Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Stephen Starr

GET UPDATES FROM Stephen Starr
 

Syria's Minorities Are Afraid - After Assad, They Shouldn't Be

Posted: 09/07/2012 00:00

Residents of the hillside town of Saidnaya 25 miles north of Damascus are a close, united community. They pray together at several of the town's churches that cater for hundreds of Greek Orthodox, Syriac Catholic and Syriac Orthodox families. Their sons and daughters regularly take part in church-organised scout and band activities. Their Christian faith features strongly in their daily activities - and political stances.

Syria's Christians, like other minorities, have voiced serious unease with the nature and makeup of the current uprising. Church leaders continue to back the regime which in turn tells minorities it will protect them from extremist Islamic elements.

When a shell passed through a monastery wall last January but failed to explode, locals blamed 'armed terrorist groups' in nearby towns and thanked god no major damage was caused. When a Christian soldier is killed in action, his family and community are afforded space, time and peace for his funeral, something activists inside the country can only dream of.

Counting for around 25% of Syria's population, most minorities do not want the minority Assad regime to fall. Communal ties between Christians and Alawites, the two largest minority religions, are close. Alawites regularly nightclub with Christians. In the mountains of southwest Syria Christians, Druze and Alawite families regularly lunch at restaurants that serve beer and araq, an alcoholic drink.

Alawites in Syria are tied to the regime out of fear and because many hold jobs of consequence across the Syrian economy. Christians readily identify with the Russian Orthodox Church, which has publically opposed foreign intervention in Syria. Syria's Shia population look to Hezbollah, still a staunch supporter of the Assad regime, for guidance. All these factors work to push minorities closer to the Syrian authorities. On top of this is the state's media campaign tells minorities what they want to hear - that the regime is a bastion of stability.

But Syria's minorities should not fear a government born out of revolt.

My experience of Syria over almost five years is a country far more liberal than neighbouring Jordan or Iraq. In Latakia on Syria's Mediterranean coast, young girls have waited on restaurant tables for years. Wealthy hijab-wearing teenagers (generally Sunni) in Damascus I have met are more likely to quote from the American television series Gossip Girl than the Quran; they are Syria's future.

In the seats of power - Damascus and Aleppo - radical Islam is a very side-lined ideal indeed. People want security, functioning schools and jobs, and they will not stand for an Islamist regime taking the place of one (Assad's) they have watched kill thousands.

And there are historical precedents that point to tolerance of those who have sided with forces opposing Syria's Sunni majority. When French colonial forces upped sticks and left Syria in the late 1940s, Syria's Alawites and Christians pleaded with them to stay - they feared a backlash from Syrian Sunnis because of the privilege extracted through close ties to the French regime. The French duly left but no reprisals took place. Many Sunni activists I have spoken to point to the fact that Fares al-Khoury, a Christian, was twice prime minister of Syria before the Assad regime took over. "The Assad family shames the Alawite people," they say.

In any case, with Assad and his mafia gone, what will remain for his security forces to fight for? It is possible, likely even, that for a time some Alawites may retreat to their home villages in the mountains along the Syrian coast. But they will not wish to bring violence into their own villages. Once Assad is gone they will know that nothing remains to fight for.

Certainly, reprisals against the overwhelmingly Alawite shabiha and security forces are possible, but not on the scale that will lead to a concentrated targeting of the entire Alawite sect and of other minorities.

There are zero good options for anyone living in Syria at the moment - Sunni or minority. But the regime's brutality has ensured this revolt will overcome. The question for Syria's minorities today remains this: when will they grab hold of reality and begin to shape their own futures?

 
 
 

Follow Stephen Starr on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@stephenstarr

FOLLOW UK POLITICS
Residents of the hillside town of Saidnaya 25 miles north of Damascus are a close, united community. They pray together at several of the town's churches that cater for hundreds of Greek Orthodox, Syr...
Residents of the hillside town of Saidnaya 25 miles north of Damascus are a close, united community. They pray together at several of the town's churches that cater for hundreds of Greek Orthodox, Syr...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:01 AM on 07/15/2012
I don't buy the argument of Stephen Starr. He may have spent some time there but this is a very complicated country and region. Did he spend time talking to the Kurds as well as Sunnis or Alawhites and Christians?
12:56 AM on 07/15/2012
Evidence points to Moslem Brotherhood domination of the Syrian National Council, the principal exile group that wants to replace Assad. The Coptic Christians in Egypt have reason to fear the domination of a similar MB in Egyptian elections. Your reassurances are not much comfort for minorities in Syria.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nathan0316
TrueBlueTory Age quod agis
12:33 PM on 07/10/2012
Yet more reasons for us to stay out of Syria militarily. We don't understand it, don't know the players and can't possibly predict the outcome.

Bring all our troops home from this increasingly unstable region and leave them to sort out their own problems, we've got enough to be dealing with here at home.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jonas caldwell
10:28 PM on 07/09/2012
Mr.Stephen Starr blames syrian government on all violence and even calls it 'mafia', saying minorities should not fear the raising of a government born from revolt. We should say: armed revolt, armed rebellion, armed by the occident who now says, in the voice of one of its journalists, that 'girls who quote from american tv series' are 'Syria's future' ... That's to say: we mount the scenario for violence (by arming insurgents and encouraging them to uprise) and then we blame Assad, Russia, pro-Assad groups and whoever for all existing violence, suggesting the only solution is his ousting or resigning (stepping down), accompanied by the westernization of people and habits. Funny, ludicrous, unbearable.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:15 AM on 07/09/2012
I hope you're right Mr Starr, but I bet you aren't. I've never been to Syria, so I'll bow to your superior knowledge of that country.
But we need to accept that the opposition is to a large degree fundamentalist Sunni and Salafist. The Syrian people may bear the Christians and Alawites no great animosity, although I find that quite hard to believe in the circumstances, but you can be sure the boys with guns, and their backers in the Gulf states and Saudi Arabia are not liberal pluralists.
The minorities are pinning their hopes on 'the devil you know' and I think there's enough historical precedent to suggest that might be a wise move.
11:10 PM on 07/08/2012
Syria has a lot in common with Rwanda and Bosnia. The opposition groups are executing captured Alawites, Armenians and Christians as a matter of policy, they are also eliminating security risks via ethnic profiling within their own ranks.
08:04 PM on 07/09/2012
You may be right, you may be wrong. Do you have anything that verifies the claim?
10:24 PM on 07/12/2012
The UN has cited them for war crimes, and nobody has encountered a soldier loyal to the regime who has survived capture. Anything the FSA occupy will have very few if any Christians or Alawites. They are fun guys when on a roll.

http://static.prisonplanet.com/p/images/june2012/270612top.jpg

'One soldier stated that he believed the creed 'an eye for an eye,' which he described as being part of Sharia law, supersedes international standards. Another FSA soldier told the [commission] that Alawite soldiers are normally killed immediately upon capture, while soldiers from other sects are offered the chance to join the FSA'

http://blog.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2012/06/27/inside_syrias_civil_war

They don't keep their POWs at the Hilton. In Aleppo province they are basically mountain savages and kill everybody.
05:01 AM on 07/11/2012
Armenians, as you probably know, are Christians.
10:26 PM on 07/12/2012
If Turkey invades Syria, as I also probably know, the Armenians will be leaving.