Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Richard Burden

GET UPDATES FROM Richard Burden
 

Israel Release 55 But 106 Palestinian Children Remain in Jail as Shackling Continues

Posted: 22/12/11 00:00

On Sunday, Israel released 550 Palestinian prisoners, the second and final phase of the prisoner swap which secured the release of Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit, in October.

Israel reserved the right to make the final decision on which Palestinian prisoners to release, and which should remain in jail. Not surprisingly then, it attracted widespread criticism when not one of the 164 Palestinians held by Israel under the age of 18 were released in the first round of the prisoner swap. This time it was different. On Sunday, 55 Palestinians aged between 14 and 17 were freed by Israel.

Whether or not it took place in response to the international pressure, Israel's change of heart is welcome. But it is no more than a start. Like many other countries, Israeli law defines under 18s as children. The UN Convention on the Rights of the Child requires member states to uphold standards of judicial behaviour in respect of children, including only using imprisonment as a last resort. According to Defence for Children International (DCI), however, even after Sunday, 106 Palestinian children still remain in Israeli detention.

Each year around 700 Palestinian children are held by Israel. Unlike Israeli children, they are subject to military, not civil jurisdiction. Widespread concerns about their treatment have been catalogued by DCI and a range of other Israeli and international human rights organisations.
Children are frequently taken from their homes in the middle of the night, without telling their parents why they are being arrested or where they are being taken. Painful hand ties and blindfolds are used for extended periods of time. Prior to interrogation, children are often not informed of their right to silence or allowed to meet with a lawyer. Rarely are they even allowed to speak to their parents.

Threats and physical and mental abuse during arrest, transfer and interrogation are widespread, making prosecutions based on evidence regularly extracted from confessions more than worrying.

It's shocking when you hear about these things. It's worse still when you see them for yourself and meet some of the young people who have been through it. I'll certainly never forget the sight of 13-year-old boys being led into Israel's military courtrooms at Ofer prison in leg shackles and handcuffs. The leg shackles stayed on throughout the hearing. Necessary to prevent them absconding? I don't think so; the courtroom was inside the walls of a high security prison.

Last month I met half a dozen young ex-prisoners from the Hebron area of the West Bank who are now receiving support from a psychological counselling centre run by the YMCA near Bethlehem. As their answers to my questions unfolded, the sheer extent of the Israeli military's practice of shackling child prisoners became clear.

I was told how some of them would be picked up from a jail near Haifa by prison vans at around 1.00am to take them to the court at Ofer. The journey should take just a couple of hours. In practice, prisoners are regularly kept in the prison vans for eight or nine hours at a time as they travel to different parts of Israel to pick up more prisoners before arriving at Ofer. By the time the vans get there, they are often overcrowded. The 14 to 17-year-olds inside are shackled throughout the journey. Sometimes they are hand cuffed together too.

When I asked the young people about food, water or even how they go to the toilet during the journey, they shrugged. If you are lucky, they told me, you may get a break outside the van during the journey. Often you do not.

When I raise this kind of treatment with representatives of the Israeli government, I am usually cautioned to remember Israel's security concerns, and its need to be vigilant to the threat of suicide bombs. In fact, most of the children are detained for offences such as throwing stones. But that is hardly the point. Mistreatment of prisoners - especially child prisoners - does not stop being mistreatment depending on the offence they are accused of.

That is why DCI calls for Palestinian children to have the same rights as Israeli children to recognised standards of juvenile justice rather than military courts. It is why they say all children should be accompanied by a lawyer and parent during questioning, and all interrogations of children should be audio-visually recorded as a means of independent oversight.

And it is why - as we approach a new year in the 21st Century - Israel's shackling of child prisoners must stop.

 
On Sunday, Israel released 550 Palestinian prisoners, the second and final phase of the prisoner swap which secured the release of Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit, in October. Israel reserved the right...
On Sunday, Israel released 550 Palestinian prisoners, the second and final phase of the prisoner swap which secured the release of Israeli soldier, Gilad Shalit, in October. Israel reserved the right...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 71
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
14:13 on 02/01/2012
Israel has no regard for international law or human rights,whilst the people of Israel think they are the chosen people of God and as such can treat other non Zionists as they like peace will never be known to the people of the world let a lone the middle east.
The people of God would not steal land and murder women and children, awake the children of Israel you live the life of satan and are nothing but thiefs and murderers, we true Jews still wait and know your taking is wrong and your actions evil you are not true Jews and insult and shame the name Jew you are zionists first and should make this clear to the world you have no love of God or his creations but only take,kill and hate.
03:57 on 28/12/2011
These are clear human rights abuses, yet leaders of other countries turn their head away from these well-documented happenings and pretend that everything is hunky dory. It's disgusting.
photo
AJ Raalte
Israel forever - warts and all.
17:47 on 25/12/2011
When you're killed by one of those illegal "child" combattants, you're just as dead as when you're killed by a more adult terrorist.
photo
AJ Raalte
Israel forever - warts and all.
16:51 on 25/12/2011
Throwing stones is assault with a deadly weapon. How many American minors who commit such heinous crimes, are tried as adults?

If you can't do the time, don't do the crime!
photo
AJ Raalte
Israel forever - warts and all.
16:49 on 25/12/2011
Very nice "debate" going on here. NOT.
16:18 on 25/12/2011
Every comment posted here is pro Palestinian. Every deleted post is probably pro Israeli.
Says a lot about the site doesn't it, and those editing it.
22:10 on 26/12/2011
You are absolutely right;all my pro-Israel posts have been deleted,It is disgusting.I intend to keep well away from it.
08:12 on 27/12/2011
Anything that is PRO-Israel is deleted, Thats why I put anything I say about my country is up to me.j

It is discusting and it is discrimnation, Where is the freendom of speach.

Huffpost STOP DISCRIMINATING - AND BEING ANTI-SEMETIC
Thelonius
Lived in Middle East for
23:19 on 23/12/2011
This shocking and revealing article brings to mind the prophetic words stated in 1944 by Lessing J. Rosenwald, president of the American Council for Judaism: "The concept of a racial state - the Hitlerian concept- is repugnant to the civilized world, as witness the fearful global war in which we are involved. . . , I urge that we do nothing to set us back on the road to the past. To project at this time the creation of a Jewish state or commonwealth is to launch a singular innovation in world affairs which might well have incalculable consequences."
This comment has been removed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
This comment has been removed.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Steve LeRoy Moore
14:46 on 24/12/2011
Good article, but from visits there not suprising.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.
18:08 on 22/12/2011
B'Tsalam the Israeli information centre for human rights in the Occupied Territories states that from 2005-2010 835 Palestinian minors were arrested for alleged stone throwing.
Thirty four of them were not sent to prison
14-15 were imprisoned for 20 days
41 were imprisoned 10-29 days
112 were imprisoned for 1-2 months
212 were imprisoned for 2-4 months
270 were imprisoned for more than 4 months but less than 6 months
88 were imprisoned for 6-12 months
Only 1 of these 865 was aquitted all of the rest were found or pleaded guilty!
Palestinian minors are tried under military legislation they are not allowed the special rights granted to Israeli children of their age. These military courts do not confirm to either international or Israeli law. These children are not allowed to have their parents present when being interrorgated. Many of these children are taken from their homes in the middle of the night. Their parents were not allowed to accompany them! Only 23 were released on bail. As a result of this and the pressure of the interrorgators most of the children are influenced to plead guilty thinking they will be released!
This comment has been removed.
14:57 on 22/12/2011
I was sure I was reading about North Korea and then I saw my mistake...
This comment has been removed.
21:31 on 22/12/2011
you wouldn't know anything that goes on on in North korea.
This comment has been removed.
This comment has been removed.