Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Nabeela Zahir

GET UPDATES FROM Nabeela Zahir
 

'My Tram Experience' Race Relations in Modern Britain

Posted: 1/12/2011 00:00

The racist torrent of abuse that spewed out of the mouth of a woman travelling on a London tram has left many Brits horrified. Documented and uploaded to Youtube as 'My tram experience', the video has received over 4 million views so far. The woman, later named Emma West, was subsequently arrested and charged with Racial Harassment, after the video came to the attention of the British Transport Police. On Monday, Twitter saw the hashtag #mytramexperience trending with the majority of people shocked that such racism could still exist.

Taking into consideration the ongoing Stephen Lawrence trial; a racially motivated killing unresolved 18 years later, I question whether the video represents a mentally ill woman, or a serious level of racism in the UK?

Growing up as a British Pakistani, I have always been aware of my race. Break times at my predominately white Primary school saw playground taunts about smelling of curry and laughter at my mum's "funny Paki outfit". I never mentioned it at home as I felt ashamed and believed that somehow I was to blame. I came to understand that I was expected to grin and bear it. As I grew older, I learned to defend both my ethnicity and my right to be deemed British. Despite these devastatingly negative experiences, they faded in my overall experience of being a British Asian, I felt the UK was my home.

However, in the months that followed the terrorist attacks of 9/11, things began to change. Fear of the 'other' was exploited and racist discourse was not only accepted, it was also promoted by particular arms of the popular media. People I considered friends began making unknowingly offensive remarks about my faith. I have also been the victim of verbal racism from strangers on several occasions in the past 10 years. Highlights of 2011 include being called a "F****ing Paki" in South End, whilst out filming for work and being threatened at a Kilburn Cafe, for simply looking in the direction of someone who clearly did not like the colour of my skin.

Worryingly, the Far Right have begun to re-emerge and the growing problem of extremist groups such as the EDL is seemingly ignored. In November 2010 the first ever hate crime figures for England, Northern Ireland and Wales were published. The statistics showed that in 2009 there were 43,426 reported cases of race-related hate crimes, with an additional 2083 cases of faith related hate crimes.

Despite the shocking number of racially motivated hate crimes, the figures only provide a limited insight into the real level of racism. Hate crimes do not always go reported and it would be utterly naïve to assume that racism only exists in the form of violent attacks. Whether it be verbal, online, indirect or direct, at the work place, in our hospitals, within our education system, or on public transport, racism exists in many forms. If asked "Do you hold racist views?", I doubt that many would tick the yes box.

Sunday's incident also highlights the fact that racism is not targeted at any specific community. Following the UK riots, the age-old racist rhetoric of 'Black culture as aggressive and violent' once again re-surfaced. On 12 August David Starkey appeared on Newsnight, speaking to Owen Jones, author of Chavs: The demonization of the working classes, he stated:

'What has happened is that the substantial section of the 'chavs' that you wrote about have become black. The whites have become black'

Specifically, Starkey was referring to West Indian culture with his remark directed at the use of Patois by British youth. Starkey was clearly blaming what he phrased as a 'dominant' West Indian culture for the riots. Following the incident there were over 700 complaints to the BBC, demanding a public apology from Starkey. Despite receiving harsh criticism from Ed Miliband, no apology was ever made and the issue was seemingly swept under the carpet. Ofcom decided to take no action.

Starkey was not alone in his attitude. On 17 August John Bird, co- founder of The Big Issue wrote a piece for The Independent, titled 'Fashion has become a weapon on the streets of London'. A rather uncomfortable read, Bird echoes Starkey's sentiments and blames the riots on a loss of White culture, to a dominant threatening Black, specifically West Indian culture.

"For me one of the most significant (images) is the shorter, weaker, white boy being made to strip while a bigger black boy, or man, watches. The uniform that the white boy, and many white boys wear, is being taken from him. He is no more a human being. He is no more one of the boys who run with the riot."

Taken aback that the founder of a magazine like the Big Issue wrote with such a Victorian hand, I expected backlash or at least some sort of reaction to the piece. If there has been any, I have yet to hear about it.

Following the flurry of #mytramexperience tweets, I tweeted asking followers if they had ever experienced similar situations. I was overwhelmed with the level of responses ranging from cases of a few insulting words, to aggressive and sometime violent attacks. Most shocking were the tweets from Myriam Francois-Cerrah @MFrancoisCerrah, a writer, activist and a convert to Islam. She explained :

"Spat at, verbal abuse, swearing, one bald-headed man rolled up his paper, shoved it under my chin & told me to rethink my beliefs"

She elaborated:

"Have had glass bottles and beer cans thrown at me and my daughter on tube, threats online, etc"

Other tweets included:

@SuperFabRae
"I remember two male Sikh members of staff getting pics drawn/images made of them with the Twin Towers..."

@DocSyK
"Have been spat at in Oxford and called 'Paki' by a bunch of chaps passing me in the street (when I used to wear a hscarf)"

@Gizz_T
"I was on the bus and this lady said 'This is my country and I can't even get a seat on the bus. Go back to your own country'"

@Hassan_Offistan
describes the racial abuse he suffered as a door to door salesman:

"I was called a P*ki or a Talibani. There was one particular house where the guy came out of the house, threatening me too..."

Despite receiving over 40 tweets and emails regarding experiences of racial abuse, declaring that the abhorrent words of one woman represents the views of a majority would simply be sensationalist. The UK has not yet reached a level where Far Right groups represent any type of significant majority, but they are rising in popularity. The increase in racist discourse as well as the acceptance of it fuels xenophobic sentiment. Terms such as Islamists and Islamification are bandied around, confusing people, leading them into believing that anything associated with the term Islam is violent, oppressive, and threatening. The likes of Starkey and Bird remain free to demonise minorities, in a biased view of freedom of expression.

Granted, the 'My tram experience' incident may be an extreme form of racism that may not necessarily represent the day to day experiences of Britain's minority groups. It does however highlight the fact that we are yet to overcome racism and thus, the core issues of what creates such intolerance must be readdressed. There has never been a time when a racial utopia has existed and I doubt such a thing could ever exist, but we are losing sight of what makes the UK a racially tolerant and welcoming society. It is time for us to bring the discussion of race relations back to the forefront.

 

Follow Nabeela Zahir on Twitter: www.twitter.com/nabeelazahir

The racist torrent of abuse that spewed out of the mouth of a woman travelling on a London tram has left many Brits horrified. Documented and uploaded to Youtube as 'My tram experience', the video has...
The racist torrent of abuse that spewed out of the mouth of a woman travelling on a London tram has left many Brits horrified. Documented and uploaded to Youtube as 'My tram experience', the video has...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 19
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
09:47 AM on 12/07/2011
I arrived in UK just 3 months ago as a student. I found the Britishers very warm and welcoming people. My black hair and brown skin didn't cause me any trouble. In my opinion UK is a bridge where people from different communities and cultures come together and amalgamate. This amalgamation will cause some friction, but why does the media only highlight bad things. A British white man helped me find my address a couple of weeks ago, this will never be reported by the meda.
03:22 PM on 12/06/2011
the figures for race / faith hate crime dont show who is committing them. many of these crimes are committed by ethnic groups against each other and against the white community. in London various ethnic groups have a real hatred for each other.
also in many areas the faith attacks are by muslims against other religions. churches are often the targets of these crimes.
you mention Stephen Lawrence but dont make any mention of the recent racist attack by a group of black youths on a white boy leading to his death.

in a free society it is wrong to impose racial laws on the population. if someone doesnt want to nix with or deal with those of a different ethnic group that is their choice as long as there is no physical violence why should the law be involved?
people worry about the rise of the right but the major parties have always ignored the concerns of the people .
02:16 PM on 12/07/2011
But you just said that race and hate crime are committed amoungst ethnic groups! what rubbish there are many groups that dont get on ie british and Travellers­­. The stephen lawrence case was white against black and as for Danny o'sea that was black against white both are two deaths because of intolleran­­ce to one another. No-one choses what they are you are just born. Yes its a choice not to mix with other groups but then your just segregatin­­g yourself and what does that achieve ( more ignorance)­­. We live in a world that will continue to mix whether one like it or not. What we need to do is stand together as a community and filter out the bad people from all groups not tarnish a group as a whole!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daviejohn
All the world's a stage,
12:53 PM on 12/04/2011
Race is not the issue, Integration is the key, if you want all peoples to fit in society then there has to be a willingness to accept it's customs, Religion,Language and way of life.
03:23 PM on 12/06/2011
correct but at this time it is society that is expected to change to the new.
02:11 AM on 12/03/2011
As a white "Brit" living in a former British colony, I am in a racial minority, the one which is usually blamed when things go wrong, though British authority packed up and left many years ago.

We humans like to find scapegoats when things go wrong. "Politicians" among us will use "scapegoats" for political capital. Hitler cited the Jews. Bob Mugabe offered up the white British. There are many more examples in history. We should all be very wary of those "politicians" inciting us against each other like that. They do it for their own interests, not ours.

It is my humble view and experience that racism is aggravated by imbalance in society and insecurity. Too many of one makes the other feel threatened, particularly in hard times. Privileges for one deny the other, and so on. We are seeing something like that situation developing in Europe. In simple words, the fair balance and sense of security that makes it easier to tolerate one another is being lost and the blame for that I place firmly at the door of the politicians and the naive "politically correct". They allowed society to become unbalanced for narrow party-interest and half-baked, ill-informed liberal ideology. Now they must try to restore balance and provide that sense of security for all, to prevent Enoch Powell's alarming prediction ever coming near reality. Believe me, that reality is not a pretty sight.
03:25 PM on 12/06/2011
a very good point. i have often argued with my left wing friends on a similar point. why is a child of immigrants born here classed as British, yet white people born in Africa whose family have been there for several hundred years are never counted as Africans?
12:53 PM on 12/07/2011
are u serious! i think you need to check your facts! I have both white and black born African friends and they are African, African passport African Birth certificate!!!
10:34 PM on 12/02/2011
Why was no one in Government arrested when the labour party admitted last year that they enabled the mass immigration to the UK of millions of third work=ld immigrants that will create cultural friction at the very least for generations, simply, in their word' to rub the rights nose in diversity"
Emma West should not be arrested, she should be in the government representing her people that see their language,history,ethicity and culture being swamped and washed away forever by a tidal wave of unasked for immigration.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Tara Thomas
... Say hello to my puggie: Goldie, everyone!
12:48 PM on 12/03/2011
Pretty simple then isn't it. It's the 'millions of 3rd world immigrants' who caused the economic difficulties in the UK. Go figure ..... they must have been around in the 30's & 70's as well.
03:31 PM on 12/06/2011
actually they were. in the North East in the 1930`s there were race riots between the locals and the yemani population there was also a huge number several hundred thousand east europeans and jews arrived in the UK.

by the 1970`s large number of immigrants had arrived in the uk, in particular into many of the mills etc in the north west and in many parts of Yorkshire and London, usually working for far lower wages
12:52 PM on 12/03/2011
Robb all I can say is that it hurts when the shoe is on the other foot!

How about making the same argument to native Americans, aboriginals in Australia and the maori in New Zealand. Some of the biggest migration in the world came from the British Isles. No one thought about the language, etnicity and culture of the people who were being swamped by mass migration from England at the time...unasked for might I add.

I suggest we all learn to get along..everything changes, cultures, language ethnicity etc
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daviejohn
All the world's a stage,
12:58 PM on 12/04/2011
They are better places for it though, better us than some other European nations.
03:33 PM on 12/06/2011
all the above peoples were immigrants arriving in those countries and in the case of America wiping out the peoples there before them. so the Arrival of the British (most emigrants from the UK were Scots Irish and welsh) is no different to what you support now