Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Martel Maxwell

GET UPDATES FROM Martel Maxwell
 

50 Shades of Grey: Why Women Are Reading it in Their Horny Droves

Posted: 06/06/2012 00:00

"Have you read Fifty Shades of Grey?" my friend Aileen was leaning in, her voice lowered conspiratorially.

Her eyeballs moved in their sockets extreme left and right; a strand of hair was in her cappuccino. I wondered if we were being followed.

"No," I breathed.

"Get it. It's basically porn. Huge in the States. Fabulous."

In the weeks that have passed since our conversation, E L James' trilogy, an erotic tale set in America of two lovers, has become a chart-topping phenomenon.

I know - I'm behind the times. Fifty Shades has spread like wildfire, igniting the nether regions of women all over the world.

My excuse? Getting married then honeymooning in Italy for most of May, where I read the classics. Silly me.

My reasoning for buying the first in the series upon return, was manifold. Well it would be. I'm British and female - I can't just gleefully rub my knees and tell you with husky voice that I want to read about sex.

I was also intrigued as to how something that is "basically porn" could achieve this mainstream success, knocking mighty The Hunger Games off the top spot after a 16-week reign in the U.S.

As a novelist who is toiling with the writing of sex scenes in her second book - having already had a few juicy episodes published in my first (Scandalous, published by Penguin) - my interest was piqued.

Completing even a sentence involving sex that is not cringe-worthy is tricky and I wanted to know just how E L James did it; how she had captivated so many people throughout what - my friend promised - was most of the book.

One hundred pages in and there was still no sex. It wasn't even very well written - not badly, but a bit immaturely. The character of the narrator, Ana, may only be 21 but a teenage Katniss manages clarity and wisdom in the sci-fi adventure trilogy The Hunger Games - though the books are obviously wildly different.

But every fifth word could have been Yugoslavian and I would still have kept reading because E L James' ability to build anticipation to the climax - or Ana's - is top drawer.

As I say, from experience I know good sex is very hard to write - more of that in a moment.

And this is precisely why my respect for E L James rocketed, circa page 113, paragraph two. Not that it's etched in my head.

She excels at sex - pages of it. She has you in the palm of her hand, feeling every sensation experienced by Ana at the hands of young billionaire Christian Grey.

It's rude - unafraid to foray into the dark world of sex where one is the dominant, the other the submissive. She gains our respect and attention because the field is incredibly well detailed and researched, leaving the mind boggling with beads, eggs, collars, bondage, flogging, whipping, caning, spanking and so much more.

By reading Fifty Shades, relationships - or some 'me time' - will have benefited, for there are only so many page-turning details you can read about Ana's climb to orgasm before you want one of your own.

On this note, couples looking spice things up on holiday should make Fifty Shades compulsory reading.

When my agent handed me back my first draft of Scandalous, she said: "We have a problem."

Like any self-respectfully insecure writer, I feared she had howled at the moon in agony at reading my words before showing all her friends and belly laughing - and not at the funny bits.

"It's good chick lit', she said.

Unlike some, I embrace the tag - and not in a sniffy "well Jane Austen was chick lit too" kind of way. My debut novel: Man Booker it 'aint. Me, it is.

We laugh at popular women's fiction at our peril, for E L James is proof of its popularity. She is also having the last laugh - all the way to her bank account at Coutts.

"But the sex scenes, Martel," my agent continued, "They're... well, they're awful."

I blushed.

"The rest of the book sounds like you, it sounds current. But 'throbbing manhood'? 'Pulsing member'? - it's like very bad Mills and Boon."

Purple of face, I knew she was right. I had never used any of these phrases to describe a penis and I'm not sure anyone ever has in actual conversation.

Since, I have admired any writer who can convey a love (though 'love' is not always present or necessary) scene that doesn't have the reader squirming.

Writing sex is a bit like having it - if you're awkward and uptight it's not going to be much fun for the guy, or in the case of books, the reader.

Start enjoying it and it feels natural and uncontrived.

Sex sells and of course this is nothing new.

The book I read before Fifty Shades was DH Lawrence's Lady Chatterley's Lover.

The first edition was printed privately in 1928 in Florence - where I started it - because the story of the relationship between an upper class woman and working class man was too sexually explicit, with words then unprintable. Not until 1960 was it published openly in the United Kingdom.

Dios mio, I am not comparing the literary merits of the two books. But they do have similarities, which make for their success, no matter the era.

If either Lady Chatterley or Ana dropped their knickers in the first chapter, it would have been dull.

The sweetness of expectation makes for a thrilling climax, when it finally arrives, by which stage you have a vested interest in the characters.

If a message is to be transferred into real life, it is: don't put out on the first night.

The women are more adored the longer they hold out, though one could argue Lady Chatterley didn't exactly play hard to get. But still, her journey to liking - let alone loving - sex, builds throughout.

Women are not known for boasting about their love of porn but we are reading Fifty Shades in our horny droves - 100,000 of us in the first week to be precise, beating John Grisham, James Patterson and Suzanne Collins to the top of the charts.

After taking a stall to sell Scandalous at an event in Glasgow, I'm not surprised.

"Does it have sex in it?" a grandmother asked (I know she was a grandmother because she introduced me to her 12-year-old granddaughter.)

"Not really," I lied, not wanting to put her off.

"Oh well," she sighed and wandered off.

When asked again, I said: "Sex? Yeah, loads, I hope you've got good foundation - you'll be blushing. A lot."

And whoosh, these women took one, two, three - muttering things like "Oh my pal Eleanor will love it," and one: "that's right up my mum's street."

Our thirst for erotic fiction - or quasi porn - on the page is the key to James' success. She has simply given the market what it wants - and we really, really, really want sex.

Martel Maxwell is the author of romantic comedy Scandalous, £6.99, published by Penguin.

www.martelmaxwell.com

 

Follow Martel Maxwell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/MartelMaxwell

FOLLOW UK CULTURE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 68
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:07 AM on 07/31/2012
This book has had massive "Media" coverage to "saturation" point, figure out which tribe the author belongs to, then find out the tribe who owns all the media in the Western World and the problem is solved,but!!, in saying that, good luck to them, they have convinced the simple minded sheep to buy it in millions,lol,what a "Con", but well done, keep it up, the sheep will buy the next ten books by the same author, luvely jubely, im gonna take up writing a book like in myself but!!!, what tribe do the Publishers belong to, i will leave that to the sheep to figure out, lol, you couldnt make it up could you,lol ha ha ha ha.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BigWillyG
07:27 AM on 07/12/2012
Just when I thought literature couldn't get worse than the Twilight Series a series that started as smutty Twilight fan-fiction tops the best seller list. :(
05:46 AM on 07/11/2012
If you are interested in this type of story but want to read something wonderfully WELL-WRITTEN that TRULY captures the imagination and is really hot to boot, read Jacqueline Carey. WAAAAAAAYYYY better.
05:37 PM on 07/19/2012
Noted. Thanks Jim John
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shan Ellis
10:14 AM on 07/04/2012
I know women who have read it and loved it, I, however gave up on the book somewhere along the line. Ana is infuriating! She constantly blushing, awkward, and frankly, if you sign a contract that stipulates vaginal douching the blushing stage passes quite quickly I would assume. I've read and edited lots of better quality material than Fifty shades by amateur writers. The read was bumpy, and akin to a very adult version of Twilight without vampires, but still inclusive the two main characters of a dominant brooding male and a shy virginial female. I'd prefer to spend my time re-reading The Wetlands by Charlotte Roche. Far superior first person perspective novel in my honest opinion.
11:54 AM on 07/05/2012
Hi Shan. I'm with you, there are infinitely better-written books out there; books that stay with you long after the last page is read. With Fifty Shades I was, however 'in it' at the time. The anticipation of sex, the sex (pages of it) and turn-on-ability (new word)..well, I got caught up. But even at the time, I knew it was repetitive and in many places cumbersome in fluidity. With the benefit of hindsight, it all seems a bit daft now - she orgasmed if he as much as brushed her nipple. And how many times can one woman bite her lip..and one man been turned on by it. It's not real life. But then, that's perhaps the point. We want to be titillated and it doesn't have to be in the running for a Man Booker. Also, EL James made the point the other day that she's heard from thousands of women thanking her for making them pick up a book for the first time in years..if not ever. They might not have a comparison, but this allows them to be taken out of their routine and into another world..which is a good thing, no?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Shan Ellis
10:23 PM on 07/05/2012
Hi Martel, I guess I have high standards having edited erotica for press freelance. The orgasming continually and constant biting of the lower lip (bella-twilight) bleeuuugh! Escapism is the right word for the majority of readers, and although formulaic it's still made the Times top 10. I'm feeling rather sorry for my friends who write erotica on a daily basis and haven't managed to forge the contacts within the publishing industry to get a three book deal!
04:33 AM on 06/30/2012
Want the sex toys featured in the 50 Shades of Grey Trilogy?!? Check out NoveltyPlus.com for all of the 50 Shades of Grey books, adult toys, & MORE from the series! Use promo code GREY for 20% OFF anything on the site now! http://www.noveltyplus.com
11:56 AM on 07/05/2012
And I thought I was a master plugger
PS buy my book - not as much sex as 50 Shades, but still, it's called Scandalous and it made Lorraine Kelly and Piers Morgan blush
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neechie
Not to be taken seriously
10:27 PM on 06/29/2012
I loved the first book. I kept hearing about it from girls I knew and read a review about how it was bad for women, she just gives in to him, etc. The book isn't the most well written, but it is a fun read. I did like how you go with her on this roller coaster relationship and every time I wanted to just finish the chapter, I ended up reading another. So it really is easy to read and fun. I liked the way it ended as well. Not as happy with the second book. Had the first one down in a couple of days, the second I am not as in to. It seems like she was trying to stretch the story in what could have been put into half the amount of pages. I think people have too much to read in to what it is saying or teaching women. It's just a fun read. I wanted to know what would happen at every turn. I didn't want it to be my life. I think that's the point. If it was realistic and something that could happen in my life, it would probably be pretty boring!
11:59 AM on 07/05/2012
I agree Neechie. As time lapses after having read it, I have to admit I can stand back and make a more critical analysis - it wasn't fine literature and it wasn't without fault. But it hooked me at the time and I certainly wouldn't count out reading books two and three. I'll have to wait until I'm on holiday thought because I lost two straight days and lots of my own writing to the first..and if that's not the sign of a good read, I'd like to know what is.
05:12 PM on 06/26/2012
Besides the fact that these books are so poorly written, the characters wooden and unbelievable, the plot unimaginative and unrealistic, lies the real evil - the destructive message they’re sending to women. American women are barraged with messages telling them they're not good enough - you're not thin enough, young enough, hip enough, fertile enough, smart enough, worthy enough. Women’s access to some very basic, gender specific medical care is under siege, with the Right-Wing sounding like they'd like to have women go back to the 1950's. Then there are the unrealistic expectations in terms of how many men think women should look, thanks to breast implants, hair extensions, waxing, liposuction, and mostly Internet porn. Adding to this toxic mix is the economic downturn, which affects women disproportionately, because they STILL get paid less than men do. Is it any wonder women incorporate and internalize these negative messages? But the worst thing about these novels, (and I speak from experience having experimented with being a Sub to a Dom at one point), is that they romanticize something that, in reality, is not healthy spiritually, emotionally or culturally. This book blatantly encourages violence against women. And if you get off on it, maybe you should take a long look at why.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Furdurp
Get the facts First. Then you can distort them.
03:44 PM on 06/26/2012
These books are total crap. Unbelievable on every level Grey is not a dominate he is a weak minded man that wants things his way, and Ana, is a whiney sniveler until its time to be submissive and then she rebels. They should cast Robert Pattison and Kristen Stewart in the movies as well because they are the same kind of drivel stories (and we all know Kristen can bite her lip alot). Woman cant get over her need of a man so she changes herself entirely. Blah If you want to read a reall story about the subject try readiing the retelling of Sleeping Beauty by Anne Rice
04:39 AM on 06/26/2012
I love the books! I was addicted to each page. Even after reading the whole trilogy, I've been rereading some of my favorite scenes. I hope they make a movie of it. Ian Somerhalder is the best Christian Grey! :)

Read my review here: http://complicatedmelody.com/content/fifty-shades-trilogy
06:02 PM on 06/24/2012
Why is it so hard to admit that most heterosexual women have a predominately masochistic sexual orientation, get off on the idea of a man dominating them? Some of the brainest women I've been with, when they are feeling horny, want me to -- as more than one has put it -- "F-ck my brains out!" That doesn't mean that after sex they don't immediately revert to form, want to reassert their braininess and be treated as equals (or, in some cases, superiors). Why apologize for this state of affairs, as if it were a cause of embarrasment? Just the way we are made.
09:00 AM on 06/29/2012
Hmmmmm ;) See, not all men are dumb and from another planet! There is hope out there!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PhilEssex
Statistically, 6 out of 7 dwarves are not happy.
08:55 PM on 06/29/2012
@terriminx2 Rofl...;o)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neechie
Not to be taken seriously
10:31 PM on 06/29/2012
It's not hard for me to admit. It can be fun. People try to think too much into why people like this or that. It takes the fun out of it. I think most control freak women (at least the ones I have met and know about) like the men to be in control in the bedroom. Sometimes it's nice to not be the one in charge for a while
01:43 PM on 06/16/2012
I have to say all these people saying the books are trash and poorly written, get over it stop being snobs. It's entertaining it's not a piece of art work. I loved these books. Christian grey was NOT abusive he WAS abused. This is a story of two disfunctional people that meet and help each other grow. People stop being so judgmental and critical....just enjoy.
02:41 PM on 06/12/2012
You're right, sex sells and the market definitely wants it. What I don't get is why this sex has to be between an older experienced man versus a virgin who orgasms at the tweak of a nipple, and in a dominating framework which edges worrying close to eroticised domestic violence. As for a man helping you to discover your 'inner goddess' ? Please. I'm a twenty one year old girl and this book did not turn me on. Us girls can do better.
08:45 PM on 07/24/2012
Older? He was like what 6 years older?
08:38 AM on 06/11/2012
Apologies, Martel. Not q awake yet.
08:37 AM on 06/11/2012
Nice multiple plug for your book Maxine, disguised as a review of someone elses. Well done.
09:55 AM on 06/11/2012
..though Maxine is in fact the name of the main character in Scandalous. Whoops there I go again. Your praise is coveted, FlyingScott
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
paul679
03:41 PM on 06/10/2012
Give these "Horny Droves" my address, will you Martel.
04:24 PM on 06/10/2012
Sure thing Paul