Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Poppy Mardall

GET UPDATES FROM Poppy Mardall
 

Funerals: Why Do We Spend So Much?

Posted: 28/07/2012 01:00

Funerals. We love to spend money on them. Well, we don't love to spend money on them. But we're terrified not to. Most of us feel the amount of money we spend on a funeral correlates to a chart which measures how much we love the person who has died. In our grief we don't know what else to do.

The elaborate coffins. The embalming and chapel of rest. The limousines and teams of men in black. We can't help but buy the package. Do we really want these things? We don't want to be in this situation in the first place. In the undertaker's office, choosing a coffin from a catalogue.

But since we're here, we ought to buy the best (most expensive) coffin. We certainly can't buy the worst (cheapest). What message would that send the world?

This is why the average cost of a funeral in the UK is £3091. A recent report by Sun Life Direct and Bath University reveals The Government Funeral Payment System is being overwhelmed with applications for support to pay for funerals with the average sum awarded coming in at £1,217. Almost half of applicants are turned down.

The report concludes that we should begin saving for our funerals now. But surely the logical conclusion is to question why we spend so much on funerals in the first place. Are we getting value for our money? Why aren't we using alternative and more affordable means of transport to take the coffin to the crematorium? Why aren't we buying more affordable coffins? Why aren't more people taking control of the logistics of their funerals and buying only the services they need from the undertaker?

Think about it. How would you feel if someone you loved had to plan your funeral? Would you be urging them on from the other side, "Buy the most expensive coffin. Yes! I know you have a huge mortgage and your husband has just been made redundant. But you HAVE to get the thick quilted lining and I want three limousines. I demand to be transported by hearse. I've always loved hearses!" Does anyone think like this?

I'm pretty sure the answer is no. The reason we blow money on funerals and 92% of us only ever visit one undertaker is a mixture of the unstoppable pain we feel after a death, mixed with our complete inexperience of arranging a funeral, with a drop of terror at finding ourselves in an undertaker's shop decked out in the style of Oliver Twist. We will go along with anything they suggest. Which is insane. Because whilst undertakers are often lovely people, they rarely know your family or what respect and dignity mean to you. They are running a business and they need to pay for the costs of the fleet of hearses, the chapels of rest, the embalmer's salary. So they're going to encourage you to buy the whole package.

And some of us want the whole package. And that's great. If the limousines and the hearse and the formality and the embalming mean something to you, pay for them!

But what if they don't hold meaning for you? What if you want something simple?

It goes without saying you want a high standard of service, and care and dignity for the body. But you don't want the package. You just want the body of your mum to be respectfully and simply cremated. What you need from the undertaker might be something along the lines of: mortuary facilities, coffin and transport of the coffin to the crematorium.

Funeral directors commonly call this a Basic Funeral. It doesn't sound good does it? It sounds cheap and worrying. It's not far off 'pauper's funeral'. The message being - you're choosing a Basic Funeral because you can't afford anything more.

And 'basic funeral' is wrong anyway. You might be planning a knock your socks off funeral. The only thing basic about it is the services you want from the undertaker.

Let's look at it another way.

If I walk into the supermarket and buy a loaf of bread from the 'simple' range, am I buying something broken or shameful? Do I feel like a 'pauper' who can't afford anything better? No. I buy this bread because I like my bread to be simple. I don't want it stuffed with olives or topped with a Stilton crust.

If I walk to the supermarket with my own recyclable bag, does this mean I can't afford the cost of delivery? No. It means I want some fresh air and to collect my own bread.

When it comes to my bread, I won't be paying for services and products I don't want or need. A Stilton crust means nothing to me. I want to buy what I want to buy. And I am glad I have the choice.

The expense of the coffin, the level of decoration, the model of the vehicle - these details do not correlate to the amount we loved the person who died. These things do not inherently represent dignity or respect.

Dignity in my book means the respectful care of the body after death. It means saying goodbye to the person who has died in a fitting manner. No model of coffin or form of transport can represent love or respect.

When planning a funeral, it should be about getting what we want and need. And value for our money. Let's rethink our understanding of 'dignity' and the concept of a simple funeral and stop flushing cash down the toilet to show we care.

 

Follow Poppy Mardall on Twitter: www.twitter.com/poppysfunerals

FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:02 PM on 07/31/2012
As a well informed individual on the state of the funeral industry, coming across this article seems slightly ironic as it has been an age-old debate about how the funeral industry overcharges and how funerals are ridiculously expensive. Truth is, this couldn't be more then a misconception that has been used to flog an industry and flaunt every isolated misdeed that has ever happened to it.

Imagine how surprised one would be to find out that the funeral industry, like any other business has only grown with the increase of annual wages - and more so, they only charge enough to keep themselves operational. Funeral directors are not reach by any means. They are not swimming in riches of the bereaved as many like to believe.

Learn more about the fallacies of the misconception of expensive funerals: https://mysendoff.com/2012/07/the-economics-of-death-the-high-cost-of-dying/
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Poppy Mardall
07:58 AM on 08/02/2012
It's not about funerals being too expensive, it's about value for money. In my experience the vast majority of funeral directors are caring, thoughtful and provide value for money if you are using all the services they provide. But if you want limited support - for example use of mortuary space and simple transport, it can be very difficult to access. And I think this is a problem.
04:08 PM on 07/28/2012
I like reading ornate sculptured headstones which give a moment's immortality to the heroic & lavish dead.

Other tombstones are so word minimal as if the occupant preferred obscurity.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jessjesskk
Benevolent Zombie Power
08:57 AM on 07/28/2012
Cremation. Forgotten. Life is about life. And life only. Not about being a corpse.

Not fun discussion, clear answer :/
01:27 AM on 07/28/2012
I currently live in southern Mexico in a working class community. When someone dies they are usually buried within 24 hours, no embalming, simple casket and many times the funeral is held in the family's home. I've seen caskets being carried by friends and family to the cemeteries as well. The cemeteries are not like parks as in the USA and are quite crowded. No fuss, no muss. Different culture.
photo
erebus99
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
07:53 PM on 07/27/2012
Back in the mid sixty's my oldest brother lost his new wife in a traffic accident. My mother, who had just finished reading "An American Way of Death", by Jessica Mitford, handled all the arrangements for the funeral.
I don't think the local mortuary owner ever got over the experience - he sold the business and retired shortly afterward.

Knowledge is power.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Poppy Mardall
07:49 AM on 08/02/2012
Indeed! I totally agree. We need to be informed in order to make the best decisions. Your mother sounds like an amazing woman.
photo
erebus99
Violence is the last refuge of the incompetent
08:39 AM on 08/02/2012
At every city council, land-use board or zoning committee meeting, when my mother would walk in everybody on the bench would roll their eyes or just groan, cause they knew it would be a long night. She would show up when no one else did, and she couldn't be intimidated into silence or to take no for an answer on an issue that she cared about. Extremely intelligent, and a first-rate poltical gad-fly
photo
Buckeye54
...the One your mom warned you about!
07:30 PM on 07/27/2012
If we were smart we'd do our funerals the "green" way. We wouldn't be embalmed, and we'd be buried in a simple burlap or canvas sack that would disintegrate just as we would, in time.

Do away with the public viewings of a made-off corpse that still looks dead. Put a nice poster size photo on display.

Do away with all this religious and superstitious tomfoolery. One hundred years from now--no one's going to care who you were or where you're buried.
04:31 PM on 07/28/2012
You haven't met a Genealogist yet then? They are people who consider a step backwards as progress.
photo
grayplace
Life's a dream within a dream.
09:35 PM on 07/28/2012
Cremation and scattering is the way to go. My mother died recently and that's what we did for her. Cost was only $1,500.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BillKen
06:56 PM on 07/27/2012
The reason funerals cost so much is because there is a sense of guilt that is exploited by
the industry. During the counseling session every rock of guilt is turned and you are offered
a way to make amends by purchasing an elaborate funeral ceremony. Guilt relief has it's price
and it's what ever the traffic will bear. Give yourself a break and go swim with Neptune.
Semper Fi
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Poppy Mardall
07:44 AM on 08/02/2012
Guilt definitely makes us very vulnerable. Of course there are many, many wonderful funeral directors out there offering choice and flexibility and a personal service. You just want to make sure you find one that is right for you.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Sheng Paule
Either we fix this planet or we all lose
06:40 PM on 07/27/2012
The answer is stop the insanity. Proper respects for the dead do not include thousands of dollars on perks like expensive coffins that only see public viewing for days at most. Some cultures believe in minimalist expenses for these items and I agree. Perhaps you should tell your loved ones you love them and would rather they spend the extra cash on important things for them.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Poppy Mardall
07:39 AM on 08/02/2012
I absolutely agree. Letting your family know your feelings is the key.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
05:56 PM on 07/27/2012
There really isn't a whole lot of wiggle room in the price...depending on where you live, there may only be a single funeral home in the area, a casket costs x, the mass costs y and the burial is z.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Poppy Mardall
07:38 AM on 08/02/2012
Interesting thoughts Seaniebhoy. If there is only one funeral home, it can be tricky. In the UK some coffin suppliers are starting to sell directly to the public. Certain funeral homes are willing to provide individual services rather than a package. And you can hold a funeral anywhere you want - it can be in your own back garden (where you can also be buried). So we have wiggle room - but lots of us don't know how much choice we have.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
01:59 PM on 08/02/2012
LOL...can you imagine what the neighbors would say if they saw you buring dear old mum in the back garden!!