Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Robin Lee

GET UPDATES FROM Robin Lee
 

'Bipolar... My Arse'

Posted: 19/09/11 01:00

"I shouted at you... because I'm Bipolar."

"I murdered my kids... because I'm Bipolar."

"I forgot to pay the gas bill... because I'm Bipolar."

"I can't help it... I'm Bipolar."

All of the above statements are ridiculous, and all were used recently. I heard or read them. Being Bipolar is the latest must-have personality accessory. A few years ago it was trendy to have a stalker. If a stranger got off the bus at the same stop as you two days running... Stalker! Or the new woman in accounts sent you two non-work e-mails within 3 hours... Stalker! Luckily the distraction of handbag dogs, Fixie bikes, Bikram Yoga and Ugg Boots came along and we were able to smile at our neighbours again without fear of arrest and/or disciplinary action.

According to the US Library of Medicine (who are surely in some way responsible for morphing what was known as 'Manic Depression' into the publically accessible and acceptable version of 'Bipolar Disorder' in order to sell pharmaceuticals and give their nation something else superfluous to own) the definition is thus: 'Bipolar disorder is a condition in which people go back and forth between periods of a very good or irritable mood and depression. The "mood swings" between mania and depression can be very quick'.

Hold on! I've had that! Loads of times! For instance I've been to restaurants, eaten magnificent lobster bisque and beetroot and nectarine salad causing a state of bliss then stepped out into a sodden pavement and become cranky in a matter of minutes. Then the next morning woke up feeling fresh, invigorated and happy, then gone for my morning run and had an argument with a pillock whos' dog has just bitten my hand and then been grumpy for the rest of the day.

Does this mean I'm Bipolar? No it doesn't, it means I am, at worst, in a word.... Arsey. I've got 'Arsey Disorder'. Maybe I should lend it my name? 'Robin Howard Lee Syndrome'. You're welcome. Has a ring to it. In years to come I may get a windfall of royalties from Pfizer after they develop the antidote. More likely is that I simply don't like getting cold and wet on the way home from a great meal with the wittiest girl I've ever met or being mauled by mutts while I am wallowing in the smug morning sunshine. I see no reason to find a medical explanation for it. But that is exactly what's happening. People have found a medically recognised excuse for being mardy now and then. And it is fast becoming the unarguable convenient chant for people wanting to deny responsibility for their questionable behaviour.

There are people who have unmanageable and debilitating acute extremes of behaviour that become social problems and may cause their long suffering family and friends to despair. These people require and deserve intense supervision, treatment and support before their situation becomes depression or an embedded mental imbalance. These mood swings can range from reckless euphoria to attempted suicide, within minutes of each other. They now have to wait in a queue behind people who simply need to impart a reason to their friend as to why they lost their rag at a taxi rank during her hen night.

I met a lawyer the other day who had dealt with a case of a bloke who's house was raided on suspicion of drug possession. The police found two loaded Uzi machine guns and two wardrobes full of Amphetamine and Skunk Weed. His defence was that he was self-diagnosed Bipolar and used the drugs to counter the extremes of his condition. The charge on the drug possession was then discontinued. He was however convicted on firearms offences. I then typed 'Bipolar murderers' into Google search. There are thousands! People are literally using it to try to get away with murder. They may end up succeeding.

My experience of mental health issues, and over the years I have seen it from many aspects, is that sufferers generally shroud their problems and quietly find ways of coping, with the help of a few trusted friends and professionals. But fakers proudly cruise around in Bipolar Disorder like it's a 24 Carat gold carriage.

It's the dream diagnosis for Hypochondriacs and Arseholes. Their every action and reaction and day on sick can be attributed to being 'in a bad place' that day, due to their supposed disorder. It provides them with everything they require: attention, sympathy, guilt-free excuses, denial of any responsibility. It's the modern day adults' equivalent of crying after getting caught stealing sweets on the way to school. And we're not allowed to question it because that would be insensitive. I doubt that a true sufferer would even think about using it as leverage. It's maybe high time we started to let them know that they are culpable. There's too many of them. They've been rumbled. How else will these Charlatans move on? The British medical profession questioned the (by then) default prescription of Valium to people suffering with The Blues a few years ago. The drug was banned soon after. Maybe lazy diagnosis of Bipolar Disorder should be next on the agenda.

Surely I am not the only one who's heard enough of it?

 

Follow Robin Lee on Twitter: www.twitter.com/robinhowardlee

 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:06 on 28/09/2011
Now, now. I think what the man meant, but communicated in a thoughtless and unfunny fashion, was how a diagnostic category has drifted into the colloquial and further into an "excuse". Let me be clear, the author is an 'Arse', and wildly uninformed. He has forgotten what I took to be a truism (perhaps, I confess, it's a stereotype), that a true and proper Englishman would not comment on a subject he knows little about for the sake of a spot of attention. I don't side with him in this.

There is some debate in the mental health literature these days about appropriateness of diagnostic categories, and whether "Bipolar" means anything. A crashing debate ought to begin shortly after the release of the next "American" mental health manual next year. I fear it will put the good reputations of many MH workers like myself and Carolyn (above) in jeopardy. The fact that the term 'Bipolar' has drifted into the common English as an excuse does not in any way reduce the pain and suffering of people who suffer from the disorder the term describes.

I, for one, am tired of uninformed Bloggers who can start fights with mere words and pose as authorities on subjects. Remember, words and reality are two separate things. As, apparently, is being an Englishman and being merely a man from England.

God Save the Queen.
18:00 on 28/09/2011
Well said!
18:29 on 25/09/2011
I find your post offensive. I come from a family where bipolar disorder runs rampant. I have raised two daughters with bipolar disorder and attention deficit disorder. Until you live with it, you can not speak of it. My daughters show rapid cycling, being manic one moment and depressed the next moment. Until you see the impact it has on families and the outside world, I don't feel you can comment. Yest bipolar disorder has become the catch all diagnosis these days, just like attention deficit hyperactivity disorder was the catch all phrase for diagnosis in the 90's. I did not raise my children to use it as an excuse to get out of doing things. They are both hard working young women in the workforce and coincidentally have bipolar disorder. Having it myself, I cannot live without my medication. Bipolar disorder can be crippling depending on the severity of it. I work full time as a therapist with the disorder, but I do not let it stop me from living a full life.
22:01 on 24/09/2011
This article rings true with me personally. Over a period of 35 years I have had four “manic episodes” in my lifetime but never accepted a “label” of BiPolar Disorder. I’ve learned “mania” can be handled by “reducing sources of stimulation” and depression by “changing focus”. Thank goodness I didn’t swallow the “medical model” (or more than a handful of the “pills”)!
17:30 on 26/09/2011
I would question if you truly have bipolar disorder. Having manic and depressive episodes are not a choice you can choose yourself out of. My son can not choose to leave depression by changing his focus or stop his mania but eliminating stimulation. That is why he needs medication, it is a disease in his brain affecting his brain chemistry, something completely out of his control. People don't commit suicide because they didn't "change their focus", they do so because they are seriously ill.

Thank goodness you never experienced what my son has.
21:05 on 20/09/2011
My spouse is bipolar,diagnosed in 1976, has had eight serious psychotic breaks and doesn't use it as an excuse. Indeed,she gets angry at those who do. She states that it is bad enough to have to live with it but for those who use it as an excuse, it is outrageous. So, as much as I would like to disagree with the article, there is something to it. Bipolar can vary, it is insidious, and it is traumatic on the family. But it should never be used as an excuse, especially so if the person is one who self-diagnoses. GAWD, the arrogance of that.
17:12 on 20/09/2011
I find it disturbing that you would compare your changing moods to those that suffer from bipolar disorder. It’s obvious that you have no idea what you’re talking about. Those with bipolar disorder don't have mood changes as you describe. It’s no different than you comparing a paper cut to a person who has had their arm amputated.

I have watched my 10 year old son who has rapid cycling fall to the ground, crying that his moods are starting to change. From there he will switch to crying, then start to laugh, then back to crying with a frightened look on his face as he realizes that he has no control on his mind. This will happen over and over every few seconds his mood will abruptly change. Feeling desperate, he'll start to slam his head into the ground, begging to help him make his moods stop changing. From there he may start to see monsters as he experience­s psychosis from his changing moods, he'll go into a violent rage wanting to hurt me or he'll fall deeper into depression and want to kill himself. Can you imagine having to take a knife out of your child's hand because he wants to kill himself or pull him out of the street because he wants to have a car run him over? This is our life. This is my son’s illness. It is no laughing matter and definitely doesn't look anything like the illness you mock fun of.
17:00 on 20/09/2011
"I shouted at you... because I'm Bipolar."

"I murdered my kids... because I'm Bipolar."

"I forgot to pay the gas bill... because I'm Bipolar."

"I can't help it... I'm Bipolar."

You say all of these statements are ridiculous—you have no idea. All of these statements can be true for sufferers of bipolar disorder. My child has bipolar disorder and lives with serious pain in his life. This article pokes fun at this diagnosis and continues the stigma that already exists. In the end, sufferers will quietly hide their symptoms and avoid the treatment they so desperately need causing them possibly self-medicate, commit a crime or harm themselves or others. Maybe you should spend some time with those that suffer with bipolar disorder before you mock them.
chickeyd
www.themindstorm.net
03:47 on 20/09/2011
So, explain why 60% of teens with serious depression and classic bipolar disorder NEVER get treatment? NEVER, as in no drugs, no therapy, no nothing?
14:58 on 19/09/2011
Nope, you're not the only one who has heard enough of it. Great article and I agree. Those who do actually suffer seem to do so quietly and get treated and don't make a fuss.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miserable Swine
15:21 on 19/09/2011
A valid point. I`m just concerned about the lack of treatment.
15:34 on 19/09/2011
I know someone who suffers and she has been getting treatment for it for many many years. It is possible to get the correct treatment and live a happy life. But you have to realise the treatment is forever and keep at it, or you go into that low place, which isn't fun.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
13:49 on 19/09/2011
How to put mental illness in to catogories :-
Thoes that know they are ill, and worry about it are Neurotics.
Those that don't think they are mad, but everyone else does are PSYCHOTIC and,
Those that know they are mad, and don't worry about it are NORMAL
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Miserable Swine
13:48 on 19/09/2011
Non-issue. Non-story. There is a difference between saying you have a mental illness and having a diagnosis.
13:10 on 19/09/2011
Maybe I move in the wrong circles, but I really don't encounter this as an every day or even every month occurrence. Maybe I should spend more (or even some) time reading about 'celebrities'?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lawyer13
retired Lawyer, General and Psychiatric Nurse, wit
12:37 on 19/09/2011
How right you are, blame everythink on mental illness