Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rebecca Greig

GET UPDATES FROM Rebecca Greig
 

A Jew in Palestine: 'Shlomo, We're Not in East London Anymore'

Posted: 05/12/2012 16:59

First things first:

I'm a Jew.

A Jew in Palestine (I'm just waiting for some smartarse to 'politely' inform me that Palestine is not a country, although, as of last Thursday, I have the might of the UN behind me).

'So what?' you might ask, and go back to your lunchtime panini and the work you should be doing.

I hear you. What does it matter? Why does it matter?

It shouldn't but it does. When I first decided to move to the West Bank as a freelance journalist, many of my friends thought this was one of my crazy peccadilloes. My mother, of course, was horrified.

"It's dangerous", she wailed. "What will my family say?" My mother's family in Israel are ultra-orthodox Jews, black-hatted and bewigged, who initially took a rather dim view of my mother's marrying out (that is to say, a non-Jew, and a revolutionary socialist at that). Over time (give or take a couple of decades) relations mellowed: now my religious family see my father for the mensch he is, and my father, well, let's just say his views are starting to look alarmingly neo-conservative...

My religious family weren't, however, wild about the idea of me moving to Ramallah ("Didn't I know that was where, at the start of the second intifada, two off-duty Israeli soldiers were lynched?") but they weren't surprised.

First, I got a job with Al Jazeera English (to their minds synonymous with the evildoings of Al-Qaeda) and now I was moving in with them (the 'them' in this instance referring to 'Arabs', as my family would dismissively refer to them).

As I patiently explained to anyone who asked, I wanted to explore the Palestinian Territories for myself, to see first-hand, even if I could not, as a privileged white Westerner, experience the grim realities of living under occupation.

And to allay my mother's fears I promised to spend regular Shabbat meals with my Chassidic family chowing down on cholent (traditional slow-cooked stew) and stuffing myself with chocolate rugelach (sticky pastries that are something of a Jewish speciality).

I found myself in the unique position (at least to my knowledge - I'd be pleased to hear of any similar stories) of dividing my time between Palestinian Authority-controlled 'Area A' and the ultra-orthodox enclave of the old city, acting as a de facto messenger between populations with little or no access to each other. Israelis are prohibited from entering the West Bank, and likewise, West Bank residents are not permitted into Israeli-controlled areas (it goes without saying that the average Israeli citizen has far greater freedom of movement than her Palestinian counterpart).

The main point of interaction between Israelis and Palestinians is through the dreaded checkpoint (if you've ever had the misfortune to cross Qalandia you'll know exactly what I mean), which, as you might imagine, is not the kind of situation that is conducive to great friendliness. Most Palestinians know Israelis as soldiers, as stroppy teenagers with guns (due to mass conscription of 18-21 year-olds this is often what they are) issuing commands and generally making life as complicated as possible for any Palestinian who crosses their path. I am not saying all Israeli soldiers are culpable, but rather that there is a well-documented culture of humiliation and abuse.

For their part, most Israelis I meet have no real understanding of Palestinians or Palestinian society. At one of my Aunt's Friday-night meals a wide-eyed American-Israeli woman tells me, "You can't trust them. They say one thing and mean another. They will do anything for the camera". It was fitting that this woman should mention a camera as I'm quite sure the only interaction she'd ever had with a Palestinian was mediated through a TV screen.

I'd like to say such ignorance was uncommon. I'd be lying. Some of the most avowedly liberal and secular of Israelis, who hate haredim (ultra-religious communities) even more than they hate Palestinians (that's a whole lot of hate) spout unreconstructed racist views of a kind that went out of fashion in the UK around the time Nelson Mandela came out of prison.

A couple of months ago, when couch-surfing with such a 'liberal' Israeli near the coastal town of Hadera, after explaining that I was writing an article for the New Statesman (cheeky plug, read it here) on the demolition of Arab Bedouin homes, I was informed that "They [Arab Bedouin] steal. Anything not watched over and tied to the ground is up for grabs".

I knew then, I was a long way from home.

 

Follow Rebecca Greig on Twitter: www.twitter.com/bloodsweattweet

FOLLOW UK
First things first: I'm a Jew. A Jew in Palestine (I'm just waiting for some smartarse to 'politely' inform me that Palestine is not a country, although, as of last Thursday, I have the might of t...
First things first: I'm a Jew. A Jew in Palestine (I'm just waiting for some smartarse to 'politely' inform me that Palestine is not a country, although, as of last Thursday, I have the might of t...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 29
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:49 AM on 12/07/2012
You force people of their land into a ghetto called Gaza, control every aspect of their lives, continually terrorize them with military incursions and when they fight back you call them terrorist's.
You continually rely on the legal argument that there was never a Palestinian state and block them from creating such a state. At the same time Israel ignores all UN resolutions.
It's sheer hypocrazy.
11:18 PM on 12/07/2012
Reality check: Hamas ARE terrorists.
02:50 AM on 12/08/2012
By the same token the Germans in Warsaw in 1942 could call ZOB a terrorist organization.
06:03 PM on 12/06/2012
Another piece of liberalist, hand-wringing propaganda masquerading as neutral journalism. And as far as your "smartarse" comment, just because you don't like the truth you can't negate it by calling those who mention it insulting names. Indeed there have never been "Palestinians" who have Palestinian ancestors, no historical record of a Palestinian state, no historical Palestinian currency or coinage, no Palestinian royalty or ruling family, BECAUSE THERE HAS NEVER BEEN SUCH A STATE. Just the country of Israel with Arabs who moved there over a period of time, since Israel has been under the occupation of various occupying forces since the Romans, as non-native inhabitants who didn't want to be part of Israel and continue to do their best to destroy Israel and kill the Jews. Ever since 1948 the Arabs have been trying to destroy a legal soveregn state. Aided and abbetted in their murderous activities by niaive and ignorant western supporters. Jordan was taken from the Jews and given to the Arabs, but they are still not satisfied and will never be until they destroy Israel.
Michael II
Neither the one, nor the only
08:00 AM on 12/07/2012
Gosh, you've just made her point for her.

Basically, you are repeating the mantra of "Palestinians, What Palestinians?"

As a reminder, states that did not exist as such before achieving independence: India, Ireland, Italy (before unification), most African states (a whole continent right there), Canada, Australia, the United States of America, etc.

Which of these do you think are lesser states?
04:40 PM on 12/07/2012
Gosh, actually you made my point for me. Simplistic, auto-reply mentality ignoring the facts. Read what I said first, respond to the information. The simple fact is the Arabs want everything, are hanging out those Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza to dry as disposable sacrifices in their efforts to destroy Israel. Pity the poor women and children stuck between Islamist terrorist states and Israel defending itself. Why should Israel not defend itself and limit the movement of Arabs who continuously murder its citizens without pity in pursuit of a demented, middle-aged religious agenda?
03:41 PM on 12/06/2012
How is it constructive to accuse even 'the most avowedly liberal' of Israelis of racism? Not only is that a gross and insulting exaggeration, it feeds negative stereotypes that perpetuate conflict. The sad fact is most Israeli mistrust of Palestinians is the result of Palestinian violence, which has personally affected nearly all Israelis. Likewise, Palestinian mistrust of Israelis is largely the result of wrongs perpetrated on their population by Israel. But I know from experience -- I am also a Western Jew with (in my case 'avowedly liberal') Israeli family that there are large numbers of Israelis who desire nothing more than peace, a two state solution and an end to occupation. It is clear that you were biased against Israel before you ever moved to the middle east, and while it is not clear what exactly you hope to accomplish with this sort of article, slandering an entire population (of your own people, no less) is not likely to help.
lastpost
see biography
03:00 PM on 12/06/2012
“I'm a Jew.”
Well how do you do? Since we’re all humans. It really shouldn’t matter wa-who’s wa-who.

“I'm just waiting for some smartarse to”
ask why produce grown on occupied land isn’t labelled accordingly? No need for subterfuge.

“the might of the UN”
is underwritten by the US. And whoever pays the rent, expects to make the house rules.

“a rather dim view of”
horseless carriages, aeroplanes and other inexplicable contrivances. Not nuclear weapons though.

“Over time (give or take a couple of decades) relations mellowed:”
At the current rate a few more millennia should do it. Sooner, if conditioning reinforcement was ramped down.

“decided to move to the West Bank”
before it becomes rive jewish?

“stroppy teenagers with guns”
should be disarmed immediately, and allowed to riot in peace.

“issuing commands and generally making life as complicated as possible”
Basically a remake of ancient Egypt, with reversed role play. How about swapping some bulrush babes? To see if they notice they’re in the wrong tribes, when they’re older.

"You can't trust them. They say one thing and mean another.”
But speaking as a mother, more settlements dear?

“the time Nelson Mandela came out of prison.”
It’s a wonder he didn’t take one look at us, walk back in and lock the door behind him.

“Anything not watched over and tied to the ground is up for grabs".
But we’ve solved that, by simply taking the ground away. From under them, as it were.
01:15 PM on 12/06/2012
Bravo! I hope you post here frequently and wish you safety and success. The whole debate needs alot more honesty and objectivity which I hope you will strive for. Their are deep intergenerational wounds on both sides. If you take on the lessons from history Israel is not doing itself any favours. Oppression never leads to peace and security.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
12:28 PM on 12/06/2012
Good luck to you, this isn't being behind enemy lines, just being bold to see and experience the other side.
11:57 AM on 12/06/2012
Rebecca - good luck. Hope to read more from you on hp.
10:59 AM on 12/06/2012
I'd have liked this to be more in depth - I want more! Sounds interesting. Good luck to you.
04:06 PM on 12/06/2012
You and me both whilst a bit on the light side this has the potential to inform people to inform them of something hardly anybody realized.One problem is it me or most the the attackes are comming from pro Jewish groups.
This comment has been removed.
11:59 PM on 12/05/2012
Well, I guess HuffPost doesn't like certain opinions, however sincere, and suppresses them, thus skewing the perception of public opinion. Such massaging of the facts undermines your credibility.
11:52 PM on 12/05/2012
Brave, but nuts. Your self-indulgent desire to show up others who are less enlightened than you puts yourself and others in danger. You are a clear target for a kidnap, or a hit. When it happens, you will drag others into danger trying to save you or to avenge your death. It is past time for you to grow up.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sue Harvey
01:17 PM on 12/06/2012
She's in Palestine not Afghanistan!
05:13 PM on 12/06/2012
The Middle East is a simmering war zone because of the tensions between Palestinian Arabs and Jews. Both have historic hatreds, long memories and short fuses. Anybody who goes there with the intention of taking sides is part of the problem, not a solution.

The risk is that she may be used until it suits someone to take her out and claim Israel did it. Palestine is all about propaganda and everyone gets used, even their own kids.

While we are on the subject, 1500 rockets sounds pretty like Afghanistan, doesn't it?