Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Sue Cross

GET UPDATES FROM Sue Cross
 

Eat Shoots and Leaves: A Case For the Vegan Option

Posted: 12/07/2012 00:00

In the countryside the fields burgeon with pasture and crops. But where are the animals?

See the industrial-sized buildings in this agricultural landscape? The lack of life on the outside belies the fact that inside are living beings, crammed together in vast numbers, fed and watered by automation. For them - unlike the fields outside - there is nothing natural.

This is intensive farming and these are factories for animal processing.

Economies of scale are key. Like commodities on a production line the aim is to breed and rear animals so that meat, eggs and milk can be produced using the smallest amount of space, at the lowest possible cost, in the shortest possible time. Maximizing profit to produce cheap food can never be reconciled with anything approaching the humane treatment of animals. Above all the giant agri-corporations strive to satisfy the consumer for whom price, taste and food safety are what matters - in that order.

The list of animals is long. Chickens, ducks, turkeys and geese; laying hens; quail and game birds reared for sport; dairy cattle; beef cattle; veal calves; rabbits; fish, goats; and, in some countries dogs.

Not for them a life according to their kind. Ducks have no water for swimming. Unable to preen they live out their seven week lives with eyes and nostrils encrusted with dirt, their feathers curled and sticky with filth. Meanwhile those raised for foie gras are force fed to enlarge their livers, their throats so bruised and damaged that they would never be able to eat naturally again. Broiler hens spend their six week lives on a bed of mounting excrement, kept alive with routine doses of antibiotics and vaccines.

In vast barns sows in crates, wedged between steel bars, are unable to turn around or take a break from their voraciously suckling piglets. If their environment was suited to their needs they would mark out a special 'dunging' area but in these conditions they have to defecate where they stand. These animals never know what it is like to have earth to root in, to search for food. They never feel the sun on their backs or sense the passing of the seasons.

And the result? Confined in vast numbers; stressed; unable to form a pecking order or any normal social relationship, they turn on each other. And so to minimise injuries they are 'mutilated'.

Castrated males - piglets, lambs and calves - are easier to handle. Castration also improves the quality of the meat. The spermatic chords of lambs and calves are crushed. Week old piglets have their testicles removed surgically (with a knife), their screams very much louder on the second cut.

The beaks of poultry - hens, turkeys, quail - are 'trimmed' to reduce injuries from 'feather pecking'. Yet under a beak's hard outer casing are nerve endings which makes this procedure akin to amputating a human limb.

Piglets' teeth are either filed or clipped to prevent injuries to their sows' teats and each other - yet their teeth and gums are no less sensitive, nor their nerve endings any different, from those of humans. Piglets' tails are also docked - surgically - since, like human babies, they teethe and need something to chew on. In a barren environment of concrete and steel tails become obvious comforters.

In the western world most farmed animals - about 95% - are produced on an industrial scale in industrialised units. But there are systems that are more humane; where the needs of the animals are provided for and where they have a good relationship with those that rear them; where sows have straw to nest in, hens dirt to scratch in, ducks water for swimming, piglets earth to root in and calves space to play and a diet that suits their immature digestive systems.

But systems like these cost considerably more than those ultra efficient units that treat animals as if they were inanimate agricultural products. If consumers care they have to pay the price. And those that do not? They support the vast agri-conglomerations for whom animals are nothing more than a product to profit from. Even those who buy milk and cheese support the beef and veal industries. And those who buy eggs also help swell the profits of giant agri-corporations (since most eggs derive from an industry too large to care about the welfare of hens, including a large proportion of free-range hens).

But there is a way to avoid contributing to the meat industry's coffers. The vegan way. Plant based food. Leaves, shoots, stems, seeds, nuts, fungi, pulses, fruit. A huge diversity that top chefs are at last drawing attention to.


Sue Cross is author of On the Menu: Animal Welfare (Published by Pen Press, 2009) and Today's Freaks: An A to Z of How Farm Animals Live and Die (ebook published 2011 and free in PDF form from: http://www.onthemenu-animalwelfare.co.uk)
Both book are available from Amazon in the UK and also the US

 
FOLLOW UK LIFESTYLE
In the countryside the fields burgeon with pasture and crops. But where are the animals? See the industrial-sized buildings in this agricultural landscape? The lack of life on the outside belies th...
In the countryside the fields burgeon with pasture and crops. But where are the animals? See the industrial-sized buildings in this agricultural landscape? The lack of life on the outside belies th...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
Taterhead McGobstopper
Paddle faster, I hear banjos ...
07:00 AM on 07/13/2012
Well done post ... vegans are cool :)
09:31 PM on 07/12/2012
What is it with the so called Eco warriors and stretching the truth. In the EU legislation is in place to protect animals. the most recent been the act banning battery cages for hens.(1/1/12) Yes some people brake those laws and when caught they are charged. In the UK we have
http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2006/45/contents
The irony here is, there is now a band of people who claim eating veg is cruel and they only eat wind fallen fruit.Google vegetablecruelty.
Meanwhile a 1/3 of the worlds population insist on slitting the throat of animals because they claim god told them to and the person behind this post remains silent on that fact.
07:26 PM on 07/12/2012
Given the vegetarian options open I dont know why so many people find meat so vital to their lives, veganism? no, I enjoy milk eggs and cheese all of which can be sourced from organic cruelty free sources.
As to the claim we are all carniviores because we have canines, bit daft innit
However given the thrust of the article, VAT at 30% on factory farmed meat could perhaps be a move in the right direction.
photo
Taterhead McGobstopper
Paddle faster, I hear banjos ...
06:55 AM on 07/13/2012
All eggs and dairy involve massive amounts of cruelty. Especially the dairy.
09:44 AM on 07/13/2012
Wrong, my eggs come from my allotment and the milk around here is supplied from local dairy herds, nobodys arguing there is no cruelty in the meat trade but massive amounts of cruelty in the dairy industry? any evidence?
Mind you I am talking about the UK, what goes on in the continent is another matter.
01:39 PM on 07/12/2012
Sorry, difficult to read through this tripe with the sheep in the field next to our house full of sheep and the mooing of the cows from the next field over. Also the neighbour's free-rangechickens make a bit of noise.

But of course you're telling me there are no animals in fields. So you must be right and all these animals in fields are ghosts or hallucinations.
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
01:03 PM on 07/12/2012
Humans are top of the food chain, we're natural meat-eaters. Our canine teeth and our like for the taste of flesh. It's that we have evolved to live in a molliie-coddled society which means we don't have to go hunt & forage for food, unless you live in a primitive tribe well away from civilisation. However what we see going on in some abatoirs, & the way some animals are hunted, I don't blame people for going veggie or vegan. I was veggie for the most part when growing up, but the protein in meat is quite essential in our diet. that's not to say a vegan diet is not a bad thing, it's still very much tastey & healthy, so long as those nutritions are sought via other means.
02:23 PM on 07/12/2012
canine teeth, hahahah take a look in the mirror
photo
vividrick
I came, I saw...I had a cup of tea!
11:31 PM on 07/11/2012
I started my journey to become vegan ( yes it IS a journey) after taking in rescued farm animals..I got to see first hand, the intelligence, the comradery, the humor, and love that ALL of them had for myself and for eachother..Especially the chickens!! I know most people think they are dumb and useless except for eating but they have rich complex emotions and languages and vastly different personalities..If you want to go vegan, take the time to make a plan..It took me eight months. I removed one or two foods a month and let my body cleanse of those foods..It's just like quitting smoking! or a drug! You can and will relapse, but get back on the wagon! DOn't forget- for some dairy is the hardest...But the most important to purge out of your system. And I'm a mother with a busy life and career- its not that hard..try your freezer section for meat substitutes..like Quorn, Boca, gardena, great stuff!!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
adam in oregon
11:04 PM on 07/11/2012
It is pretty funny where I work. A couple of people have had heart problems and their doctors put them on a vegan diet. After years of teasing, and funny looks when I eat lunch, and now they are all on a vegan diet because they want to live. Just think how much healthier they would have been if they ate vegan all along. There are sooooo many reasons to do it. Better for you. Better for animals. Better for the enviornment.
10:20 PM on 07/11/2012
Why wait till you are sick? Why wait till you are obese? Why wait till you are old before your time? Help yourself and help the planet, go Vegan!
09:04 PM on 07/11/2012
This is a big reason why I went vegetarian. I have tried to go vegan, but I really struggle with dairy. Unfortunately, I am just not dedicated enough to really make it stick. The sad fact is, the dairy industry is the worst. So, if I am going to be bad and eat dairy, I try to pick a product that is manufactured on a small scale, and usually goat cheese. I really, truly enjoy being meat free. There are many good things, kitchen is cleaner, and you can eat marinades, no worries about cross contamination,etc...no blood dripping from packages in the fridge. It's nice.
11:24 PM on 07/11/2012
Janet- I've heard that the chemical makeup of cheese is like that of morphine and some become literally addicted to it.. I was..It's just like quitting smoking, or a drug..Once your system is "clean" of dairy- EVERYTHING changes...I was so addicted to cheese that I couldn't go near the chesse section in the grocery store, Iwould literally lose my mind and buy 5 BRICKS of cheese, go home and binge...Once cheese is out of the picture EVERYTHING gets better, your mood, your mental clarity, your skin, your digestion!!!!! Its amazing...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Briarcircle
Yankee
07:26 PM on 07/11/2012
You won't know until you try, so try the vegan diet. At the very least you will discover foods you've never tried before and enjoy new ways to serve a plant based diet.
photo
homer winslow
Truth in Beauty, Beauty in Truth
07:38 PM on 07/11/2012
And the most important thing is that you will prolong your life and feel so much better.
01:43 PM on 07/12/2012
Who wants their life prolonged? Years more in an old people's home, being treated like a moronic baby or worse. I eat meat. I do not intend to stop. You do not have a moral high ground on me and I'm sure you do not feel better. You just feel smug.
06:58 PM on 07/11/2012
Yes on bringing to light the plight of industrial farm animals. I wholeheartedly agree that the way the west raises industrial farm animals is cruel and sadistic, but vegan is not for everyone including me.

Putting personal diets aside, lets join together around a common cause. Americans will not quit eating meat, so lets promote local, non-feedlot raised, antibody/hormone free beef, pork, and chicken. It's healthier, better for the environment, and the meat just tastes better.
01:46 PM on 07/12/2012
This is sensible advice. Practically every place that sells eggs does so free-range in the UK, because people demanded it. I look for locally sourced meat, but it is expensive and I cannot always afford it. I eat fish once or twice a week and have one meat free day. I like meat and will not give it up. Lord knows there are few enough pleasures in life without forcing yourself to eat rabbit food. Watched all of River Cottage Veg and wasn't impressed.