iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Rob Atkinson

GET UPDATES FROM Rob Atkinson
 

The Worst Manchester United Manager Ever?

Posted: 02/01/2013 00:00

I'm not inviting nominations here. I have but one candidate for this title, a man whose personal qualities and actions during his period of tenure put him, I would argue, clear ahead of the field as the worst Old Trafford boss of all time.

Ladies and gentlemen, I give you: Sir Alex Ferguson.

Now, let's not be simplistic about this. The worth of a football manager - who, let's not forget, carries the responsibility for how his club is perceived by friends and foes alike across the globe - cannot be measured by a mere count-up of baubles won. What is the standing of the football club when he arrives? How will he leave that club when he finally clears his office?

In Ferguson's case, the answer is glaringly obvious. He has presided over the most horrendous degradation of a football club's standing and image that I can bring to mind. Manchester United, thanks almost entirely to the stewardship of Sir Matt Busby, was once upon a time the football club most closely associated with honour, dignity and The Way Things Should Be Done. Only Arsenal, and later Liverpool would come anywhere close to matching the standards set by Sir Matt.

Busby did not have it easy. He arrived at a bombed-out Old Trafford in 1945, with a history as a Manchester City and Liverpool star behind him. This was hardly calculated to endear him to the devotees on the Stretford End. He also had to contend with the slightly shady influence of the ruling Edwards family over the club, and of course he suffered hideous personal injuries in the Munich air disaster, as well as losing the core of his second great team. Against this backdrop, he created a club that was known as 'everyone's second favourite team', and beloved of their own massive following.

Looking back, it is sad to see how the legacy of Sir Matt Busby has been squandered. Manchester United these days are perhaps the most hated brand - I use the word advisedly - in the sporting world. Given the amount of trophies won under Ferguson's ruthless management, it would be easy to ascribe this to envy. But there have been successful, dominant clubs before, and none have attracted quite the same level of opprobrium.

The Ferguson Factor is the difference here. Busby and Ferguson were both at the helm long enough to be completely identifiable with the club they represented. Busby stood for dignity and respect, Ferguson stands for arrogance and intimidation. His most recent rant is symptomatic of this. A playground taunt whereby he is manager of the most famous club in the world, and his opposite number is at "a wee club in the north-east".

The small-mindedness of such language is mind-boggling in such a major sporting figure, and Ferguson has plenty of form in this regard. His club suffers more with every such outburst, and for all their fans claim they don't care as long as the trophies roll in, I beg leave to doubt this. We all need to be loved, respected, admired. Manchester United has little of this now, outside of its own rabid support, but there was a time when the club was a byword for affection and respect among football lovers everywhere. This is the scale of the downfall; this is the measure of the negative effect of Ferguson's reign.

Sir Alex Ferguson - the original knight you wouldn't send a dog out on. J'accuse.

 

Follow Rob Atkinson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/RobofLeeds

FOLLOW SPORTS
I'm not inviting nominations here. I have but one candidate for this title, a man whose personal qualities and actions during his period of tenure put him, I would argue, clear ahead of the field as t...
I'm not inviting nominations here. I have but one candidate for this title, a man whose personal qualities and actions during his period of tenure put him, I would argue, clear ahead of the field as t...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 92
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:40 PM on 01/09/2013
The credibility of Rob Atkinson can be measured by his repeated interaction with the comments. He's clearly insecure, jitty and knows he's talking nonsense.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
06:34 AM on 01/08/2013
He hurls insults at Manchester City so often I forgot to mention the old goat's predilection for being spiteful even to his neighbors.
10:28 PM on 01/06/2013
Is this the best that the HuffPost can do? I'm sure there are some school children out there who can write better articles than this.
I know,I'll be controversial....Liverpool are shit....discuss.
p.s. I support Manchester United....go for it people.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
Vapula
Failure is not an option
05:08 AM on 01/08/2013
And you have shown what a lowlife you are ... thankyou for proving the point.
07:08 PM on 01/06/2013
I'd like to thank all those who have so far posted comments - it's helped make this article very popular and quite widely-read, which is of course oxygen for any writer. The comments have come rather too thick and fast - mostly the former it has to be said, rather than the latter - for me to respond to all individually. But I will say that the general tone has done a lot to confirm my opinion of a great proportion of all those who follow the Mighty Manchester United, whether it be from an armchair in Devon - or a bar in Singapore. Really, thanks guys. I have most of the material for a follow-up article already to hand.
02:46 PM on 01/06/2013
Maybe it is a pselling mistake and his first name is Ron!
02:35 PM on 01/06/2013
If fans from any other club were honest they would of loved to of had fergie as their manager
05:20 PM on 01/06/2013
Yup.
08:43 PM on 01/06/2013
"Would of loved to of had". Wow.
02:34 PM on 01/06/2013
I think modern media attention , would have made Sir Alf look bad... I've had 50 years of supporting United, and the whole game has changed. its not only fought on the pitch.. Maybe one should blame Mohammed Ali, he exploited the press and his banter probably won several fights before the first bell.

I honestly do not see SAF as the arrogant person you describe, but his persona , oh yes. Very arrogant.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jessjesskk
Benevolent Zombie Power
08:38 AM on 01/06/2013
Not having been born at the time of busby, for me this is like comparing horse carriage and airplane...
05:22 PM on 01/06/2013
Gold plated horse carriage and supersonic jet eh? I get it, only who is who?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jessjesskk
Benevolent Zombie Power
07:15 PM on 01/06/2013
busby is the horse carriage. there is no doubt in the mind of anybody that current teams are much better than in the past. and the environment is so different that comparing them makes zero sense
today Pele would be a good player but not the superstar he had been
02:50 AM on 01/06/2013
I actually enjoyed reading the authors responses to critisism in this comments section more than his article.

Rob Atkinson
Actor, Writer and Carer

Maybe just stick to the acting and caring this year Rob. I think it's also a bit rich that you have responded to people by saying it's easy to interpret the article the wrong way, as that would be your fault being the author. Good luck with the acting.
07:17 PM on 01/06/2013
The Bible is notoriously easy to misinterpret as well. I hope you're not having a go at the writers of the gospels...

Either way, I appear to be in good company.
10:57 PM on 01/03/2013
@ UK Visitor. I'm not from Manchester, but live here. Your statment that if your relatives are from Manchester, you could be a Stockport fan misses the point. They may as well be Bury fans, or Wigan. Stockport is in Cheshire? They should be City fans, as that is in Manchester, unlike United, though I appreciate borders have changed.
09:47 PM on 01/03/2013
But Manchester United were one of the most hated clubs before Alex Ferguson arrived; just not as successful with regards league titles.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jacksdad41
Quant Je Puis
08:01 PM on 01/03/2013
Nah, I didnt think my post would make it past the huffstapo calling out this lavatory blogger, a balanced informed opinion would'nt do would it?
05:24 PM on 01/06/2013
I have had loads of comments not make it through and I honestly do not know why. The only thing I can think is that I disagree with old Ron (sorry Rob) here. I think he must either be a fan from the wee club or from the dark (blue) side of Manchester.
09:22 AM on 01/03/2013
Actually Sir Alex may also have been on the "grassy knoll", hiding out in Loch Ness and if you look carefullly you can see his reflection in Neil Armstrongs spacesuit helmet during the "moon landing". Nuff said.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:09 AM on 01/03/2013
Oh give me strength.
Manu were hated before Fergie came to OT. I can't stand the club and detest Fergie, but he's a brilliant manager and his achievement at ManU is frankly extraordinary. He took a sleeping giant and woke it up. That is an incredibly hard thing to do.
And he's kept them at the top for decades.
I really hate to say this, but he's easily the best manager of the premiership era and to be honest has achieved far more than the Busby's Shankly's and Revies that we all love. The only manager who stands comparison for achievement is Clough, but I'm afraid Fergie may be the best there has ever been. I need to take a shower now, but facts is facts!
09:42 PM on 01/02/2013
Oh dear, I've actually gone red with embarrassment for you Rob
04:01 AM on 01/08/2013
Sorry about that. I can't think of a worse fate than going red, but I presume embarrassment is nothing new to you.