Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sofia Ahmed

GET UPDATES FROM Sofia Ahmed
 

Anti-Muslim Attacks: Telling MAMA Is Not Going to Solve the Problem

Posted: 31/01/2013 00:00

Islamophobia has not only passed the dinner table test but it has permeated British society at every level. The media, politicians, security services, policymakers and other public institutions can all be held responsible for the rise in anti-Muslim sentiment over the past few years.

Speaking at a dinner held by a new government-backed organisation, Tell MAMA - set up to monitor anti-Muslim attacks - Baroness Sayeeda Warsi the Conservative Minister for Faith and Communities, hit out at the media, which she claimed fuels the rising level of hatred and suspicion of British Muslims.

Having recently been the victim of a hate crime in which three men verbally abused me and threatened me with physical violence; seemingly due to the "rag" I choose to wear on my head, I can't help but think that this new initiative is yet another inane and tokenistic attempt by the government to tackle a problem that they are essentially to blame for.

Recording the amount of attacks and providing support for victims is pointless if nothing is being done to stop them happening in the first place. Warsi claims that it is part of her job to counteract anti-Muslim sentiments. Pointing the finger of blame at the media while conveniently ignoring the actions of the current government suggests she is not doing her job very well. Some of the policies and decisions made by the government that she is a part of will negatively affect British Muslims for many years to come.

During the speech, Warsi cited a recent YouGov poll in which half of the participants believed that there would be a 'clash of civilisations', between Islam and the West. Another recent survey has indicated that up to 75% of people believe that Islam is incompatible with British values and that Muslims are a threat to the Western world. Opinions like this are not plucked out of thin air, Warsi is right in suggesting that this kind of thinking is formed due to media representations. Yet, she fails to acknowledge the fact that the creation of these of the 'West versus Islam' discourse, is nothing short of war propaganda that has been carefully constructed and disseminated from the same corridors of power that Sayeeda strolls down on a daily basis.

Britain's on-going presence in Afghanistan and its support of Western Interventions in Muslim countries are making matters worse. The neverending 'War on Terror' means that there will be no real attempt to try and tackle the rampant Islamophobia in the press, mainly because it serves a purpose. The demonization of Islam and labeling of men, women and children, as 'Jihadists', 'Islamists', and 'collateral damage' leads to the dehumanization of Muslims. Which, in turn, ensures an unsympathetic domestic population, from questioning or speaking out against tens of thousands of innocent people being killed with bullets and bombs that their tax money has paid for.

It is becoming increasingly clear that this war against Muslim countries is also being waged on the home front, where British Muslims are increasingly viewed as the enemy within. If Baroness Warsi feels that that statement is over exaggerated, she just needs to cast her mind back to the 5 February 2011. On the day that the English Defence League held one of their largest marches, David Cameron was at the Munich security conference, using a lot of the same arguments that you would hear at the march. The only difference between the far right group and Cameron that day, was he was in a suit and tie and they were in tracksuits and baseball caps. He was hiding behind a thin veneer of respectability and they were unashamedly displaying their hatred on the streets of Luton.

Both David Cameron and The English Defence league demonised and stereotyped a demographic of nearly three million British Muslims that day. He failed to convince me that state multiculturalism had failed, but events that day did convince me that Islamophobia had triumphed. There is no doubt that Cameron's speech and the resulting media hysteria, further exonerated the type of mentality that lead to those men attacking me in the street. Muslim women who choose to wear the veil are visible representations of everything that David Cameron vilified and deemed as outsiders during that speech.

If Baroness Warsi is serious about tackling anti-Muslim hatred and stopping Muslim women getting spat on and kicked to the ground for wearing a piece of cloth on their heads, I suggest that she should begin with her own party. I can see that she has her hands tied. It must be hard to stand up to someone who handpicked her as his pet Muslim. But she does not have much to lose. What is quite clear is that she remains a token Muslim for the Conservatives. Rolled out whenever she is required to pacify and pay lip service to Muslim audiences and banished to Conservative HQ, labelled as a liability, once she is done.

I think I can safely speak for the majority of the community when I say that the government is guilty of double standards and an inability to tackle the issue appropriately. On the one hand we have politicians frequently scapegoating Muslims when they need to distract the public from their own failures, and on the other they think we should be grateful for the fact that they have provided us with a helpline to monitor the consequences of their actions. If there is too be any real change in attitudes then Sayeeda and her peers need to get to the root of the problem, which is, the ongoing wars in Muslim countries and the resulting demonisation of Muslims living in Britain. Until then, Muslims will remain the primary targets of hate crime. The next time someone is brutally attacked on the street, I don't think they will find solace in the fact that the government has allowed them the privilege of Telling MAMA all about it.

 

Follow Sofia Ahmed on Twitter: www.twitter.com/sofiaahmed1

FOLLOW UK STUDENTS
Islamophobia has not only passed the dinner table test but it has permeated British society at every level. The media, politicians, security services, policymakers and other public institutions can al...
Islamophobia has not only passed the dinner table test but it has permeated British society at every level. The media, politicians, security services, policymakers and other public institutions can al...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 232
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
09:30 PM on 03/21/2013
strangely attacks on white British people are not even reported as a racial attack and yet there is more pandering to poor innocent muslims....
03:17 PM on 02/17/2013
If we are to make "islamophobia" a crime we have to set out parameters, for example if a muslim is personally attacked for their beliefs that should be a hate crime. However if the ideology is criticised then that should be allowed. I would describe myself as Anti-Islam because of its well documented views on homosexuality, I view it as a hate group. But as for being anti-muslim I respect them just as I would any other human being.
12:21 PM on 02/20/2013
I agree with most of what you have said (although I don't want to get into the whole homosexuality issue because that's a totally different debate and controversy!) I understand the point you're illustrating, that one can have their opinions on are particular religion or faith. This article however is centered on violence against individuals just because they have a certain faith- which is totally unacceptable. I don't remember the last time an atheist got physically attacked because they don't believe in God, it doesn't happen (on the large scale) because atheism is not badly stigmatised whereas Islam is- thus Muslim's suffer. Not refuting you by the way, just thought I'd share some thoughts. As a muslim myself, I can totally relate to the author of this article, I have experienced hate crimes similar to this and know others who have. It is very much prevalent within our society and needs to be questioned why. :)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ABrads
ira contra lucis moriendum
08:10 AM on 02/10/2013
Islamophobia is overstated - 340 hate crimes against muslims, crimes ranging from trivial insults to more serious incidents, does not make a serious threat to muslims in Britain. I can understand the author's concern especially after being threatened herself. However don't lay all the blame on the media - people like Choudray or the vile radical clerics, do not help foster good relations or trust.

The author should note the number of people strongly opposed to the Iraq invasion and how that translated into the then PM leaving office. Many British non muslims don't want the UK to get involved in action in muslim countries.
05:22 PM on 02/07/2013
This is the most ridiculous story yet, Warsi hitting out at the media, claiming they are fueling the rising level of hatred and suspicion of British Muslims.
So it's NOT the act's of Terrorist Fanatical Muslims murdering people that is responsible for the hatred, it's actually the press.....WRONG !
The biggest problem is the lack of effort the British Muslims put into combating this problem amongst there own people.
Why on earth would any Muslim want to live amongst NONE BELIEVERS if it flies in the face of all reason to them. There is a simple way to solve the problem!
01:27 PM on 02/07/2013
all muslims reap what you sow
02:59 AM on 02/04/2013
The comments here show the problem. Gratuitous violence against someone because of what they cannot change is a crime and must be dealt with as a crime. This is what it is about.

If someone is disloyal - deport them. If doesn't know English, revoke their citizenship. Violent? Imprison them. There are remedies for all of the perceived problems with Muslims.

Gratuitous violence sanctioned by the majority is not Britain, but very close to Nazi Germany. And this is what this initiative hopes to avoid, not least by shaming leaders and authorities.
09:39 PM on 03/21/2013
....and killing innocent people by flying aircraft into the Twin Towers is also an act of aggression similar to that of Nazi Germany, so we are right to be wearey of people that bomb us on our own soil especially when mosques do not report suspicious behaviour!!!!
to be disloyal to a country that you choose to live is treason, no matter what religion you are
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nwsaia
The Voice of Reason, Truth & Intelligence
10:20 PM on 02/01/2013
if they don't like it here..there is another option
12:22 PM on 02/20/2013
And may I ask what that is?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nwsaia
The Voice of Reason, Truth & Intelligence
01:40 PM on 02/20/2013
yes u may
04:07 PM on 02/01/2013
It is not what's on their head?
It is not what colour their skin is?
It is not what beliefs they hold in their head?

It is however their attitude towards the people who have accommadeted them. They do not understand the concept of adapting to another country, like we would have to. It is their rigid and deep routed devotion to their religion that stops this happening.

Would people be so negative if they didn't build mosques?
Would people be so negative if they didn't create communities that look like another country?
Would people be so negative if they backed this country when it tries to innocently protect itself against terrorism?
Would people be so negative if they respected the Christian beliefs that generates the money to keep many of them ?
Would people be so negative if they actually showed interest in mixing with people of different religion and become more like a traditional British person?

There will always be some people who look for an excuse to lash out, but they are a small part of the problem. The large part of the problem can only be solved by themselves and if they are not happy with that, they would be happier leaving to a muslim country.
This comment has been removed.
03:41 PM on 02/01/2013
I would guess that, unpalatable though it may be to the writer, many people in this country do not want muslims living here. Possibly they are sick of "institutionalised" islamophilia being preached to them and do not see how Britain benefits from the introduction of a new and in many ways quite alien culture.
Richard Britton
British Socialist Global Realist
10:17 PM on 02/01/2013
indeed

the whole country would be more peaceful if they were not here, it's very simple even if some people refuse to think about it
11:59 AM on 02/01/2013
No Islam, no Islamists. Islam IS incompatible with the west. Read the Quran. A Warlord and professional slaver who claimed conference with his creator who is nothing more than a terrorist cast into the heavens who will burn you forever if you refuse to 'believe' in him. Islam is incapable of reform. Everyone else has to 'reform' around it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:40 PM on 02/05/2013
Neither Quran nor Bible is compatible with the current laws of the land in the West.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pat Brand
Getting on a bit, but loving every day I get.
10:28 AM on 02/01/2013
...and Muslims aren't guilty of Christianaphobia????
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:26 PM on 02/05/2013
Some are. What is your point?

There are Muslims like you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pat Brand
Getting on a bit, but loving every day I get.
04:11 PM on 02/05/2013
Muslims like me??? I'm Christian. My point was Christians are constantly being castigated for inciting Islamophobia - I was considering whether Muslims are guilty of Christianophobia.
10:15 AM on 02/01/2013
I am in the unfortunate position to have rented a house to 2 mulims of pakistani descent.
They have been nothing but trouble since they moved in. I have to have witnesses with me and recording devices if i have to visit the house. I have been refused rent on the grounds that I do not respect them ? Well whoopey do dey. They the muslims just bring it on themselves.
04:12 PM on 02/07/2013
Having some experience of the matter, I can tell you you are in for a long drawn out legal battle.

The only way to get shot of them other than through the court,not always successful, is to make their miserable lives even moire miserable. The means and opportunity is in your hands.
But whatever you do, do NOT allow them to dictate terms.
04:51 PM on 02/07/2013
Thanks for that  with you all the way.
12:44 PM on 02/20/2013
I really don't see how you're personal encounter with one Muslim family makes you judge every one of them as the same bunch of people. It's a ridiculous and unintelligent generalisation!
01:26 PM on 02/20/2013
With a name like kou karaci becons you
09:54 PM on 03/21/2013
well living in a city that, has areas that were once 'posh' are now run down and scruffy what can only be due to the people that live there, even though the council spends more money with subsidies for public transport services etc than anywhere else. That is why there is generalisation.
09:53 AM on 02/01/2013
Let's not forget that Al Qaeda-inspired terrorism against the West predated the War on Terror by a matter of a decade - so it is wrong to claim that Western occupaton/intervention in muslim countries 'caused' Islamist terrorism (and the resulting Islamophobia). It has exacerbated it and globalised it, certainly.

The root cause of Islamophobia in the UK is fear of Islamist terrorism itself - a very real fear, unfortunately - combined with Islam's failure, or unwillingness, to modernise its core messages and thereby marginalising worshippers who gain inspiration from the Koran to justify their bigotry, homophobia, religious supermacism, mysoginy, and vengefulness.

I'm afraid 'The West is wholly to blame for Islamophobia' argument simply doesn't wash, Sofia.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:30 PM on 02/05/2013
Let's not forget that Al Qaeda-inspired terrorism against the West predated the War on Terror by a matter of a decade.

But it did not predate the British rule of the region. Did it?
05:47 PM on 02/05/2013
... and how far back do you go to play the 'my terrorism is justified because of what so-and-so did to us in the past'?  Presumably you decide do you?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
steve sayers
Old enough to know better
01:09 AM on 03/29/2013
There has been a definite shift to UK rejection of fundamentalist Islamic preaching teaching and activity. I can't see that it is all down to parochial prejudice, no smoke without fire. Rather than accuse people of islamophobia Islamists and their advocates in this country need to do more to demonstrate that their views accord to our secular society and to show respect for UK institutions and customs. I have no problem with any specific person (excluding mad mullahs) and do not consider myself anti Islam but get twitchy when they want to stone a woman to death for showing her boobs or for indoctrinating a suicide bomber to do their thing for the promise of twenty virgins in heaven. All fundamentalism is a problem, it just appears that most of it arises from Islam. Worried.
07:29 AM on 02/01/2013
When are the muslims going to be held responsible for the dislike of muslims and there useless iron age death cult? Or is it everyone else's fault as usual with you guys?
Richard Britton
British Socialist Global Realist
10:22 PM on 02/01/2013
good question