Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Peter Blair

GET UPDATES FROM Peter Blair

Destroying Schools, Destroying Hope in the West Bank

Posted: 08/09/11 06:00 BST

The United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) for Palestinian refugees recently published a worrying story about the proposed demolition of Khan al Ahmar in the West Bank. The 180-person community is slated for demolition to make way for the expansion of settlements in the Ma'ale Adumin area, and the expansion of the West Bank separation barrier - both of which are illegal under international law.

What struck me most about this story was that the plans include the destruction of the Khan al Ahmar Jahalin School - which provides the only primary education to 70 children in the area. When a school is destroyed, often so is the community - leading to displacement and plunging people further into poverty. This is one tiny example of what is happening across the West Bank as land is increasingly partitioned and swallowed up, but if repeated elsewhere it has the potential to create a huge problem for the future of both Israel and Palestine. If we create a generation of Palestinian children who have no access to education, what are their other options?

One of the reasons that the recent attempts at Middle East peace have floundered may be that none of the personalities have changed over the last three decades, yet strangely none of the debate has been about the young leaders who are going to replace the old guard. Already the possibilities for compromise are slipping away as young moderates get sidelined, and on top of that Israel now risks creating a huge up swell in the number of uneducated Palestinian youth. The brutal symbolism of closing schools will not be lost on young Palestinians - as has been evidenced by declarations of support from four UNRWA schools in Jordan in the last week.

In Northern Ireland schools were one of the few places where parents could send their children to be safe at the height of the Troubles. They were also one of the first places that a lot of Protestant and Catholic children met each other, and learned that other children were not so different from them. As young minds began to expand and learn how to solve arguments with words instead of violence, the old hardliner generation began to be replaced by a new generation - a generation more interested in becoming doctors and engineers than in becoming fighters. When children were able to get an education, they could break away from the sectarian council estates they grew up on and learn skills on which to build a career. These are the opportunities being snatched away from Palestinian children in the West Bank and Israeli children in Sderot. Their only knowledge of the other side is through Israeli tanks and rockets launched from Gaza. Fear turns to hatred and becomes entrenched, then that too turns into further physical attacks - the cycle is doomed to start again. Sadly at the moment it's unimaginable that any sort of integrated schooling system encompassing both Israeli and Palestinian children will become widespread (despite success stories like Bridge Over the Wadi), but teaching young children about tolerance and the acceptance of others is still possible - unless schools are closed.

Above all, children on both sides should be able to focus their young lives on simply being kids. Climbing trees, splashing in puddles and getting covered in paint might not seem connected to the Israeli/Palestinian peace process but in reality it could play a huge role in creating a safe atmosphere where young leaders can grow and develop. Children who grow up surrounded by conflict are robbed of their childhood. They grow up thinking about war and the death of their friends and family, in an atmosphere of constant fear and worry. Understandably they aren't going to grow up empathetic to the other side's point of view. Destroying schools takes away that vital protective space.

It should also be recognized that any permanent peace agreement will revolve around both the Israeli and Palestinian communities being able to live side by side, with some level of economic interaction. A functioning education system is a prerequisite for a functioning economy in whatever form the final Palestinian state takes. For Israel to have an economic partner it is in its own interest to support a Palestinian school system or it risks being burdened with an impoverished, uneducated neighbor unable to support its people. It stands to reason that an educated Palestinian populace will be better equipped to engage in dialogue and negotiation rather than resorting to violence. Ongoing dialogue is the essential coda to any peace agreement becoming more than just words on a page, as difficult compromises play out in political and social reality.

Schools should provide bastions of normality, where young minds are stimulated with science, language and maths. When we take those safe havens away we'll be left with a young generation who won't have the basic skills to positively contribute to society in the future. The negative symbolism of bulldozing schools should not be lost on Israel. If an entire generation is created who instead of learning in the classroom end up learning on the streets with stones and tear gas then compromise becomes even harder. Then war will become the only game in town.

 

Follow Peter Blair on Twitter: www.twitter.com/peterhblair

 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:52 PM on 09/10/2011
I would just like to add what is not apparently clear from this article.

By my understanding this Palestinian village is located in 'Area C' in the Palestinian West Bank which is under full Israeli security and administrative control.

The village itself is located very near to two illegal Israeli settlements one of which is Ma'ale Adumim. This particular illegal Israeli settlement (which happens to be build mainly of private Palestinian land) has approx 20 schools and 75 kindergartens.

The impetus for destroying this Palestinian village came from a far right 'settler advocacy group' called Regavim which by its own admission is a 'political movement', Regavim as also petitioned for the demolition of other Palestinian buildings including a sports stadium near Ramallah.

So to sum up, a far right Israeli political movement is petitioning the Israeli courts for the destruction of Palestinian villages and infrastructure in the Palestinian West Bank, the Israeli Army are carrying out these demolitions and destroying the livelihoods of hundreds of Palestinians.

This wanton destruction of Palestinian villages is a deliberate attempt to 'cleanse' Area C of Palestinians for the purpose of expanding the illegal Israeli settlements and annexing this Palestinian land. It should be noted that without Area C there can be *no viable* 'Two State solution' as Area C (approx 55% of the WB) is considered the economic and agricultural region of any future Palestinian state.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Gunness
Universal Values Rock
07:11 AM on 09/10/2011
If anyone is interested in "twinning" a school with the school at Khan al Ahmar, please go to www.facebook.com/unrwa ... best wishes, Chris
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Gunness
Universal Values Rock
07:10 AM on 09/10/2011
Dear All, As Peter correctly reports, four schools in Jordan have twinned with the school in Khan al Ahmar. Twinning can involve as little as going to our face book page www.facebook.com/unrwa and posting messages or sending pictures and ideas for support. Some schools in Jordan are sending school supplies, but we need to quite sure what the community in Khan al Ahmar needs before going any further down this road. Many thanks and best wishes to all. Chris
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Gunness
Universal Values Rock
07:06 AM on 09/10/2011
It's not just the isolated community in Khan al Ahmar that is facing the bulldozers. I am sad to report that after a month long suspension, the Israeli authorities have resumed home demolitions in the West Bank.In the early hours of this morning five residential structures in the Um al Khayr Bedouin community near Hebron were demolished displacing twenty people and severely affecting the 145 strong community. A two year old boy, abandoned accidentally as the bulldozers moved in was severely traumatised. The demolitions also reportedly resumed at An Nassariya Village north east of Nablus where three water cisterns were destroyed; and in the community of As Samu, south of Hebron where the Israeli authorities reportedly demolished electrical infrastructure. More than seven hundred people have been displaced in the West Bank this year alone, surpassing the entire number displaced during all of last year (594 people). Under the Israeli "zoning" policy Palestinians can build in just 1 per cent of Area C (62 per cent of the WB under Israeli control which under Olso SHOULD have been handed over to the Palestinians). Clearly this policy is unfair -- in what other part of the world does an occupying power allow the occupied population to build on just one per cent of their land? So we in the UN are calling for all demolitions to stop until a fair "zoning" or development policy can be agreed. It's really hard to see how all this contributes towards peace.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Gunness
Universal Values Rock
06:59 AM on 09/10/2011
Dear Peter, It is so heartening to see an article like this, in which the experiences of one conflict actually come to bear on another. And of course we in the UN are perpetually accused of lacking institutional memory so it is particularly gratifying. As you rightly ask, what is left once hope in a dignified future has been bulldozed? Many thanks from all of us here on the ground for shining some intelligent light into the black hole we inhabit. If people are intersted in the UN campaign to save the school from demolition, please go to http://www.unrwa.org/etemplate.php?id=1085. (Also in Arabic http://www.unrwa.org/atemplate.php?id=852, Hebrew coming soon) www.facebook.com/unrwa .. many thanks to all. Peter I am very grateful. Best wishes, Chris
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
07:41 PM on 09/08/2011
"In Northern Ireland schools were one of the few places where parents could send their children to be safe at the height of Troubles. "

Not if you went to Holy Cross Primary School.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Peter Blair
08:39 PM on 09/08/2011
The height of the Troubles was the 1970s, while the incidents at Holy Cross happened in 2001 and 2002 - three years after the Good Friday Agreement.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
09:52 PM on 09/08/2011
While the majority of the deaths occured during the 1970's, 783 people were killed in the 1980's. 455 people killed in the 1990's. 16 people were killed in 2001 alone in "troubles" related deaths. Just because it didn't happen during your specific time period does not make it any less relevent; your statement says that school is where parents could send children where they could be safe which, is not entirely true.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Gunness
Universal Values Rock
07:07 AM on 09/10/2011
Sorry folks, I should have said above that the demolitions at Um al Khayr started on Thursday89 September early in the morning. Chris
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:26 PM on 09/08/2011
"For Israel to have an economic partner it is in its own interest to support a Palestinian school system or it risks being burdened with an impoverished, uneducated neighbor unable to support its people. "

Thank you! Without education there can`t be much dialog.
05:40 PM on 09/08/2011
If Israel is to Survive as a Political Entity then THERE IS ONLY ONE ANSWER!

500,000 Israeli Jews now live east of the Green Line and that is the core of the current dangerous position that the government of Israel finds itself in through its policy of illegal settlement in the West Bank. These so-called 'facts on the ground' that were intended as a ploy to gain an advantage upon final-sett­lement, now appear to have been a terrible political error and a serious misjudgeme­nt as the UN and the majority of the world reject such transparen­t moves to make the whole of former Palestine free of the majority indigenous people of the region, the Muslim Arabs. The only answer now is a total repatriati­on of all 500,000 illegal settlers back to Israel - a huge but essential move if Israel is to survive as a political entity.