Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Natalie Bennett

GET UPDATES FROM Natalie Bennett
 

We Need to Bring Our Troops Home

Posted: 22/11/2012 00:00

Paddy Ashdown is right to call for the troops to come home from Afghanistan. The ongoing occupation of the country is a running sore that can only be healed after we've shown a commitment to allow the Afghan people to choose their own destiny. Currently we are pinning in place a corrupt regime and many of our allies that our governments hope will inherit the country after we leave are as indifferent to human rights and the rights of women as the Taliban ever were.

Ashdown describes us as "the tainted partners of a corrupt government whose writ, along with ours, has progressively collapsed". We cannot talk of promoting democracy while we're backing a crooked regime. We must not pretend to ourselves that we are a force for democracy when we help close down meaningful dissent against that government.

Years ago, in 1997, Robin Cook was right to argue for an ethical foreign policy, saying that there has to be "an ethical content to foreign policy [which] recognises that the national interest cannot be defined only by narrow realpolitik."

The mission in Afghanistan has lost sight of any progressive ideals it may have once held and we remain from a simple desire to maintain our international prestige and ensure 'our' Kabul government stays in place after withdrawal. However, our standing in the international community is harmed not enhanced by the failed mission in Afghanistan.

Ashdown said that "we should have engaged Afghanistan's neighbours, instead of going out of our way to make them enemies" referring to the fact that far from eradicating the Taliban we have spread their influence into Pakistan while drone and artillery attacks across the border raise tensions, deepen divisions and most importantly kill the innocent.

Malala Yousafzai, the brave school girl activist in Pakistan, was shot down by members of the Pakistan Taliban, an organisation that did not even exit before the invasion. Far from protecting girls like Malala we have been the unwitting cause of spreading the hold of murderous misogyny across the region and our drone strikes and military arrogance deepen the problem rather than solve it.

Al Qaeda may no longer have much influence in Afghanistan but their brand of terror touches more nations on Earth than it ever has. Their seeds of hatred have been sown across the world blown by an ill-wind we helped create. The world is a more dangerous place than it was at the start of the century as a direct result of the US foreign policy that the UK has been so complicit in.

We have lost sight of any meaningful objectives and are now desperate to find a way out without losing face. We should not continue to award ourselves the moral right to occupy other nations.

Our most recent occupation of Afghanistan has been marked, much like the others, by a directionless war that turns Afghans into enemies while getting bogged down in mud and blood. The growing occurrence of so called 'green on blue' attacks on allied forces are not simply a failure of security checks but a deeper sign that more Afghan's than ever are unconvinced that the 11 year occupation has been for their benefit.

We should bring home the 9,000 British service men and women still stationed in Afghanistan, taking them out of harm's way. We should learn the lessons of the last decade of war by becoming genuine advocates of peace, scrapping our arms deals and targeted strikes. Being an advocate and supporter of peace should be Britain's place in the world.

 
FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Paddy Ashdown is right to call for the troops to come home from Afghanistan. The ongoing occupation of the country is a running sore that can only be healed after we've shown a commitment to allow the...
Paddy Ashdown is right to call for the troops to come home from Afghanistan. The ongoing occupation of the country is a running sore that can only be healed after we've shown a commitment to allow the...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 74
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
03:39 AM on 01/17/2013
Hello everyone, if you're in favor of pulling troops out of Afghanistan prior to 2014, kindly visit this page!
http://www.facebook.com/#!/TroopsBefore2014
02:06 PM on 12/04/2012
While shedding tears for the soldiers who volunteered to take part in this illegal invasion, spare a thought for their innocent victims.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathan0316
TrueBlueTory Age quod agis
01:00 PM on 12/02/2012
This is the fourth time we've gone to war in Afghanistan. If someone doesn't learn their lesson after the 3rd time they've failed miserably, wouldn't you normally suggest that perhaps a different tactic may be in order?

I couldn't agree with this article more if I wanted to. The nature of the pointless war in Afghanistan is such that no matter when we left, we couldn't declare a victory. The whole area is a quagmire, parts of the ME are worse than they were before we invaded, we've spent trillions of pounds, lost far too many British personnel and for what? Nothing I can see, certainly nothing that was worth a single one of those lives!

Cut our losses, pull out now and leave these mountains to the barbarians who've controlled them for centuries and will continue to do so long after we've left, whenever that might be.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:48 PM on 11/27/2012
Good call, Natalie Bennett. Miles ahead of arch-plodder Paddy Ashdown.
11:23 AM on 11/25/2012
Ever since the invasion of Iraq, and Afghanistan, the Middle East has become a powder keg, and the World is now a much less safe place. It doesn't matter how many terrorists are training in Afghanistan, Iraq, or anywhere else, as long as we stop them entering the UK. British troops would be far better used in the UK to police our borders, and make sure that no one enters the UK who is a threat to us.
We have troops in Afghanistan, and meanwhile the UK border agency is so understaffed, that anyone, and everyone is being let into the UK. Not to mention people smuggled into the UK in the back of lorries etc, that is our biggest threat to security, and that is the job that our troops should be doing.
photo
Straggler
Life is a protrusion within a lawn mower
01:26 PM on 11/23/2012
As a Green Party voter in the USA, I say great article Ms. Bennett! It was a lonely world back in 2001 when only 10 percent of Americans agreed with me that invading Afghanistan and toppling its government would be a HUGE mistake. But the arms merchants who purchase our members of Congress preferred to militarize the West's response to 9/11, all in the name of corporate profits. A defunct and tiny cult in Afghanistan, with its dead 19 hijackers, continues to play the world for fools. Incredible.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spawnrules
12:26 PM on 12/02/2012
I'am a Green Party supporter myself. I voted for Jill Stein.
12:39 PM on 11/23/2012
I just wish we would stop interfering and meddling in other countries affairs. We might not like the way they run their countries, but it is their country. The western world shows an insufferable arrogance and ignorance regarding other countries culture and time-honoured practices. Not all cultures value democracy, equality etc. as we do. They have their own ways that have served them well for centuries.
10:29 PM on 11/22/2012
Why can we not accept that our conflict in Afghanistan has been an unmitigated disaster? As an ex-serviceman I have seen first-hand how the Afghans despise us except when we are giving them money or gifts.

The attitude to life in this backward country is totally different to ours and nothing we do will ever change it. The Taliban are just one tribal sect that demonstrates how they place no value on lives and any single foreign casualty is worth losing hundreds of their own.

The Russians were forced to retreat - we should follow suit rather than sacrifice more of our precious lads and lasses and we should also withdraw all aid, leaving the country to fester back to where it was always going anyway.

Stop our politicians from playing games with lives and money - most of them are barely out of nappies and all of them would need to change their underwear if a brown-paper bag were burst nearby.
08:43 PM on 11/22/2012
oyyyyyyyyyyyyy huff why was my comment not posted too near the truth was it on bush and blair
07:35 PM on 11/22/2012
No one wants our troops to stay in afganistan, we want them home and out of danger.
The heartbreaking part about this is that they will eventually come home knowing that many many of their friends, colleagues will not, this has been a no win war .and the sacrifices that have been made has brought little to this country in terms of peace.
Being murdered by the very troops, or police that our forces have trained, no more thinking needs to be done get them out of that godforsaken place fast,
photo
25sammy25
We just wanna be togever !!!!
06:53 PM on 11/22/2012
Of course it's time to bring our troops home NOW. Not next year or the year after, but NOW. They have been out their fighting a no win war from the onset. What have we learnt from this war ?? Nothing, except that it has cost us hundreds of troops lives. Bring them home to their families for Christmas. What a bonus !!!!
07:36 PM on 11/22/2012
So very true Sammy well said. They are in a no win situation in a country that does even want them there. We just followed the Americans again. Forgetting the actual money cost the cost of even 1 life in this conflict is 1 too many. Come on David, you want to go up in the poles then do bring them all home for Christmas.
photo
25sammy25
We just wanna be togever !!!!
10:39 PM on 11/22/2012
keithalgarve - Absolutely.  Let's hope Paddy Ashdown gets it across to DC and hope thast DC has the backbone to stop being dictated to by US.  As you say, 1 life lost is 1 too many.  Take good care.  xx
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
spawnrules
12:29 PM on 12/02/2012
And a lot of innocent Afghani's have died.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:32 PM on 11/22/2012
you will never win a so called war with an inviserble enemy whoes willing to die for something he or she believes in...?....allthough in reality it dosent even exist...will go on forever.....
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Mickey Mouse 1
There are no lies or deceit on a chess board.
06:14 PM on 11/22/2012
You're a bit slow, but welcome to the bandwagon that started years ago.
photo
Reith
what's a micro-bio?
05:44 PM on 11/22/2012
No one has a clue how many Taliban are among the troops and police we're training out there. The indigens just watch occupiers come and go. They've got their AK47s from the last lot, they'll pick what they can from the current lot. In a few years another lot will come along.
photo
Reith
what's a micro-bio?
05:22 PM on 11/22/2012
"The growing occurrence of so called 'green on blue' attacks on allied forces are not simply a failure of security checks "

Security checks? What checks? They're taking anyone who comes in and, I don't know, asking a few questions? Most of these people can't read or write. How is any security check possible?

Yes, bring our people back asap. As soon as the Americans start pulling out, Karzai will be booking a seat on their last plane so he can go and live wherever he squirrelled that aid money. He won't stay once the UN leaves, you bet.