Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rachel Hosie

GET UPDATES FROM Rachel Hosie
 

Weighing Up the 5:2 Diet

Posted: 09/01/2013 13:47

Ahh January. If there was ever a good time of year to try and kick-start a healthy eating regime, it's now. How appropriate that Dr Michael Mosley has chosen tomorrow to launch his new diet book. Clever man.

There are all sorts of faddy diets out there which most probably do more harm than good (the cotton ball diet, anyone?), but the general consensus amongst people who've tried the 5:2 diet - and then told the world online - is that this one is different.

So what exactly is the 5:2 diet? I hear you ask. Allow me to explain:

Also known as intermittent fasting, the 5:2 diet - originally tried and documented by Mosley - is actually (refreshingly) simple. For two non-consecutive days of the week you reduce your calorie intake to just 500 calories for women and 600 for men, but then you get to eat normally for the other five days. Easy peasy, surely?

Well, it's supposedly a great diet for food-lovers (like myself) as you don't have to give anything up. There are no rules as to what you can or can't eat, just the quantity on those two days. So if you wanted to eat one 500 calorie piece of cake on your fast day and nothing else, you could (I wouldn't though!). Or if you wanted to drink 35 cups of tea with skimmed milk to get your 500 a day you could do that too (but again, I wouldn't.)

The fast days must be utterly foul, but I suppose they're just about tolerable because you know it's only for one day, and you can eat what you like (within reason, I imagine) tomorrow. The 5:2 diet has caused a real stir in the health world because people are actually managing to follow it and see results.

My guess is that the reason it's gone down so well with so many people is that the majority of us struggle with willpower. We're feeble. Most people can't stick to their New Year's resolutions for more than a few days before giving up, yet the 5:2 diet doesn't seem like a daunting complete diet overhaul forever and ever, it's just a couple of days a week. Totally manageable, right?

However, the 5:2 diet isn't just about losing weight, oh no. Scientists have long believed in the health benefits of fasting such as increased lifespan, and reduced blood glucose and cholesterol levels. All good stuff then.

The oh-so-trusty people on the internet are generally raving about the diet. Many claim that it's transformed their lives for the better in various ways - people say they have more energy on the fast days and don't even feel like they want to over-indulge on the normal ones to compensate.

Once you realise you can tolerate feeling hungry, apparently it's fine. Mosley claimed that 'After the settling in period, it has become quite easy'. He's probably right, as when it comes to eating habits, I've found it's all down to routine.

Obviously, there are some concerns when it comes to the 5:2 diet. Some worry that it may encourage eating disorders, but then again you could say that about most diets (not to mention every film, advert, magazine and TV show we're shown in society today.) It's all about being sensible, as far as I'm concerned, which may be a life principle I follow a bit too religiously.

So could the 5:2 diet really be as great as everyone claims? I may just have to give it a try to find out. Watch this space...

The Fast Diet: The Secret of Intermittent Fasting - Lose Weight, Stay Healthy, Live Longer by Michael Mosley and Mimi Spencer is on sale from 10th January 2013

For more about the science behind intermittent fasting, read Dr Andrew Weil's article here

 

Follow Rachel Hosie on Twitter: www.twitter.com/rachel_hosie

FOLLOW UK STUDENTS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 17
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:51 AM on 02/09/2013
Have been on this diet for 4 months now and have lost 18 lbs. I have been struggling for 10 years to lose this amount trying all sorts of diets. I can't believe how easy this is! I do fast for three days a week but it is so flexible it doesn't impact on your social life. I skip breakfast, have banana and crisp breads for lunch and a massive plate of vegetables with a weight watchers meal for dinner. The day following a fast day is lovely as food taste so much better and you know you have earned it. I am careful not to over indulge on non fast days. My husband has now joined me on this diet and is steadily losing weight. I get a real kick out of wearing clothes that have hung in the wardrobe for ten years.
12:20 AM on 02/10/2013
Congratulations! That's brilliant and really impressive!
08:57 PM on 02/04/2013
virtually no info in this article
12:21 AM on 02/10/2013
I'm sorry you didn't find what you were looking for, but it's a blog post, not an article as such, so is more meant to discuss, not explain - hence "Weighing up".
05:31 PM on 01/28/2013
Been doing tihs for 2 weeks (5th fast today). Weight has gone up nearly 2 pounds and body fat up 1.8%.

Sticking to sub 600 cals per day on 'Fast Days' split between breakfast and dinner - no cheating.

Been folowing Atkins for about 14 months before hand and losing weight staedily but bored with it and needed a change.

Any ideas what I could be doing wrong?
04:27 PM on 02/02/2013
Oh gosh, that's really odd. I'm not sure why. Are you drinking plenty of fluids? Often if your body thinks it's not getting enough food it goes into starvation mode and clings onto fat, so perhaps that could be the case? I'm not a doctor or nutritionist though so really not sure, sorry!
05:43 AM on 01/18/2013
I love this diet! I have tried it for 2 weeks now and lost 2.5kg! It just fell off despite the fact that on 'normal' days, I had toast with butter, chips, movie popcorn, chocolate, burger, pizza, pasta, ice cream and generally all those things that are forbidden on normal diets. That's why this diet works. I don't mind not eating one day, because I know I can have what I like the next day. And it's flexible too so very sustainable. On fast days, I generally eat nothing all day (which is surprisingly easy) and then have a healthy dinner of up to 500 cal. The rest of the time I eat whatever I want. I still eat vegetables and fruit and healthy food generally, but I also allow myself to have treats, without the guilt. I don't count calories, but am mindful not to overstuff myself. And I have noticed that my tolerance for high fat, high sugar, and high salt food has decreased dramatically (eg I could only handle 1 slice of pizza instead of 3-4). It's like win-win.
05:35 PM on 01/18/2013
Wow that's brilliant, well done! It's really impressive to hear it's worked so well for you. Keep up the good work, I say.
10:48 AM on 01/13/2013
Never eat breakfast, only eat after 1pm. That means you should have gone at least 16 hours without food. Two eggs for your afternoon breakfast. Nibble on you evening meal.
05:25 PM on 01/13/2013
Yeah I suppose if you can go without, skipping breakfast might be a good way to go about it. I bet most people find the evenings the hardest!
photo
mmartini54
Roll on 2015!
05:38 PM on 01/11/2013
500 calories? Blimey, that's equivalent to two mince pies, or a bowl of pesto pasta! And that's all you can eat on a fast day? I think I'd rather exercise more.
10:27 PM on 01/12/2013
I know, it's not much at all! However, if you choose low-calorie foods you'd actually be surprised at how much you can eat... I got a good three meals (albeit small ones) out of my 500 the other day.
02:34 PM on 01/15/2013
I have been following it for a couple of months and lost about 4 kgs. On a FAST day I have 100ml of Tropicana Orange juice for breakfast, a cup of soup for lunch and the same again (or 2xscrambled Egg and a tomato) for dinner about 6.. and to stave of the hunger pangs about 10pm a 40Kcal cup of hot chocolate or something.. overall about 600kcal.. I fast on Tuesdays and Thursdays