iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Simon C. Johnson

GET UPDATES FROM Simon C. Johnson
 

Frenemies of Our State

Posted: 15/12/2012 00:00

I'm no stranger to same-sex marriage arguments. My Colombian partner and I had differing opinions of our own civil partnership sandwiched between the Olympics and Paralympics. The contentious topic? The inclusion of a mariachi band at our reception. We managed to overcome those cultural differences in favour of a life long commitment to each other.

Petty you might say, yes - but consider the laughable statements against same-sex marriage or those who have made sweeping statements on behalf of gay men and women. We supposedly do not want equal marriage and did you know that same-sex marriage will pave the way for polygamy?

2012-12-14-PhotocLauraMacarto.jpg


I have to wonder if those who said, and those who have risen to these ridiculous statements want to encourage rational discussion and debate or if they're grabbing headlines and column inches for their own profile. And with same-sex marriage proposals now made public I'm worried that those same voices are quick to dismiss the advances of equality the proposals lay out.

A 'hear, hear' for David Cameron - those plans should be celebrated by the gay community, but I have a feeling the most militant of us won't be cosying up to the Conservative party just yet. But can we take a step back and acknowledge that equality can't happen overnight? It should, but it takes time and railroading of individuals or institutions will, in the long run, require much more earth moving to dig their heels out.

Whilst I'm not in favour of voting on equality, I support Cameron's free vote. As I've already mentioned, it's been mistaken by some backbench Tories as license to demonstrate intolerance and out of touch views of a Party that introduced Section 28 banning schools and councils from recognising the LGBT community - and those views will certainly be used against any Party or person in upcoming elections.

Maria Miller has only recently changed her tune from suggesting that we, the gay community, would have "locks" placed on our "freedom" - reworded to "legal locks" - to protect and appease the Church. Confusing statements coming from the minister whose remit is to promote equality and freedom. Is she really on our side?

So, I say it's time to take a break and "celebrate not discriminate" as shadow equalities minister Yvette Cooper rightly said. For those who have been vocal against gay marriage to now support or simply accept the view of the majority of the House of Commons and that of the British people who are broadly in favour of same-sex marriage. And for those questioning whatever motivation David Cameron might have in pledging to legalise same-sex marriage, the fact is, he's doing it and with that equality wins.

The mariachi band was canned. I hope same-sex marriages won't be.

Photo (c) Laura Macarto

 

Follow Simon C. Johnson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/amazingexpress

FOLLOW GAY VOICES
I'm no stranger to same-sex marriage arguments. My Colombian partner and I had differing opinions of our own civil partnership sandwiched between the Olympics and Paralympics. The contentious topic? T...
I'm no stranger to same-sex marriage arguments. My Colombian partner and I had differing opinions of our own civil partnership sandwiched between the Olympics and Paralympics. The contentious topic? T...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:15 on 22/12/2012
What I wonder will they be teaching our children about marriage and family values. Will they try and impose a sense of normality on such such "marriages" between same sex partners. How do they square this with the teachings of the Bible - who for instance if God made Adam and Eve who made Adam and Steve?. Will they be teaching the same fundamentals to Muslim,Hindu Jewish,Buddhist, RC children in those schools. What on earth can be wrong with the status quo. My mother who became a widow and subsequently married a widower,(my Stepfather) could not get married in his Church,(RC) because she was an Anglican C of E so they married in a registry office viz civil partner ship - what on earth is wrong with that it conferred all the same civil rights as if they had been both of the same Church. I say humbug to all those gays who are discontent.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathan0316
TrueBlueTory Age quod agis
17:41 on 16/12/2012
Another step on the long road towards equality for all, anybody should be able to marry the partner of their choice, so long as it's between consenting adults.

I mean, really, what is all the fuss about? Is it going to negatively affect anyone's life in any way if two men can walk down the aisle and enter into a legally-recognized union in front of all their friends and family? I can't see it changing anything except allowing two people in love to commit to each other!
17:30 on 16/12/2012
Why do the gays want there Partnership called Marriage so much,
A man and woman is Marriage, they can have Kids , Same sex couples cant ,
So be happy with it being called a Partnership ?.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathan0316
TrueBlueTory Age quod agis
17:38 on 16/12/2012
Why? Would you be happy to have your marriage downgraded to a partnership instead?

Equality means just that, equal.
23:21 on 16/12/2012
My Marriage is a man & Woman , The Proper way, So we can have children ?,
Yours I assume is Same sex Partnership, It will never be a Marriage
so you will never be Equal has you cant have kids
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
22:22 on 14/12/2012
You write ..... "Maria Miller....... Is she really on our side? " To me that says it all about this debate.
Its about getting your own way. That's ok - I can understand that. But what I can't stand is the pious hypocracy that its about equality and freedom. These are impossible.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
21:20 on 14/12/2012
Why does the issue of gay marriage entail battles with the Church of England, maybe a little bit of fisticuffs with the Catholics and nothing else? When are the Muslims, Jews, Sikhs and Hindus going to be invited to participate and contribute to the discourse of this process? The UK is a multicultural country. Gay marriage is for everyone. isn't it?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hellhound
fangs `aint what they used to be!
10:38 on 15/12/2012
Not for me it isn`t! Who would you suggest we volunteer to approach the muslim heirarchy to invite them to embrace marriage of homosexuals within their communities, George Galloway??