iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Matthew Hirtes

GET UPDATES FROM Matthew Hirtes
 

Spain's New Dictatorship

Posted: 26/11/2012 00:00

20 November 1975. Spaniards remember the date. For this was the day democracy returned to their shores, with the death of dictator Generalísimo Franco. Indeed, actor Antonio Banderas, despite being only 15 at the time, recalls toasting El Caudillo's demise with cava.

20 November 2011. Exactly 36 years after the passing of Franco, Spain's PP return to power. With the election of Mariano Rajoy as Spanish president. The PP, or Partido Popular as in People's Party, were famously formed by Franco henchman, Manual Fraga - one of his most repressive ministers.

Unsurprisingly, #RajoyAño1 started trending on Twitter. So it seems a perfect time to take stock. Just what's happened to civil liberties under Rajoy?

Traditionally, the misnamed People's Party have represented the pijos, the sector of Spanish society which put money right at the top of their list of interests. So, that's Rajoy's focus group: right-wing Spanish snobs. If he's got them on their side, that's all that seems to matter.

On a recent press trip to cover the forest fires in La Gomera, I met a PSOE politician. This socialist could see why voters increasingly found little difference between the two major parties. However, they were adamant their party wouldn't have got rid of public healthcare for immigrants if they'd stayed in power. "That's so typical PP", they told me.

During the Franco years, even when tourism started to take off, a visit to Spain felt not dissimilar to taking one to Eastern Europe. Spain was very much a police state back then. And it looks like it's becoming so again.

The increasingly hard-line policies by Rajoy have resulted in dozens of demonstrations; the right to protest the keystone of any democracy. Perhaps people are protesting while they still can. For, in Madrid at least, the PP's main representative there, Cristina Cifuentes is determined to put a stop to them. The Delegada del Gobierno de España den la Comunidad de Madrid is hell-bent on changing a law regulating the right to congregate and protest she deems "broad and permissive".

Although there has been some anti-social behaviour by protestors, for example lobbing bricks through banks' windows, the vast majority of people attending such demonstrations have been peaceful. Which only goes to highlight the bully-boy tactics of the police. Tactics which have included autographing plastic bullets with the message 'Souvenirs of Spain' in Pamplona, mistaking people's heads for baseballs in Madrid, and concealing their identity badges in order to "give it them hard". Them being the demonstrators of course, although sometimes it's hard to tell who's who. Especially as the police have taken to infiltrating protestors and acting as agent provocateurs to encourage them to break the law. As reported by The Guardian's man in Madrid, Giles Tremlett.

The police were at their most brutal, last week in Tarragona. Where they attacked a 13-year-old boy. His crime? Merely being at the protest. Clearly, this government now has blood on its hands.

Famously, Franco was a shy individual. Rajoy seems to be that way inclined too. As can be seen on a clip which has become a YouTube classic. Watch his reaction to being asked questions by the press. Yes, he really does just turn around and walk in the opposite direction. I mentioned this to a friend and he gave me the shoulder-shrug before replying, "Matthew, he's Galician." Worryingly, so was Franco. One would hope history doesn't continue repeating itself.

Matthewhirtes.com

 
 
 

Follow Matthew Hirtes on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@MatthewHirtes

FOLLOW LATINO VOICES
20 November 1975. Spaniards remember the date. For this was the day democracy returned to their shores, with the death of dictator Generalísimo Franco. Indeed, actor Antonio Banderas, despite being ...
20 November 1975. Spaniards remember the date. For this was the day democracy returned to their shores, with the death of dictator Generalísimo Franco. Indeed, actor Antonio Banderas, despite being ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:40 on 27/11/2012
I think Spain problems comes out the fact its 2 biggest parties have a socialist ideology...... PP party founded by Fraga, a minister in Franco’s fascist gov and National Socialism’s transformer to adapt it to the new era post pure fascism is the actual “right wing” in Spain political spectrum. ..... PSOE is the party of the sons and grandchildren of the socialists and communists defeated by Franco...... how much have both parties evolved from its original ideologies?????......... not much I think...... from the castrofascism friendly Franco to the open castrofascism supportive Fraga passing by the orally "hostile" to castro Aznar and ending in castro repression "tolerant" Rajoy we see a PP that is a lot leaned to the left if you compare it with right parties in central Europe or northern Europe....... PSOE has been in the necessity to move yet more to the left in order to make bigger the ideological gap with PP....... the result ...... both parties lies to the left of the spectrum in most ideological issues........ it is a lot hard to find differences when you compares fascism or its heirs with socialism or communism and its heirs....... extremes touches at the end of the circle.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Hirtes
08:30 on 27/11/2012
Some original observations here, Sigmund. However, I think big parties tend to gravitate to the middle. Yet, recent developments have seen the PP lurch to the right again. Despite Franco's links with Germany, which resulted in the destruction of Guernica for example, I've never thought of the Falange as national socialists. When, for instance, noted historian Paul Preston writes about the Civil War, he mentions a left and a right.
16:53 on 27/11/2012
Well dear Matthew, the world has become so polarized between right and left that even historians has fell into this trap. To find how national socialist Franco's regime was is a hard thing that depends of which historian you read........ take Wikipedia definition of Falangism for example:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falangism

As you can see this definition explains us in the first and second paragraphs Franco's Falangism as a socialist and nationalist been very close to Nazism but with some particularities and also disentions with Italian fascism...... but the fourth paragraph surprises us by placing Falangism to the right according to scholars !!!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts
13:15 on 26/11/2012
As a Spaniard, I find your parallel between Franco and Rajoy extreme, although sadly, not entirely inaccurate. There is a democratic process in place, yes. It may not be perfect, and in particular votes are computed using the D'Hondt method, which favours large parties, a system that has limited the country's ability to make small course corrections, favouring big swings instead. But what has not changed much since Franco is that those in power hold a strong sense of entitlement to make snap summary judgments coupled with a total lack of accountability. Rajoy not feeling compelled to make a public statement minutes after signing what are perhaps the most savage health cuts in the history of the country is an example of that behaviour. So yes, while we do have a mechanism to practice democracy, we still lack the values to make it real. This lack of values permeates through all layers of society, not just the political class: nominate any individual as people manager, community representative, any type of role demanding collective responsibility, and watch them turn into monsters, little dictators with no regard for the individuals they manage or represent. It seems as though we can't handle power just yet, although everyone (with Artur Mas' latest independence tantrum being a recent example) craves it. I left Spain long ago, and while I watch developments with interest and genuine concern, I'm not sure I want to go back. It's not the recession... it's the values.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Hirtes
15:07 on 26/11/2012
Thanks for your overview of the Spanish voting system. I'm sorry you felt moved to leave Spain yourself. Unfortunately, there's another mass exodus occuring. It hasn't really got anything to do with the cracks starting to show in Spanish democracy either. Rather, the lack of positions for young, qualified jobseekers has led to a brain drain.
17:45 on 26/11/2012
Well unfortunately as you know the lack of positions for young people in Canary Islands and the unemployment is really severe in this Comunidad Autonóma And yes, you are right I know lot of young nurses who have been forced to leave to your country
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
battleofalma
12:43 on 26/11/2012
People's expectations of Spain as an economy were too high. Only out from under a dictatorship since the 70s, removing the bad habits of that form of government (mainly the corruption) was always going to take a very long time. And an economic boom + corruption is always asking for trouble. Just ask Ireland.

Spain as a country was a fundamentally flawed project anyway, and the sooner regions such as Catalonia and the Basque region are devolved the better.
Essentially, Isabella of Castille married the wrong guy and should have married into Portuguese royalty instead....
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Hirtes
15:10 on 26/11/2012
Like your take on Isabella and the way you compare Ireland's woes to the pain in Spain. I'm watching developments in Catalonia and the Basque Country with interest, from afar.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
battleofalma
15:57 on 26/11/2012
Thanks.

 

The historic argument is that Castile + Portugal
would have made more sense as a kingdom than Castile + Aragon. Arguably the
Catalans would have fit better into a Northern Italian/Provencal/Sardinian cultural
bloc than they do Spain.
10:36 on 26/11/2012
Spain is now deep in debt (yes, I read the Spanish press) and the austerity measures are only going to bite deeper and deeper which is why Mr Rajoy is taking so long to accept more bale-out money:he knows how deeply in debt Spain is and the effects the austerity measures are having but he also knows that if he accepts more bale-out money to give him a breathing space,then Spain will be in debt for generations and austerity measures will need to be introduced that will lead Spain to total melt-down.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Hirtes
11:02 on 26/11/2012
Sean, I appreciate your comment. I understand Rajoy has some tough decisions to make. However, it's the way he and his party approach these decisions which worries me. I could have written an article about the austerity measures but instead I chose to write a not unrelated one about the erosion of democracy in Spain.
11:28 on 26/11/2012
Hi.I also lived in Majorca for a number of years and saw some of this coming so I sold-up in July 2006,just before the housing market collapsed.I still visit Majorca every year and Tenerife where my Brother lives and I see the effects the austerity measures have had on a proud people and these measures are eroding Spanish democracy,which is only 35 ish years old and I know from what I hear that people are turning to the right again and that is something Mr Rajoy fears,Spanish democracy is not as rock-solid as we think and austerity and democracy are not strange bed-fellows in the Spain of 2012 and Mr Rajoy knows this.
09:38 on 26/11/2012
As a new arrival to the country and having been up to my neck for the last two years in the personal concerns that a relocation carries with it, I don't feel I'm adept with Spanish politics. I do feel however that a pattern we've seen across Europe has been replicated here - the knee-jerk replacement by electorates of centrist or centre-left governments with administrations that lean to the right in terms of policy but especially in terms of rhetoric. The mood is ugly, and under those circumstances the right thrives. We're seeing everything from separatism to an unreasoned increase in anti-immigration sentiment and xenophobia in many countries and Spain is no exception. What is different here is the severity of the crisis and hence the possibility of social unrest, and it is a worrying time.
While I take the point from Alex's comment that Rajoy is a product of the democratic process and that this obviously undermines a comparison with Franco, you'd have to go a long way to convince me that PP loyalties are all that different to the dictator's. Today's government is obliged to operate within the parameters of a democracy but the question "Who are they operating FOR?" remains.
The project for the courageous politician is to challenge the modern orthodoxy that our human concerns are best resolved, in all cases, in the market. Our markets are poisoning our democracies. If you want to find a truly modern dictatorship, look to the markets.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Hirtes
10:59 on 26/11/2012
Thanks for your comment, Robin. And can see where you're coming from regarding the markets. It's the ugly mood you mention which inspired me to write the article in the first place.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Matthew Hirtes
00:47 on 26/11/2012
Thanks, Alex. I'm not the first to compare a "democratically-elected" leader to a dictator, however. When Margaret Thatcher took on the unions in the UK, she was viewed as being more dictator than prime minister. The people will continue to take to the streets because they realize the People's Party doesn't represent them. Although perhaps they should start wearing body armour like the police do. To protect them from the so-called peace-keepers.
This comment has been removed.
23:56 on 25/11/2012
Nice article, although I think it is a bit of a stretch to compare Rajoy to Franco. He is, after all, the democratically elected leader of the country. Democracy is now well established in Spain and there is no danger of dictatorship returning.

Cienfuentes is a fairly extreme figure in Spain and all her rather silly coments about banning demos has achieved is to get people out on the streets to protect their democratic rights. Not the best thought-out public statement!

Police brutality in Spain is a serious issue and has no place in modern Spain whatsoever. Good to see the point highlighted on The Huff.
12:06 on 26/11/2012
Wish I could be as positive as you about the extent to which democracy is entrenched in Spain. The extent to which the move towards an independence referendum in Catalonia have been met with heavy handed threats from the PP government and their allies - see www.helpcatalonia.cat - are quite worrying.