration figures, which highlight only marginal progress being made in tackling Britain's extant immigration crisis.

Some of these small steps have reduced student visa fraud, but the same cannot be said for tackling the rampant abuse of family, work, and tourist visas. The same applies to gripping short-stay visa fraud. These are visas issued to non-EU citizens who accompany their EU relatives to Britain. All continue to be misused and misapplied on an industrial scale.

Like all illegal immigrants they take advantage of British tolerance and exploit every legal and technical loophole inherited under the liberal visa regime left over from the last Labour administration. In turn, illegal overstayers continue to take up permanent and illegal residency in Britain.

From the cost of interpreters in schools and hospitals, to increased demand for public and private sector housing, to cheap labour, the scale of immigration into Britain is impacting on the 'bread and butter' life-experiences of thousands of British families - from coast to coast. Ministers are right to talk about the advantages of controlled immigration, and there are many, but little is said of the disadvantages of uncontrolled immigration.

However, immigration is not the only cause of crowded public services. The hidden multiplier effect felt in countless urban and rural communities is the often dramatic change brought to local communities by supposedly, 'temporary EU migration'. In reality, these temporary migrants become permanent immigrants. Something Whitehall prefers not to talk about.

Both large and small communities bear witness to the varied and cumulative effects of the 'legal' free movement and 'settlement' of peoples from other EU countries into Britain; a phenomenon sociologists claim is having a far greater social and economic impact on communities than any 'illegal' non-EU immigration. That is why it is inaccurate for illegal immigrants to be made the scapegoats for any community tensions caused by EU immigrants.

Moreover, with increasing unemployment in the eurozone and the wider European Union, further sharp increases in EU immigration could follow. For those EU immigrants unable to find work they will probably join the tens of thousands that already work in Britain's expanding cash in hand, and unregulated black economy, where extortion is rife and where workers human rights are non-existent. Others will probably join countless other European immigrants that avail themselves of Britain's already over-stretched welfare system, as is their entitlement under EU law.

In work or out of work, these economic travellers will put additional pressures on Britain's struggling public services. Couple this with the prediction that, at some point, the euro will either contract or collapse altogether, and the potential for further economic and social turmoil on the continent increases. With the very real prospect of thousands more EU immigrants queuing up at Britain's open borders. Further, if the eurozone and wider European Union enter into a severe recession or even depression then EU immigration could well turn into a 'surge'.

Such a scenario might be 'events in extremis', and may never happen, but the duty of policy makers and responsible governments is to plan for both hard and 'soft' threats to our borders. That is why it is the coalition government must ensure that it puts in place all the necessary 'legal and physical' measures to protect our borders, should these events occur.

The euro may survive, and over time, and with the right state and market remedies, the economies of Europe will undoubtedly recover. In the meantime, the government must act to put the national interest before the European interest, and protect Britain's borders.

 
There's a lot of tough talk on immigration, but not enough is being done to bring down immigrant numbers from the hundreds of thousands experienced under the last Labour government, to the tens of tho...
There's a lot of tough talk on immigration, but not enough is being done to bring down immigrant numbers from the hundreds of thousands experienced under the last Labour government, to the tens of tho...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
07:33 AM on 03/13/2012
Surely the whole point of being in the EU is to have the EU in control? The rights of EU residents to move to the UK is sacrosanct i.e. the UK government has no control whatever under EU law.
03:04 AM on 03/13/2012
why do you think david cameron would not give british born subjects a vote on leaving europe ?
one of the very reasons I voted concervative was the belife that david cameron:s party would not just stop ilegal immigrants getting in -but would reduce illegals already here. but of course it never happened -david is more interested in his own agenda -not the voter;s ! needles to say my vote will not go to concervative next election ! unless concervatives put a stronger leader forward who will stand up for british born subjects !
12:12 AM on 03/13/2012
The MP seems to forget that freedom of movement goes both ways. Brits are free to go to the continent and many do for work, retirement, business, etc... These Brits have the right to many of the same benefits that EU migrants receive in the UK.

Personally, as an EU citizen, I appreciate the right to live, work and study in a variety of countries. It not only gives me a chance to find the best lifestyle and career for myself, it also provides me with a rich overall experience in an integrating world. We live in a new age which makes it easy to travel, communicate and experience the world around us like never before, it would surely be a pity to spend it all working and living in the same town or country our whole lives.
10:08 PM on 03/12/2012
Being a EU citizen you can travel across Europe without a passport and without being stopped at borders. Travel for shopping, leisure or business from one country to another will be cheap because there is no money exchange and no commission paid. So basically any EU citizen can live ,work and retire in any EU member state if they wish so.

The European Union (EU) has 27 democratic countries, working together for the benefit of all their citizens. So the EU came up with the idea of using practical achievements and to create a sense of common progress between member states. A thousands of people
come in from Europe, but a millions British people have gone into Europe.
08:25 PM on 03/12/2012
As a neo-Maltusian, while I am all in favour of stricter controls on people entering the UK across our borders; I am still waiting for a politican with the guts to say we need stricter controls on people entering the UK via their mother's birth canals. We desparately need a policy of reducing the birth rate, rather than encouraging professional breeders.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
Sabu.Satsang, Samsara, Solitude...
02:11 PM on 03/12/2012
The Wetminster puppets will listen to nobody. The people are so apathetic, that aready Britain is finished, they walk around with their heads up their Ar>>>, believing and trusting whatever any of the predictable 3. Say. Like them or loathe them, the BNP, has an open website, tap into that and be seriously troubled at what they say, and have been saying for many years. That is of course if one wants to hear the real truth at what your elected leaders have done to Britain....
03:21 PM on 03/12/2012
a good post mate
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
Sabu.Satsang, Samsara, Solitude...
04:17 PM on 03/12/2012
Thanks pal, now we await the armchair stataticians to give their verdicts, on how wrong we have all got it. Problem is, many haven't been outside to have a look at how overpopulated we really are. Demand for everything has heightened beyond all proportion. Water right now is going to be rationed, this country has always had this problem, now it has inreased intensely by demand, and it will be rationed earlier this time..Do they listen, why of course they don't, it is far easier to keep lying till their time in Wetminster is up, then they will hand over the baton of lies to the next load of liars, and so the story goes hey.........
02:06 PM on 03/13/2012
As I'm not in favour of reporting "foreigners", nationalisatilicy) I'll stick with UKIP who have the right answers and aren't far left, racist extremists.know how to deal with immigration, the EU and the economy without being racist or far left extremists.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mokgee
Sabu.Satsang, Samsara, Solitude...
02:48 PM on 03/13/2012
You mentiond extremist twice, sounds like you have a problem. Can't argue with UKIP, favour them for their real intentions. So I have no idea who the extremists are according to your post....
01:07 PM on 03/12/2012
Migration is integral to the 'reserve army' approach to the labour force.

By having competition for jobs, wages are kept flat while profits continue to rise.

The neoliberals want nothing else!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:40 PM on 03/12/2012
There is truth to that Tom, but since there are few limits on the movement of capital, wouldn't jobs just migrate to areas with lower wages, if we put harsh limits on EC migration? Not trying to score points here mate, just asking a genuine question.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Ben Wilson
What's the story mourning Tories?
11:28 AM on 03/12/2012
What's the point in moaning about immgration. It's a nice litlle Tory racket. Immigration is a conservative must-do kept in place by do gooding liberals who willingly take the credit and the flack, for a bunch of Tories who insist they didn't lower the draw bridge and lock it in place. Immigration will become a problem for the UK and it's going to end very ugly because there are no nice solutions. 60 million people, 60 million acres. How full and less green do we want to be? There is a tipping point in all this and you can be sure no one cares about that because it wont come to be in our lifetimes...out of sight out of mind.
04:29 PM on 03/12/2012
actually it was the B-liar who allowed massive immigration. it has been revealed he and other cabinet members wanted it so as to change the make up of this country.
08:31 AM on 03/13/2012
we've let them in in droves since the fifties and sixties, all parties are responsible for the current state of the country regarding foreigners.
09:17 AM on 03/12/2012
Why do we give any kind of benefits to Polish and other East Europeans who come here! I am sure we don't do that in their countries!!!!!
We need to get out of this EU lark!
10:29 AM on 03/12/2012
For a start get your geography right, Poland is in central Europe - Eastern Europe is Belarus, Ukraine and countries to the east. I am a UK citizen who now lives in Poland and am able to claim benefits here in Poland.
04:32 PM on 03/12/2012
yes but look at the amount you get. that is why they are rushing here, the child tax, and child benefits here are equal to a months wages in poland.
Michael II
Neither the one, nor the only
08:45 AM on 03/12/2012
In parallel, it might be worth checking the figures on the numbers of Britons that live in other EU countries, many for years on end. Plus the numbers of Britons that put a burden on local services by retiring to Spain and France. I could be wrong, but I don't think I've heard members of parliament asking for their return to the UK.
08:58 AM on 03/12/2012
As a Briton in Germany Mr Pritchard's views appall me - not just because I think they are wrong but because they are so impractical. For Britain to thrive we need free labour mobility. It's bad enough that we still have so many daft barriers to business across the continent without imposing new barriers to employment.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Drg40
Representative Democracy is all we have.
09:42 AM on 03/12/2012
In what way do you think these retired people are a burden? Sounds to me a few minutes checking of facts is called for. Unless of course you're suggesting that everybody who retires overseas is a criminal, fiddling the system?

Most of the retired people I meet who live in these dreadful third world countries across the channel occasionally come back to the UK for major holidays and recoil in horror at the state of this nation whilst the spawn of thatcher have been at the helm.
Michael II
Neither the one, nor the only
10:13 PM on 03/12/2012
Retired people tend to be old and use social and medical services more often.

"Most of the retired people I meet who live in these dreadful third world countries..."

LOL. So dreadful that Britons choose to end their lives there over their native country? Something wrong in your logic there. I had yet to hear Cannes or Nice being described as third-world towns. But this is HP, after all.
12:59 AM on 03/12/2012
Try to remember why you became a Tory. I assume it was as some kind of free-market chap in the early days. If there is free movement of capital, then the logical corollory is that there should be free movement of labour.
01:55 PM on 03/13/2012
Perhaps you could explain to us what, for instance, EU directives on battery farmed eggs have to do with the free market or free movement of labour? Or the Common Agriculture Policy or Common Fisheries Policy? Or perhaps the EU directive bannig incandescent light bulbs? The EU is a political project, it's not been about trade for a long time.
02:09 PM on 03/13/2012
Is there any particular reason why you have raised a number of irrelevant issues, which are completely beside the point I made?

The ex-Tory MP is complaining about immigration, which is essentially the movement of labour. As a Tory, he would have been in favour of the free movement of capital and goods. I simpy wish to know why someone who was once a Tory is now espousing protectionism, which is of course a socialist sort of nonsense.

If you wish to discuss lightbulbs feel free, but they it's not a subject that I have any strong feelings about, and therefore don't propose to comment on.